logo
Parliament to debate suspending Maori politicians who performed protest haka

Parliament to debate suspending Maori politicians who performed protest haka

Irish Examiner15-05-2025

A New Zealand parliamentary committee has recommended the unprecedented suspensions of three Maori politicians for performing a protest haka in the debating chamber last year.
The haka is a chanting dance of challenge of great cultural importance in New Zealand, and the three politicians from Te Pati Maori, the Maori party, performed one to oppose a Bill that would have redefined the country's founding document.
A committee on Wednesday recommended record suspensions and severe censure — the harshest penalties ever assigned to New Zealand parliamentarians — after finding the trio in contempt of parliament.
Government bloc politicians, who hold the majority, are expected to endorse the penalties in a vote on Tuesday.
The report recommended that Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke be suspended from parliament for seven days (Mark Tantrum/AP)
But parliament's speaker Gerry Brownlee took the unusual step on Thursday of saying that he would first allow unlimited debate before the vote due to the severity of the proposed punishments.
The recommendations were the latest twist in the fraught saga over the Bill, now defeated, that opponents said would have provoked constitutional havoc and reversed decades of progress for Maori, New Zealand's indigenous people.
Video of the legislators in full cry drew global attention last November.
The Bill they opposed was vanquished at a second vote in April.
But some politicians from the centre-right government objected to the Maori Party legislators' protest during the first vote and complained to parliament's speaker.
It is not acceptable to physically approach another member on the floor of the debating chamber
At issue was the way the trio walked across the floor of the debating chamber towards their opponents while they performed the haka.
'It is not acceptable to physically approach another member on the floor of the debating chamber,' Wednesday's report said, adding that the behaviour could be considered intimidating.
The committee denied the legislators were being punished for the haka, which is a beloved and sacred cultural institution in New Zealand life, but 'the time at and manner in which it was performed' during a vote, according to the findings.
The committee deciding the fate of the politicians has members from all political parties. The government's opponents disagreed with parts or all of the decision but were overruled.
'This was a very serious incident, and the likes of which I have never seen before in my 23 years in the debating chamber,' the committee's chair, Judith Collins, said.
The process was grossly unjust, unfair, and unwarranted, resulting in an extreme sanction. This was not about process, this became personal
The three legislators did not appear before the committee when summoned in April because they said parliament did not respect Maori cultural protocol and they would not get a fair hearing.
'The process was grossly unjust, unfair, and unwarranted, resulting in an extreme sanction,' Maori party spokesperson and politician Mariameno Kapa-Kingi said in a statement.
'This was not about process, this became personal.'
The report recommended that Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke, who at 22 is New Zealand's youngest politician, be suspended from parliament for seven days. The co-leaders of her political party, Rawiri Waititi and Debbie Ngarewa-Packer, face 21-day bans.
Three days is the longest a politician has been barred from the house before. Suspended legislators are not paid during their bans.
Mr Waititi and Ms Ngarewa-Packer, the leaders of the party that advocates Maori rights and holds six of parliament's 123 seats, have lambasted the committee's process as intolerant of Maori principles and identity.
Maori protest movements have wrought growing recognition of the founding document's promises in New Zealand's law, politics and public life (Charlotte Graham-McLay/AP)
The pair received more severe sanctions than Ms Maipi-Clarke because the younger politician had written a letter of 'contrition' to the committee, the report said.
The Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill sought to redefine New Zealand's founding document, the 1840 pact between the British Crown and Maori leaders signed during New Zealand's colonisation.
The English and Maori language versions of the treaty differed, and the Crown immediately began to breach both, resulting in mass land thefts and generations of disenfranchisement for Maori, who remain disadvantaged on almost every metric.
But in recent decades, Maori protest movements have wrought growing recognition of the treaty's promises in New Zealand's law, politics and public life.
This produced billion-dollar land settlements with tribes and strategies to advance indigenous language and culture.
Such policies were the target of the Bill, drawn up by a minor libertarian party who denounced what they said was special treatment for Maori as they tried to rewrite the treaty's promises.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Russian military losses top 1m in three-year-old war, Ukrainian military says
Russian military losses top 1m in three-year-old war, Ukrainian military says

