Fianna Fáil MEPs still to pick a side ahead of no-confidence motion in European Commission president
European Commission
president
Ursula von der Leyen
.
The no-confidence vote was tabled by a far-right Romanian MEP and 74 others, predominantly from right-wing populist and nationalist parties.
On Thursday, Members of the European Parliament will vote on the proposed motion of no-confidence in Ms von der Leyen, the head of the
EU
's executive arm that proposes laws.
The effort is widely expected to fall far short of the required two-thirds majority needed to censure the commission. If the motion was successful, it would likely force Ms von der Leyen and her team of EU commissioners, including former Fianna Fáil minister
Michael McGrath
, to resign.
READ MORE
Fianna Fáil's four MEPs, Barry Andrews, Billy Kelleher, Cynthia Ní Mhurchú and Barry Cowen, have yet to declare what way they will vote. Fianna Fáil have been weighing up the possibility of supporting the motion or abstaining in the vote.
The no-confidence vote centres on the 'Pfizergate' controversy, where the commission faced criticism for refusing to release text messages exchanged between Ms von der Leyen and the chief executive of Pfizer, during negotiations to secure supplies of Covid-19 vaccines at the height of the pandemic.
Copies of the texts had been sought in access-to-information requests made by the New York Times, which later
took the commission to court
for blocking the release of the texts.
Speaking in the European Parliament on Monday, Ms von der Leyen said the motion was supported by extreme political movements, 'from anti-vaxxers to Putin apologists'.
Defending her role at the top of the EU executive during the pandemic, Ms von der Leyen said it was 'no secret' that she was in contact with senior figures in companies producing Covid-19 vaccines.
'Every single contract negotiated was examined in detail in the capitals before being signed by each of the 27 member states. There were no secrets, no hidden clauses,' she told a sitting of MEPs in Strasbourg.
'The implication that these contacts were somehow inappropriate or against the European interest is, by any measure, simply wrong.'
The motion was an attempt to spin 'debunked conspiracies' and try to rewrite the history of how Europe 'successfully overcame a global pandemic together', she said.
The EU executive needed to be in a strong position during ongoing tariff negotiations with the United States, the German politician said.
Sinn Féin's two MEPs, Lynn Boylan and Kathleen Funchion, said they would vote against Ms von der Leyen, due to the failure of the EU to hold Israel to account for its conduct during its invasion of Gaza, among other things.
Fine Gael's four MEPs will oppose the motion, which they said had been 'tabled by far-right members of the European Parliament in a bid to destabilise the EU for political gain'.
Iratxe García, a senior Spanish MEP who leads the centre-left Socialist and Democrats (S&D), the second largest grouping in the parliament, said its members would not support the motion, as it refused to work with the far right.
The motion has divided some right-wing populists, with hard right Italian prime minister Giorgia Meloni's party opposing the effort to bring down the commission leadership.
Nicola Procaccini, an MEP from Ms Meloni's Brothers of Italy party, said the move was a mistake. 'This motion is doomed to fail and we know it, without even getting close to the level of votes needed,' he said.
The proposal was one 'big political show' from the far-right to undermine democracy, according to Bas Eickhout, the co-leader of the European Greens.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
35 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Hike in personal injury awards called off and why technology needs the human touch
Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has bowed to pressure on a plan by the Judicial Council to hike personal injury award guidelines by almost 17 per cent, confirming that he will not ask the Oireachtas to rubber stamp the judiciary's proposed tweak to payouts. However, as Joe Brennan reports, the Minister warned that the decision opens up the risk that judges could start making increased awards outside of the guidelines while the Personal Injuries Resolution Board remains bound by the current guidelines. Irish customers of Betfair and Paddy Power have been notified in recent days of a data breach at the Flutter-owned brands, which has impacted as many as 800,000 users in Ireland and Britain. Hugh Dooley has the details. Planners could rule shortly on night flights at Dublin Airport, ending almost a year of speculation over a crunch issue for airlines there. As Barry O'Halloran reports, State planning board, An Coimisiún Pleanála, last September issued a draft ruling limiting night-time flights to 13,000 a-year, fewer than 36 a-night. This year's Wimbledon may have been notable for the fact that it has replaced line judges with computer technology, but as Ciara O'Brien writes, sometimes more tech isn't the answer to all our problems. READ MORE Cantillon analyses unions' CIE pension warning , while also assessing the changing fiscal stance taken by the German goverment. It also looks at that the National Competitiveness Council is really worried about. In Innovators to Watch, Olive Keogh meets an Irish tech firm aiming to cut last minute chemotherapy cancellations by as much as 25 per cent. Technology explores the terrifying world of artificial intelligence's growing role in elections globally. Ageing working populations will dampen productivity growth in the world's biggest economies as fertility rates have 'plummeted' in recent generations, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development has warned. Hugh Dooley has the story. The Government will change the law to enhance the enforcement powers of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) in dealing with supermarket retailers, the Dáil has heard. Marie O'Halloran reports. Drone delivery company Manna expects to have regulatory approval for new technology that would cut noise pollution from its aircraft by 40 per cent within months. As Colin Gleeson reports, the company has drawn criticism from members of the Oireachtas and the public alike due to noise complaints after it set up a facility near Blanchardstown Centre last year, where its base is surrounded by popular fast-food chains and cafes. Irish mortgage interest rates dropped to their lowest levels in two years in May, the Central Bank of Ireland said on Wednesday, but remained higher than the euro zone average. Ian Curran has the story. DCC, the Irish conglomerate seeking to narrow its focus to energy, may end up securing just £633 million (€733.4 million) for its technology division, according to Goodbody Stockbrokers. Joe has the story. Dún Laoghaire Rathdown County Council has granted planning for a seven storey , 71 unit, apartment development in Sandyford despite concerns expressed by a local parish priest, local residents and businesses over the scheme. Gordon Deegan has read the decision. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
