When should Detroit expect Alim McNeill and Malcolm Rodriguez to return from injuries?
Despite an overwhelming number of defensive injuries in 2024, almost all the injured players are expected to be ready for the opener on September 7 at Lambeau Field. The exceptions are Alim McNeill and Malcolm Rodriguez who had late-season ACL tears.
Now that the schedule has been released, let's take a look at the specific game that we can expect to see their return. Looking at the return-to-play data of recent NFL players with late-season ACL's, we can anticipate a 10-11 month gap between live game action.
Advertisement
Here are some recent cases. The first date is the ACL injury, the second date is the next appearance in an NFL game, and finally the length of absence.
Jameson Williams 1/10/22 ⟶ 12/4/22 = 10 months + 3 weeks
Kyler Murray 12/12/22 ⟶ 11/12/23 = 11 months
TJ Hockenson 12/24/23 ⟶ 11/3/24 = 10 months + 1 week
Tyler Higbee 1/14/24 ⟶ 12/22/24 = 11 months + 1 week
Talanoa Hufanga 11/19/23 ⟶ 9/22/24 = 10 months
Kendrick Bourne 10/29/23 ⟶ 10/6/24 = 11 months + 1 week
Daniel Jones 11/5/23 ⟶ 9/8/24 = 10 months
Rashan Gary 11/6/22 ⟶ 9/10/23 = 10 months
Von Miller 11/24/22 ⟶ 10/8/23 = 10 months + 2 weeks
If there is significant associated damage (which is not suspected with McNeill or Rodriguez), the timeline can stretch beyond a year:
Jack Conklin (ACL/MCL/PCL/meniscus) 9/10/23 ⟶10/13/24 = 13 months
Nick Chubb (ACL/MCL/meniscus/medial capsule) 9/18/23 ⟶ 10/20/24 = 13 months
For all you eternal optimists, seek inspiration from this former Lion:
Adrian Peterson 12/24/11 ⟶ 9/9/12 = 8 months + 2 weeks
CONCLUSION
Based on recent data, a 10 to 11 month return-to-play is expected. I would expect to see McNeill and Rodriguez closer to the 11-month mark for both player and team reasons. With Rodriguez who is in the final year of his rookie contract, he will still be able to show many games of proof of recovery with a return at the 11-month mark. With McNeill who signed an extension last offseason which carries through 2028, there is no financial/contractual reason to rush a return.
Advertisement
For the team whose goals are firmly planted now in playoff success, a longer recovery timeline increases the chances that both players will be healthy for the end-of-season and playoffs.
OUTLOOK
McNeill ACL - December 15, 2024
Rodriguez ACL - November 28, 2024
Here are their target return games with an 11-month return-to-play:
1: @ GB2: vs CHI3: @ BAL4: vs CLE5: @ CIN6: @ KC7: vs TB8: Bye9: vs MIN - Malcolm Rodriguez10: @ WAS11: @ PHI - Alim McNeill12: vs. NYG13: vs GB14: vs DAL15: @ LAR16: vs PIT17: @ MIN18: @ CHI
This article originally appeared on Lions Wire: When to expect injured Alim McNeill and Malcolm Rodriguez to return
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
25 minutes ago
- USA Today
11 best post-June 1 NFL free agents, from Asante Samuel Jr. to Keenan Allen
11 best post-June 1 NFL free agents, from Asante Samuel Jr. to Keenan Allen June 2 is an important date on the NFL calendar. It's the day players released in the offseason can have their dead salary cap hits spread over the current season and the next. It's also the day players can be signed in free agency without affecting a team's compensatory draft pick formula. The NFL's compensatory pick formula is designed to bolster teams who lose more than they gain in free agency. Compensatory picks are awarded at the end of rounds three, four, five, six and seven based on the value of players lost and the offsetting contracts of veterans signed as free agents. By waiting until June to sign players, teams can maximize the value of losing players in March by bringing in draft assets for the following spring. 1 GLARING WEAKNESS FOR EVERY NFL TEAM: What's your favorite team missing this offseason? That means the Philadelphia Eagles can ensure a mid-draft haul after losing starters Milton Williams, Josh Sweat and Mekhi Becton after their Super Bowl-winning season. The Pittsburgh Steelers can capitalize on their losses and potentially find a starting quarterback (even if he's a 41-year-old media headache who was 2024's 22nd-best passer). The post-June 1 free agent market won't be a spending spree, but it will provide more action than we've seen in the last six weeks of NFL roster building. Let's talk about the best players available late in the free agent process, in no particular order. CB Asante Samuel Jr. 2024 team: Los Angeles Chargers Samuel lacks ideal size as an outside corner (5-foot-10, 180 pounds) and has minimal experience in the slot. Though he's failed to live up to his father's spectacular example, he's been a solid presence who allowed a 87.8 passer rating in coverage (two interceptions, 15 passes defensed, three touchdowns allowed) over the last two seasons. His return from the shoulder injury that ended his 2024 after four games may loom in the heads of general managers considering him. WR Keenan Allen 2024 team: Chicago Bears WR Amari Cooper 2024 team: Cleveland Browns/Buffalo Bills Let's tackle these two former Pro Bowlers at the same time. Both Allen and Cooper had their least productive seasons of their past eight years. But both remained moderately useful on a per-snap basis. Allen's 1.65 yards per route run (YPRR) ranked 50th among 90 qualified wideouts. Cooper's 1.62 ranked 53rd. Allen is more productive. Cooper is younger and more engaged as a blocker. Either brings value as a WR3 type on a one-year deal -- think Adam Thielen in Carolina. But further decline is expected for two players in their 30s who play a position that relies heavily on athleticism. RB J.K. Dobbins 2024 team: Los Angeles Chargers A draft flush with running backs has dented Dobbins' value despite his comeback 2024 campaign. The oft-injured back ran for 905 yards in 13 games last season after totaling only nine games the previous three seasons. While he brings modest value as a receiver, Dobbins' 0.6 rush yards over expected (RYOE) per carry ranked 14th among qualified running backs last season and he's still just 26 years old. S Justin Simmons 2024 team: Atlanta Falcons Laying a bet on a safety who turns 32 in November is a tricky wager. While Simmons wasn't able to keep a streak of All-Pro selections alive in his lone year as a Falcon, he remained a valuable asset against the pass. He knocked down seven passes, intercepted two more and just 57 percent of his targets to be hauled in as the nearest defender. He may no longer be an explosive presence, but he remains a disruptor in the right secondary. CB Mike Hilton 2024 team: Cincinnati Bengals Need a veteran slot corner? Hilton's your huckleberry, even though he took a step backward alongside the rest of a defense that helped get Lou Anarumo fired this offseason. Hilton allowed 75 percent of his targets last season to be caught, which is a troubling trend for an aging veteran. But he's not *that* old (he just turned 31) and he remains a useful asset against the run (46 stops in 257 run snaps last season). A modest bet on a revival could pay out huge. G Brandon Scherff 2024 team: Jacksonville Jaguars Poor Brandon Scherff has only played for two NFL teams in his 10 year career; the Dan Snyder-era Washington Commanders and the Jacksonville Jaguars, whose dysfunction escapes eras and shines like the aurora borealis. He may be removed from his perennial Pro Bowl days, but at 34 years old he can still bring steady play and above-average pass blocking to the offensive line. EDGE Za'Darius Smith 2024 teams: Cleveland Browns, Detroit Lions Smith is entering the Jadeveon Clowney phase of his career, where he inks a one-year deal, gives you six to nine sacks per season and generates some trade interest near the deadline. His pressure rate has hovered around a solid 15 percent each of the last three seasons. CB Shaquill Griffin 2024 team: Minnesota Vikings The success rate for 30-year-old cornerbacks isn't great. Griffin's history of inconsistency doesn't help matters. But he's recorded a passer rating allowed of under 76.0 each of the last two seasons, albeit in much more of a "rotational guy" role than as a lock-solid starter. S Julian Blackmon 2024 team: Indianapolis Colts A market failed to develop for Blackmon after a frustrating 2024 in which his missed tackle and yards per target allowed rates spiked. That's been the case in four of his five NFL seasons, but his 2023 campaign was Pro Bowl worthy (four interceptions, four total missed tackles, a 46.6 passer rating allowed). Now it will only take a modest bet for a team looking to restore him back to pretty-goodness. ST Jalen Reeves-Maybin 2024 team: Detroit Lions How much do you value special teams play -- not from a returner or gunner, but from a linebacker who offers little utility as a defender? Reeves-Maybin saw his tackling and coverage skills decline in a 10-game 2024, but he's an intuitive special teamer who brings high effort to the kicking game and was a 2023 second-team All-Pro as designated special teamer.