Irish Examiner

time30 minutes ago

  • Irish Examiner

Russian military losses top 1m in three-year-old war, Ukrainian military says

The number of Russian troops killed or wounded in Ukraine has topped one million, military officials in Kyiv said on Thursday, describing the huge price that Moscow has paid for its three-year-old invasion. The claim by the General Staff of the Ukrainian armed forces is in line with Western intelligence estimates. Russia has suffered 1 million combat losses in Ukraine since the full-scale invasion. This is the devastating human cost Putin is inflicting on his own people. This invasion is a betrayal of his people who are bearing the true cost of this war.#StandWithUkraine 🇺🇦 — Ministry of Defence 🇬🇧 (@DefenceHQ) June 12, 2025 The UK Ministry of Defence also said in a statement posted Thursday on X that Russia has suffered more than one million casualties, including roughly 250,000 killed since it launched the full-scale invasion on February 24 2022. On June 3, the Centre for Strategic and International Studies in Washington said Russia would likely hit the mark of one million casualties this summer in what it called 'a stunning and grisly milestone'. Russia last reported its military casualties early in the war when it acknowledged that about 6,000 soldiers had been killed. Earlier this year, the General Staff of the Russian armed forces claimed that Ukrainian military losses had topped one million. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky last spoke of Ukrainian military losses in February, when he said in an interview that 45,100 troops had been killed and about 390,000 injured. The mutual claims of the other side's losses could not be independently verified. A rescue worker evacuates a woman from a building which was damaged by a Russian strike in Kharkiv (Ukrainian emergency services via AP/PA) The casualty estimates came as Russian forces pummelled Ukraine with drones and other weapons, killing three people and injuring scores of others despite international pressure to accept a ceasefire. According to the Ukrainian air force, Russia launched 63 drones and decoys at Ukraine overnight. It said that air defences destroyed 28 drones while another 21 were jammed. Ukrainian police said two people were killed and six were injured in the past 24 hours in the eastern Donetsk region, the focus of the Russian offensive. One person was killed and 14 others were also injured in the southern Kherson region, which is partly occupied by Russian forces, police said. The authorities in Kharkiv, Ukraine's second-largest city, said 18 people, including four children, were injured by Russian drone attacks overnight. Kharkiv Mayor Ihor Terekhov said Russian drones targeted residential districts, educational facilities, nurseries and other civilian infrastructure. 'Kharkiv is holding on. People are alive. And that is the most important thing,' Mr Terekhov said. Rescue workers put out a fire of a building which was damaged by a Russian strike in Kharkiv (Ukrainian emergency services via AP/PA) Russia has launched waves of drones and missiles in recent days, with a record bombardment of almost 500 drones on Monday and a wave of 315 drones and seven missiles overnight on Tuesday. Ukraine responded to the Russian attacks with drone raids. Russia's Defence Ministry said that air defences downed 52 Ukrainian drones early on Thursday, including 41 over the Belgorod region that borders Ukraine. Regional Governor Vyacheslav Gladkov said three people were injured by Ukrainian attacks. The recent escalation in aerial attacks has come alongside a renewed Russian battlefield push along eastern and northeastern parts of the more than 1,000-kilometre (over 600-mile) front line. While Russian missile and drone barrage have struck regions all across Ukraine, regions along the front line have faced daily Russian attacks with short-range exploding drones and glide bombs. A building is seen on fire after a Russian strike in Odesa, Ukraine. (Ukrainian Emergency Services via AP) On Thursday, the Russian Defence Ministry claimed its troops captured two more villages in the Donetsk region, Oleksiivka and Petrivske. The Ukrainian military had no immediate comment on the Russian claim. The attacks have continued despite discussions of a potential ceasefire in the war. During their June 2 talks in Istanbul, Russian and Ukrainian negotiators traded memorandums containing sharply divergent conditions that both sides see as nonstarters, making a quick deal unlikely. In Rome, Nato Secretary-General Mark Rutte commended US President Donald Trump for his 'crucial' move to start direct peace talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin. At the same time, Mr Rutte criticised Mr Putin for appointing his aide Vladimir Medinsky as the top negotiator for the talks in Istanbul. Mr Medinsky ascended through the Kremlin ranks after writing a series of books exposing purported Western plots against Russia and denigrating Ukraine. Nato Secretary General Mark Rutte commended US President Donald Trump for his move to start peace talks with Russian president Vladimir Putin (AP Photo/Virginia Mayo) 'I think that the Russians sending this historian now twice to these talks in Istanbul, trying to start with the history of 1,000 years ago and then explaining more or less that Ukraine is at fault here, I think that's not helpful,' Mr Rutte said. 'But at least step by step, we try to make progress.' Also on Thursday, German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius arrived in Kyiv on an unannounced visit, noting the stepped-up Russian attacks send a message from Moscow that it has 'no interest in a peaceful solution at present,' according to German news agency dpa. Mr Pistorius said his visit underlines that the new German government continues to stand by Ukraine. 'Of course this will also be about how the support of Germany and other Europeans will look in future – what we can do, for example, in the area of industrial co-operation, but also other support,' he said.

Israel to deport six more activists detained on Gaza aid boat, rights group says
Israel to deport six more activists detained on Gaza aid boat, rights group says

