Televise grooming gang inquiry given public interest, Labour peer urges
Broadcaster Baroness Hazarika, who was previously a political adviser to former prime minister Gordon Brown, Baroness Harman and Energy Secretary Ed Miliband, also called for a two-year time limit on the probe, arguing that 'justice delayed is justice denied'.
Speaking in Parliament, the Muslim Labour peer again apologised for the crimes carried out by 'wicked, wicked men' and said many in her community felt 'deeply ashamed'.
Responding, Home Office minister Lord Hanson of Flint also said he would like to see the inquiry 'speeded up', but this would be subject to discussion with the chairperson, which the Government was looking to swiftly recruit.
The full-scale investigation was announced by the Prime Minister following a major review by Baroness Casey into grooming gangs, leading to accusations of a U-turn by Tory critics.
Her report, published on Monday, found the ethnicity of perpetrators had been 'shied away from', with data not recorded for two-thirds of offenders.
Home Secretary Yvette Cooper claimed officials had dodged the issue of ethnicity among the groups of sex offenders for fear of being called racist, even though available data showed suspects were disproportionately likely to be Asian men.
Lord Hanson told peers on Wednesday: 'The Government is determined to root out the horrific crimes of grooming gangs and secure justice for victims.'
He pointed out all 12 recommendations made by Lady Casey had been accepted by the administration, including the establishment of a national probe.
The minister added: 'The inquiry will be time limited, have statutory powers to direct targeted investigations into local areas with the aim of holding institutions to account for current and historic failures in their response to group-based child sexual exploitation.'
Lady Hazarika said: 'I welcome this inquiry. And I just wanted to say that, as a Muslim woman, I want to profoundly apologise for what these wicked, wicked men have done to white working class girls.
'Many of us feel deeply ashamed, and let's not call them grooming gangs. These are rape gangs which operated on an industrial level.
'I hope the inquiry will also hear the voices of Muslim girls who were also abused by these animals.'
She added: 'The minister talks about a time limit. Could the inquiry be capped at two years because justice delayed is justice denied?
'Given the public interest, can this inquiry be televised?
'And finally, given the incredible work that Baroness Casey has done, can she be appointed the chair? Because in a world of appalling systemic failure, she is the only public figure that many victims trust.'
Lord Hanson said: 'She asks about the timescale for the inquiry, Baroness Casey has indicated it would be around three years. I would like to see it speeded up, but we have to discuss that matter with the potential chair of the inquiry.
'And the Government intends to try to recruit the potential chair of the inquiry as a matter of some speed, and we are in the process of doing that now.
'Baroness Casey herself is currently now going to be engaged in a further report, but we will appoint a chair as soon as possible.'
He added: 'As to the matter of televising the proceedings, again if she will bear with me, that again will be a matter of discussion with the chair to determine.
'We want to ensure that we take action speedily on this issue.'
He pointed out other recommendation made by Lady Casey would be implemented 'in very short order'.
These included making it mandatory to collect ethnicity and nationality data of all suspects in child sexual abuse cases, a change in the law so that all adult sex with under-16s was considered rape, and a review of the criminal records of exploitation victims.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
an hour ago
- Spectator
The unvarnished truth about rape gangs
Some crimes are so horrific that our instinct is to look away. And there can be few as appalling as those perpetrated by the rape gangs whose activities Dame Louise Casey reported on this week. Girls as young as ten were beaten and sexually abused. They were tortured with baseball bats, knives and meat cleavers. They were urinated on, had cigarettes stubbed out on them, were burned by lighters and branded on their buttocks. Some contracted venereal diseases. One 12-year-old was compelled to undergo an abortion. These crimes weren't rare, but sustained and widespread, carried out in up to 50 towns and cities across Britain over decades. The perpetrators were overwhelmingly Muslim men from Pakistani diaspora communities. They identified girls in the most vulnerable circumstances – often those in care who'd already suffered abuse and neglect – and exploited their need for attention and affection with calculated cynicism, plied them with alcohol and drugs and violated them in the most degrading fashion imaginable. Their crimes were facilitated by family businesses such as kebab shops and taxi firms, and covered up by the community. The victims were ignored, disbelieved or even stigmatised by police and local authorities. While the details of these crimes are so horrific they make one weep at the evil of which man is capable, we need to look at the circumstances which allowed this barbarity to flourish and act to ensure it can never happen again. That requires total honesty. It helps no one, least of all the victims, to look away from the cultural, ethnic and religious factors that lie behind so much of what happened. Too many people have avoided such honesty for too long. Casey says she learnt from police forces that local authorities had prevented them from 'publicising the success-ful conviction of perpetrators of group-based child