Lila Marsland: 'We are waiting for apology over daughter's death'
The parents of a five-year-old girl who was sent home from hospital with suspected tonsillitis hours before dying from meningitis have said they are still waiting for a direct apology from the hospital. Lila Marsland was examined by various medics over several hours at Tameside Hospital in Ashton-under-Lyne, Greater Manchester, on 27 December 2023.But despite displaying warning signs of meningitis, no-one began the treatment which could have saved her life, Manchester South Coroner's Court heard.A jury at her inquest ruled Lila's death was contributed to by hospital neglect. In a statement to the BBC, a hospital trust spokesperson said it "apologised unreservedly".
Lila's mother Rachael Mincherton said: "We've known for 17 months that she wasn't treated correctly but to hear neglect - I can't put into words really."Every question was just met with a different excuse. "You know 'we haven't caused this'."There was no accountability. We've never received an apology."The first time we [heard] an apology was when we saw it on the news after the inquest."
Ms Mincherton, of Hyde, Greater Manchester, took Lila to the hospital's A&E after finding her lethargic, with a headache and a worryingly fast heartbeat, the inquest heard.The mother, who was a nurse at the same hospital at the time, said she queried whether Lila could have meningitis.About nine hours after arrrival, Lila was discharged from the observation ward and sent home with her mother."I felt reassured by them to be honest," said Ms Mincherton."She was seen by an advanced nurse practitioner, a junior doctor, a senior paediatric registrar and they all reassured me it wouldn't be meningitis and I put her to bed thinking it wasn't."But when she woke up the next morning, she found her daughter unresponsive. "I knew she'd been dead for quite some time so I rang for an ambulance, started CPR and then the paramedics arrived within five minutes and they couldn't do anything," she said.
A jury at Manchester South Coroner's Court returned a narrative conclusion, finding that Lila died of natural causes and the cause of death was meningitis. They also decided her death was contributed to by hospital neglect.Her father Darren Marsland said the outcome of the inquest "wasn't a victory knowing she had been neglected by someone that you trust".Ms Mincherton said more awareness was needed over the signs and symptoms of meningitis to ensure other families do not suffer the same heartache. Tameside and Glossop Integrated Care NHS Foundation Trust, which runs the hospital, said: "We'd like to reiterate our statement following the inquest. "It is clear from the investigation that there were missed opportunities in Lila's care. "We accept the coroner's findings and apologise unreservedly. As a trust we have made and will continue to make improvements to ensure we learn from this case."Unfortunately, we are unable to comment further at this time as this is still an ongoing process."
Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Father's Day treats contain 'reckless' sugar levels, shoppers warned
Retailers are packing their Father's Day chocolate ranges with record levels of sugar and calories – putting dads at risk of a host of health conditions. An analysis found some paternal-themed bars and treats include almost a week's worth of sugar in a single item. Critics and nutritionists blasted the use of 'humour' and 'oversized packaging' to target men with products that pose 'real health risks'. As part of their Father's Day range Morrisons offers a 360-gram Toblerone Milk Chocolate Bar packing a worrying 216 grams of sugar or the equivalent of 54 teaspoons of sugar, plus an astonishing 1,822 calories. NHS experts say the average adult should consume no more than 30 grams of sugar a day or seven teaspoons worth - plus a maximum 2,500 calories for a man. High-sugar diets lead to having too many calories, which leads to weight gain, while being overweight increases your risk of heart problems such as heart disease, some cancers and type 2 diabetes. And similar levels of sugar were found in treats from rival chains. Marks & Spencer says its 'Big Daddy bar' has been recognised as 'the UK's answer to Dubai chocolate' - a popular bar filled with pistachio - thanks to its 'irresistible pistachio flavour '. But nutritional information for the treat posted online shows it packs an extremely high 119 grams of sugar - the same as 30 teaspoons and more than four days' worth, plus a waist-expanding 1,500 calories. Sainsbury's offers 200-gram box of Lindt Lindor Pistachio Milk Chocolate Truffles as part of its Father's Day range. But small print on the supermarket giant's website confirms the 'bliss' inducing treat packs a hefty 84 grams of sugar – that equates to 21 teaspoons of sugar or three days' worth - plus 1,252 calories. Paul Evans, registered nutritionist at The Nutritionist UK, said: 'The levels of sugar being packed into these so-called 'Father's Day treats' are not just excessive — they're reckless. 'We're talking about single products containing nearly a week's worth of sugar, sold under the guise of a novelty gift. 'This is indulgence pushed to the point of absurdity. There's a worrying trend in how food brands target men — using humour, oversized packaging, and 'treat culture' to disguise the fact these products pose very real health risks' Elsewhere, Tesco is selling its own Toblerone themed treat designed to give dad's waistline a battering. The 400-gram Toblerone Tiny Milk, white and dark Chocolate Bars Pouch includes a tooth decay inducing 163 grams of sugar or the same as 40 teaspoons of sugar. That's almost six days' worth of the white stuff. The 35 Toblerone treats per bag specials also includes an eye-watering 1,476 calories. Tesco said: 'From grooming kits to books, we offer a great range of affordable products in store and online to help families celebrate Father's Day this year.' Mondelez International, makers of Toblerone added: 'These products are intended as an occasional treat and are clearly labelled to ensure they can be consumed as part of a healthy and balanced diet. 'We offer a wide range of different products and sizes to suit the varied needs of our consumers, each of which have nutritional information on pack. All other supermarkets were contacted for comment.
