Ireland's defence spending is labelled a 'bad joke'
Ireland's continuing low level of defence expenditure — stuck at 0.2% of GDP — has been described as a 'bad joke' just a day after EU partners in Nato agreed to boost their target spend from 2% to 3.5% of GDP.
The development comes as Tánaiste Simon Harris, minister for foreign affairs and defence, is on Friday expected to announce plans to join the EU's new security procurement mechanism to accelerate the acquisition of defence equipment.
Ireland is not yet joining the loan part of the mechanism — with a total fund of up to €150bn available — but the Government is expected to consider this in the coming weeks, with Mr Harris believed to be keen to explore the prospect.
Figures provided to the Irish Examiner by the Department of Defence show defence expenditure was 0.2% of GDP in 2024. It has remained at that rate since 2021, and is slightly lower than 2020 (0.3%).
Gross National Income (GNI) is considered a more accurate estimate of national wealth than GDP in Ireland, as it excludes global profits of international companies sent to Ireland for tax purposes.
The department figures show Ireland's defence spend is 0.4% of GNI (twice as much as GDP), with the latest figure for 2023. It is the same rate as 2022, and slightly lower than previous years (0.5%).
The estimates are despite increased defence budgets since the report of the Commission on Defence Forces in February 2022.
This followed the Government's adoption of the commission's 'Level of Ambition 2' (LOA2) investment. This involves increasing the budget from €1.1bn in 2022 to €1.5bn, in 2022 prices, by 2028.
The Irish Examiner reported last February that Ireland had the lowest defence spend of 38 European countries in 2024 — by far the lowest based on GDP, and joint lowest with fellow neutral Malta based on GNI. Our GNI-based spend was more than half that of another EU neutral state, Austria.
The Department of Defence said the international comparison of military expenditure was 'made difficult' by the lack of publicly available data and the differences between nations' defence policies. As such, it said international perspective is 'best used for context rather than comparison' between militaries.
Responding to the department figures, the association representing officers in the Defence Forces said the department "continually refers to the 'record allocation' in the defence budget'.
Lieutenant Colonel Conor King, general secretary of Raco, said: 'With Ireland still far below the levels of investment of comparator EU countries, despite the increasingly unstable global security environment, and with the personnel levels so low, how can we be satisfied that this level of spend remotely addresses Ireland's needs to defend our citizens? If we're honest, we can't.'
He added: 'Look at the Nato commitment to 5% ([3.5% on national defence and 1.5% on critical national infrastructure and resilience]. Now look at us at 0.2% of GDP or 0.4% of GNI. We are so far away from reality it's like a bad joke. And many of those countries are our EU partners so it's not just a 'Nato thing'.'
The Raco general secretary said the capabilities of the Defence Forces was in a very poor state: 'With our naval service unable to put to sea, our air corps grounded after dark, and huge difficulties in staffing overseas, not to mention our technician strengths below 50% in most areas, which capabilities are we delivering on fully? And at what cost?'
The Tánaiste is expected on Friday to sign up to the EU Security Action for Europe (SAFE) in a bid to speed up, possibly by two years, the acquisition of key defence capabilities, such as: ammunition; artillery systems; critical infrastructure protection; air defence systems and maritime capabilities.
Mr Harris is focusing of using SAFE to address gaps in specific equipment, particularly through joint acquisitions with other member states.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
EU leaders agree to extend Russian sanctions
The EU's 27 leaders have agreed to extend sanctions on Russia for another six months, resolving fears that Kremlin-friendly Hungary would let the measures lapse, officials said. The decision at a summit in Brussels yesterday means that the EU's sweeping sanctions over the war in Ukraine, including the freezing of more than €200 billion in Russian central bank assets, will remain in force until at least early 2026. It comes after officials said they were preparing contingency plans to keep the bloc's economic punishments on Moscow in place should Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán refuse to budge. EU counterparts had feared a refusal by Hungary to renew the measures could impede the leverage the bloc holds over Russia as the United States presses peace efforts. Mr Orbán took the decision to the wire the last time the sanctions, which need to be extended every six months, came up for renewal in January. But while the EU made sure its existing measures will remain in place, it failed to get clearance on a new package of sanctions due to a blockage by Hungary's ally Slovakia. At the summit, Slovakia's Prime Minister Roberto Fico refused to greenlight the new round of sanctions due to a separate dispute with Brussels over plans to cut off imports of Russian gas by the end of 2027. Slovakia remains dependent on Russian gas imports and earns money from transit fees for supplies piped across its territory. Mr Fico held talks with EU chief Ursula von der Leyen yesterday but failed to get the concessions that he wants and announced he would hold approval of the sanctions package. Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky urged EU leaders in a video address to adopt the strong package "targeting Russia's oil trade, shadow tanker fleet, banks and supply chains that bring equipment or parts for making weapons". Officials say, however, that a push to lower a price cap on Russian oil exports has been shelved after the United States failed to back the push as part of a broader G7 initiative. Trade talks Meanwhile Ms von der Leyen did not rule out that tariff talks with the United States could fail, saying "all options remain on the table" as the EU leaders discussed new proposals from Washington on a trade deal. Time could be running out for the bloc to find a common position before a respite on higher tariffs threatened by US President Donald Trump expires on 9 July, which will impact exporters from cars to pharmaceuticals. However, the White House said Mr Trump could extend a July deadline for higher tariffs on imports. Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters the "deadline is not critical". European leaders were meeting to decide whether they want to push for a quick trade agreement or keep fighting for a better deal, with the EU's two biggest economies apparently at odds. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz urged the EU to do a "quick and simple" trade deal rather than a "slow and complicated" one. But in a separate briefing, French President Emmanuel Macron, while also wanting a quick and pragmatic trade deal, said his country would not accept terms that were not balanced. All tools must be used to ensure a fair deal and if the US baseline rate of 10% remained in place, then Europe's response would have to have an equivalent impact, he said. "Our goodwill should not be seen as a weakness," Mr Macron added. French officials have argued the commission should take a firmer stance including by targeting US services. Taoiseach Micheál Martin said there is a strong appetite at EU level for a trade deal with the United States. Mr Martin said "every effort has to be made to get a landing zone that we can live with". "It's not ideal. It's not optimal. Europe doesn't want tariffs, but we have to deal with the situation that is before us," he added. Similarly, Mr Merz said European leaders were "basically united" on concluding the Mercosur trade deal with the South American trade bloc, but Mr Macron said he could not support the deal in its current form. Ms Von der Leyen said yesterday the EU had received the latest US document for further negotiations and the bloc was still assessing it. "We are ready for a deal. At the same time, we are preparing for the possibility that no satisfactory agreement is reached," she told reporters, adding: "In short, all options remain on the table." No specifics were immediately available on the document, which one EU diplomat described as a "two-pager, principle agreement", adding the United States did not want to get into specific industrial sectors. The bloc is already subject to US import tariffs of 50% on its steel and aluminium, 25% for cars and car parts along with the 10% tariff on most other EU goods that Mr Trump has threatened could rise to 50% without an agreement. The European Union has agreed, but not imposed, tariffs on €21 billion of US goods and is debating a further package of tariffs on up to €95 billion of US imports. Among the EU rebalancing options is a tax on digital advertising, which would hit US giants like Alphabet Inc's Google, Meta, Apple, X and Microsoft and eat into the trade surplus in services the US has with the EU. The EU leaders also discussed ideas to carve out a new form of trade cooperation with Asia-Pacific countries that would be a way of reforming what they see as an ineffective World Trade Organisation. Mr Merz said the idea was in its early stages but could include mechanisms to resolve disputes as the WTO was meant to do.
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Ireland set to speed up defence spending by signing up to €150bn EU programme
The Security Action for Europe (SAFE) initiative was brought into force last month as the EU aims to become more sovereign and better equipped to defend itself. The aim of the programme is to finance urgent and large-scale investments defence technology to strengthen Europe's overall defence readiness. Tánaiste Simon Harris is expected to formally sign up to the SAFE legislative instrument today which will allow Ireland to invest in defence in a more speedily fashion. It is expected to now make it much faster for Ireland to acquire specific equipment in areas prioritised by the Defence Forces, in some cases up to two years quicker than under current procurement rules. The capability areas covered by SAFE include air defence systems, maritime surveillance, drones and anti-drone systems, as well as artillery systems. Mr Harris, who is also Minister for Defence, says he has been 'steadfast' in his commitment to invest in the Irish military. The Tánaiste also emphasised he is determined to 'provide for the development of a full spectrum of Defence Force Capabilities that will bring Ireland in line with other similar-sized European countries.' 'I have agreed, therefore, that the Department of Defence should leverage the common procurement opportunities offered under the SAFE Regulation as much as possible to progress delivery of Ireland's defence capabilities needs as quickly as possible,' he added. The European Commission says that member states that wish to invest in defence industrial production can do so through common procurement to boost production capacity and address existing capability gaps. While Ireland will focus on procuring equipment quicker through the programme, it may not require the SAFE initiative to access funds. It will also allow the EU to further support Ukraine by associating its defence industry to the SAFE initiative from the start. Announcing the instrument coming into force last month Adam Szłapka, Polish Minister for the EU, said that the first large-scale defence investment programme is worth €150bn. 'This is unprecedented instrument which will boost our defence capabilities and support our defence industry. The more we invest in our security and defence, the better we deter those who wish us harm,' he said.
