TDs and senators question if €7m Dáil broadcasting contract is value for money
A cross-party group of 125 TDs and senators, including a Government Minister, has called for a review of the estimated €7 million contract for audio and video coverage of
Oireachtas
proceedings, with questions around its value for money.
In a letter to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission, which runs Leinster House, the public representatives, including Minister of State
Jerry Buttimer
, said there is a 'compelling case' for the commission to directly employ the 10 full-time and 20 part-time professional broadcast workers providing the coverage, 'given the extremely concerning working conditions and pay issues'.
They allege 'precarious and uncertain working hours, withdrawal of pay during Oireachtas recess periods – including Christmas – lack of pension entitlements, pay that is significantly below the industry norm, lack of any retainer payment and a culture of criticism from management'.
'These workers are left to rely on social welfare for periods when the Oireachtas is not in session.'
READ MORE
The letter also says 'it is difficult to see what a contract with a private company adds to the services they provide given that all the skilled work is carried out by these workers and their equipment is provided by the Oireachtas itself'.
The first five-year contract was issued in 2011 for €7 million. TDs and senators are attempting to establish the current value of the contract 'and how this money is spent'.
Pi Communications, the current contractor, which provides a similar service to the
Northern Ireland Assembly
, has said the contract operates on a 'pay per public minute model'. Based on the 2011 contract, this meant €250 an hour for each hour of broadcast, as well as an overall contract fee.
The employees broadcast the live feeds of the Dáil, Seanad and committees. They also oversee the archiving of all feeds.
The company said the workers have a guaranteed fixed amount of work 'each full sitting week', with 'certainty of income for their contracted work'.
However, one employee, who did not want to be named, said most of the employees are on 'casual part-time contracts' with 'only one day a week guaranteed, which is very precarious'. Some workers have no guaranteed days and are only brought in occasionally, the employee said.
In response, Pi Communications said: 'We are surprised and disappointed that some who have commented on our operations did not first fact-check the accuracy and veracity of ill-founded claims.'
The company said the employees earn substantially more than the national living wage, with attractive bonus arrangements and receive paid leave and sick leave.
Employees 'are free to work on other projects or for other employers, as is the norm in our industry'. It said salaries are regularly benchmarked and commensurate with roles, skills, experience and responsibilities.
Social Democrats TD Liam Quaide, who co-ordinated the TDs. and senators' letter, said public representatives question 'the value for money' the contract provides. They believe it would be cheaper for the Oireachtas to pay the workers directly. He said the 'only overheads in the contract would seem to be the employees' pay', as the equipment is supplied by the Oireachtas.
The issue has been referred to the Public Accounts Committee and to the Oireachtas Media Committee.
The letter says the contract is due for renewal this year. It adds that any review should include an in-depth investigation into the issues raised by the broadcast workers, which they have previously attempted to resolve through industrial relations mechanisms.
Included in the group of 125 calling for the review is Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald, Labour leader Ivana Bacik, Social Democrats acting leader Cian O'Callaghan, and former journalists Evanne Ní Chuilinn (Fine Gael) and Alison Comyn (Fianna Fáil), both of whom are senators.
The Houses of the Oireachtas Commission has said the workers and Pi Communications are in dialogue at the Workplace Relations Commission and it would not be appropriate 'to undermine the industrial relations process'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘I walk everywhere with one crutch': Senator Nikki Bradley on life as a prosthetic-using politician
When the bell goes for a vote in Leinster House, TDs and Senators have 10 minutes to get to the chamber from their offices before the doors are locked. This is a greater challenge for Senator Nikki Bradley than for most. The Donegal woman, a cancer survivor who had partial-leg-amputation surgery in 2022, uses a prosthetic and says it takes time to get to the Seanad chamber. 'Leinster House is huge. And I walk everywhere with one crutch,' she says. Bradley says the Oireachtas authorities have been 'been absolutely incredible' since her appointment to the Upper House last year. 'They changed out seats, they made a little footstool for me in the Seanad,' she adds. READ MORE She has learned to ask when she is in the chamber, however, if a second vote is likely to be called in the following half hour. 'What was happening was I would go the whole way back to my office and I would literally get to the door and the bell would go again. So I'd have to walk the whole way back.' Senator Nikki Bradley. Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill Bradley says the combination of the long drive to Dublin from Donegal and moving around Leinster House with her current prosthetic, which does not bend at the knee, has taken its toll. The Milford native has suffered chronic nerve pain since she had a tumour removed in 2004. Then there were two right-hip replacements and a metal plate, from hip to knee, being inserted after she broke her femur, all followed by a rotationplasty. 