sexual exploitation due to fears of raising tensions'. Too many people conspired to see, hear and speak no evil 'for fear of appearing racist, raising community tensions or causing community cohesion problems'. If managing multiculturalism required tolerating systematic child rape, so be it. The scale and nature of these crimes and the consequent cover-ups mean that the national inquiry, which Casey recommends, cannot simply be an aggregation of local investigations. There are questions of public policy which must be addressed. The police's failure to record ethnicity data, join the dots, root out collaboration or connivance in their own ranks and challenge community complacency about medieval attitudes is a national failure. Too often and for too long, police forces have hidden behind the doctrine of 'operational independence' to evade accountability. That they pursued innocent figures such as Harvey Proctor and the late Leon Brittan for imagined crimes based on the lurid inventions of the fantasist Carl Beech, while failing effectively to confront the real child abuse being perpetrated across the country, requires more than just a mumbled apology. And in investigating that abuse, uncomfortable questions cannot be evaded. Why do a disproportionate number of perpetrators come from Pakistani backgrounds? Why are so many from communities with links to rural Pakistan and Kashmir? Has our approach towards chain migration and cousin marriage been misguided? What is it in the Islamic teachings within those communities that has appeared to offer either licence for the exploitation of women or, at the very least, no challenge to brutal misogyny? When these questions have been even tentatively explored in the past, those who stood up for victims have faced silencing. Ann Cryer, the former Labour MP for Keighley, raised the horrors two decades ago, only to be dismissed as racist. In January, Keir Starmer described those calling for an inquiry as 'jumping on a bandwagon' of the far right. Lucy Powell, the Leader of the Commons, has branded discussing the rape gangs 'a dog whistle'. The left-leaning journalist Lewis Goodall suggested there was 'little evidence' for Muslim grooming gangs, dismissing it as a far-right 'trope'. His podcast colleague Emily Maitlis branded Rupert Lowe, the former Reform MP crowdfunding a private inquiry into the scandal, a 'racist' for focusing on Pakistani grooming gangs. This campaign of denial may have its roots in a noble sentiment: the wish not to give succour to those intent on driving further divisions in our society. But wilful blindness to the nature of the rape-gang scandal only feeds the far-right narrative that cover-up and conspiracy characterise the British state. There is, of course, another democratic pressure at work here. Some in Labour may fear that an uncompromising reckoning with the facts means that Muslim voters, already alienated from the party by foreign policy concerns, may further desert them for independent candidates. Such an attitude is, in itself, effectively racist. It implies that Muslim voters would rather see crimes committed by co-religionists covered up than confronted. But it serves no interest, no community, no idea of what a multi-ethnic society should be and no version of morality to look away. Unsparing questioning and un-flinching honesty are the only paths to justice.
Spectator
an hour ago
- Spectator
A small world: Shibboleth, by Thomas Peermohamed Lambert, reviewed
Two shibboleths are treated in Thomas Peermohamed Lambert's audacious debut novel. The first is the University of Oxford; the second is the Israeli-Palestinian controversy. 'It is the great issue, isn't it? The great shibboleth.' Edward, the protagonist, is a state-educated undergraduate whose connection to Islam is a Muslim grandfather from Zanzibar. He finds himself in a world of wealthy public school boys with 'a social calendar, rugby fixtures and sexual assault hearings', and girls from sister schools, 'fully recovered from eating disorders'. This fictitious world is outdated, but Lambert's satirical touch still hits the mark about 'the creatures of the written word [the university] specialised in churning out, as if the country needed more of them'. There is the statue on the facade of one of the colleges of 'some monocled old colonialist'. An aged don, whose reputation was established many decades earlier with an article for the London Review of Books, will probably die in college and 'get transubstantiated into a conference room or essay prize'. Edward's fellow students are ciphers. There is Youssef, his close friend, an African Muslim 'with a splash of Blue Nile' in his veins; Liberty, an activist from a well-off black family; Angelica, a privileged white liberal; and Rachel, a Jewish girl who feels herself an outsider and with whom Edward has an affair. There is little depth to any of them, but they serve their purpose. The narrative points up the patronising ways of the wealthy and the tension between Israel and Palestine. In the small world of college politics, Liberty is told that she exploits her role as a black woman surrounded by rugby players who 'bounce around like wrecking balls'. The verdict is that 'in Oxford, being black has helped; being Jewish hasn't'. The writing is full of memes, tropes, mythemes and paradigms. There are longueurs in the debate about Israel and Palestine, but valid points are made. Rachel claims that she risks a charge of anti-Semitism if she asserts: 'I suspect that killing everyone in the Occupied Territories might not be an excellent long-term strategy for Jews in Israel.' This challenging satire that declares 'Oxford is a dream' should not be missed, because today's city with its 59 EDI staff is a nightmare.
