Heritage protection discouraged
Churches across Dunedin are singing from the same hymn sheet, asking the council not to protect their buildings, some of which are slated for demolition.
Church representatives have urged the council not include Highgate Presbyterian Church, the former Holy Cross College and Kaikorai Presbyterian Church on the heritage schedule, a request echoed by the owner of former Andersons Bay Presbyterian Church.
At a hearing yesterday, commissioners Rob van Voorthuysen (chairman), Cr Sophie Barker and Cr Jim O'Malley were told trying to protect some buildings could hasten their demolition.
Speaking on behalf of the Roman Catholic Bishop of the Diocese of Dunedin, Conrad Anderson opposed the inclusion of the former Holy Cross College.
Mr Anderson said last year the council had granted a certificate of compliance allowing demolition of most of the main building, excluding the central structure, within the next five years.
"The best way to seek to protect this building — and I realise this is quite ironic — is by not listing it," he said.
If the building were listed, the certificate of compliance for demolition would become a "countdown".
"Anyone who's looking at using the site may activate [the certificate] before it expires," he said.
On behalf of the Synod of Otago and Southland and Southern Presbytery, Mr Anderson also opposed the protection of the Kaikorai Presbyterian Church.
He said it was earthquake-prone and surplus to requirements, with a limited future.
"It's visual but it's not a landmark," he said.
"By protecting the building you'll actually make the land resource unavailable for sustainable use."
Parish representative John Milnes said the proposed listing of the Highgate Presbyterian Church removed the "autonomy" of its owner, the parish.
"Various loud members of the community oppose us doing what we want to the building but they are not members of the parish, they do not financially support the parish ... they just want a pretty building.
"We all like pretty buildings but at the end of the day, somebody has to pay for them."
The site was still fit for purpose, even if the the building was not, Dr Milnes said.
"Applying a heritage listing to the building would effectively preclude its demolition or easy future development."
On Tuesday, the owner of former Andersons Bay Presbyterian Church, Campbell Paton, told commissioners the building was "too far gone" to qualify for protection.
Costs for earthquake-strengthening and weather tightening exceeded $2million and the council had granted a certificate of compliance for demolition within five years and resource consent for a multi-unit development on the site.
If the building were listed, it would be demolished within the five years, he said.
The hearing was adjourned. Commissioners would make their recommendation to the council once they had considered the council staff's right of reply.
ruby.shaw@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
28-05-2025
- Scoop
Bay Of Islands Boat Anchoring Ban Unlikely To Expand Despite Caulerpa Spread
A Bay of Islands boat anchoring ban is unlikely to be extended in spite of exotic invasive caulerpa now being found outside its 1058 hectare restricted area. The equivalent of 1525 rugby fields around the eastern Bay of Islands mainland at Te Rāwhiti is currently locked up to boat anchoring, most fishing and kaimoana gathering under a Government controlled area notice (CAN). But invasive exotic caulerpa has now spread north to infest the iconic picture postcard and international drawcard Ipipiri Islands for the first time - across the equivalent of 180 rugby fields (24ha) outside the current anchoring ban area. At least six of the Bay of Islands tourist hotspot Ipipiri islands seven main islands - of Urupukapuka, Moturua, Motukiekie, Poroporo, Okahu and Waewaetorea Islands, and some areas in between now have confirmed caulerpa. Moturohia or Roberton Island has been previously surveyed. Caulerpa was not found at the time of the survey. Biosecurity New Zealand deputy director-general Stuart Anderson said there was no current plan to increase the Bay of Islands CAN because of the seaweed pest's new locations. His comment comes in spite of the Ipipiri islands being among New Zealand's most popular local and international boating anchorages. Boating has been identified as a major cause of spread for exotic invasive caulerpa. 'The detections of further sites in the Bay of Islands outside the CAN area are obviously disappointing, but unfortunately not unexpected. We are dealing with a challenging pest that readily spreads on vessels and in water currents,' Anderson said. 