RTÉ's ‘Noraid: Irish America and the IRA' leans towards the Che Guevara version of history
The makers of Noraid: Irish America and the IRA , RTÉ 's flashy new two-part documentary about the Provisionals' support base in North America, say they want to 'tell a story that is misunderstood or not known at all'. But of course, anyone who was alive during the Troubles will remember only too well how elements within Irish America helped fund the IRA's campaign and, in so doing, contributed to the bombings of civilians, the kneecappings, the murder of Gardaí and the sectarian campaign against Protestant farmers along the border. How shocking to think this part of history might be in danger of slipping between the cracks of popular recollection. The film (RTÉ One. 9.35pm) doesn't quite paint Noraid – a contraction of 'Irish Northern Aid Committee' – as misunderstood heroes. However, it might have gone further in making explicit what they were supporting. That is, the slaughter of pensioners on Remembrance Sunday, the kidnapping and murder of businessmen, industrial-scale bank robbery. That isn't to absolve the British state of its sins in the North , its backing of loyalist death squads or the stain of colonialism, as dark as not-quite-dried blood. But the documentary does not convey, or even really acknowledge, the horror the overwhelming majority of people in Ireland felt at the time towards the Provos. And that is relevant to the story, as it also explains the widespread revulsion towards Noraid. If anything, the first of two episodes leans ever so subtly towards the Che Guevara version of history – never mind the body count; look at the cool poster we got out of it. READ MORE Hipster touches abound as the producers play up the New York element of the story. The Beastie Boys feature on the soundtrack, and the title cards are modelled on old cop shows. These are flourishes that do not always sit well with the grim subject matter. Still, there are flashes of humour, too – such as when activists recall arranging for senior members of the republican movement in Belfast to be interviewed by one of America's most widely-read journals, Playboy. Meanwhile, taxi driver John McDonagh remembers booking an ad in Times Square supporting the IRA – it finished with the initials 'UTP'. This spelt 'Up the Provos', though the company that took the booking thought it meant 'Up the Pope'. 'They never asked me what type of charity,' McDonagh says. 'I said I wanted to send season's greetings to the Irish people. They never asked what type of Irish people. I didn't offer what type.' If the film doesn't take a strong enough stand on the Provos, it does give a voice to senior Noraid figures and allows them to communicate their views uncritically. It introduces Martin Galvin, a lawyer and leading figure in Noraid. He was banned from entering Northern Ireland but went anyway in 1984. In the riot that followed his appearance at a rally in West Belfast, British security forces shot dead a protester with a rubber bullet. Galvin obviously wasn't to blame for the bloody excesses of the British security establishment. However, the violence would not have broken out had he not been there. 'We support Irish freedom ... the only way the British are going to leave Ireland is for the fight to be successful,' Galvin says – seemingly cleaving to the old republican shibboleth as seeing the British as an entirely external force and ignoring the inconvenient presence of a million unionists. Still, it is revealing to learn that Galvin and other Noraid members are far removed from the misty-eyed Irish-American stereotype. Noraid was largely based in New York, and its members have the hard-bitten qualities of characters from a Scorsese movie. That said, modern Sinn Féin's hipster-Marxist axis won't be thrilled to learn that Noraid expunged any hint of socialism from imported copies of An Phoblacht because that sort of thing would not have gone down well with Irish Americans. Nor do the producers address the uncomfortable fact that Irish America – so keen on the physical force of republicanism – would go on to become a power base for Donald Trump and, thus of 21st century Neo-Fascist. Interviewed today, Galvin is unapologetic and still retains some of the firebrand qualities that are a feature of his archive appearances. The documentary is also careful to point out that while Noraid organised fundraisers for Sinn Féin, it never supplied arms to the Provos. The task of smuggling guns across the Atlantic fell to organised criminals. That story will be told in part two and will touch on the role of Whitey Bulger (as later played on screen by Johnny Depp). But part one provides a fascinating portrait of a crucial element of the struggles – of true believers from across the sea who seemed to fancy themselves more Irish than those in the 26 counties who didn't much care about the Constitutional status of the North, only that people stopped dying. 'What I've found is the diaspora make a serious attempt to understand the Irish culture, whereas a lot of people that are actually from the island of Ireland have never made an attempt to understand the diaspora culture,' says Chris Byrne, a former New York cop and republican sympathiser. It is a reminder few are as committed to the spilling of blood in Ireland as those who never set foot here.
