
MPs slam ‘disgraceful' rollback of Northern Ireland veterans legislation
MPs critical of the move suggested it would open a 'witch-hunt' against veterans who served to protect citizens across communities in Northern Ireland.
The debate followed a public petition against repealing the legislation which attracted more than 170,000 signatures.
Conservative MP John Lamont, who opened the parliamentary session, said the rollback could lead to 'two-tier' payouts for figures such as former Republican politician Gerry Adams.
Mr Lamont said: '[The change] could result in a six-figure payout for Mr Adams, simply because his interim custody order was not considered by the secretary of state, but rather a junior minister.
'That is simply outrageous.
'We have seen a lot of examples of two-tier justice since the Labour government came to power, but this may simply be the worst of all.
'Is the Government really contemplating creating a system to drag northern Irish veterans through the courts, whilst potentially paying millions to terrorists?
'We should also be clear about the differences between the actions of soldiers and terrorists. When terrorists get up in the morning, they go out with murderous intent to use violence to attack our democracy. Soldiers do not.
'The Legacy Act is by no means perfect, but it is better than the disgraceful spectacle of veterans being dragged through the courts.
'Doing so is not sustainable – legally or morally.'
(left to right) Rohit Pathak, Denise Walker, 58, former catering corps veteran from Glasgow, and Anthony Johnson, 67, veteran and protester, participate in a march outside Parliament (Lily Shangaher/PA)
Others echoed Mr Lamont's comments, highlighting the implications the rollback could have on the armed forces in future conflicts.
Conservative MP Sir David Davis argued the change would mean that British soldiers would be abandoned by the country they served.
He said: 'Getting this right is not just a matter of historical justice.
'The legal witch-hunt won't end in Northern Ireland.
'It'll cast a shadow over every future conflict that our armed forces engage in, and undermine their abilities to defend us.'
He added: 'Those who freely talk about human rights would do well to remember that our rights, our law, our democracy and our nation were protected by the very veterans that are at risk today.
'So let us all make one promise, that no British soldier will ever again be abandoned by the nation they have so bravely protected.'
Other MPs voiced their support in favour of the Government's proposals, arguing that the current act is not fit for purpose.
Labour MP Louise Jones suggested that the lack of support for the legislation among victims, politicians across parties in Northern Ireland, and veterans themselves meant it ought to be repealed.
She said: 'This Legacy Act has been found to be unlawful. It gives immunity to terrorists, and it denies justice to the families of the 200 service personnel that were murdered by terrorists during the Troubles.
'It is not supported in its current form by victims, it's not supported by a Northern Irish party, and many veterans are troubled by it. It must go and be replaced, and I call on the minister to outline how we can protect veterans from malicious lawfare of any conflict.'
'We have a huge duty here in Westminster to work with those communities not against them, and I hope everyone here will reflect on that important undertaking.'
Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn pointed to statistics from the Centre for Military Justice that show that only one British soldier has been convicted since the Good Friday Agreement in 1998.
He suggested that this was the case over the 27 years, despite immunity for British military personnel not being enshrined in law for the majority of this time.
Catriona Wallace, a veteran and protester (Lily Shanagher/AP)
Mr Benn also argued that the changes would allow incomplete investigations into the deaths of soldiers to reopen.
He said: 'Legacy is hard. This is the unfinished business of the Good Friday agreement.
'And that is why we need to listen to the many families who lost loved ones, including the families of British service personnel, who served so bravely.
'There are more than 200 families of UK military personnel who are still searching for answers 30, 40, 50 years ago about the murder of their loved ones.
'The Police Service of Northern Ireland recently confirmed they had 202 live investigations into Troubles-related killings of members of our armed forces, and a further 23 into the killings of veterans.
'Each and every one of those investigations was forced to close by the Legacy Act, and we will bring forward legislation to deal with that.
'The other challenge is the lack of confidence in the act on the part of communities in Northern Ireland, which we are going to seek to reform.