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Highly-rated Irish funds sector offers a lucrative career path
Ireland's funds sector is creating a wealth of rewarding career paths as the nation cements its reputation as an EU funds industry leader. EU-based investors have €1 trillion of investments in Irish-domiciled funds, giving them access to investments in Europe and globally. And by attracting global capital into the EU, Irish-domiciled funds have €1 trillion invested into assets across the EU. The funds industry in Ireland generated €11.45bn in revenue and contributed €15.4bn in gross value added (GVA) to the Irish economy in 2023. A recent report by Irish Funds, the voice for Ireland's investment funds and asset management industry for more than 30 years, showed that the sector employed more than 19,500 people and contributed nearly €1bn in direct tax revenue in 2023. Direct employment in the sector has grown by 22% over the past five years, with nearly half of those working in the industry now located outside Dublin. In this Q&A interview, Pat Lardner, CEO of Irish Funds, outlines some of the factors driving new jobs growth in the sector, as well as looking at how actions to support the sector and to boost people's financial literacy can be of huge benefit to the Irish economy. How have remote and flexible work options boosted talent retention in the sector? The Irish funds and asset management industry was quick to adapt to remote working during the pandemic, and that agility has paid long-term dividends. Today, flexible and hybrid work models are commonplace. The industry's ability to incorporate regional talent has significantly increased, with employment outside of Dublin now accounting for almost 46% of the total workforce. This expansion across the country, which supports balanced regional development has deepened the talent pool and improved retention. Flexible work has also been a critical factor in supporting gender inclusion. Hybrid working supports women staying in, or re-entering, the workforce. Returner programmes at several companies in the funds and asset management industry are a testament to this shift. Firms are positioning themselves to attract and retain the best talent across the country. How are employers helping to address the fact that over 50% of adults in Ireland fall below the OECD minimum level of financial literacy? Ireland's financial literacy gap is a serious concern, but the funds and asset management industry is actively part of the solution. Increasingly, firms are investing in outreach programmes, including Transition Year (TY) initiatives, that equip young people with the financial knowledge they need to navigate adulthood. Irish Funds, the representative body for the sector, has worked to scale these types of educational engagements, including through the Irish Funds TY Programme. Last year the programme reached 750 students in 23 schools in 14 counties across Ireland, supported by 43 industry volunteers. Financial Literacy programmes are designed not only to inform students but to demystify the world of investment and savings. This outreach is essential: understanding how money works, how to manage it, and how to plan for the future are foundational life skills, yet many adults report lacking confidence in these areas. By targeting teenagers, the industry is aiming to shift long-term behaviours. These efforts complement broader policy goals to enhance financial wellbeing and reduce inequality of access to financial tools and advice. We are also supporters of the National Financial Literacy Strategy, launched by the Minister for Finance earlier this year. How does the fund and asset management industry support savers in Ireland and the broader economy? Ireland's funds and asset management industry plays a crucial role not only globally but domestically as well. At its core, it helps channel savings into productive investment such as supporting businesses, infrastructure, innovation, and economic resilience. For individual savers, the industry provides access to better long-term outcomes than traditional savings accounts. With inflation and rising living costs, holding wealth in deposit accounts often leads to value erosion over time. Investment funds help grow savings and preserve purchasing power. On a macro level, the industry is a major economic contributor. According to the latest Indecon Economic Impact report, it added €15.4 billion in gross value to the Irish economy and supports 37,500 full-time equivalent jobs across the country. This includes a notable 100% increase in regional employment over the past five years. As more Irish people engage with investment products — whether through pension funds, ETFs, or private assets — the sector's relevance to everyday lives is only set to grow. How will the proposed Savings and Investment Union (SIU) reform support Irish savers? The EU's proposed Savings and Investment Union (SIU) is a transformative initiative aimed at boosting financial market integration across Europe, and Ireland is well placed to lead in this area. Its goals are simple — make it easier and more attractive for people across the EU to invest their money, rather than leave it idle in deposits. For Irish savers, SIU could mean greater access to a broader range of investment products, improved transparency, and potentially more favourable tax and regulatory conditions. It would also help to reduce some of the structural barriers that currently discourage long-term investing, such as the high exit tax on fund returns compared to deposit interest. Ireland's funds industry has an important role to play in shaping and delivering the SIU. As a leading EU domicile and distribution hub, our expertise and infrastructure can support the mobilisation of savings into investments that power the real economy. Whether it's funding climate transitions, digital infrastructure, or housing, the SIU can help ensure capital flows to where it's needed most while supporting savers in achieving better financial outcomes.