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
Can Ursula von der Leyen's Commission be toppled?
For the first time in more than a decade, the European Commission President and her entire College of Commissioners are facing a vote of confidence. European politicians will have their say on it this afternoon in Strasbourg. The "motion of censure" was launched by Romanian MEP Gheorghe Piperea, from the ultra-conservative party AUR, over the so-called "Pfizergate" – the text messages EU President Ursula von der Leyen exchanged with a vaccine chief at the height of the Covid-19 pandemic. The texts haven't been made public despite the ruling of an EU court that the Commission was wrong to deny access to those messages. In their motion, the group of 75 MEPs accused her of acting without "transparency and accountability". President von der Leyen called those accusations a "lie" when she descended on the Parliament on Monday, accompanied by all 26 Commissioners. During what proved to be an explosive debate, Ms von der Leyen described those behind the motion as "extremists" and "Putin's puppets", who are "trying to drive a wedge between the pro-democratic and pro-European forces" in the parliament. She defended her government's response to the pandemic, saying that the procurement of vaccines was transparent and "all 27 Member States decided to buy their vaccines on their own will." "There were no secrets, no hidden clauses, no obligation to buy for member states," she told the packed chamber. The EU leader also celebrated the "development of the vaccine in record time" and the "Europe of solidarity" that "the extremists hate." The vote on the motion is destined to fall far short of the two-thirds majority needed to force out Ms von der Leyen's Commission as centrist groups that hold a majority in the parliament have said they will not support it. However, it exposed mounting discontent among Ms von der Leyen's allies in the centrist coalition. Europe's liberals, socialists and democrats and the greens used the opportunity to vent their frustration with the EU leadership. The Commission's move last month to withdraw its proposed law to fight corporate greenwashing after a request from conservative lawmakers, drew a lot of criticism from EPP's coalition partners. The Renew Group leader Valérie Hayer accused Ms von der Leyen of seeking "alliances of convenience with the far right". In her fiery speech, President of the group of Socialists and Democrats Iratxe García Pérez, asked the president whether she wants "to govern with those who want to destroy Europe or those who fight every day to build it?" Among Irish MEPs, there's hardly any support for the initiators of the motion but also enough criticism for Ms von der Leyen's governance. The members of the European People's Party grouping were asked by its leadership to unanimously reject it. As part of it, the Fine Gael delegation said it will be rejecting the motion tabled "by far-right members of the European Parliament in a bid to destabilise the EU for political gain." Barry Andrews, Ireland's MEP in the Renew Group representing Fianna Fáil, called those behind the vote "fascists and neo-fascists", adding that he has "confidence in von der Leyen's management of the pandemic". He will, however, abstain because of the president's "utter silence on the ongoing genocide in Gaza". Cynthia Ní Mhurchú, also from the Renew Group, will be voting against the motion to avoid "the collapse of the Union's leadership … at a critical moment," while adding that Ms von der Leyen must face "political scrutiny" over her "failing to hold Israel to account for its war crimes in Gaza". Aodhan O'Riordan, Labour Party MEP in the group of Socialists and Democrats, called the motion a "fascist stunt," though he didn't vote for the President to be re-elected last year and will abstain. Sinn Féin MEP's Lynn Boylan and Kathleen Funchion said they will be voting to censure Ursula von der Leyen for "refusing to pass sanctions or suspend trade with Israel" and for "militarising the EU."
