Lack of planning led to Kaitāia's aquifer project budget blow-out and delays, review finds
Photo:
Peter de Graaf
A report on a Kaitāia water project that took 14 years instead of five and cost millions of dollars more than expected has found a lack of planning was one of the key reasons for the project's troubles.
In 2011 the Far North District Council, under the former mayor, decided to drill two bores into the Sweetwater aquifer north of Kaitāia
to stop the town running out of water
during its frequent summer droughts.
However, bore water only started flowing through the town's taps early this year, prompting councillor Mate Radich to call for a judicial review.
Radich had also become frustrated by being unable to establish the project's total cost.
In May this year,
councillors voted to seek an internal review
instead, given the high cost of a judicial review.
The report, presented at Thursday's council meeting in Kaikohe, finally provided a definitive project cost of $18,016,070.
Of that, just $2.4 million was spent developing the initial bore site from 2011-17.
The bulk of the money, $14.9m, was spent on bore improvements and pipeline construction between 2020 and 2024.
A significant part of that, just under $2.5m, went on "access costs" including land purchase ($250,000) and easements/compensation payments to landowners ($1.63m).
Another $708,000 was spent this year on a membrane bio-reactor treatment trial, when it became apparent Kaitāia's existing treatment plant was unsuited to the silica-rich water from the aquifer.
The town's water is usually drawn from the drought-sensitive Awanui River.
The money came from rates and reserves ($3.3m), loans ($11.7m) and external grants ($3m, mostly from the Provincial Growth Fund).
The report found the key reason for the delays was "the absence of a single, over-arching project plan".
The project lacked a proper business case, which would have identified all the components required, provided an overview of the expected cost and delivery timeframe, and established key milestones for reporting and decision making.
Failing to engage early with affected property owners and mana whenua forced re-designs and cost time, while the use of external project managers increased the expense.
The report also found delays resulted from inadequate asset management and the "stop-start effect" caused by staff turnover.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
6 hours ago
- RNZ News
Wellington council's planned sludge minimisation plant faces increased costs
An artist's impression of the new sludge minimisation facility at Moa Point. Photo: Supplied / Wellington City Council Wellington City Council's sludge minimisation plant, which is expected to be completed by next year, is facing increased costs. On Friday morning several councillors confirmed to RNZ they had been made aware of a budget blow-out during a public-excluded session last week. On Friday afternoon Wellington City Council said elected members had been given a preliminary briefing about the challenges faced with building the new Te Whare Wai Para Nuku sludge minimisation facility currently under construction at Moa Point, with several factors driving increased costs to complete the project. The project is expected to be built to a $428 million budget. Initially up to $400m was raised for its construction, with a levy introduced to ratepayers in August last year to fund the the facility without affecting council funding for other important infrastructure and community projects. The levy will be collected for a period of 33 years commencing 1 July 2024. A council spokesperson said while staff were still investigating the situation, several key themes that were driving increased costs to complete the project had emerged. "These include a later practical completion date than anticipated, changes in design, identification of historical costs which weren't originally included, and re-assessment of risks with the pathway and process for commissioning the plant," the spokesperson said. A more detailed report on cost and funding implications will be outlined to elected members in a briefing on Thursday 14 August. The matter will also be considered at the council's long-term plan finance and performance committee on Wednesday 20 August. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
6 hours ago
- RNZ News
Nelson Mayor Nick Smith launches his re-election campaign
Nick Smith was elected mayor of Nelson in 2022. Photo: RNZ / Samantha Gee Nelson Mayor Nick Smith has launched his re-election campaign, with a pledge to keep rate increases over the next three years under 5 percent, except in the case of an extraordinary event like a natural disaster. Smith, a former National MP, retired from Parliament in June 2021. He had been the MP for Nelson for 24 years and was elected mayor of Nelson in 2022. He said the cost of living and the increase in rates were the biggest issues facing ratepayers in this year's local elections. "Nelson's rate increases have been lower than most councils over the past three years, despite the huge costs of the August '22 storm damage , but we need to work harder at getting efficiencies and savings to keep rates down." Smith said he was confident that the required investment in infrastructure and city revitalisation could be made while keeping future rate increases to under 5 percent. He signed the pledge at his campaign launch in Nelson on Friday evening. "Nelson rates increased 38 percent during the decade 2010-20 as compared to inflation of 15 percent. My long-term goal is for rate increases to be in line with inflation and economic growth." Smith said he could not achieve the rates cap alone and invited any other council candidates to make an under five rates pledge, which he said was a statement of common policy, not endorsement. "There are wider benefits for Nelson from committing to rates increases of under 5 percent with many councils around New Zealand proposing ongoing double-digit rate rises. A commitment to under 5 percent will give Nelson a competitive advantage in attracting business, investment and people and help our economic recovery." Smith joins current Nelson City councillor Aaron Stallard, Money Free Party New Zealand's Richard Osmaston and John Wakelin in contesting the Nelson mayoralty. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
6 hours ago
- RNZ News
Coloured blocks on your CV - and other job-hunting mistakes you might be making
Applicant's should tailor their CVs to each job application because tracking software looks at key words and phrases in them and matches them to the job advertisement, a career consultant says. Photo: 123rf If you're applying for jobs and keep missing out, recruitment experts say there are some common mistakes you might be making. Unemployment increased this week, to 5.2 percent, and the underutilisation rate reached 12.8 percent. It's a tough environment to be looking for a new role. Career consultant Merrie McDougall told Morning Report people who were job hunting should make sure their CVs were fit for purpose. She said in the past five years applicant tracking software had become widely used. This would look at key words and phrases in an applicant's CV and match them to the job advertisement. "If you don't have that match, you're never going to get to the next stage… it's as simple as that." She said the software would also only read the first two pages, and often could not process blocks of colour. She recommended a "simple word doc". But she said paper copies were no longer necessary. Hayley Pickard, founder of Fortitude Group, said even though someone might be applying for large numbers of jobs, they should not use a generic resume and cover letter. "In a recession, employers are flooded with applications. Generic materials don't stand out." Each application should be tailored to the job description, highlighting a person's most relevant skills and achievements, she said. Pickard said people also shouldn't apply for anything and everything. "You appear unfocused or desperate… apply only to jobs where you meet at least 70 percent to 80 percent of the requirements and can add value." But applicants should consider what transferable skills they might have and not limit themselves to jobs that were the same as those they had held before, she said. Pickard said any long gaps in employment in a CV would need to be addressed. "Recruiters may assume the worst." It was a good idea to "briefly and honestly" explain them and emphasise what you did during that time, whether it was freelancing, volunteering or more study, she said. Most jobs would be filled through referrals in tight job markets, Pickard said. Contacting former colleagues could help, as would taking up any networking opportunities. She said people should not give up after a few rejections. "Job searches during a recession can take longer and require persistence. Track your application, follow up, learn from rejection and stay consistent. Treat job hunting like a job itself." She also recommended people applying for jobs tidy up their online presence so that their LinkedIn profiles matched their resumes and highlighted their accomplishments. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
