NYPD wants massive overtime pay back after Jeffrey Maddrey sex scandal
The NYPD is trying to claw back more than $200,000 in overtime paid to the female lieutenant who alleged the OT cash was used by disgraced ex-Chief of Department Jeffrey Maddrey to coerce her to perform sexual acts, The Post has learned.
Lt. Quathisha Epps, a 19-year-vet who retired in December after The Post uncovered the scandal, was the department's highest paid cop last year.
'She was paid for work she did not do,' a police source said. 'She has received notice that she owes this money.'
Advertisement
4 Former NYPD Chief Jeffrey Maddrey, who was the NYPD's No. 1 uniformed cop, abruptly resigned after The Post reported that he allegedly used overtime to 'coerce' an underling to perform sexual favors.
Brigitte Stelzer
Epps called the NYPD demand that she pay back $231,890.75 retaliation for her blowing the whistle on the department's No. 2 cop.
'I will not be silenced,' she said. 'This isn't just my fight — it's the fight of every woman who dared to speak up and was punished for it. If the department — or anyone – believes they can erase what happened by attacking me, they've gravely underestimated the power of truth.'
Advertisement
The demand was a result of an NYPD investigation into the overtime and involved Epps' direct supervisor, former Deputy Chief Paul Saraceno, who was fired last month, sources said. Saraceno was Maddrey's second in command and allegedly signed off on Epps' overtime retroactively, the sources said.
Epps' lawyer, Eric Sanders, said the letter Epps received from the NYPD included no evidence that she didn't work the hours she claimed to work.
4 NYPD top earner, ex-Lieutenant Quathisha Epps, filed a federal EEOC complaint against Maddrey.
NYPD
'The overtime issue is a red herring—manufactured to distract from the real legal and moral crisis inside the NYPD,' Sanders said. 'Under New York labor law, the burden is on the employer to maintain accurate records, not the employee.'
Advertisement
The Post revealed in November that Epps pulled in $403,515 in fiscal year 2024, including $204,453.48 in overtime pay on top of her base salary of $164,477, according to city payroll records.
4 Epps told The Post she had sex with Maddrey in his office multiple times and asked him to stop during their first encounter.
LP Media
On Dec. 20, Epps, who was an administrator in Maddrey's office at One Police Plaza, told The Post that the chief paid her the dough to 'coerce' her to have sex with him in his office at NYPD headquarters.
Sanders, a former cop, filed a federal Equal Employment Opportunity complaint against Maddrey on Epps' behalf the next day.
Advertisement
Maddrey resigned the day The Post story went online Dec. 21. A week later, he held a press conference in Manhattan where his lawyer told reporters that the relationship with Epps was consensual. He also accused Epps of going after his client because of the investigtion into her overtime. Maddrey didn't take questions.
While the NYPD goes after Epps, Maddrey is expected to pull down an annual pension worth around $259,000. When Epps reaches her 20th anniversary this summer, she will receive a pension of less than half the pay of a lieutenant — under $50,000, police sources said. She will also miss out on the variable supplement of about $12,000 per year.
4 Deputy Chief Paul Saraceno was fired by the NYPD over allegations that he approved bogus overtime slips.
50-a.org
In the wake of the scandal, Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch made department-wide changes, including replacing the head of the storied Internal Affairs Bureau and transferring officials at Police HQ to other precincts and divisions.
Maddrey's home was raided on Jan. 2 by agents with the U.S. Department of Justice, which opened an investigation after news of the imbroglio broke. The Manhattan District Attorneys Office also said it was launching a probe but later said it dropped the case. The DOJ has refused to comment on the status of its review.
One retired NYPD officer who worked with sex assault victims said the NYPD demand for repayment from an alleged victim is misguided — especially since her accused harrasser, Maddrey, was allowed to retire with a full pension.
'If you listen to her, she says she asked him to stop when he had sex with her in his office,' the ex-officer said. 'She's asserting criminal misconduct.'
Advertisement
The NYPD did not return a request for comment.