Spectator
an hour ago
- Spectator
Portrait of the week: War in the Middle East, drought in Yorkshire and a knighthood for Beckham
Home Sir Keir Starmer, the Prime Minister, announced a full national statutory inquiry into grooming gangs (which he had previously opposed) on the recommendation of Baroness Casey of Blackstock, who had been asked to audit the matter. His announcement came after four men born in Pakistan and three Rochdale-born taxi drivers of Asian descent were convicted of offences against two teenage girls who were repeatedly raped and assaulted in Rochdale from 2001 to 2006. The Casey report said that Greater Manchester, South Yorkshire and West Yorkshire had 'disproportionate numbers of men from Asian ethnic backgrounds amongst suspects for group-based child sexual exploitation'. At the G7 summit in Canada, Sir Keir managed to sign a limited agreement on tariffs with President Donald Trump, who left early. British Steel secured a five-year, £500 million contract to supply rails for Network Rail. A London Underground driver was sacked after knitting and watching videos while operating a train. Blaise Metreweli is to head MI6. MPs voted 379 to 137 for Tonia Antoniazzi's amendment to the Crime and Policing Bill, decriminalising abortion at any stage. Taxpayers discovered that the spending review assumed council tax will rise by the maximum allowed of 5 per cent a year and that police funding assumed a rise in the police precept added to council tax. Rachel Reeves, the Chancellor, said that a priority of the spending review was 'to grow Britain's economy so that working people are better off'. Gross domestic product fell by 0.3 per cent. Inflation remained at 3.4 per cent. Rioters set fire to a leisure centre in Larne, Co. Antrim, used as a refuge for migrants from previous days' violence – and live-streamed on TikTok the burning of a house in Ballymena. The government said it would phase out the use of hotels for asylum-seekers by building state-owned accommodation and cutting small-boat crossings. In the seven days to 16 June, 1,733 migrants arrived in small boats. Among the 1,215 recipients of the King's birthday honours (48 per cent women), Roger Daltrey of the Who and David Beckham, the ex-footballer, were made knights. Penny Mordaunt, who carried the Sword of State at the Coronation, and the ceramicist Emma Bridgewater became dames. The darts player Luke Littler, 18, was appointed MBE. Alfred Brendel, the pianist, died aged 94. The waiting list for routine hospital treatments in England fell from 7.42 million in March to 7.39 million in April. A drought was declared in Yorkshire. Abroad Israel went to war with Iran, launching dozens of strikes on long-range missile sites and targets related to the nuclear programme. The first attack killed General Mohammad Bagheri, Iran's chief of the military staff, and Hossein Salami, the commander of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, as well as leading nuclear scientists. Benjamin Netanyahu urged Iranians to overthrow their rulers. Iran retaliated with missiles and drones, some hitting near Tel Aviv and Haifa, as Israelis took to shelters. In the first three days, 24 people were killed in Israel and 224 in Iran. During a bulletin from the Iranian state broadcaster, debris fell and dust filled the studio. 'This is the dirty work Israel is doing for all of us,' Friedrich Merz, the German Chancellor, said. Mr Trump posted a message on social media: 'Everyone should immediately evacuate Tehran.' Russia carried out a missile and drone attack on Kyiv, killing at least 21 people. Mr Trump made a speech on his 79th birthday at the military parade in Washington, DC, to mark the 250th birthday of the American army; thousands demonstrated against him in several cities. Mr Trump called on the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency (ICE) to carry out 'the single largest Mass Deportation Program in History'. On the way to the G7, President Emmanuel Macron of France visited Greenland. A London-bound Air India plane carrying 242 people, including 53 Britons, crashed shortly after take-off at Ahmedabad, falling on accommodation at the Byramjee Jeejeebhoy medical college; one passenger survived, a man from Leicester. Fire engulfed the 67-storey Marina Pinnacle in Dubai Marina; all 3,820 residents were rescued. A Chinese captain was jailed for three years by a Taiwanese court for damaging an undersea cable to the Penghu islands. Brian Wilson, the songwriter with the Beach Boys, died aged 82. CSH