'We owe it to all these families.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
20 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Trump says 50-50 odds of trade deal with EU
Published: | Updated: President Donald Trump gave even odds for reaching a trade deal with the European Union as he left Washington to begin his trip to Scotland – with a path to a solution where the Europeans 'buy down' the tariffs he is imposing. 'I would say that we have a fifty-fifty chance,' Trump said, amid reports that the two sides are narrowing in on a possible deal. 'Maybe less than that,' he hedged. 'But a fifty-fifty chance of making a deal with the EU. And It will be a deal where they have to buy down their tariffs. Because they're right now at 30 percent,' Trump said, referencing the tariff set to take effect by the new 'doomsday' August 1 deadline unless there is an agreement. 'They'll have to buy them down - maybe. Or they can leave them the way they are.' Trump, using a favorite negotiating tactic, described his counterparts as desperate. 'But they want to make a deal very badly. I would have said we have a 25 percent chance with Japan and they kept coming back and we made a deal,' Trump said. He was referencing the deal he announced days ago, which has Japan paying a 15 percent tariff, lower than the threatened 25 percent tariff, while opening markets to U.S. exporters. Trump and his top negotiators continue to gush about the Japanese investment – while describing it in terms different than what is coming out of Tokyo. 'Don't forget Japan's putting up $550 billion,' Trump said Friday. 'That's a lot of money. And also paying tariffs. The biggest part of the Japan deal and maybe we get this with EU maybe we don't is we have the right to go in and trade. They've totally opened Japan just for the U.S.' Trump made the comments as he left the White House at the start of a five-day trip that will have him visit his two Scottish golf courses – and meet with British PM Keir Starmer to try to 'refine' an existing U.S.-UK trade deal. He had earlier escalated his demands with the EU in mid-July by raising the tariff threat. In his Truth Social post announcing the deal, Trump said: 'Japan will invest, at my direction, $550 billion dollars into the United States, which will receive 90 percent of the profits.' Andy Laperriere, head of U.S. policy research at Piper Sandler, told CNBC that Japanese officials are 'describing it differently' and 'see the $550 billion figure as a cap and inclusive of government loan guarantees.' But Commerce Secretary Lutnick has been describing it as an investment kitty that Trump can personally direct to ramp up industrial production – with no mention of a legislative role. 'This is literally the Japanese government giving Donald Trump $550 billion, and says: Go fix whatever you need to fix,' he told host Laura Ingraham on Fox News. 'Donald Trump can take the Japanese money and say 'let's go build a factory. Let's get an American company to operate it, we'll lease them the factory. They don't make much money - so what. That's the beauty of this deal,' he said. As he calls for the Europeans to 'buy down' tariffs, Trump may have been emboldened by other moves besides the Japan deal. On Thursday, Columbia University reached a settlement with the Justice Department where it will pay $200 million and a civil rights investigation will be dropped.


The Herald Scotland
22 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Donald Trump: The highs and lows of his relationship with Scotland
Though Trump has said he "feels Scottish", his relationship with the country has had its ups and downs. Here are the highs and the lows. Read More: Trump's Scottish connection The President is connected to Scotland by blood, his mother, Mary Anne MacLeod, was from Stornoway. Born in the village of Tong in 1912 to Malcolm, a crofter and fisherman, and Mary Ann hers was a tough upbringing, the Hebrides at the time being described by historian James Hunter as "where I always considered human wretchedness to have reached its very acme" and by the President as "serious Scotland". She grew up speaking Gaelic, only learning English when she went to school, but Tong didn't have much to offer a young woman. Mary became one of the roughly half a million Scots who emigrated between 1919 and 1938, with over three-quarters of those heading to North America. The day before her 18th birthday, May 11 1930, she arrived in New York City under immigrant visa 2669191. As she arrived on the RMS Transylvania, Mary would have passed the Statue of Liberty on her way to the immigration centre on Ellis Island. Records show she had never visited the U.S before and was carrying the sum total of $50. Inscribed on the statue, the first thing new immigrants from Europe would see, is a poem which concludes: "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free/the wretched refuse of your teeming shore, send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me/I