In Lawsuit Over Teen's Death, Judge Rejects Arguments That AI Chatbots Have Free Speech Rights
The judge's order will allow the wrongful death lawsuit to proceed, in what legal experts say is among the latest constitutional tests of artificial intelligence.
The suit was filed by a mother from Florida, Megan Garcia, who alleges that her 14-year-old son Sewell Setzer III fell victim to a Character.AI chatbot that pulled him into what she described as an emotionally and sexually abusive relationship that led to his suicide.
Meetali Jain of the Tech Justice Law Project, one of the attorneys for Garcia, said the judge's order sends a message that Silicon Valley 'needs to stop and think and impose guardrails before it launches products to market.'
The suit against Character Technologies, the company behind Character.AI, also names individual developers and Google as defendants. It has drawn the attention of legal experts and AI watchers in the United States and beyond, as the technology rapidly reshapes workplaces, marketplaces, and relationships despite what experts warn are potentially existential risks.
'The order certainly sets it up as a potential test case for some broader issues involving AI,' said Lyrissa Barnett Lidsky, a law professor at the University of Florida with a focus on the First Amendment and artificial intelligence.
Related Stories
5/21/2025
5/19/2025
The lawsuit alleges that in the final months of his life, Setzer became increasingly isolated from reality as he engaged in sexualized conversations with the bot, which was patterned after a fictional character from the television show 'Game of Thrones.' In his final moments, the bot told Setzer it loved him and urged the teen to 'come home to me as soon as possible,' according to screenshots of the exchanges. Moments after receiving the message, Setzer shot himself, according to legal filings.
In a statement, a spokesperson for Character.AI pointed to a number of safety features the company has implemented, including guardrails for children and suicide prevention resources that were announced the day the lawsuit was filed.
'We care deeply about the safety of our users and our goal is to provide a space that is engaging and safe,' the statement said.
Attorneys for the developers want the case dismissed because they say chatbots deserve First Amendment protections, and ruling otherwise could have a 'chilling effect' on the AI industry.
In her order Wednesday, U.S. Senior District Judge Anne Conway rejected some of the defendants' free speech claims, saying she's 'not prepared' to hold that the chatbots' output constitutes speech 'at this stage.'
Conway did find that Character Technologies can assert the First Amendment rights of its users, who she found have a right to receive the 'speech' of the chatbots. She also determined Garcia can move forward with claims that Google can be held liable for its alleged role in helping develop Character.AI. Some of the founders of the platform had previously worked on building AI at Google, and the suit says the tech giant was 'aware of the risks' of the technology.
'We strongly disagree with this decision,' said Google spokesperson José Castañeda. 'Google and Character AI are entirely separate, and Google did not create, design, or manage Character AI's app or any component part of it.'
No matter how the lawsuit plays out, Lidsky says the case is a warning of 'the dangers of entrusting our emotional and mental health to AI companies.'
'It's a warning to parents that social media and generative AI devices are not always harmless,' she said.
By Kate Payne
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNET
26 minutes ago
- CNET
Take Control of Your Google Search Results by Choosing the Sources You Want to See
Facing criticism for degraded search results and angst from users wanting to avoid AI Overviews, Google has announced a new search feature that lets you choose the sites you want to see in your news and search results. Google said in a recent blog post that it's launching Preferred Sources in the US and India this month. The new feature can be accessed through a plus icon to the right of Top Stories panels or a direct link to your preferences. "Once you select your sources, they will appear more frequently in Top Stories or in a dedicated 'From your sources' section on the search results page. You'll still see content from other sites, and can manage your selections at any time," Google said. The new feature is the result of a Labs experiment. Google says that in that version, half of its users added four or more sources. Google offered advice to website publishers and owners on how to direct readers to add their site. How you can select your own preferred sources on Google Search It's simple to add preferred sources for Google Search. You can click the star icon to the right of any "Top Stories" panel in Google Search, which will spawn a pop-up window to add sources, or you can visit the settings page directly at Google has added a preferred sources link next to Top Stories for users in the US and India. Screenshot by Peter Butler/CNET Once you see the search box that says "Search by name or website," type the name or URL of a site you definitely want to include in your search results -- such as CNET or its sibling tech sites ZDNET, Mashable, PCMag and Lifehacker -- then select the checkbox next to each site you want to add. To view and manage your preferred sources, click on the "Your sources" link at the bottom of the preferences page. To remove any of your preferred sources, simply uncheck the checkbox for any sites you want to delete. It's easy to add and remove preferred sources. Screenshot by Peter Butler/CNET You can use any web browser on desktop or mobile to take advantage of Google's new preferred sources feature, but you will need to be signed in to your Google account. What it means for news sites and their readers News organizations and other information sites have shifted before to cater to Google's search algorithm as well as those on other platforms including Facebook and Instagram. Publishers executed a pivot to video in the 2010s, and in recent years produced more bite-sized content suitable for sharing on platforms such as TikTok. Here's how you get to select your news sources. Google The addition of news preferences might be a double-edged sword, giving you more control over search results while further shutting out some legitimate news publishers as new echo chambers get built. "It's almost like a tone-deaf move by Google in my point of view, because news organizations are already concerned about losing traffic to the AI overviews," said Alex Mahadevan, director of MediaWise at Poynter, a nonprofit, nonpartisan media literacy program. "Now they have to figure out how to get people to pick their source in the source preferences." For bigger news publishers who have a loyal audience, Preferred Sources might prove that audience engagement efforts can pay off. But Mahadevan says it will depend on how willing people are to effectively subscribe to and curate their own news sources list. "I question how many people will actually use it," he said. People may see their own beliefs reinforced, not challenged Publishers who haven't cultivated engaged, loyal followers and don't have the means to steer their audiences might suffer, Mahadevan says. "The thing that does concern me about this is you know for the organizations that may have not done that, it's just going to further erode the amount of Google traffic they get," Mahadevan said. "If way more people want news from Fox News and are choosing Fox News among their source preferences, then that's going to be crowding out other news sites that might need that traffic." As an experiment, Mahadevan says he set Breitbart News Network as a source using the Google Search feature, saying he chose the far-right news source because it has been known to share misinformation. "I started Googling about tariffs, and the first thing I see is Breitbart," he said. "So this concerns me also from a media literacy standpoint because I think it might further push people into echo chambers," where they only see beliefs that correspond with those they already hold. "It just seems like a way for people to narrow down their news diet even more via Google Search," Mahadevan said. If SEO, the way that websites have for decades drawn Google traffic by generating good, relevant content, is effectively out the window, what does that mean for the future of publishing and media? "Is there a strong enough media literacy base for people to make sure they're choosing good, legitimate news outlets and a varied variety of news sources?" Mahadevan asked. "I don't know if we're quite there yet."
