COURIER OPINION: Parole fiasco of Angus killer Tasmin Glass raises serious questions on victim welfare
The Angus killer was recalled to prison in April after breaking the conditions of her release.
She was granted her freedom last year, halfway through a ten-year sentence for culpable homicide for her involvement in the murder of Steven Donaldson.
No official reason has been given as to why Glass finds herself back in prison, not even her victim's family know the details.
But under the current law in Scotland, the killer must be considered for parole again 'immediately' after recall.
In reality, that 'immediately' was two months, where the possibility of her re-release has hung heavy over the Donaldsons.
Now it's been pushed back for another six to eight weeks.
In the words of Steven's father Bill: 'This means this is, yet again, going to drag on for us.'
The words 'yet again' are very important here.
Since Glass first became eligible for parole consideration on February 28 last year, her case will have been before the panel five times when it is called again.
Five times in 18 months. Three deferrals.
It could be more if the board fail to come to a decision again at the next oral hearing.
This presents an obvious issue with victim care and victim welfare.
The Donaldsons have been left in limbo for nine of the last 18 months, wondering if Steven's killer will remain in jail.
For the other nine? Glass was walking free.
These delays take a serious toll on victims and their families and there is no respite for them during these periods.
That they are numerous is frightening, and raises serious questions over how this process is handled and governed.
The parole board and the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) knew for two months that Glass' case would be coming before them.
They had from April 1 to June 4 to prepare.
It is unacceptable that they did not have the required information on the day to make a decision.
Because there is no doubt that it is the victim that suffers in these situations.
It is them who steel themselves for an answer, only to be told they must continue to wait.
It's an emotional nightmare for those involved and flies in the face of the 'trauma-informed' direction our justice system is supposedly headed.
Unfortunately, the Donaldsons are not alone in being put through this turmoil, and deferrals and indecision do not appear to be outliers.
Last August, the survivor of Dundee murderer Robbie McIntosh travelled to Perth on the morning of his parole hearing only to be told it had been postponed at the eleventh hour.
Linda McDonald made official complaints to both The Parole Board of Scotland and SPS about the circumstances that morning – she is still awaiting a satisfactory reply.
Through our A Voice for Victims campaign, The Courier has been fighting for parole reforms in Scotland.
The treatment of the Donaldson family, of Linda, in these cases show that there is a dire need for widescale changes in how this process operates.
The Justice Secretary has announced a public consultation on parole will begin this August.
Lowering the deferral rate should be a high priority.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
5 days ago
- The Herald Scotland
Nicola Sturgeon's legacy may be defined by Isla Bryson
Nicola Sturgeon has said she was 'like a rabbit caught in the headlights' when asked if double rapist Isla Bryson was a woman. In her new book, the former first minister said she was 'completely blindsided' when the case prompted a public outcry. 'I had no advance warning that the case was pending,' she wrote in Frankly. 'To this day, I do not understand how no one in the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) or Scottish government officialdom thought it important to flag it up to me.' Read more from Unspun: Bryson was convicted at the High Court in Glasgow in 2023 of raping one woman in Clydebank in 2016 and another in Glasgow in 2019. He began identifying as a woman only after being charged and has not legally changed gender. Although the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service expected Bryson to be sent to Barlinnie, the SPS initially moved him to the women's prison at Cornton Vale. It was only after a backlash, and Ms Sturgeon's intervention, that Bryson was transferred to HMP Edinburgh. The row came just weeks after MSPs passed the controversial Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill. Although the Bill never became law, the SPS had for years allowed prisoners to self-identify their gender. Which is why nobody flagged it to the first minister. Despite the Bryson scandal, subsequent policy changes, and the Supreme Court case, the SPS continues to house dangerous, biological men in the women's estate. Its post-Bryson 2023 Policy for the Management of Transgender People in Custody states that a transgender woman 'will not be eligible to be considered for admission or transfer to a women's prison' if convicted of serious offences such as murder, assault, robbery, abduction, rape, and sexual harassment. However, the policy includes an exception: the SPS Risk Management Team can approve transfers if there is 'compelling evidence' the prisoner does