lift my lamp beside the golden door." Those lofty sentiments clearly haven't rubbed off on the President who declared in October last year: "We're a dumping ground. We're like a garbage can for the world. Every time I come up and talk about what they've done to our country I get angry and angrier." A few years later Mary met property developer Fred Trump and the rest is history. Donald, who was born in 1946, may have been named after her maternal grandfather, who died at sea aged 34 but he's visited Lewis just twice in his life, once as a toddler and once for around 90 minutes on the way to one of his golf courses. Highs Donald Trump with The Wee Red Book at Turnberry (Image: Colin Templeton) While most of Trump's dealings with Scotland and in particular the Scottish Government have been adversarial, there have been some moments of harmony along the way. When the future President first purchased the land which would become Trump International Aberdeen, he was welcomed with open arms by First Minister Jack McConnell. The Scottish Labour leader invited Trump to become a 'Globalscot', a network of overseas Scots and friends of Scotland who served as business ambassadors. McConnell said: "Donald has shown me a real passion for Scotland. He is a globally recognised figure who can help us to promote Scotland. I am delighted that he has taken up my offer. This is a good bit of business for all concerned." Indeed, the First Minister wanted to go further by making him a 'platinum member' of the Globalscot club, a unique status which would have been reserved only for The Donald. Such was the love-in, Green MSP Patrick Harvie quipped: "It's beginning to look embarrassing that the leader of the government is behaving like a teenager with a crush." Things continued in much the same vein with McConnell's successor, Alex Salmond - at least initially. In 2007 Aberdeenshire Council rejected planning permission for Trump's golf course and, rather than submitting a new application, the Apprentice host announced he would look elsewhere. In an unprecedented move, the Scottish Government called in the proposal, saying it "raises issues of importance that require consideration at a national level". Trump had met with Salmond the day before. Holyrood eventually approved the proposal, with Trump saying: "I hardly know [[Alex Salmond]], but what I know is that he's an amazing man. "Alex Salmond and I have virtually never even talked about this job but I know for a fact that he - and anyone else who's representing Scotland, unless they're the enemy - wants billions of pounds to come into Aberdeenshire and Scotland." It was on the way to a public hearing about that golf course in Balmedie that Trump visited his mother's croft on Lewis - for a grand total of 97 seconds - and declared "I do feel Scottish". In 2010, Trump was given an honorary degree by Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen raising a chuckle when he was introduced as "the highest-paid speaker in the world" and replied "not today". Speaking of his mother he said: "She was very thrifty. The Scots have this reputation for watching the dollars, so she really had a natural business instinct. "She loved everything that this great place stood for and she'd be very proud today." Lows Donald Trump at Turnberry (Image: Colin Templeton) Trump would not have such an easy relationship with Scotland for long, indeed he was stripped of that degree in 2015. The process of building that first golf course in Aberdeenshire was long and controversial with one local farmer, Michael Forbes, refusing to sell his land to the billionaire. An exasperated Trump ultimately offered £450,000 and a £50k per year job for the small farm. The response? "He can take his money and shove it up his arse." Trump did, of course, finally get his course built but was soon on a collision course with the Scottish Government over one of his pet peeves - wind turbines. As well as objecting to them aesthetically, the President appears to genuinely believe that the noise made by the rotating blades causes cancer. When permission was granted for a wind farm off the coast of Aberdeenshire - in full view of his new course - the future leader of the free world was apoplectic. He wrote a furious letter to Salmond asking: "Do you want to be known for centuries to come as 'Mad Alex - the man who destroyed Scotland'?" So incensed was The Donald he appeared before the Scottish Parliament to give evidence, drawing laughs from the public gallery when asked for his evidence of the negative impact of turbines and responding: "I am the evidence." "He came, he saw, he blustered," said CBS News. Trump threatened to withdraw all investment in Scotland if the plans went ahead, but ultimately decided to expand his portfolio with the acquisition of the Turnberry course in South Ayrshire. He abandoned the Republican primary in 2016 to open the course, where he famously predicted that the UK would vote for Brexit, stunning the political pundit class with his foresight. As he told The Sun: "I predicted Brexit. I was cutting a ribbon for the opening of Turnberry - you know they did a whole renovation, it is beautiful - the day before the Brexit vote. 