Children should not be strip-searched or detained unless a last resort, say MPs
Harrowing testimonies of children in England and Wales who were strip-searched and who accused police of racism and making damaging, disrespectful comments are included in the research for the all-party parliamentary group (APPG) on children in police custody.
The reports – the culmination of a year's research involving children, police forces and parents – were released days after the sacking of two Metropolitan police officers who were involved in the strip-search of a schoolgirl who become known as Child Q.
While a police misconduct hearing found that racism was not a factor in that incident, the research gives voice to young people who said that racism was a factor in their strip-searches.
Children as young as 10 in England and Wales are currently subject to the same processes and have essentially the same protections as adults when they are detained in police custody.
Instead, the MPs on the group say that police detention should be the last resort for a child and that any initial detention period should be limited to 12 hours – half of the time that adults can be held before they must be charged or released.
Dr Miranda Bevan, a law lecturer at King's College London who led an inquiry for the APPG, said that children who were detained were disproportionately likely to have special educational or communication needs, to have been exploited or suffered victimisation, and to have been known to mental health authorities.
'Yet these children – some as young as 10 – are being left alone in a police cell, with very limited adult support, for up to 24 hours,' she said. 'They are expected to decide whether or not they want to accept legal representation; a decision that they should not be asked to make in those circumstances.
'We must reshape police custody into a space that recognises and responds to the unique needs of children. Reform must be rooted in evidence, and that evidence starts with listening to children and examining their experiences.'
The APPG puts forward 10 recommendations, including a ban on strip-searching children unless under truly exceptional circumstances and making it a requirement that legal advice be provided for all children detained in police custody.
Evidence was taken from police forces volunteers and experts in the field while first-hand accounts were given to the APPG by 10 children who had been strip-searched. 'They took all my clothes off me … They didn't give me a chance to suggest anything else they could do instead,' said one.
Making an allegation about a cavity search, they said: 'She didn't say nothing about it. I just felt it. I know that's not meant to happen … There wasn't no appropriate adult. I had to wait til the next day to have one. While this was happening, I was saying bad words. They charged me for that.
'I get flashbacks of it for sure … My dignity has just been taken.'
Another whose testimony was cited, and who said that there had been a racist dimension to their treatment, said: 'I felt a hatred. I actually was very angry because I felt like I could do nothing about it … Racial slurs or whatever else I've been called when I've been grabbed in searches and whatever else.
'I've been called a 'spear chucking N-word' and I've been called the Middle Eastern racial slur for Pakistanis.'
Alex Carlile, a barrister and officer of the APPG, said: 'Children are not miniature adults – they are vulnerable, developing individuals who must be treated as such when they come into contact with the criminal justice system.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
9 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Lord Kinnock urges Rachel Reeves to launch a VAT raid
Lord Kinnock has urged Rachel Reeves to launch a VAT raid on private healthcare. The former Labour leader said the move would give the NHS 'vital funding' as it looks to slash waiting lists. It is estimated that removing the VAT exemption for private healthcare firms would raise £2 billion – if work the private sector does for the health service is exempt. The Chancellor is looking to fill a black hole of up to £30 billion in her autumn budget as economic growth remains sluggish and recent u-turns on welfare reform and winter fuel need to be paid for. Labour promised in its manifesto not to raise the headline rate of income tax, national insurance or VAT, but has applied VAT to private school fees. The party has already been accused of breaking the pledge by hiking employers' national insurance in the last budget, but a raid on private healthcare could get the Chancellor around the commitment by not raising the headline rate. Lord Kinnock, who lost two general elections for his party, told the i newspaper: 'Introducing VAT on private health provision could provide vital funding for the NHS and social care. 'After 14 years of underinvestment, many people are turning to private healthcare not out of choice, but because they cannot afford to wait. This has increasingly led to unequal access to care. 'Ending the VAT exemption to generate much-needed revenue is a reasonable and widely supported step.' The former Labour leader's comments come after he used an interview with Sky News last month to back a wealth tax, which led to weeks of speculation over whether such a policy would be implemented. The Chancellor appeared to shut down the speculation last week by saying Labour had already 'got the balance right' on wealth taxes after it increased capital gains tax and abolished non-dom status. It is feared any tax raid on private healthcare would lead to longer NHS waiting lists by making it more expensive for people to skip the queue by going private. Such an effect would echo that of the VAT raid on private schools, which has led or will lead to the closure of 44 schools according to Telegraph analysis. Wes Streeting, the Health Secretary, has previously said Labour will use the private sector for 'as long as it takes' to get waiting lists down. Data from private healthcare analyst LaingBuisson suggested 4.68 million people now have private medical insurance, the highest proportion since 2008. The raid on private healthcare was backed by the Good Growth Foundation think tank, which was founded by former Labour candidate Praful Nargund. It said private health companies had enjoyed bumper profits as people have turned to them to avoid a lengthy NHS wait, meaning any raid would amount to a windfall tax. Polling of more than 2,000 people for the think tank found 55 per cent of the public backed the raid, with just 17 per cent against the move. Mr Nargund, who stood unsuccessfully for Labour against Jeremy Corbyn at last year's general election, said: 'We are sleepwalking into a two-tier healthcare system, and we have to back our NHS. 'The NHS is in a dire state: from 8am GP scrambles to months-long waits for cancer care, this is simply not good enough. People are being forced to go private for care they should get for free. 'That's not a system in need of tweaks – it's a system on the brink, in need of major reform. A windfall tax on private healthcare would be a bold, fair first step to fund the innovation and change we need in the NHS.' A spokesperson for the Independent Healthcare Providers Network told the i newspaper: 'With record demand for both NHS and privately funded treatment, along with increasing numbers of employers providing medical insurance to keep their staff healthy, we would strongly warn against any changes to the tax system which may dis-incentivise people from accessing the healthcare that they need to live full and productive lives.' A Government spokesperson told the newspaper: 'Thanks to this Government's record investment, reforms and the hard work of NHS staff, we've cut the waiting list by over 260,000 since July 2024, which also fell for the first time in 17 years in April and May outside of the pandemic. On top of this, we have also delivered 4.6 million appointments – more than double the two million we promised.'