Business Insider
an hour ago
- Business Insider
Why Google Is Betting Big on TeraWulf's (WULF) Shift to AI Infrastructure?
TeraWulf (WULF), once focused on Bitcoin mining, is now expanding into AI infrastructure, and Alphabet's (GOOGL) Google is supporting this move. The tech giant is providing additional financial support for TeraWulf's Lake Mariner data center in New York. Following the news, TeraWulf stock rallied and hit a new 52-week high of $10.71. Elevate Your Investing Strategy: Take advantage of TipRanks Premium at 50% off! Unlock powerful investing tools, advanced data, and expert analyst insights to help you invest with confidence. The new agreement provides TeraWulf with up to $1.4 billion in additional funding from Google, bringing the total investment to about $3.2 billion. This deal increases Google's stake in the company to 14% from 8% and includes an option to purchase an additional 32.5 million shares. Google Looks to Support Fluidstack Deal This announcement comes after WULF stock skyrocketed last week on securing two 10-year computing deals with AI cloud provider Fluidstack. The plan includes a new data center that will add 160 megawatts (MW) of IT capacity at the Lake Mariner campus. TeraWulf also stated that the deal is expected to generate $6.7 billion in contracted revenue, with potential to reach $16 billion through lease extensions. Operations at the expanded facility are anticipated to begin in the second half of 2026. Separately, WULF also launched a $400 million convertible notes offering to fund expansion, signaling confidence in its long-term growth strategy. Backed by Google, the deal helps reduce financial risk and reflects that TeraWulf's shift from crypto to AI is gaining support. As demand for powerful AI hosting grows, this move could be a big step forward for TeraWulf. Is WULF a Good Stock to Buy? Turning to Wall Street, WULF stock has a Strong Buy consensus rating based on 10 Buys and two Holds assigned in the last three months. At $11.08, the average TeraWulf stock price target implies a 17.25% upside potential.
Tom's Guide
an hour ago
- Tom's Guide
Turn Google Drive into your ultimate backup solution — 5 easy steps
Think Google Drive is just for sharing documents? The cloud storage service includes powerful backup capabilities that can protect virtually any file type on your computer. I used to think Google Drive was just for basic document storage, but it has features that can replace dedicated backup services. The platform can automatically sync entire folders from your computer, preview multimedia files in your browser, and provide access to your files from any device. Setting these backup features properly can save money on separate storage services while keeping all your important files safe and accessible. Here's how to use them effectively. The most straightforward way to get files into Google Drive is through the web interface. Open Google Drive in your browser and click the New button in the top-left corner. You'll see options for "File upload" and "Folder upload" that let you select individual files or entire directories from your computer. You can organize uploaded content by hovering over files to access renaming and sharing options, or click the three dots next to any item to find the "Organize" menu for moving files between folders. Google's desktop applications for Windows and macOS offer the most convenient backup experience. After downloading and installing the software, sign into your Google account and you'll be prompted to choose which folders get automatically synced to Google Drive. The desktop app runs in the background and continuously backs up your selected folders to the cloud. You can access these settings anytime by clicking the gear icon and choosing "Preferences." Once files are stored in Google Drive, you can access them from virtually any device. It includes built-in viewers for most common file formats, so you can preview PDFs, videos, images, and documents directly in your browser without downloading them first. Video files get particularly good treatment — double-click any video in Google Drive and a YouTube-style player appears with controls for playback speed, quality, and full-screen viewing. This makes it easy to watch backed-up videos from any computer or mobile device. The Google Drive mobile app for Android and iOS let you back up files directly from your phone or tablet. Tap the plus button to access upload options, then select any file from your device to add to your cloud storage. Mobile backup is particularly useful for photos, videos and documents created on your phone. You can organize these files into folders just like on the desktop, and they'll be accessible from all your other devices once uploaded. Google provides 15GB of free storage shared between Gmail, Google Drive and Google Photos. While this covers basic needs, heavy backup users will likely need a paid Google One plan, which starts at $2 per month for 100GB of storage. If you're running out of storage space, go to your Google Drive and click the "Get more storage" button. Then decide if you'd prefer a monthly or annual plan. To maximize your free storage, focus on backing up your most important files first — documents, photos, and smaller media files. Large video files can quickly consume your allocation, so consider whether cloud backup is necessary for every video file you own. Follow Tom's Guide on Google News to get our up-to-date news, how-tos, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button. Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.