Additional reporting by Larry Celona.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
34 minutes ago
- New York Post
Crypto ‘kidnap' mystery deepens as sources say alleged victim's parents ‘received texts' and didn't know anything was wrong
The parents of the man allegedly held captive and tortured by crypto bros in Manhattan got regular updates saying he was OK, The Post has learned. Italian national Michael Valentino Teofrasto Carturan, 28, was allegedly held from May 6 to 23 in a luxury apartment on Prince Street for by John Woeltz and William Duplessie, who stand charged with tying up Carturan and torturing him for his digital wallet containing an estimated $28m in digital currency, according to cops. However, sources in Italy say through the apparent kidnap 'Michael's phone and his parents exchanged messages on WhatsApp,' although sources pointed out it was possible the alleged kidnappers had been sending the messages so as not to raise the alarm. 7 Michael Valentino Teofrasto Carturan, with face blurred, in security footage taken after he escpaed the apartment where he was allegedly held captive for 17 days, with the police officer whom he alerted to his plight. WNBC 7 Prosecutors say Carturan had been tortured and held aginst his will for his crypto password and wallet, worth approximately $28m WNBC Carturan's reclusive parents, Maurizio and Lidia, only learned of the kidnap on May 25 when a family friend, Pietro Zucchetti, informed them, according to sources. However, the family were seemingly on high alert and had recently hired private security, according to a source, who also said they had put their $1m home in Rivoli, near Turin, up for sale. New York prosecutors have also said they believe the lives of Carturan's family in Italy had been threatened during the kidnapping period. Maurizio confirmed to Italian newspaper La Repubblica he had recieved texts he assumed were from his son through the 'kidnap' period. A neighbor told The Post Carturan has recently started travelling around the world a lot, although they said they had no idea what line of business he was in. Carturan had previously worked on Zucchetti's farm, and he described him as a 'curious young man, not one to seek out trouble.' 7 The Carturan family home in in Rivoli, near Turin, which they are said to have put up for sale for $1m. 7 Carturan's reclusive, parents, Maurizio and Lidia, in the herbalist shop they own. After hearing of their son's kidnap they flew to the US and met with him and cobsulate officials. L'Erbatisana/ YouTube 7 The cover of one of Maurizio Carturan's books. He mainly covers topics related to alchemy and spirituality and also speaks at conferences, according to sources. Videos which show Carturan seemingly partaking in parties at the house and talking about drugs were published this week by TMZ, although in some videos he appears to be restrained to a wheelchair or led by a leash around his neck. Reports also say he was monitored with an Apple AirTag around his neck to ensure he didn't leave the house. No missing person report was filed by Carturan's family, who were shocked when they found out what had happened to him and immediately went to ground. They declined approaches for comment from The Post. Carturan's father Maurizio – an author who has written 10 books about alchemy and spirituality – deleted all of his social media accounts and closed the family's shop selling herbal remedies. The parents then traveled to New York, where they met with the Italian Consul General in New York. His deputy took them to see Carturan at the local District Attorney's Office, the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs told The Post. The Italian Consul General said it is working with US authorities in the case and assisting them in matters of the Carturan family. 7 Suspect John Woeltz being escorted by Police in Manhattan after his arrest. David Burns 7 William Duplessie being escorted by two NYPD officers after surrendering in the crypto kidnapping case. He is currently being held without bail, but his lawyer claims the case against him will 'unravel'. Steven Hirsch Carturan escaped from the alleged ordeal on May 23 and flagged down a nearby traffic cop. He was taken to hospital, where he was treated for injuries sustained from allegedly being pistol-whipped, dangled from the top of a staircase, urinated on and having his arms and legs cut with a chainsaw. Woeltz was arrested the same day, Duplessie a few days later. Woeltz, dubbed the Crypto King of Kentucky, is said to have a private jet and live a high octane party lifestyle alongside Duplessie. They are both held in custody on charges including kidnapping, unlawful imprisonment, assault and weapons possession. At Duplessie's arraignment last week his lawyer claimed the criminal case will 'begin to unravel' as more details come out. 'The facts here are hotly disputed, his involvement is hotly disputed,' attorney Sanford Talkin told the judge during the hearing.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
ACS and babysitting contractor to be investigated following Post story on alleged child abuse
