Cooper defends live facial recognition technology expansion amid privacy row
Yvette Cooper denied the technology was being used to catch lower-level crimes such as ticket-touting, as it has been previously in Wales, and said 'safeguards and protections' will govern its deployment.
Critics including Labour peer Baroness Shami Chakrabarti have attacked new plans to roll out 10 vans equipped with facial recognition technology across seven police forces in England as part of a Government overhaul of neighbourhood policing.
The former shadow attorney general said the expansion was a step towards a 'total surveillance society' in the UK.
Asked whether the rollout would infringe on people's privacy, Ms Cooper said: 'Well, the way this technology is being used is to identify people who are wanted by the court, who maybe should be returned to prison, or who have failed to appear before the court, or who have breached things like sexual harm prevention orders, so serious criminals.
'And I think being able to identify them, alongside having proper legal safeguards and a legal framework in place because there do have to be safeguards and protections, but we also need to be able to use the technology to catch dangerous criminals and to keep communities safe.'
In 2017, South Wales Police said facial recognition was being used to track suspects including ticket touts as the force prepared for the Champions League final in Cardiff.
Pressed on whether she was happy for the technology to be deployed in this way, she said: 'No, that's not how they've (police in South Wales) used it.
'They used it for targeting where there's serious organised crime, where there are criminal gangs, but in every case that they do use it, they need to obviously have safeguards in place and we need to make sure that we've got a new legal framework for it to be operating under, and also that it can be used to tackle serious crimes and keep communities safe.'
Ministers have said a new legal framework will be drawn up to support use of the technology following a consultation launching this autumn.
Checks would only be done against police watchlists of wanted criminals, suspects and those subject to bail or court order conditions such as sex offenders, the Home Office said.
The vans would be deployed across seven forces – Greater Manchester, West Yorkshire, Bedfordshire, Surrey, Sussex, Thames Valley and Hampshire – in the coming weeks.
They would be manned by trained officers operating within College of Policing guidance.
But Lady Chakrabarti said the technology was 'incredibly intrusive' and had been 'developed pretty much completely outside the law'.
'Some would say this is yet another move towards a total surveillance society – challenges to privacy, challenges to freedom of assembly and association, and problems with race and sex discrimination because of the higher likelihood of false matches in the context of certain groups,' she told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.
'It's particularly odd that this has all been developed pretty much completely outside the law.'
She welcomed plans to consult ahead of possible new legislation, but warned that to date, 'it's been a bit of a Wild West'.
Policing minister Dame Diana Johnson dismissed the claims, telling BBC Breakfast: 'With the greatest of respect, that's not what this is about.
'This is about giving the tools to our police officers to enable them to keep us safe.'
Forces already deploying live facial recognition had used it to arrest rape, domestic abuse, knife crime and robbery suspects as well as sex offenders breaching their conditions.
Meanwhile, the Home Office said every community across England and Wales had now been assigned a 'named, contactable' officer to handle reports of crimes such as anti-social behaviour.
Their details would be made available for residents on their local force's website, it is understood.
The pledge was made as part of the Government's previously announced Neighbourhood Policing Guarantee, under which forces have signed up to a commitment to respond to neighbourhood queries within 72 hours.
The Government said the move would help ensure 'the public will have consistent direct links to their local force, with dedicated anti-social behaviour leads and new visible patrols in town centres'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Deploying the military for homelessness is a shameful overreach
If I visit a foreign capital and see homeless people on the street, it's never a pretty sight. But if I see military personnel on the street, I start to worry, because the homeless can't arrest me at gunpoint, but the military can. A military response in Washington, D.C., to what is a social problem is heavy-handed and just plain wrong. It smacks of King George's approach back in the late 1700s when he tried to show the colonies, "might makes right." More: President Trump's plan to remove homeless encampments sparks fear in major cities It's not like Washington, D.C., is the only place in the U.S. that has a homeless problem. Most major metro areas are in the same boat, including Cincinnati. Does deploying soldiers help in any way to make things better? And we're hearing the usual trash talk instead of learning that the current administration is having serious discussions with the Washington metro government to address this issue. More: Trump's order on homelessness is more humane than failed liberal policies | Opinion On the other hand, it's probably just another distraction du jour in the hopes that people will eventually quit questioning Trump's past bromance with Jeffrey Epstein. Robert Sharkey, West Chester Township This article originally appeared on Cincinnati Enquirer: A military response to homelessness is an admission of failure |Letter
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
More than 100 migrants in one vessel thought to have bumped crossings to 27,799
A vessel carrying more than 100 migrants is thought to have helped bring the number of small boat arrivals to 27,799 this year. Home Office figures show 325 migrants crossed the English Channel by small boat on Wednesday, in the same week that the number of arrivals since Labour won the election hit 50,000. The PA news agency understands that 106 people attempted the crossing between France and the Kent coast on a single boat. A total of 51,041 migrants have been detected crossing the Channel since Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer entered No 10 on July 5 last year. A former home secretary has said that the figure 'demonstrates the way over the last six or seven years that the criminal gangs have got an absolute foothold in the tragic trafficking of people across the Channel'. Baroness Jacqui Smith of Malvern, who is now an education and women and equalities minister, told BBC Breakfast on Monday: 'It is an unacceptable number of people.' Speaking on the Isle of Wight this week, Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch said: 'My team are now looking at what we can do in terms of detention centres, but stopping people from coming here in the first place – if they think they're going to be sent to Rwanda and not get here, get a free hotel, get benefits, then they won't come here.' Asked if her party could reduce the five-figure numbers to zero if it was in power, Mrs Badenoch said she thought 'it wouldn't happen straight away, but it would happen quickly'.