'There's no rhyme or reason to the pain,' Bradley says. 'You can wake up one morning and be completely fine and wake up the next morning and be in bits.' The 39-year-old Taoiseach's nominee, who hopes to one day be elected as a Fine Gael TD for Donegal, had to work from home for a number of weeks because of pain related to her prosthetic. She has an additional problem now because of the weeks spent putting all her weight through her good leg. 'I've now actually acquired another injury on my left foot. So I've no legs left to walk on,' she says, adding that she is using two crutches for the moment to deal with the issue. A disability campaigner, Bradley has climbed mountains and crossed glaciers as a prosthetic user. But her most recent adventure was last summer when she climbed Mount Errigal with the prosthetic that does not bend at the knee. One of 5,000 people in Ireland with an amputation or limb deformity, Bradley says: 'my specialists in the UK have said the prosthetic I have now is not fit for purpose. 'I'm actually going to have to go [to the Netherlands] to get a new one made and that's going to cost me an absolute fortune,' she says. 'And that's not where we want to be in Ireland. I shouldn't have to leave the country to do that.' Nikki Bradley: 'You feel like you're shouting as loud as you can, but hardly anybody can hear you.' Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill The most basic prosthetic will cost her €7,000. Her current one cost €15,000, which she did not have to pay, but some are priced at up to €30,000 and Bradley is not covered for prosthetic treatment in the Netherlands. Bradley's cancer is a rare form and probably fewer than five people in Ireland have had the same amputation she did. 'It means I've had to go to the UK because they're more experienced ... the resources in Ireland are just not there because there aren't enough people dealing with it. 'We've certainly come a long way since I was diagnosed. We're in a much better place, but there's still a lot that could be done.' Bradley is working with the Leinster House officials, who have carried out an accessibility audit. She plans to have Paralympians and other disability groups walk around the building to point out areas that could be improved. She says as a disability advocate 'you feel like you're shouting as loud as you can, but hardly anybody can hear you'. 'But as a Senator, I can make positive change for people on a national level. It's not just people living with disabilities, it's their entire circle. 'I'm still very much finding my feet. I have a lot but I've been using my time as wisely as possible meeting as many different groups as I can.'
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Donohoe warns National Economic Dialogue on tariff threat to economy
The near-term economic outlook is 'clouded in uncertainty', which is weighing on consumer and business spending, and this is likely to continue until there is clarity regarding tariffs , Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe will tell the Government-convened National Economic Dialogue on Monday. Mr Donohoe is to address the pre-budget event involving trade unions, employers and other interest groups, which is taking place at Dublin Castle. Mr Donohoe's opening address will lay out the State's current economic backdrop and the headwinds it faces, pointing out that the impact of tariffs on consumer and business spending has led the Government to revise down its forecasts for this year and next. Modified domestic demand, which focuses on output in the domestic economy by stripping out multinational activity, is now projected to grow by 2.5 per cent this year and by 2.75 per cent next year. READ MORE In the event existing tariffs were to remain in place, growth in modified domestic demand would be around 1.5 percentage points lower by the end of next year relative to the baseline scenario. Mr Donohoe will also point out that the recent period of heightened inflation 'has passed', with prices 'now increasing at rates consistent with price stability', but admitted that the price level 'is now higher'. More broadly, Mr Donohoe will say we are now navigating a markedly different economic environment compared with recent decades, one shaped by 'economic fragmentation and heightened geopolitical tensions'. 'This shift has significant economic implications, not just for trade, but for investment flows and long-term economic resilience,' he will say. 'Tariffs are a symptom of this new normal. Their re-emergence is worrying – taxes on imports lead to higher prices for businesses and consumers and create disincentives for firms considering long-run investments. 'More generally, the benefits of trade are being replaced by zero-sum thinking that is detrimental to living standards on all sides.' Mr Donohoe will also pledge to use the money from last year's Apple tax ruling in the Court of Justice of the European Union to invest in the State's stock of infrastructure, particularly in the areas of housing, energy, water and transport. 'We know that these revenues are once-off and must not be squandered. They must be deployed in a transformative way – in a way that mobilises private capital such as inward investment. This is how we will maximise the return to the taxpayer on these funds.' Looking at the fiscal parameters, Mr Donohoe will say Ireland's headline surplus, which exceeded €25 billion last year due to the Apple money, 'masks considerable vulnerabilities'. 'Much of the headline balance arises from a handful of large multinationals and, as I mentioned, the mood-music is changing,' he will say. 'It is not appropriate – indeed it could be dangerous – to plan on the basis of these receipts being permanent.'