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Millions of patients to be treated by GPs instead of hospitals under radical reforms to cut NHS waiting list
Patients will be treated by GPs rather than getting specialist care in hospitals under radical reforms as Keir Starmer battles to tackle the NHS crisis. Routine appointments will be dealt with in community services close to patients' homes in a move they believe could 'fix the waiting list'. The health service will also ramp-up technology meaning patients will have less in-person appointments - instead using like the NHS app and wearable devices to monitor patients remotely. NHS bosses claim half of the 135 million hospital outpatient appointments every year are 'pointless' and follow-ups and consultations could instead be done in high-street surgeries. It comes as the government is set to launch a ten-year plan to create a 'neighbourhood health service', The Times reports. 'As we deliver the transformational shifts in our 10 Year Plan, from hospital to community, analogue to digital, and sickness to prevention, it will have radical implications for services,' Health Secretary Wes Streeting told the NHS ConfedExpo in Manchester. 'Much of what's done in a hospital today, will be done on the high street, over the phone, or through the app in a decade's time.' The plans are set to link family doctors, nurses, social care services and volunteers with money being paid to NHS regions based on how effective their care is rather than how busy the hospitals are. Streeting added: 'We will use financial incentives to invest more in public health outcomes, not just in more activity that reacts to sickness.' Earlier this week, figures revealed that the number of patients waiting has fallen to its lowest point in two years - but the number of patients waiting for more than a year for hospital treatment has increased. The news comes after Chancellor Rachel Reeves gave the NHS a cash injection worth an extra £29 billion per year. Speaking to the Commons, the Chancellor said she is making a 'record cash investment' in the NHS, worth an extra 3 per cent a year in real terms. The Chancellor insisted this would lead to 'more appointments, more doctors and more scanners' as Labour seeks to deliver on its manifesto promise to get the NHS 'back on its feet'. But the settlement received a lukewarm response from NHS bosses, who said they would need even more money if the Government is to achieve its aim of treating 92 per cent of patients within 18 weeks of a GP referral by the end of this Parliament. Matthew Taylor, of the NHS Confederation, which represents health organisations, said: 'Difficult decisions will still need to be made as this additional £29billion won't be enough to cover increasing costs of new treatments, with staff pay likely to account for a large proportion of it. 'On its own, this won't guarantee that waiting time targets are met.' Sir Jim Mackey, chief executive of NHS England, told the NHS ConfedExpo conference in Manchester that the health service has done 'really well relative to other parts of the public service'. But he added: 'We all know it's never enough because of the scale of advancement, all the ambition, the day-to-day cost pressures... but I think everyone's starting to accept and understand we've got what the country can afford to give us. 'We really need to get better value for that money – it is broadly the equivalent of the GDP of Portugal, so it's a huge amount.' Government documents accompanying the Spending Review show that, on average, from 2023/24 to 2028/29, the NHS in England will receive 3 per cent real-terms growth in day-to-day spending, equivalent to a £29billion increase in annual budgets The Government said it will also invest up to £10 billion in NHS technology and digital transformation by 2028/29, plus £6 billion to speed up tests and treatments. Scanners, ambulances and urgent treatment centres are among things the additional cash – part of the overall £29 billion – will pay for, with the aim of providing up to 4 million more tests and procedures in the next five years. NHS England figures show 7.42 million treatments were waiting to be done at the end of March, relating to 6.25 million patients – up from 7.4 million and 6.24 million respectively at the end of February.
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Camilla's GP recognised by King in Birthday Honours
The King has recognised the Queen's GP and a senior medical consultant serving the royal household in the Birthday Honours. Dr Nicholas Hugh, who has the title Apothecary to the Queen, and Ranan Dasgupta, sergeant-surgeon to the royal medical household, have been made Lieutenants of the Royal Victorian Order (RVO). Awards under the RVO are in the King's gift and are bestowed independently of Downing Street to people who have served the monarch or the royal family in a personal way. Mr Dasgupta is a consultant urologist at King Edward VII's Hospital, where members of the royal family have been treated for decades, and specialises in a number of areas including treating prostate disease and kidney stones. He joined the monarchy's medical team in 2020 and was appointed sergeant-surgeon three years later. The consultant was working in this role when in January 2024 the King underwent a procedure on an enlarged prostate, during which time his cancer – not affecting his prostate – was discovered. Charles has been receiving ongoing cancer treatment for an undisclosed form of the disease since early last year and continues to carry out a full programme of royal duties. Also recognised was the King's head valet Lee Dobson, a member of the RVO who has now been made a lieutenant. David Quick, house manager at Bagshot Park, the Surrey mansion of the Duke and Duchess of Edinburgh, has been made a member of the order.