'I said, 'Brexit will happen'. The vote is going to be positive because people don't want to be faced with the horrible immigration problems that they are being faced with in other countries. I said Brexit will happen, and I was right.' The only slight flaw in this story is that Trump arrived in Ayrshire the day after the vote when the result had already been announced. He did not meet with Salmond's successor, Nicola Sturgeon, on that visit with the First Minister later telling ITV: "I expect the people of the United States will have the good sense not to elect him." The two may not share much in common, but it appears prognostication skill is one of them. Sturgeon was forced into something of a climbdown with what the White House described as "a short congratulatory call" and a letter, though the First Minister made clear she would "not maintain a diplomatic silence" in the face of "abhorrent comments". When Trump was defeated by Joe Biden in 2020, she offered a "cheerio" and "don't haste ye back", with the businessman commenting on the former First Minister's own travails on a trip to Turnberry in 2023 as he said "she has not been a great person for Scotland". John Swinney then caused a stooshie of his own when he urged American voters to back Kamala Harris in November's election, only for Trump to win in a landslide. Son Eric Trump said: "My father adores Scotland, and you have a First Minister coming out and just being fairly nasty in the days leading up. 'I mean, who did that benefit? Did that benefit Scotland?" The First Minister is expected to meet with Trump on his short visit to Scotland - things may be a little frosty.


Scottish Sun
22 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Every road closure ahead of Donald Trump's visit to Scotland revealed
Ten roads will be closed completely over the weekend as the US President visits Scotland DON THE ROAD Every road closure ahead of Donald Trump's visit to Scotland revealed Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DRIVERS have been warned that several roads will be closed ahead of Donald Trump's arrival in Scotland. The US President is expected to touch down on Air Force 1 at Prestwick Airport in Ayrshire later this evening for a private four-day visit. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 President Donald Trump is scheduled to arrive on Air Force 1 at Prestwick Airport later this evening Credit: Alamy 4 A multimillion-pound police operation has been launched ahead of his arrival Credit: PA 4 A ring of steel has been erected around Trump Turnberry Credit: AFP 4 Several road closures and restrictions are in place over the weekend Credit: PA Trump is set to spend the weekend at his golf resorts -Turnberry on the Ayrshire coast and Menie in Aberdeenshire. The Republican leader is scheduled to meet with Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and Scotland's First Minister John Swinney during his stay. He will also cut the ribbon on his second golf course at Menie ahead of an official State Visit planned for September. A multimillion-pound security operation has been launched in preparation for the President's arrival. Around 6,000 police officers have been drafted in from across the UK in the largest police operation since the passing of Queen Elizabeth II in 2022. A ring of steel has been erected around Trump Turnberry, with 10-foot fencing encircling the exclusive Ayrshire resort. Over the weekend, ten roads in the vicinity of Maidens, Turnberry, and Prestwick Airport will be fully closed. A further eight roads will face restrictions on waiting and loading. Road closures include: Turnberry Lodge Road Lodge Road Maidens Road Station Road (Turnberry) Shanter Road Seabank View Kirksowald Road Harbour Road Baineshill Drive Sandyford Road Protesters hang off bridge in major demo ahead of Trump's Scotland visit Prohibition of Waiting and Loading restrictions include: Station Road (Monkton) Kilmarnock Road Baird Road Newdykes Shawfarm Road Monkton Road Mcintyre Road Elvis Street Welsh Road The airspace around Turnberry, Prestwick and Aberdeenshire also will also face restrictions from Thursday, July 24 until July 29. Cops have warned drone operators to ensure it is legal to fly in the area. We told previously how ten activists shut down a major road by hanging off the side of it as part of a protest against the President's visit to Scotland. Emergency services raced to the Forth Road Bridge in South Queensferry, near Edinburgh, this afternoon. The alarm was raised at around 1.05pm after cops received reports of a protest starting to build. Police are urging the public to stay clear of the area as they deal with the incident, adding that they are "engaging" with those involved.