Colston statue toppling shows 'history isn't static'
The beginning of the end for Colston's close relationship with Bristol began thousands of miles away in Minneapolis, Minnesota, on 25 May, 2020.Police were called to a grocery store to reports of a 46-year-old man allegedly paying for a pack of cigarettes with a counterfeit $20 bill. That man was George Floyd.Former police officer Derek Chauvin knelt on Mr Floyd's neck for more than nine minutes during his arrest. Mr Floyd's pleas of "I can't breathe" as he died sent shock waves around the world - including towards Bristol.Black Lives Matter protests sprung up across the world, calling for an end to racism and police brutality.George Floyd: What happened in the final moments of his lifeChauvin was convicted of Mr Floyd's murder along with three other officers - Tou Thao, Thomas Lane and J Alexander Kueng - who were convicted of aiding and abetting second-degree manslaughter.
The Black Lives Matter protest in Bristol attracted an estimated 15,000 people who gathered on College Green before heading down to Colston Avenue, where the bronze statue was erected in honour of the slave trader in 1895. On the day of the protest, the figure was covered up with a canvas material. It had already been targeted by egg-throwers, but the canvas was later torn off by protesters saying they wanted to look Colston in the eyes. Shortly after the cloth was removed, three protesters climbed up to the statue and attached ropes to its head. To roars of celebration from the crowd, they pulled on the ropes and 30 seconds later the statue was on the ground.
Many ran towards the fallen figure, jumping on it and kicking it. One protester placed his knee on the statue's neck, mirroring the actions of Chauvin during Mr Floyd's arrest. Other protesters climbed the empty plinth, chanting and holding anti-racism banners.The statue was later dragged the short distance over to the harbour, where it was dumped into the water. For many that was symbolic, as Bristol's waterways had plenty of links with the slave trade.Four people - dubbed the Colston Four - were charged for their involvement in the toppling, but were later acquitted of criminal damage.
The toppling of the statue was dramatic. Other change has been slower, but over the last five years, Colston's name has gradually started disappearing from the city. In fact three years before his statue was toppled, the city's largest music venue, Bristol Beacon - known formerly as Colston Hall - announced that it was considering dropping the link to Colston. Massive Attack, perhaps the most famous band from Bristol, had always refused to play the venue due to its name.The name change proposal led to a debate, with bosses maintaining that the venue was named after the street it is located on, rather than the slave trader. There was no investment from Colston in building the venue.Plenty of Bristolians were against the change, it should be noted, but on 23 September 2020, the Bristol Music Trust, which runs the venue, decided to go ahead with the rebrand.Several schools in Bristol also implemented changes after the statue came down.Colston's School in Stapleton became known as Collegiate School, Colston's Girls' School became Montpelier High School and The Dolphin Primary School changed its logo from the Colston family crest.
Karen Macdonald, head of public engagement on Bristol City Council's culture team, said the toppling was "symbolic".The statue was temporarily displayed at the M Shed museum in the city in 2021 after it was retrieved from the harbour. The council launched a public survey which more than 14,000 Bristolians responded to with "very clear wishes" of what they wanted for the statue's future. The majority of the responses called for the statue to be displayed in its damaged state, alongside balanced historical information and context about Colston's past.So that is where you will find the Colston statue now, lying on its back in a glass case, surrounded by the real placards left behind by the protestors.
