Replacement urged for joint housing program
In March, the Canada-Manitoba Housing benefit temporarily stopped accepting requests for funding. It offered a monthly top-up of as much as $422 for a private apartment, on top of employment income assistance.
Officials with both governments confirmed Wednesday that the pause is permanent because the program is fully subscribed.
MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES
Executive director of St. Boniface Street Links, Marion Willis: 'We can't end homelessness without this.'
'The top-up program is the only way to end homelessness. We can't end homelessness without this,' said Marion Willis, executive director of
St. Boniface Street Links.
She said her organization knows of almost a dozen housing units that are empty because people cannot afford the rent. In total, social assistance pays $638 for monthly rent.
'One of the suites we have is $995 for a one-bedroom plus hydro, another is $895 for a one-bedroom plus hydro, and there is a bachelor for $750,' Willis said.
'Nobody on benefits can afford to be in them. This (top-up) benefit allowed them to rent a place for more than $900 per month. When all we have to work with is $638 — and that has to include utilities — we can't do it.'
Willis urged the provincial and federal governments to devise either an enhanced agreement or a new agreement to put a top-up program back in place for new applicants.
She also urged the province to create strict rent control laws so people can continue to afford suites once they move in.
Willis said people who were able to rent a suite based on submitting the top-up application have had to move out when the program suddenly closed for new applications without notice in March.
'It only adds to that sense of hopelessness people feel. As soon as you feel hopeless, the challenges become greater because people give up.'
New Journey Housing executive director Codi Guenther said the program was crucial to getting people into shelter.
Guenther said they have helped 648 households apply for the program since January 2022.
'We see people who can't afford private market rent, whether with low-end jobs or social assistance. Now we have to tell them the heartbreaking news there is no Canada-Manitoba benefit,' she said.
'We heard from clients who signed a lease, thinking they were going to get an extra $350 per month with this program, who then got the letter saying it was closed. That left them with a choice of taking money from food or transportation or they had to move.
'A lot of people need this help.'
The program was created in 2020 by the two levels of government, who promised to spend $154.6 million over eight years, including $17.5 million in the first two years. It was intended to help about 3,300 Manitobans.
'Our government is committed to ensuring that every Canadian has a safe and affordable place to call home,' said Ahmed Hussen, who was the federal families minister at the time.
Heather Stefanson, who was the provincial families minister, said 'our government is committed to providing housing to vulnerable Manitobans throughout our province.'
In June 2023, 923 people were receiving monthly benefits. However, after the then-Tory government raised the maximum top-up benefit to $350 from $250, applicant numbers swelled. One year later, 3,088 Manitobans were receiving it, and a total of 4,677 people were getting it by September 2024.
The program first ran out of money for new applicants last summer, but in September the provincial government added $1.7 million to the pot. The federal government did not put in additional funding.
The money ran out in March and since then only people who have been approved are receiving monthly rent top-ups.
The federal government released an email statement Wednesday: 'In the last year, Manitoba has experienced a significant rise in applicants, which has resulted in their decision to close the program to new intakes. This allows them to strategically focus available CMHB funding for people experiencing or at risk of homelessness.'
NDP MP Leah Gazan, whose Winnipeg Centre riding has some of the poorest people in the country, said the federal government's apparent lack of support for housing is one of the reasons her party announced on Wednesday it wouldn't vote for the throne speech.
Sundays
Kevin Rollason's Sunday newsletter honouring and remembering lives well-lived in Manitoba.
'The federal government needs to come to the table and make sure people are looked after. They go on and on in the House about the housing crisis, but they are not investing the money to get people into dignified homes and mixed kinds of homes that require support,' Gazan said
Provincial Housing Minister Bernadette Smith said she has been working on the problem.
'I recently met with the new federal housing minister to advocate for the renewal of the National Housing Strategy and to emphasize the importance of ongoing funding for housing programs,' Smith said.
'Our government has increased funding for provincial rent programs, including an additional $15 million for rent assistance. We have also allocated $116 million to Manitoba Housing, reversing years of selloffs, cuts and freezes implemented by the previous provincial government.
kevin.rollason@freepress.mb.ca
Kevin RollasonReporter
Kevin Rollason is a general assignment reporter at the Free Press. He graduated from Western University with a Masters of Journalism in 1985 and worked at the Winnipeg Sun until 1988, when he joined the Free Press. He has served as the Free Press's city hall and law courts reporter and has won several awards, including a National Newspaper Award. Read more about Kevin.