not present an unacceptable risk. What is unacceptable risk? Research by the Murray Blackburn Mackenzie (MBM) policy collective found that prisoners currently in the women's estate include Alan Baker (also known as Alex Stewart), convicted of murder in 2013 and held in the female unit at Greenock prison. So too is Richard McCabe, also known as Melissa Young, who was convicted of murder in 2014. While on remand at Cornton Vale, they assaulted a female officer, biting her stomach Peter Laing, who now goes by the name Paris Green, was also convicted of murder and torture in 2013. They were still in the female estate in 2024 and recently charged with assaulting a female guard. Do these prisoners represent acceptable risk? The Scottish Human Rights Commission (SHRC) helped draft the new SPS policy. MBM has repeatedly called on the SHRC to withdraw its submission. In June 2023, they were told their request was being considered. Despite chasing in August and October 2023, they received no reply. As reported in The Herald, they wrote again in April 2025, following the Supreme Court case, renewing their call. Almost three months later, SHRC executive director Jan Savage responded. Part of the delay, she said, was due to the prison service. On May 22, 2025, the SHRC wrote to the SPS asking how it was monitoring the impact of its policy, whether it had published data, if the policy would be reviewed, and if it collected information on sex and gender. More than two months on, the SPS has yet to reply. When asked, an SPS spokesperson told me: 'We value the important role of the Scottish Human Rights Commission and will respond to their correspondence in due course. 'We have received the Supreme Court's judgement and are actively considering its impact.' With Frankly, Ms Sturgeon attempts to define her legacy. The truth is, the chaos in Scotland's public sector, and Scotland's prisons in particular, could well define it for her.
Daily Mail
6 days ago
- Daily Mail
Now Nicola Sturgeon takes aim at prison bosses over toxic gender reform chaos
Nicola Sturgeon has tried to blame prison chiefs for trans rapist Isla Bryson being sent to a women's jail. The former First Minister hit out at the Scottish Prison Service for the way it handled the case and said she 'lost the dressing room' over the issue. In her autobiography the SNP MSP, who had just a month earlier had pushed through controversial gender reform legislation, claimed she was 'completely blindsided' when the Bryson case sparked a public outcry. She said: 'I had no advance warning that the case was pending. To this day, I don't understand how it could be that no one in the Scottish Prison Service or Scottish government officialdom thought it important to flag it up to me. 'It isn't for a First Minister to decide which prison an individual goes to, as this is an operational matter, but with some advance warning I could have been ready to explain, and hopefully calm, the situation. Maybe it wouldn't have mattered, the damage might have been done anyway, but at least I could have tried.' She said the story 'went nuclear' and left her 'on the back foot, fighting a fire that was already out of control'. Ms Sturgeon also admitted her 'communication skills deserted me' over the issue and she was 'like a rabbit caught in the headlights' when confronted by questions over whether Bryson, a male-born double rapist, formerly known as Adam Graham was a woman. She admitted that saying Bryson was a rapist did not 'cut any ice' and made her look 'weak and evasive' and unable to 'stand behind the logical conclusion of the self-identification system we had just legislated for'. 'In football parlance, I lost the dressing room,' she wrote. 'From then on, I was on the defensive.' She hit out at feminist JK Rowling and tried to suggest that the Harry Potter author's attacks 'resulted in more abuse, of a much more vile nature, than I had ever encountered before' and also 'made me feel less safe and more at risk of possible physical harm'. But Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay said: 'Frankly, Nicola Sturgeon must be delusional if she thinks the women of Scotland will swallow this drivel. The SNP MSP went on to claim the controversy around her attempt to force through controversial gender reforms as 'one of the most bruising episodes' of her political career. While she said she should have paused the legislation, she also stepped up more attacks on those who opposed it. The SNP Government's Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill had proposed removing the need for a medical diagnosis of gender dysphoria for those applying for a gender recognition certificate, and lowered the minimum age to 16. It triggered a major backlash amid concerns about the lack of protection for women's single-sex spaces like changing rooms and toilets, triggered the biggest rebellion of SNP MSPs during her leadership and was eventually struck down by the UK Government because of concerns about its impact on UK-wide equalities legislation. Claiming some had another agenda, Ms Sturgeon said: 'There are many examples I could cite, but the one that attracted most attention, not surprisingly, was JK Rowling's donning of a T-shirt bearing the slogan 'Sturgeon, destroyer of women's rights'. 