Ms Macdonald said: "There is value in listening to different viewpoints and coming to an understanding, even if you can't agree with each other. "This isn't erasing history, this is recording history. History isn't something that can remain static and preserved - that moment was history in action. "It wasn't about lumps of cast metal," she added. Nothing has replaced the toppled statue, the plinth is still empty.But it does now feature an updated plaque reflecting Colston's involvement in slavery and telling the story of that dramatic day in June.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
2 minutes ago
- The Independent
Migrant hotel protests: Police braced for further violence across country with more demonstrations planned
Police are braced for further protests and disorder across the UK, as anti-migrant demonstrations continue outside hotels housing asylum-seekers. At least four protests have been organised for the upcoming week in locations such as Bournemouth, Southampton and Portsmouth, with tensions rising further after clashes over the weekend. It comes amid warnings that the Metropolitan Police could be 'tested to the limit' on Saturday, when pro-Palestine Action supporters have been urged to turn up en masse in central London, in defiance of anti-terror laws. Protests first began last month outside The Bell Hotel in Epping after an Ethiopian refugee residing there, Hadush Kebatu, was charged with sexual assault for allegedly attempting to kiss a 14-year-old girl. Since then, far-right demonstrators have clashed with police and counter-protesters in Diss, Manchester, Edinburgh and outside the Barbican in London. On Sunday, a group wearing face masks and carrying smoke bombs made a 'concerted effort' to break into the Britannia Hotel in Canary Wharf, which is currently housing refugees. Police forces are expected to be stretched at the weekend, as a separate pro-Palestine march is also scheduled for Saturday and anti-immigration protests are scheduled to continue. It is unclear if the Metropolitan Police will call on mutual aid from neighboring forces, with the National Police Chiefs Council (NPCC) saying they are working 'closely' with partners at a national and local level. The Telegraph reports that hundreds of people are set to descend on London to support Palestine Action, after they were proscribed as a terrorist organisation. The group has claimed responsibility for damaging aircraft at RAF Brize Norton in June. Membership or expressing support for the group is now a criminal offence carrying a maximum sentence of up to 14 years in prison. With the possibility that the police may have to arrest hundreds of protesters on Saturday, there are fears that capacity in custody cells could quickly run out. Sir Keir Starmer 's spokesperson said that while the public have a right to protest, they would 'never tolerate unlawful or violent behaviour or intimidatory behavior'. Tensions over migration have further escalated after Reform UK leader Nigel Farage and George Finch, the 19-year-old leader of Warwickshire County Council, claimed there had been a 'cover up' of details about an alleged rape of a 12-year-old girl in Nuneaton. Two men have been charged in relation to the alleged incident in the Warwickshire town. Warwickshire Police has not released the immigration status of the two suspects. Mr Finch said he would be working to 'fight against' houses of multiple occupancy (HMOs) that are housing 'illegal immigrants' and also claimed that Reform UK need to 'change things' and are 'the last line of defence against the blob, the cover-ups'. In his letter to Ms Cooper, published on X on Sunday, Mr Finch claimed that a 'cover-up' of immigration status 'risks public disorder breaking out on the streets of Warwickshire'. 'Having my ear to the ground locally, it is clear that there is much appetite for protests to take place across the County,' the letter adds. When asked if the police should release the ethnicity of people when charged, a No10 spokesperson said that it was important to be as 'transparent as possible', and described the case as 'deeply upsetting and distressing'. Meanwhile, border security minister Dame Angela Eagle said that protests outside hotels must not be used to 'have a pop at the police' and insisted that Labour were working to close asylum hotels. She added that the Government was 'doing the detailed work' to crack down on small boat crossings, after the Home Office unveiled its plan to pump an extra £100 million into tackling people smuggling. With both a protest and a counter-demonstration organised by Stand Up To Racism in Bournemouth on Saturday afternoon, Dorset Police said they would seek to ensure people can exercise their right to protest legally, without disruption. 'We will seek to enable peaceful protests, but public order or criminal offences will not be tolerated and will be dealt with robustly,' a spokesperson said. An NPCC spokesperson said: 'Policing is committed to upholding and facilitating the right to peaceful protest. Where possible, we will work with event organisers and any other affected groups to facilitate protests and minimise serious disruption to communities. 'We are working closely with partners at a national, regional and local level to monitor the latest information and intelligence to ensure we are best placed to respond should we see any incidents that escalate into disorder and criminality. 'We have robust and well-tested proactive plans in place, with the ability to mobilise significant and specialist resources, if necessary. "Public order response officers will be supported by investigation teams who will gather evidence and ensure those responsible for any acts of criminality, should they occur, are identified and held to account.'
