Rachel Reeves gearing up for Dutch-style pensions takeover – everyone could be worse off
A shift to Dutch-style pension schemes could see savers given less control over their investments – and more money going towards the government's growth plans. Chancellor Rachel Reeves is paving the way for more collective defined contribution (CDC) schemes, The Telegraph reports, based on the premise that they offer better returns and less risk.
CDC schemes offer members the stability of a regular target pension income for life after retirement, based on pooled contributions from employers and employees into a collective fund.
The schemes are considered safe bets for employers and cut the risk of pensioners outliving their savings – but the downside is that the target income can fluctuate based on factors including investment performance. Since the approach is collective rather than individual, it also limits agency around choice of investments and spending in retirement.
While the Netherlands is commonly viewed as one of the world's best countries for pensions, its CDC schemes have come under scrutiny for their lower-than-expected targets based on underperforming investments.
A House of Commons briefing also warned that employees who die earlier could be worse off under CDC schemes because they have effectively subsidised their longer-living counterparts.
CDC schemes are already in place for Royal Mail employees in the UK – although in their current form, the plans can only involve a single or connected employer. A greater focus on this kind of pension could involve the introduction of industry or sector-wide multi-employer schemes – something the government has committed to facilitating.
Pensions Minister Torston Bell said last month that individual schemes meant people were facing 'significant risks about how their individual investments perform and how long their retirements last'.
'Pooling some of those risks will drive higher incomes for pensioners and greater investments in productive assets across the economy,' he said.
However, Tom Selby of AJ Bell accused Labour of plotting to use other people's money to doggedly pursue a growth agenda and criticised the government's favourable comparison of the schemes to annuities, which can be bought with pension pots and effectively guarantees an income for life.
'There is no guarantee that CDC schemes will deliver higher incomes than existing defined contribution schemes,' he said, 'And comparing them to annuities suggests the income setup is the same, which it isn't.
'Annuities pay a guaranteed income for life, whereas CDC scehemes aim for a target income which could be reduced if investments underperform, which is exactly what happened in the Netherlands.
'Offering people a choice of retirement income options is a good thing, but the Government needs to be transparent about what's really happening here – it wants to use other people's money to deliver on its economic agenda.'
READ SOURCE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
an hour ago
Suspect charged with murder in shooting that killed 2, including officer
A suspect accused of fatally shooting a man and then opening fire on responding officers, killing one of them, has been charged with murder, authorities in Southern California said Tuesday. The suspect -- 22-year-old Eduardo Roberto Medina Berumen -- is also charged with attempted murder of a peace officer in what authorities described as a chaotic gunfight. The incident occurred Saturday evening in the Los Angeles County city of Baldwin Park. Darius Wong, a 43-year-old father of two, was fatally shot after just parking his car, authorities said. "He was senselessly murdered that night," Los Angeles County Sheriff Robert Luna said at a press briefing Tuesday. "This loss is devastating to their family, and all of us." When Baldwin police officers who responded to a call of a man firing a rifle arrived at the scene, the gunman "immediately" fired upon them, Luna said. Officer Samuel Riveros was killed by the suspect's gunfire, the sheriff said. "When the bullets were flying, he ran into those bullets to try and keep his community safe and in doing so, he made the ultimate sacrifice of his life," Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman said of Riveros at the briefing. Officer Anthony Pimentel was also injured by shards of glass after a bullet "exploded through a windshield," Hochman said. A third officer who was among the first to respond to the scene was not injured, authorities said. The suspect was shot in the exchange of gunfire with officers and remains hospitalized in stable condition, Luna said. An "AR-15-style weapon" with two high-capacity magazines was recovered at the scene, according to Luna. Near the weapon were approximately 40 to 60 expended casings, according to Hochman. A motive remains under investigation, Luna said. The sheriff's department is also still investigating whether the suspect had any prior connection to Wong, he said. Medina Berumen was charged with two counts of murder with the special circumstance allegations of multiple murders and murder of a peace officer, the district attorney's office said. He also faces two counts of attempted murder of a peace officer and one count of possession of an assault weapon. His arraignment will be scheduled for a later date. If convicted as charged, he faces death or life in state prison without the possibility of parole. A decision on whether to seek the death penalty will be made at a later date, following a review that is expected to take several months, Hochman said.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Another food business in SF Ferry Building to close
SAN FRANCISCO (KRON) — Another business in the iconic SF Ferry Building is set to close, has learned. Le Marais Bakery's Grande Creperie announced it had received the 'sudden and unexpected' news that its lease at the building would not be renewed. 'In January, we were given a commitment for a new lease,' the restaurant posted. 'In April, we were told the 'team in LA' feels we are no longer part of the 'cultural mix.' We've always felt the opposite, as the only French-owned business, where our daughter has been raised riding along in her father's chef cart at the farmers market.' British Airways flight attendant reportedly found dancing naked on SFO flight Le Marais Bakery opened its first location in San Francisco in 2013 and has since expanded to five locations. The Grand Creperie opened at the Ferry Building in 2022, serving 'traditional Breton-style sweet crêpes and salé galettes made with farine de sarrasin, organic buckwheat flour,' according to the bakery's website. 'We built our Grande Creperie after the pandemic when many locations were vacant or closed, investing our savings, renovating to bring it up to code,' read a statement from the bakery's owners, who said they were told they'd be a 'longstanding tenant' and that they'd always reached target earnings. 'We struggle to understand how our space could be offered when we had been given a new lease, when we transformed it into a beloved gathering spot with lines out the door,' the statement continued. The unexpected termination of the bakery's lease comes on the heels of two other Ferry Building businesses abruptly closing. In December, Reem's a popular Arab street food restaurant, announced it would also be closing after finding out its lease would not be renewed. That same month, it was announced that Red Bay Coffee Company's Ferry Building location would also close — although the company now operates a coffee truck on the building's east side. Another Ferry Building eatery, Daily Driver bagel shop, also closed in December. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Sens. Fetterman, McCormick find common ground in FOX Nation debate
(WHTM) — Pennsylvania's two first-term senators sat in stark contrast to each other as they shared a stage Monday, but they found common ground. Democrat John Fetterman and Republican Dave McCormick participated in FOX Nation's 'The Senate Project,' an Oxford-style debate that brings legislators together to discuss topics. The event took place in Boston. Close Thanks for signing up! Watch for us in your inbox. Subscribe Now McCormick and Fetterman both expressed support for Nippon Steel's proposed investment in U.S. Steel. Previously, both senators were vocal about their opposition to the Japanese company's initial proposal to purchase the company. They also agreed on 'getting tough' on Russia and Iran, as well as sealing the border. Fetterman took aim at his own party for its handling of the issue. In recent days, the Democratic Senator has found himself on the receiving end of party attacks. Fetterman dismissed criticism from former staffers over missed votes in the Senate. He said he missed those votes because they were on Mondays. 'Those are travel days,' Fetterman said. 'I have three young kids, and those are throwaway procedural votes that were never determinative, or they weren't important, and that's a choice that I made. If you want to attack me for that, go ahead, but I'd like to point out that Bernie and Senator Murray missed more, so why aren't the left media yelling and demanding them or claiming they're not doing their job? Be genuine on that.' Fetterman claims media trying to 'smear' him over missed votes, absences Sen. Fetterman said he will be present to vote on President Donald Trump's spending plan. He said he is a 'likely no' because of its changes to SNAP benefits. McCormick said he will vote yes on the bill because it will root out waste, fraud and abuse. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