The Administration for Children's Services and a longtime city contractor will be investigated by the city's independent watchdog after a city-funded babysitter was allegedly caught on camera beating a pair of young children nearly 60 times with a belt, The Post has learned. ACS and contractor Selfhelp will be probed by the Department of Investigation just days after The Post reported on how the agency twice failed a single mom and domestic violence survivor. The story 'raises serious concerns about the vetting practices of this ACS-contracted vendor, among other issues,' a DOI spokesperson said, adding that they plan to undertake an investigation. Advertisement Nearly $400 million in city contracts have been awarded to the vendor, Selfhelp, since 2008 according to records. Bronx mother Geraldine Jaramillo says her ACS-funded babysitter, 24-year-old La'keysha Jackson, was allegedly caught on video beating two of her young children, 4 and 6, nearly 60 times inside the family's Morrisania building on May 6, according to the family and a filed legal notice. 8 A shocked family says that babysitter La'keysha Jackson – paid for by a city program – was discovered regularly beating three kids under 6-year-old, according to video footage. Courtesy Daniel Szalkiewicz Advertisement City officials appear to still have no clue where Jackson is — nearly a month after Jaramillo shared graphic footage with police of the alleged abuse. 8 Jaramillo told The Post that Jackson, pictured, was the second sitter sent to the family after the first from the same ACS-contracted agency was discovered drinking and smoking at a playground while watching the kids. Facebook / Lakeysha Jackson Jackson was the second sitter sent to the family after the first Selfhelp employee was discovered boozing and smoking at a playground while watching the kids, according to the legal filing. DOI spokesperson Dian Struzzi told The Post that 'while DOI intends to conduct an investigation,' their access to caregiver records and involvement with children 'may be precluded by State law,' an issue thoroughly laid out by Commissioner Jocelyn Strauber in an opinion essay published last week. Advertisement 'These access limitations can thwart our investigations,' Struzzi said. 8 A still from a graphic video showing Jackson beating the two young children a total of 58 times. Courtesy Daniel Szalkiewicz 8 Jackson also allegedly donned grotesque costumes to frighten the children while the single mom was at work. Courtesy Daniel Szalkiewicz 'The safety and well-being of New York City's children is our top priority,' said ACS spokesperson Marisa Kaufman, 'and we are investigating these despicable actions.' The state Office of Children and Family Services, the office that regulates ACS, and city hall officials did not respond to questions prior to publication. Advertisement Questions remain as to why Jackson wasn't apprehended immediately, with police only commenting that she remains at large, despite having the graphic five-minute-long video for nearly a month. 8 'We called the police and filed the report and we went to the hospital,' Jaramillo told The Post. 'They promised to arrest her and it's been three — almost four — weeks and nothing has happened yet.' Stephen Yang A neighbor near Jackson's listed address told The Post this week that they hadn't seen her in about a week, but her family had been living there for years. 'I'm just telling you from the bottom of my heart — very surprising video,' the neighbor told a reporter from The Post. 'The girl is very sweet. All she does is religion, school, work, and that's it — it's a very surprising video.' The longtime neighbor also doubts that Jackson donned the horrifying demonic Santa outfit, claiming 'that's not how her body is built,' and 'they don't celebrate Christmas.' 8 The Nest camera that captured the May 6 beating, plus many others later found on its storage, the family said. Stephen Yang Jackson was fired after Selfhelp learned of the video, according to the nonprofit, who said they are cooperating with investigations by ACS and the NYPD. Since 2008, Selfhelp has been awarded $393.2 million in city contracts, with $83 million in active contracts, the comptroller's office said. Advertisement Their relationship with ACS stretches back to 2009, with a total of $92.2 million in contracts for Homemaker services — the same service utilized by Jarmillo — records show, with an active contract for $19.3 million that runs until Dec. 2026. 8 The contractor who employed the babysitter, Selfhelp, has a long relationship with ACS beginning in 2009, with a total of $92.2 million in contracts for Homemaker services. William Farrington Selfhelp was founded in 1936 to aid refugees from Nazi Germany, their website states. Around 5,000 Holocaust survivors are still receiving services from them in 2024. The non-profit has $250 million in assets, a 2024 audited financial statement states, and serves over 26,000 seniors. Advertisement CEO Stuart Kaplan earned $1.1 million in annual compensation in 2022, according to their most recent tax filing. 8 La'keysha Jackson was considered a member of the family for the year she worked with them through a taxpayer-funded program. Courtesy Daniel Szalkiewicz
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Taxi driver, 68, robbed at knifepoint in LIC: NYPD
LONG ISLAND CITY, Queens (PIX11) — A woman is accused of robbing a 68-year-old taxi driver at knifepoint after hopping into the cab in Queens last month, police said Thursday. The suspect allegedly pulled a knife on the taxi driver before punching him and stealing his cash in front of 23-10 41st Ave. in Long Island City on May 4, according to the NYPD. The woman then fled and was last seen running westbound on 41st Avenue, police said. There have been no arrests. Submit tips to police by calling Crime Stoppers at 1-800-577-TIPS (8477), visiting downloading the NYPD Crime Stoppers mobile app, or texting 274637 (CRIMES) then entering TIP577. Spanish-speaking callers are asked to dial 1-888-57-PISTA (74782). Mira Wassef is a digital reporter who has covered news and sports in the NYC area for more than a decade. She has been with PIX11 News for two years. See more of her work here. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