'For this reason, our current management approach continues to be containing spread while focusing on developing the new treatment approaches. This work continues at pace.' Anderson's comments come four months ahead of a review of the Bay of Islands' existing CAN, which expires in September. It has been in place since May 2023. He said there were no plans to remove the existing CAN at that time, given the pest was now also found beyond its borders. He said local preference since the areas of new caulerpa infestation had been found around the Ipipiri Islands was for a more regional approach, rather than piecemeal extension of the existing CAN. 'The preferred approach has instead been on surveillance of anchorages and removal of small patches where possible to slow the spread – along with continued education of boaties on how they can avoid moving it,' Anderson said The Bay of Islands has one of four CANs in New Zealand, with 12,860ha shut for a mix of anchoring, some fishing and kaimoana gathering – along with Aotea/Great Barrier Island (10,060ha closed), Waiheke Island (1150ha closed) and Ahuahu Great Mercury Island (592ha closed). Anderson said the Bay of Islands' Te Rāwhiti CAN review would be done at the same time as New Zealand's three others, to ensure the most appropriate measures were in place. He said advice was being prepared for Biosecurity New Zealand's chief technical officer who made CAN decisions. 'Criteria are followed when assessing the case for implementing and updating CANs. These include the size of the infestation, location value (cultural/economic/amenity) and volume of vessel traffic. A number of the new Ipipiri Islands locations have been identified as high value boating anchorages. 'In the case of the Bay of Islands, the existing CAN contains the largest known areas of exotic caulerpa. Other confirmed areas in Northland are generally small patches.' Ministry for Primary Industries figures provided to Local Democracy Reporting show there are now 16.65ha, or the equivalent of almost 24 rugby fields, of caulerpa confirmed at Urupukapuka Island with infestations including in Urupukapuka Bay where hundreds camp annually, Entico/Otaia Bay, Cable Bay and its northern boundary with Waewatorea Channel. Urupukapuka island's Otehei Bay tourism epicentre is scheduled for survey before the end of the month. There are also about 123 rugby field equivalents of caulerpa between Moturua and Motukiekie Islands, with separately a further 32 rugby fields around Motukiekie Island. Poroporo Island has the equivalent of about one rugby field of caulerpa. Waewaetorea and Okahu Islands' caulerpa presence is scheduled to be checked before the end of the month. Anderson said the exact area of caulerpa inside the Bay of Islands CAN could not currently be estimated. This was due to varying densities of the invasive seaweed across its area. It was also because caulerpa growth was dynamic. He said there had been a noticeable reduction in Omākiwi Cove caulerpa since recent storms. CANS were only one way of preventing caulerpa spread. Boaties and fishers also played their part, Anderson said. Boaties travelling within and between major traditional boating spots including Northland and Aotea/Great Barrier Island are regularly flouting anchoring ban rules
Otago Daily Times
22-05-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Heritage protection discouraged
Churches across Dunedin are singing from the same hymn sheet, asking the council not to protect their buildings, some of which are slated for demolition. Church representatives have urged the council not include Highgate Presbyterian Church, the former Holy Cross College and Kaikorai Presbyterian Church on the heritage schedule, a request echoed by the owner of former Andersons Bay Presbyterian Church. At a hearing yesterday, commissioners Rob van Voorthuysen (chairman), Cr Sophie Barker and Cr Jim O'Malley were told trying to protect some buildings could hasten their demolition. Speaking on behalf of the Roman Catholic Bishop of the Diocese of Dunedin, Conrad Anderson opposed the inclusion of the former Holy Cross College. Mr Anderson said last year the council had granted a certificate of compliance allowing demolition of most of the main building, excluding the central structure, within the next five years. "The best way to seek to protect this building — and I realise this is quite ironic — is by not listing it," he said. If the building were listed, the certificate of compliance for demolition would become a "countdown". "Anyone who's looking at using the site may activate [the certificate] before it expires," he said. On behalf of the Synod of Otago and Southland and Southern Presbytery, Mr Anderson also opposed the protection of the Kaikorai Presbyterian Church. He said it was earthquake-prone and surplus to requirements, with a limited