Hong Kong court challenges Jimmy Lai's rights claims in national security trial
national security trial have expressed reservations about the defence characterising the former media boss's alleged endeavours to trigger Western sanctions and foster hatred towards authorities as a legitimate exercise of fundamental rights.
The 77-year-old Apple Daily tabloid founder's legal team on Wednesday started presenting its closing arguments at West Kowloon Court after the prosecution made their final remarks in his case of conspiracies to print seditious publications and collude with foreign forces.
Senior counsel Robert Pang Yiu-hung opened his speech by hitting out at what he saw as prosecutors' attempt to 'denigrate' human rights and dismiss it as 'an alien concept'.
'You can't force someone to think in one way or another,' the lawyer said. 'Nor is it wrong to hope that the government would change its policies, whether through its own internal review or through suggestion or even pressure, whether from inside Hong Kong or out.'
Madam Justice Esther Toh Lye-ping, one of three presiding High Court judges, said the charges were not as simple as that.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
3 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Widow of Hong Kong repairman who died after working 59 hours plans legal action
The widow of a lift repairman who died last year after working for 59 hours straight is planning to take legal action against her late husband's employer, as an advocacy group raised concerns about the city's lack of laws protecting against overwork. Advertisement The widow, who only wished to be identified as Mrs Chan, said on Wednesday that her late husband, Chan Ka-yee, had worked for Sigma Elevator for more than 25 years before he died in July last year at the age of 59. 'He left for work at around 7am on July 6 [last year] and did not return until almost 9pm,' she recalled, adding that he had only spent a few hours at home before he was called back to work. 'I had prepared dinner and we ate together and chatted casually at the table … I never imagined we would be at the hospital the next time we saw each other,' she said. The widow added that the couple had conflicting work hours, meaning she was unable to see her late husband in the days before his collapse. Advertisement On July 9, 2024, Chan Ka-yee collapsed at a worksite while helping a colleague. He was pronounced dead at around 7pm that day.
HKFP
4 hours ago
- HKFP
Tycoon Jimmy Lai did not ask activists to halt sanctions push after nat. sec law enacted, prosecutor says
Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai did not ask activists and foreign politicians to stop calling for sanctions even after Beijing's national security law in the city was passed, a prosecutor has said. Continuing to deliver closing arguments in Lai's national security trial, lead prosecutor Anthony Chau accused the founder of pro-democracy tabloid Apple Daily of being the 'mastermind' in an alleged foreign collusion plot against the city's authorities. The prosecution said Lai himself admitted his commitment to lobbying for sanctions was 'unwavering,' even if he risked breaking the national security law by doing so. Beijing inserted national security legislation directly into Hong Kong's mini-constitution in June 2020 following a year of pro-democracy protests and unrest, criminalising subversion, secession, collusion with foreign forces and terrorist acts – broadly defined to include disruption to transport and other infrastructure. The tycoon stands accused of two charges of conspiring to commit foreign collusion under the Beijing-imposed security law, and another charge of conspiring to publish seditious materials under colonial-era legislation. He faces life behind bars if convicted. Collaborators Chau on Wednesday said that even after Beijing's national security law in the city was passed, Lai did not stop his alleged collaborators, including members of the overseas activist group Stand With Hong Kong (SWHK), and the foreign politicians group the Interparliamentary Alliance on China (IPAC), from continuing to lobby for sanctions. The prosecution cited open letters, articles, and social media posts from SWHK calling on foreign governments, including those of the UK, the Czech Republic, Ireland, and Portugal, to impose sanctions on Hong Kong and Beijing officials, and urging support for the 'people of Hong Kong.' A focal point of Lai's trial was his ties to two activists linked to SWHK, Chan Tsz-wah, or Wayland, and Andy Li, both of whom were charged alongside the tycoon and have testified against him. Citing Chan's testimony, Chau also said that Lai had 'never' told the activist there was any change in his stance on lobbying for sanctions, even after the enactment of the law. Chau also pointed to a meeting weeks before the national security law was enacted in which Lai encouraged Chan to press on with lobbying efforts, saying the security legislation was 'more bark than bite.' Lobbying groups SWHK and IPAC, indeed, continued their efforts after the national security law took effect, the court heard. 'Lai knew exactly what IPAC was doing at the time,' Chau said, citing updates that Lai received about the international parliamentary group in the weeks after the law was enacted, as well as the tycoon's own social media activity. The prosecution also argued that Lai maintained ties with retired US army general Jack Keane, ex-US deputy secretary of defence Paul Wolfowitz, and US state department advisor Christian Whiton after the security law came into effect. Lai had admitted trying to inform foreign governments about Hong Kong's situation and appealing to them to condemn the city's authorities, Chau said. But he also argued that Lai went further than what he admitted. The tycoon sought to demonstrate to Hongkongers, through meetings with the former US officials, that 'foreign governments had not abandoned them,' Chau said. Chau also said that the Apple Daily founder used the paper as a platform to urge sanctions on Beijing, a clear betrayal of national interests and security. He added that Lai's description of the paper as both 'anti-communist' and a 'neutral defender of Hong Kong's core values' were conflicting.
South China Morning Post
5 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Trump tariffs spark India-China reset, Chinese city's biotech dream: SCMP daily highlights
Catch up on some of SCMP's biggest China stories of the day. If you would like to see more of our reporting, please consider subscribing The world's two most-populous countries made significant progress on the diplomatic front recently, and those championing such moves may have Washington to thank. South China's Guangdong province has announced its ambition to join the country's race to expand its commercial space sector, promising financial and policy support for companies wanting to build low-orbit satellite constellation systems and promote their application in futuristic industries including space mining and space tourism. Ilustration: Brian Wang Could a city best known for its classical gardens and ancient canals emerge as China's answer to Boston – the global epicentre of biotechnology innovation?