Forbes
3 hours ago
- Forbes
Guyana Government Locks In An Innovative Energy Security Solution
In the wake of last week's announcement by ExxonMobil of the commencement of production from a fourth major oil development in the Stabroek area offshore Guyana, the size of the revenue stream due to the country's government and it's 800,000 citizens now stands to rise to as high as $10 billion annually by 2030. The magnitude of such a bounty is undeniable, but with the rapid rise in national wealth comes a responsibility to manage it in a way which maximizes the benefits to the nation. An Innovative Solution Brings an Array of Potential Benefits The government led by President Irfaan Ali has proven to be nimble and open to innovative ideas and solutions as the revenue stream has grown, always with an eye towards maximizing the opportunity to the benefit of Guyana and the region. One such solution the government announced recently is an arrangement with U.S. energy logistics and infrastructure provider Curlew Midstream which will avoid the need to invest in a new domestic oil refinery. Chevron recently became an ExxonMobil partner in the Stabroek field via its $53 billion acquisition of Houston-based independent Hess Corp. In the arrangement, announced by President Ali in February's Guyana Energy Conference and Supply Chain Expo, the government plans to trade its share of the Stabroek crude production with Curlew in exchange for the refined products needed to power the Guyanese economy. Curlew will transport the crude oil to the U.S. and supply corresponding volumes of products like gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, lubricants and many other refined products back to Guyana. Telling the Expo's audience that he believes the new arrangement will have a 'transformative impact' on Guyana's economy, President Ali added, 'It is a strategic investment that goes beyond commercial relationship…These are the types of investments that we are pursuing: Transformative investments. Investments that go beyond economics and financial returns. Investments to strengthen security, integrate security, expand partnership.' Importantly, the U.S. Department of Commerce (USDoC) praised the plan following Ali's announcement. On its X feed, the USDoC said the project is 'a major win for the U.S. & Guyanese economies. This project shows the tremendous work for greater commercial ties & stability for the CARICOM region. We look forward to the completion of the agreement!' Headquartered in Bentonville, Arkansas, Curlew Midstream operates an array of storage, pipelines, and other associated infrastructure which gives it the ability to source the refined products needed from a variety of Gulf Coast refineries and plants. In a recent interview, Curlew's Founder and CEO, Aaron Grieb, told me, 'We have pipeline connectivity from our facility in Venice, Louisiana, to the entire New Orleans refining network. We also have the ability to barge products from any of those refineries.' Further east, Grieb adds that the company also has pipeline connections to Chevron's largest domestic refinery at Pascagoula, LA. By entering this arrangement with Curlew, Guyana stands to not only be able to supply its domestic energy needs at a potential savings as high as 20% below current prices, but also to profit from the export of excess supplies to the greater Southern Caribbean region, and even into Brazil. As a member of the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) alliance, Guyana stands to potentially become the 'gas station' for the region, with an ability to offer gas and other products at prices below the current market. Such positioning could give the Ali government and his successors more influence in the region and open up additional opportunities for beneficial trade arrangements. A new wealth in refined products, combined with a new highway currently under construction linking the southern half of Guyana with the remote northern Brazilian province of Roraima opens up more new trade opportunities. Currently, Roraima and its capital city, Boa Vista, must obtain gasoline and other fuel needs via barges shipped hundreds of miles up the Amazon River. An ability to get the products overland from Guyana's capital, Georgetown, will cut weeks and substantial costs out of that supply chain. Curlew is already in the process of establishing a loading and storage terminal directly adjacent to ExxonMobil's own port facility, the only port in the area with the ability to handle the largest class refined product vessels. The location is a key element to the project's success. 'We're going to go right next to them [ExxonMobil] to help justify the unit economics of being able to bring bigger ships into Guyana,' Grieb says. 'We thought it was important to have a working relationship with Exxon, because they also stand to benefit from a lot of the efforts that we're doing in country. It really is a complimentary relationship.' For Ali's government, the ability to exploit the country's equity production to source its energy needs without having to invest in a new refinery brings an array of economic and environmental benefits. Building a refinery from scratch would involve the need to secure billions of dollars in investment and consume at least 7-10 years before operations could begin. Even with the most modern technologies available, refining operations come with an array of environmental concerns including potential impacts to both water and air quality. The trading arrangement with Curlew enables Guyana to satisfy its refined products needs while avoiding such complex business involvements and environmental concerns. From Grieb's point of view, it does more than that. 'It strengthens bilateral trade between the U.S. and Guyana,' he points out. 'It creates job security for Guyanese citizens. It creates an array of new industry that doesn't exist today, and it creates additional bi-lateral trade, security and geopolitical benefits between the U.S., Guyana and CARICOM nations.' For Guyana, Responsible Management Is Crucial Curlew and Guyana's government have engaged in negotiations since February's announcement and anticipate having a final deal in place in early September. Once final, it will represent the second largest commercial deal in Guyana's history, behind only its agreement with ExxonMobil governing the Stabroek development. Once this innovative solution to a highly complex need is operational, Guyana stands to enjoy a level of optionality and flexibility related to its energy security needs which no other country in the region currently has, providing a clear example of responsible management of a key national asset.