BBC News
9 minutes ago
- BBC News
'Gaping hole' in DBS regulations let paedophile prey on children
A "gaping hole" in the law meant a convicted paedophile could lead activities for children where he used the access to abuse them, a charity has said. Nicholas Moxham ran parties in Manchester but did not need to have to undergo a Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) check, a common test for people working with young people which would have revealed his previous conviction, because he was who was detained for four years in 1992 after wounding a woman and received a caution in 1997 for indecent exposure, was jailed for at least 19 years after being convicted of a series of sex offences against women and children in 2024, some of which took place at the charity Freedom from Abuse said the law should be changed to ensure "anyone" working with children underwent DBS checks. Moxham ran party experiences involving laser tag, zorbing, go-karting and science demonstrations through companies he owned in buildings, outdoor areas and woodland he had hired from Parrs Wood High discovered that in 2016 he had lured three children who were playing laser tag to a hidden area of the woodland being filmed by a camera he had hidden in leaves and exposed himself and acted indecently while their backs were also found that between 2018 and 2019, he hid a motion-activated camera in the toilets of an outbuilding that was used by both children and adults attending his of those filmed by Moxham have been identified by also kept devices containing indecent images of children and animals in a storage unit at the school. 'Children being harmed' Teachers and other employees who work with children and are unsupervised by senior staff must have an enhanced DBS, which looks for criminal records and ensures they have not been banned from working with children. However, anyone employing themselves through their own company is not legally required to have a DBS certificate, though self-employed people can obtain checks by applying through agencies, professional organisations or specialist parents were usually present at Moxham's events, but regulations mean that only the presence of senior staff negates the need for an enhanced DBS certificate in such circumstances for anyone not working for their own whose name has been changed to protect her identity, booked Moxham for one of her son's birthday said most parents "just assume that these people have been checked and that it is safe"."I'd trusted him, it was at a school, it was a registered company, I'd done the research, I'd looked at the reviews," she said."What more can you do?" For support and information around the issues raised in this piece, go to BBC Action Line Freedom from Abuse's Marilyn Hawes said "anyone" working with children should need to undergo checks for previous convictions or cautions."It's a gaping hole that children are falling down and being harmed," Ms Hawes Miller from law firm Farleys said DBS checks were "there for employers" and in circumstances where self-employed people had been booked, it was "essentially left to the parents or guardians" to make sure that those providing the service had been "appropriately checked".The Home Office said it would not comment on individual cases but is understood to be looking at extending the scope of enhanced criminal records checks to self-employed people who work closely with children and vulnerable adults. When Moxham was sentenced at Manchester Crown Court in July 2024, Judge John Potter said he was a "determined and predatory sexual offender" who used his businesses "as a means to sexually exploit children".The judge also said his "random attack" in 1992 had been motivated by his "anger" towards women, because of their "disinterest" in him, and that Moxham had shown he had "a capacity to cause very serious harm".He added that the school should review whether "appropriate checks were made" before his business was allowed to operate teacher Mark McElwee said Moxham "ran an independent business that was not connected to our school beyond the fact that his business held events for the wider community when the school was closed on premises he hired out from us".He said "all correct procedures" were followed in relation to the site hire and "no concerns were raised with us in relation to this, either at the time or during a subsequent safeguarding review of our lettings procedures once the offending came to light".He added that the school had been "shocked and appalled by the offences committed" and "additional requirements for hire arrangements" had since been brought in. Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
BBC News
9 minutes ago
- BBC News
Six arrests after man seriously injured in stabbing in Luton
Six people have been arrested after a man was seriously injured in a Police was called to an incident in Morgan Close, Luton at about 13:35 BST on Sunday. The force said six people were arrested at a property in nearby Homedale Drive and remained in appealed for witnesses or anyone with information to come forward and said officers would remain in the area while further inquiries were carried out. Det Insp Clare Gilbert said: "We understand that this is shocking incident for those in the area."We responded quickly and were able to make a number of arrests shortly after the stabbing took place." Follow Beds, Herts and Bucks news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