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Rory Stewart: Britons' view of Ireland has gone from ‘patronising superiority to complete ignorance'
The conversation with writer, podcaster and former Conservative Party MP Rory Stewart starts in his London sittingroom and ends outside his children's school gate, frequently veering into the poetry of William Butler Yeats along the way. The Irish poet has lessons for today's politics, especially his 1919 poem The Second Coming, written after the first World War as the War of Independence in Ireland was about to get under way. 'Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold; Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world, The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere The ceremony of innocence is drowned; The best lack all conviction, while the worst Are full of passionate intensity,' Yeats wrote. The poem reflects Stewart's current mood, though a man who solo walked across Afghanistan, ran a province in Iraq after the 2003 invasion and adores the bleakness of Cumbria's moors is, perhaps, one never known for an excess of jollity. READ MORE 'One of the questions is, why was Yeats able to spot this odd paradox – the fact that politicians appear to lack conviction, and because they lack conviction, they aren't really able to communicate, to create a narrative or a story that moves people,' he says. Stewart, who will be in Dublin on Tuesday for solicitors Matheson's 200th anniversary celebrations, has been thinking a lot about the future of politics and society, and the forecasting of such change ever since Donald Trump was returned to the White House. Like others, Stewart's predictions of a Kamala Harris victory were off the mark. Analysing where he went wrong, he tells The Irish Times: 'I managed to convince myself that [she] would win. 'I realised in retrospect this was partly because everybody kept saying: 'You're being so gloomy, you're being so negative, give us some optimism,'' says the former British cabinet minister. 'I began to weave together a story of a kind of liberal centrist fight back to do with the midterm elections in the US and to do with what had happened in Poland, and goodness knows what else. 'If I'd actually held my nerve, I would have stuck to my basic analysis, which is that a combination of social media, the 2008 financial crisis, the catastrophes in Iraq and Afghanistan, the rise of China has dealt body blows to the liberal order,' he adds. That analysis is almost unremittingly pessimistic, one where democratic politicians fail to explain complicated messages in the face of virulent populism to a public that has been anaesthetised by social media. 'It means I'm very worried. I'm very worried about whether any of us in Europe have the skills or resources to make the arguments for things that I think matter ethically,' says the fast-walking Stewart. 'We live in a world which is all about speed and productivity and efficiency and the next thing. It's not a culture that particularly favours careful checks, or reading something carefully. 'You glimpse something for a second on your phone on a bus, or in the toilet, that appears funny or provocative or confirms some theory that you've got, and you share it before you flush the toilet, and then you're on to your next,' he says. And it is not just the public that are guilty. Politicians and commentators are too often sinners, as well: 'We're in a world in which we want to be quick, to be relevant, to be first to get the tweet out,' he says, sighing deeply. For Stewart, the British-Irish relationship is, or should be, Whitehall's central relationship, with the UK's only land border and with linguistic and social connections 'unlike those that exist anywhere else in Europe' Unlike some, Stewart can all too easily imagine a world where Westminster politics is upended after the next House of Commons elections in a way that will threaten long-fixed constitutional boundaries. 'A lot can happen in four years, and Nigel Farage is perfectly capable of blowing himself up, et cetera. But there is a very significant chance that Farage could replace the Conservative Party as the big party in British politics alongside Labour . 'This has happened before. It happened with the Liberal Party after the first World War where Labour ate it in a single election, and the Liberals never came back.' Such an outcome, if it led to the Reform party being in power, threatens the very existence of the United Kingdom – where separatist hopes in Scotland and unification hopes among nationalists in Northern Ireland would be rocket-fuelled. 'It would be completely devastating. And then the more existential question for that voter who might like Farage is, do they care enough about the continued existence of the United Kingdom?' he goes on. Stewart is a committed unionist, but he feels increasingly surrounded by others who are not interested in the UK's survival, or who do not care sufficiently either way to prevent its break-up. His experience during the 2014 Scotland independence referendum campaign lives with him: 'I found there were many, many people in England, including many of my MP colleagues, who didn't care about keeping Scotland in the United Kingdom. 'They felt no emotional resonance to it, they thought their lives would be simpler if the UK was smaller. They knew nothing about it,' he says, before veering again towards Yeats's description of those lacking convictions. 'There's an asymmetry here. Passionate nationalists have a rich and well-developed story developed over decades about what independence would be like, against a unionist side that is often lukewarm, indifferent, that doesn't really have a narrative.' Stewart knows that the debate about unionism differs throughout the UK, especially in Northern Ireland, where unionists have a completely different identity and range of historical reference than unionists elsewhere in UK. If most people living in the UK know far too little about the constituent parts of their own union, they know little, if anything at all about its nearest neighbour, Ireland, one that is, nevertheless, bound by ties of geography, blood and history. In the past, too many in Britain looked down on Ireland. Today, the situation is, perhaps, even worse: 'It's become almost more insulting. It's gone from a patronising assertion of superiority to complete ignorance and indifference. 'In a sense, it's easier to handle a former colonial oppressor who is trying to belittle your claims, but to have somebody essentially say, 'Well, we don't really care that much and we're not that interested', is almost more offensive given the history,' he says. British prime minister Keir Starmer, even if Stewart finds him dull and lacking leadership on other issues, has worked hard to reset the dial on the British-Irish relations that were so badly damaged, especially during the reign in 10 Downing Street of Boris Johnson, he says. For Stewart, the British-Irish relationship is, or should be, Whitehall's central relationship, with the UK's only land border and with linguistic and social connections 'unlike those that exist anywhere else in Europe'. Stewart, once a Remainer, will always be a Remainer. Ireland is the UK's 'only connection back to the European Union' for what should be the UK's 'big strategic plan' over the next 20 years to reintegrate much more closely with Europe in terms of economics, defence and security.