'I obviously don't know what her intentions were, but it seems blindingly obvious that a stunt like that was never going to elevate the debate or illuminate the issues at the heart of it. 'The trans debate was one of the most bruising episodes of my time in politics.' She claimed that she received so much vitriol, which she said is often 'deeply misogynist', over gender reform, She said: 'it was deeply ironic that those who subjected me to this level of hatred and misogynistic abuse often claimed to be doing so in the interests of women's safety, to be the standard-bearers of feminism. Nothing feels further from the truth than that.' She also claimed that it 'resulted in more abuse, of a much more vile nature, than I had ever encountered before' and 'at risk of possible physical harm'. Ash Regan, who resigned her ministeral post for community safety over the issue, said last night the ex FM had been well warned. Ms Regan said: 'I, along with others, warned Nicola and her government advisors privately, publicly and repeatedly that the GRR Bill, as drafted, carried serious risks for women and children. Those concerns were not rooted in prejudice, but in evidence, safeguarding principles and the lived realities of vulnerable women. Instead of listening, she chose to ignore those warnings, press ahead, and frame all dissent as bad faith. 'I resigned my ministerial role on principle because I could not, in good conscience, support legislation that opened the door to lobby-led ideology over robust safeguarding. Yes, my ministerial resignation put a target on my back; from that moment on, 'I faced relentless isolation and hostility - not only in politics but in the public sphere, particularly online.' During an interview on ITV News broadcast last night, Ms Sturgeon claimed that anyone like Bryson who rapes a woman 'forfeit' the right to be a woman. When pressed about the comment, she admitted it 'was not the best phrase to use'. Looking back to the gender reform debate, she said: 'We'd lost all sense of rationality in this debate. I'm partly responsible for that.' Scottish Conservative leader Mr Findlay added: 'She arrogantly ignored all warnings that gender self-ID would be a gift to male predators like Isla Bryson. And she ordered her SNP MSPs to vote down my attempts to block rapists and other sex criminals from being able to legally change their gender by self-declaration. 'Her absurd ideological belief in self-ID collapses with her belated mealy-mouthed admission that this rapist is a man, but she still can't bring herself to say sorry for all the pain and misery she has caused.'
The Herald Scotland
6 days ago
- The Herald Scotland
Nicola Sturgeon: Rapist Isla Bryson is ‘biological male'
But she claimed that when the case first emerged, she failed to say so plainly because the debate over sex and gender identity in Scotland had become so 'toxic' that 'all sense of rationality' had been lost. READ MORE 'Fenian B******': Nicola Sturgeon tells of sectarian abuse campaigning in Govan Nicola Sturgeon reveals what she thinks of the nickname that 'stuck' Nicola Sturgeon: I still miss Alex Salmond in some way While Frankly is due for official release on Thursday copies have already appeared for sale in Waterstones stores. The retailer said they had not been told by the publisher to not sell the book. A statement from Waterstones said: 'The publication date does not necessarily equal an on-sale date unless the publisher puts an embargo in place. In the case of Nicola Sturgeon's memoir no sales embargo has been arranged, which means the book can go on sale as soon as it arrives in shops.' In the book, Ms Sturgeon admits her handling of the Isla Bryson case marked a point where her 'acknowledged communication skills deserted' her, saying: 'I lost the dressing room.' Isla Bryon appearing at Glasgow High Court Bryson was found guilty of raping one woman in Clydebank in 2016 and another in Glasgow in 2019 at the High Court in Glasgow in 2023. He began identifying as a woman only after being charged, and has not legally changed gender, although they are taking hormones and requesting surgery. Despite the Scottish Court Service expecting Bryson to be transferred to Barlinnie, the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) moved him to the women's jail at Cornton Vale instead. After a public outcry, Ms Sturgeon made her opposition known to the SPS, which moved Bryson to HMP Edinburgh. The case came just weeks after MSPs passed the controversial Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill at Holyrood. Even though the Bill never became law, the SPS adopted its central premise, allowing people to self-identify as a new gender. Ms Sturgeon was asked for days whether she thought Bryson was a woman but avoided saying so. In a press conference in January 2023, she told journalists: 'She regards herself as a woman.' Asked about the comment, she said: 'What I'm saying is, Isla Bryson calls herself a woman. But what I'm trying to say is, in the context of the prison service, that is not the relevant factor here. The relevant factor is the crime that the individual