future. "It's visual but it's not a landmark," he said. "By protecting the building you'll actually make the land resource unavailable for sustainable use." Parish representative John Milnes said the proposed listing of the Highgate Presbyterian Church removed the "autonomy" of its owner, the parish. "Various loud members of the community oppose us doing what we want to the building but they are not members of the parish, they do not financially support the parish ... they just want a pretty building. "We all like pretty buildings but at the end of the day, somebody has to pay for them." The site was still fit for purpose, even if the the building was not, Dr Milnes said. "Applying a heritage listing to the building would effectively preclude its demolition or easy future development." On Tuesday, the owner of former Andersons Bay Presbyterian Church, Campbell Paton, told commissioners the building was "too far gone" to qualify for protection. Costs for earthquake-strengthening and weather tightening exceeded $2million and the council had granted a certificate of compliance for demolition within five years and resource consent for a multi-unit development on the site. If the building were listed, it would be demolished within the five years, he said. The hearing was adjourned. Commissioners would make their recommendation to the council once they had considered the council staff's right of reply.
Otago Daily Times
08-05-2025
- Otago Daily Times
A major religious minority
For the Roman Catholic hierarchy visiting Dunedin to celebrate the Jubilee of their training college at Mosgiel everybody has had a kindly feeling. Hopelessly Protestant though we be, no ungracious word has escaped our lips. We have been on our good behaviour, press and public alike. A venerable archbishop and a lengthy retinue of bishops and priests, quaint representatives of the largest communion in Christendom, were impressive. Hierarchy, meaning government by priests, is not to our Protestant liking, name or thing. But the hierarchs themselves were not shy of the word, as their speeches show; and if the people they govern prefer government in that form, who shall say them nay? The Roman Catholics in New Zealand, though the Presbyterians outnumber them by more than two to one, and the Anglicans by perhaps three to one, are not a feeble folk. Look at their schools! They pay taxes like the rest of us, and, in paying taxes, they, like the rest of us, maintain the public schools. Yet in addition they provide and maintain schools of their own. — by 'Civis' Mum's the word A number of years ago Miss Jarvis, of Philadelphia, felt the need of a day specially to remember mother. That her dreams were not mere sentimental bubbles is borne out by the fact that to-day the second Sunday in May is set apart by the Congress of the United States as "mother's day." Throughout the war men in the army were glad to remember this special observance, many letters of cheer being written to mother on the second Sunday in May. This day has now a place of its own the world over, and in Dunedin it will be specially celebrated in the churches, in the Salvation Army and the YMCA. Police give drivers a hand At the meeting of the Otago Motor Club next Tuesday a sergeant and two constables will be present to give a demonstration of the traffic signals given by the police, and also of the signals that they expect motorists to give under varying circumstances. At present motorists do not by their signals give adequate information of the direction in which they wish to proceed, and at times the instructions given by the police may be misconstrued by drivers. Unsuitable reading Embodied in the report of the rector of the Balclutha District High School to the committee was the following paragraph, which is of more than local interest: "The class libraries are now ready, and will be given out next week. In this connection I should be grateful if the committee would ask for the co-operation of the parents in an endeavour to stamp out in this district the reading by the pupils of both departments of a cheap and pernicious form of so-called literature sold, I believe, at fourpence per copy, and even lent round at a penny per book. I undertook the unpleasant task of wading through a few of these books. From a literary point of view they do nothing but harm to the pupils' study of English, while the characters held up as heroes are not of the type that we should like to have our boys and girls become. One member of the committee stated that these books were interfering with the home lessons of the pupils in some cases. It was decided to ask parents to use their influence in the matter with a view to combating the trouble." — ODT , 9.5.1925 (compiled by Peter Dowden)