BBC News
3 minutes ago
- BBC News
Man held knife to wife's throat during row at their Bradford home
A butcher who held a knife to his wife's throat and threatened to kill her during a row has been jailed for 12 the argument in March at their home in Shipley, Bradford, Farhan Mehdi hit his partner with a metal shoe horn and a long wooden pole. The woman felt the 35-year-old's threats were genuine, Bradford Crown Court heard, with Mehdi admitting charges of making a threat to kill and threatening another with a bladed article in a private place. Police officers searched the house and found a neglected bird of prey in the basement, with Mehdi also pleading guilty to an animal cruelty charge. The goshawk had been tied up with insufficient space to move around and kept in a dark area covered in bird faeces, the court heard. Mehdi was banned from keeping or owning any animal for two years and will be subject to an indefinite restraining order to stop him contacting the complainant or going back to the Jade Bucklow, representing Mehdi, told the court the couple had been arguing about money and made the threat when his wife refused to give him his said Mehdi had been keeping the bird of prey inside temporarily while he was building a shelter for it."During the course of what was a very extensive argument you took a kitchen knife and held it to the victim's throat," judge Jonathan Gibson told Mehdi. "That was, as she said in her statement, extremely frightening for her and certainly in the moment she thought that she might die." Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
Telegraph
3 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Britain's problem isn't dogs, it's their pandering, middle-class owners
My two-year-old son was scooting happily ahead of me through the park when I saw the menace approaching. A spaniel-looking thing, shaggy of coat and eager of head, sharking towards him from behind like one of the velociraptors in Jurassic Park. I started to run but not before the dog had put his paws up on the boy's shoulders and started sniffing eagerly at his face. Harmless, perhaps, but enough to spook him. I scooped him up and went to remonstrate with the dog's owner, a pathetic-looking middle-aged man trotting lamely after his charge. If you can't be bothered to train your dog, I said, possibly in some stronger language, then have it on a lead. The park was full of children. 'It's full of dogs, too, he's just a lively puppy,' the owner replied, as if they were creatures of equal value, rather than a human child and a furry lifestyle accessory. I would like to see his response if a grizzly bear or Bengal tiger placed its paws on his shoulders and slobbered over his face. We exchanged a few more sentences. Would your son like to say hello to the dog, he asked. No, I said. He would like you to train your dog. Another dad arrived, papoose strapped to his front, to tell the owner that his response was completely inadequate. I walked off. It was the third time recently that something like this has happened in a London park. The dog owner always offers the same kind of half-arsed non-apology. The standard of dog ownership in Britain has become shockingly bad. Depending on which reports you believe, the number of the dogs in the UK has risen to somewhere between 10 million and 13 million, up a fifth in little more than a decade. As my colleague Guy Kelly reported earlier this year, experts agree that lots of the newer owners are not fit for purpose. The issue is not with trained dogs, which are wonderful. Nor, strangely, is it really with the obviously terrifying attack-type dogs. At least you know to give them a wide berth, and their chain-wielding owners tend not to unleash them on playgrounds. The problem is the in-between cases: these selfish, arrogant middle-class owners who like the idea of a faithful hound gambolling off the lead but are too lazy or entitled to train them. It is unfair on children and unfair on dogs, which are not the same, as the law makes reassuringly clear. If a child bites a dog it gets a talking-to and possibly a smack. If a dog bites a child it can be summarily executed. The real Salt Path would make for a much better film The wonderful revelations about The Salt Path continue to roll in. This weekend it was the turn of local businesses featured in the book to talk about the gross misrepresentation they suffered at Raynor Winn's hands. A cafe owner in Mullion Cove, Cornwall, told The Observer that the book's depiction of a bullying cafe owner left her 'feeling sick'. There is only one cafe in the harbour, so the implication was obvious. Meanwhile the owner of the only pub in Westward Ho! that fits Winn's description of a 'dismal bar' where a pub quiz was going on says they have never had a pub quiz. And so on. The book was sold as factual, but turns out to have been a novel. Naturally it makes for a much better yarn now. Rather than earnest downtrodden self-improvers, we now know that Winn (Sally) and Moth (Timothy) were (allegedly) fleeing a fraud and their 630-mile yomp was a getaway hike. The film would be fantastic: a kind of knitwear Bonnie & Clyde. Like Lance Armstrong, Winn could have a second career turning gamekeeper, giving earnest mea culpas on chat shows and advising publishers how to spot other fraudulent nature memoirs. Call it a Winn-Winn. I'm converted: padel is just better After years of principled resistance I caved on holiday and tried padel. Our hotel had a shiny new facility next to its weed-covered tennis court. Proselytisers are always off-putting, and padel inspires bores like few other activities, so it is painful to report that the padel-pushers are right. Padel is simple, fast, energetic and less dependent on serving than its cousin. Just as many new board games, such as Settlers of Catan or Splendor, are simply better designed than the Cluedo or Monopoly we grew up with, so tennis will end up like the red squirrel; a charming native forced out by a boisterous intruder and eventually glimpsed only in rare corners. Tennis will endure for spectators, but for players the path is clear. Shocking as it sounds, the old ways are not always best.