Irish Examiner

time2 hours ago

  • Irish Examiner

Israel to deport six more activists detained on Gaza aid boat, rights group says

Israel is deporting six more activists who were detained when it seized an aid boat bound for the war-ravaged Gaza Strip, according to the rights group representing them. The six include Rima Hassan, a French member of the European parliament who Israel had previously barred from entering Israel and the Palestinian territories, citing her support for boycotts of the country. 🚨 Messages from Rima and other members of the Freedom Flotilla crew.#FreedomFlotilla #FreeMadleen — Rima Hassan (@RimaHas) June 11, 2025 They were among 12 passengers, including climate campaigner Greta Thunberg, aboard the Madleen, a boat that sought to break Israel's blockade of Gaza and deliver a symbolic amount of aid. Israel seized the vessel early on Monday and deported Miss Thunberg and three others the following day. The last two activists are expected to be deported on Friday, according to Adalah, a local human rights group representing them. It said the activists were subjected to 'mistreatment, punitive measures, and aggressive treatment, and two volunteers were held for some period of time in solitary confinement'. Israeli authorities declined to comment on their treatment. Activists, including Greta Thunberg, sailed on the Madleen, a boat that sought to break Israel's blockage of Gaza (Salvatore Cavalli/AP) Israel says it treats detainees in a lawful manner and investigates any allegations of abuse. Israel portrayed the voyage as a media spectacle, dubbing it the 'selfie yacht'. It says the blockade, which it has imposed in various forms along with Egypt since Hamas seized power in 2007, is needed to prevent the militant group from importing arms. Critics view it as a collective punishment of Gaza's roughly 2 million Palestinians. The Israeli Foreign Ministry said those activists who signed deportation documents would be deported immediately, while those who refused would be brought before a judicial authority to authorise their deportation in keeping with Israeli law. The activists have protested that they had no intention of entering Israel and were brought there against their will. The Freedom Flotilla Coalition, which organised the journey, said it was aimed at protesting Israel's blockade of Gaza and ongoing military campaign there, which experts say has pushed the territory to the brink of famine more than 20 months into the Israel-Hamas war.

Britain is our enemy number one, Russians say as new poll puts UK above even Ukraine as Moscow's top foe
Britain is our enemy number one, Russians say as new poll puts UK above even Ukraine as Moscow's top foe

The Irish Sun

time2 hours ago

  • The Irish Sun

Britain is our enemy number one, Russians say as new poll puts UK above even Ukraine as Moscow's top foe

BRITAIN has been declared as Russia's biggest national threat - even beating out Ukraine and the United States. A bombshell survey revealed that more than a quarter of Putin's Russia saw the UK as their most formidable opponent on the world stage. Advertisement 7 Putin's state TV mocked the UK after it was declared public enemy number one Credit: East2West 7 The UK and Keir Starmer have been declared as Russia's arch nemesis Credit: Getty 7 A survey taken by a pro-Putin agency showed that more than a quarter of the public saw the UK as their top opponent Credit: AP 7 The UK has been dubbed one of Ukraine's toughest allies throughout Putin's horror invasion Credit: AP Some 28 per cent of Russians named Bizarrely, Ukraine - which Moscow has been at war with for over three years - was seen as the prime foe by only 22 per cent of the public. The shocking poll was unveiled on Russia Day, June 12, which marks the country's separation from the dissolving Soviet Union 35 years ago. The new rating for the UK comes from a pro-Kremlin polling agency called INSOMAR. Advertisement It is the latest in a long history of jabs taken at Britain by Putin's propaganda machine, which has consistently branded the UK as one Ukraine 's staunchest allies since In one recent broadcast on Russian state television, leading Putin mouthpiece Vladimir Solovyov said: 'I can't understand why the British have gone mad [with the new UK defence review]. 'Where do they want to clash with us? He rambled on: "Do they think that we have already landed, entered the Thames somewhere and are now storming Westminster Abbey?" Advertisement Most read in The Sun Breaking Exclusive Solovyov made the baseless claim that the UK had staged clandestine undercover operations against Russia. The Putin yes-man said: "Actually, the attack on Russia's cyber security system was carried out by the British. New footage of Op Spiderweb shows drone blitzing Putin's burning aircraft "Then, let me remind you that the water threat [to Russia] came from the British, when they were trying to figure out who Crimea belonged to. He also claimed that British reconnaissance aircraft were "flying through our airspace". Advertisement Solovyov - who is decorated by Putin for his work as a propagandist - also said: 'Most importantly, I would like to say something separately to Starmer.' He said in a mocking English accent: 'Scottish people, you have to fight for your independence.' Reverting to Russian, he told viewers across his country's 11 time zones: 'Scottish brothers, you must fight for your independence. Right? "These English colonisers have no business on Scottish soil." Advertisement Another propagandist named Andrey Sidorov then suggested the Welsh should "break free" too. Sidorov has frequently advocated using the untested Russian Poseidon unmanned submarine to sink Britain under a tidal wave. 7 Leading Putin TV propagandists made threats to the UK following the poll Credit: East2West 7 Leading Putin TV propagandist Vladimir Solovyov [R] pictured with Vladimir Putin Credit: East2West Advertisement 7 Firefighters work on a fire after a Russian drone attack on Kharkiv, June 12 Credit: Getty He mocked Starmer who "has never served in the army ". The talking head jibed: "He had no basic military training at school." Sir Keir Starmer's new Strategic Advertisement The Prime Minister put the UK on a war footing earlier this month as he ordered the biggest investment in the production of guns and bombs since the Cold War. Writing in The Sun on Sunday, Sir Keir said Britain was facing a 'more dangerous world' and the time has come to 'transform how we defend these islands'. Read more on the Irish Sun The declaration of the UK as Russia's main enemy also came as Putin's state media announced that the US would be competing in its rip-off Eurovision song contest. Bitter tyrant Putin announced the Advertisement

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store