USA Today
41 minutes ago
- USA Today
Panthers 2024 Pro Bowl CB Jaycee Horn tabbed as team's 'bounce-back candidate' for 2025
Panthers 2024 Pro Bowl CB Jaycee Horn tabbed as team's 'bounce-back candidate' for 2025 Which Carolina Panthers player is primed to bounce back here in 2025? Well, what about one of their two Pro Bowlers from 2024? (Yup, you read that correctly.) Pro Football Focus contributor Dalton Wasserman recently named one bounce-back candidate for each NFL team, and tabbed cornerback Jaycee Horn for the Panthers. So, yes, even despite securing the first Pro Bowl selection of his career this past season, the fifth-year defender still has room to improve. Wasserman explains: Horn's 2024 season had its ups and downs. On the positive side, he played over 1,000 snaps for the first time in his career and earned a team-high 80.9 run-defense grade. However, he also posted a career-low 59.1 coverage grade. He wasn't helped by a defense that ranked near the bottom of the league across the board. The improvement of his supporting cast — including the addition of safety Tre'Von Moehrig — should benefit Horn as much as anyone. As noted by Wasserman, Horn's 59.1 coverage grade was the worst of his four-year tenure. He earned a 67.4 grade over three games as a rookie in 2021, a 73.2 in 2022 and an 83.0 in 2023. Horn did, however, play in a career-high 15 games in 2024—perhaps the most valuable stat given his early injury history. That availability helped him notch a few more bests in combined tackles (68), tackles for a loss (five), sacks (2.0) and passes defensed (13). Follow @ThePanthersWire on Twitter/X for more Panthers content.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Commanders' roster ranked outside the top 10
The Washington Commanders' 2024 season was nothing short of magical. It was an unexpected result of mixing new ingredients together, ending up with a unicorn instead of a cake. The best possible outcome of combining GM Adam Peters' scouting ability, head coach Dan Quinn's leadership skills, and Jayden Daniels' ability to inspire and elevate the players around him. It wasn't a perfect season, ending at the NFC Championship game, but it was a far cry from winning just three games in the previous season. And, it rekindled the Commanders' fans' hopes that former owner Dan Snyder had previously squashed. Advertisement Peters and the rest of the organization understood the assignment this offseason: solidify the defense, give Daniels more weapons, and protect the quarterback. They've answered all of those questions and, as analyzed by Pro Football Focus, have earned the 11th-best roster in the NFL. The projected starting lineup includes each player's PFF grade from 2024. The Commanders' biggest strength in 2024 was Jayden Daniels. He ranked fifth among all qualified quarterbacks with a 90.6 PFF grade, and he led the league with a 1.5% turnover-worthy play rate, plus forced 52 missed tackles, which led all quarterbacks. As Daniels will return to the Commanders in 2025 (and many years in the future), his presence alone improves the roster dramatically. The additions the Commanders made during the offseason were helpful, too. This article originally appeared on Commanders Wire: PFF doesn't believe the Commanders have a top-10 roster