has committed and has been convicted of.' Pressed again, Ms Sturgeon said: 'She regards herself as a woman. I regard the individual as a rapist.' READ MORE In the interview, broadcast on Monday night, Ms Sturgeon told ITV's Julie Etchingham: 'Isla Bryson identified as a woman. I think what I would say now is anybody who commits the most heinous male crime against women probably forfeits the right to be the gender of their choice.' She added: 'That probably was not the best phrase to use.' Pressed on why she did not simply say Bryson is a biological male, Ms Sturgeon replied: 'They are a biological male. But that's about whether… it gets back into the self-ID thing. "I should have been much more straightforward, I wasn't. But that's because of the debate. We'd lost all sense of rationality in this debate. I'm partly responsible for that.' Sturgeon in Parliament 'That was my failure,' she told ITV. 'Anything I say about in the wider world will immediately be taken and transferred to every trans person. "And if I sometimes still seem as if I'm struggling with how to define Isla Bryson, it's not out of any concern for Isla Bryson, it's out of concern for how that then affects the wider trans community and that is difficult.' Asked about the Gender Recognition Reform Bill and why it mattered so much to her, Ms Sturgeon said that when the legislation was first mooted 'it was not the divisive, toxic, controversial issue it became'. 'Trans people have always existed,' she added. 'They are amongst the most discriminated against and stigmatised groups in our society, and people can chuck as much hate and hostility at me on this issue as they choose.' Asked if she thought the debate and the botched legislation had made things worse for the lives of transgender people in Scotland, Ms Sturgeon said: 'No trans person has ever come to me and said, I really wish you hadn't tried to make life better. 'We really regret how it's all unfolded. 'I didn't, I think, anticipate as much as I should or engage as much as I should on some of the concerns that might then be triggered. 'At the point I knew it was becoming as polarised, I should have… I think I say in the book I wonder if I should have… I want to say it categorically — I should have said, 'Let's pause. Let's take a step back.' 'I fervently believe that the rights of women and the interests of trans people are not irreconcilable at all.' Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay accused Ms Sturgeon of 'delusional' thinking and said women would not 'swallow this drivel'. He claimed she had 'ignored all warnings that gender self-ID would be a gift to male predators like Isla Bryson' and 'ordered her SNP MSPs to vote down my attempts to block rapists and other sex criminals from being able to legally change their gender by self-declaration'. 'Her absurd ideological belief in self-ID collapses with her belated mealy-mouthed admission that this rapist is a man, but she still can't bring herself to say sorry for all the pain and misery she has caused,' he said. Mr Findlay argued that without then-Scottish secretary Alister Jack's 'common-sense decision' to block the reforms, 'every rapist in Scotland would be able to declare themselves as women with the full support of the state'. In the interview, Ms Sturgeon also spoke of being hit by a 'wave of grief' when she learned of Alex Salmond's sudden death last year, despite their acrimonious split over sexual misconduct allegations. The Alba Party leader and former first minister died of a heart attack in North Macedonia in October aged 69. Sturgeon said she still misses Salmond (Image: free) 'Even today I still miss him in some way, the person that I used to know and the relationship we used to have,' Ms Sturgeon said. 'I thought I had made my peace with it… And then I got a call to tell me that Alex Salmond had died. I started crying on the phone and I just was hit by this wave of grief. 'It was complicated because obviously we weren't just no longer friends, we were political enemies. There was no prospect I was going to be able to go to his funeral or anything like that.' She said she later found herself talking to Mr Salmond 'in my head' and dreaming they were 'still on good terms'. Ms Sturgeon also became emotional when talking about leading the Scottish Government through the Covid pandemic. She said she "just lost all perspective" and "started to believe... all the worst caricatures of myself that my political opponents would throw at me" and that she was "responsible for every death." A friend persuaded her to seek therapy. She also revealed she has had her first tattoo, which she jokingly called a 'midlife crisis alert'. The design — an infinity symbol with an arrow — stands for 'strength, resilience and continuing to move forward, even when it feels impossible'. She hinted it 'might not be my last one'. When asked about her personal life and if she could now start a relationship with a woman, after coming out as someone who has never considered her own sexuality to be 'binary,' Ms Sturgeon said: "Look, I'm just out of a marriage, so I'm not rushing into a relationship with anyone anytime soon. I'm enjoying being my own person for once."