Every piece of reporting Kevin produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
42 minutes ago
- CBC
Cumberland House women to travel Sask. spreading awareness of disruption of northern river delta
A group of Indigenous women from from Cumberland House Cree Nation in Saskatchewan say they want to raise awareness of the harmful effects of dams on the Saskatchewan River delta. For generations, the people of Cumberland House Cree Nation, located about 350 kilometres northeast of Saskatoon, have depended on the Saskatchewan River delta, the largest freshwater river delta in North America, stretching 9,700 square kilometres from northeast Saskatchewan into western Manitoba. In June, lawyers for the First Nation in northeastern Saskatchewan filed a statement of claim in Saskatoon Court of King's Bench, alleging the government has failed to uphold its treaty obligations. It names the government of Saskatchewan as the defendant. Now, a group of women calling themselves the Indigenous Saskatchewan Women's Environmental Water Advocacy Keepers Water Movement, or the Iskwewak Movement for short, are planning to travel the province sharing their knowledge of what has happened to the water system. Veronica Favel, one of the water advocates, said the delta is very important for northern people, who use the waterways to get from place to place. "Currently the waters are quite low and the river system is very hard to navigate," she said. She said in some places you come across sandbars, mud bars and rocks more often now because of low waters, which are also impacting land resources and wilderness camps. "It's very hard to navigate through that because of what's going on. It's actually dangerous to be out there if you don't know the waterways." Favel said there needs to be better management of water, because soon there will be no river delta. "We've been saying this for years," she said. "We've had elders that knew prior to this the existence of the dam. They knew that this was gonna have a huge impact, huge destruction. We've had research studies done on the Sask. River delta, which is our homeland, and we know what it's done to not only the environment, but to the animals that feed off it." Denise McKenzie, another water advocate in the Iskwewak movement, said water is essential to everyone for survival. "Water is life, to us it is sacred, and without clean, healthy water, we're done for," she said. McKenzie said the goal is to spread awareness to people all across Saskatchewan. "The way things are going now, we're not going to have a Saskatchewan River delta, especially after they put in the Gardiner Dam's $4-billion project plans they have for the irrigation project. That will be the final blow to the Saskatchewan river." McKenzie was referring to a massive, three-stage irrigation infrastructure plan Premier Scott Moe announced in 2020. Experts have said that a Saskatchewan government-funded report analyzing the costs and benefits of the project showed it is a risky venture that offers, at best, modest gains. The advocates' journey is set to begin on Aug. 4. They plan to drive from the E.B. Campbell dam in northern Saskatchewan, to Danielson Provincial Park, to Rotary Park in Saskatoon, then finally to Wascana Park in Regina. They say they will be doing ceremonies all along the way and speaking about the harmful effects the dams have on the waterway system. "Water is life. Without water nothing lives, and we see the devastation of what is happening," McKenzie said. "We know we have to do something about it. We need these much needed changes, we need to the protection." She said the Cumberland Lake used to be 30 miles (almost 50 kilometres) in length, and 30 to 40 feet deep. Since the establishment of the E.B. Campbell dam in the 1960s, the lake has drastically shrunk, she said. "Today it is less than two miles across, and it's only two feet of water with the rest sludge down below. You can't even go on a nice canoe trip across the lake," she said. Favel said this change is impacting her community's culture and way of life. "We as Indigenous people, we've always lived here and we've always been in connection with the land and what comes with the land.," she said. "We know that without the land or water our culture is going to die. It's a huge part of it. We're connected with all of that, we're the ones that experience it. We live with it, and we have children, grandchildren that are going to live here forever. So we need to do something about it, and that's this is our duty as protectors of water."
CBC
42 minutes ago
- CBC
Environmental groups launch legal campaign to stop Sask. coal plant extension
A group of citizens and climate advocacy groups have filed a court case to stop the Saskatchewan government from maintaining the province's three coal-fired power plants past 2030. Citizens for Public Justice, the Saskatchewan Environmental Society, and three people from Saskatchewan and Manitoba are behind the lawsuit. Represented by Saskatchewan-based environmental lawyer Glenn Wright, they have filed an application for judicial review against the government. "Coal is the dirtiest source of energy that we have. We argue that it has no place in any electricity grid in Canada," said Maryo Wahba, a Climate Justice Policy Analyst at Citizens for Public Justice. "Phasing out coal isn't just policy, it's also a moral imperative." On June 18, Crown Investments Corporation Minister Jeremy Jarrison sent a letter to SaskPower employees informing them of the province's decision to extend the life of the coal plants. They were previously scheduled to be closed by 2030 to help meet Canada's climate goals. The federal government wants to reduce Canada's greenhouse gas emissions to 40 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030, and reach net zero emissions by 2050. Saskatchewan currently has three coal-fired power plants: the Shand and Boundary Dam power stations near Estevan, and the Poplar River power station outside of Coronach. The groups hope for an interim stay to be placed on the province's extension plan until a judicial review. "The Government has not outlined any future process to determine whether such an extension is in the public interest, such as an environmental assessment. They simply made the decision. It is final, and therefore, ripe for judicial review." the plaintiff's court application said. The groups argue that the extension decision was made without sufficient public consultation, breaks federal clean energy regulations, contravenes the safety of future Canadian children under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and damages Canada's reputation as a climate-conscious country. "There are other options for the province," said Robert Halliday, the vice-president of the Saskatchewan Environmental Society. "Thus far SaskPower has not been really on board with taking those opportunities." "Renewable power is the way forward for Saskatchewan." According to the Canadian Energy Regulator, 41 per cent of Saskatchewan's energy generation is produced by coal. Natural gas makes up 44 per cent, while hydro, wind and solar power comprise 15 per cent. There are currently no nuclear power plants providing energy or being built. In his letter to SaskPower in June, Jeremy Harrison said the Saskatchewan government is still committed to the goal of net zero energy generation by 2050. Nevertheless, he said, coal power must be used as future nuclear plants are brought online. The Saskatchewan Government said that as the case is before the courts, it will not be commenting on it.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
As premiers push for more immigration power, experts call for a fact-based debate
Ontario Premier Doug Ford speaks to the media during the 2025 summer meetings of Canada's premiers at Deerhurst Resort in Huntsville, Ont., on Wednesday, July 23, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette OTTAWA — Some premiers say they want to have more local control over the immigration system — but experts say what the system really needs is a national conversation on immigration reform that shores up public support. 'Most of the existing policies have been formulated on the fly without any evidence or serious impact evaluations of what the various classes of immigrants are, how they're performing economically and otherwise,' said Michael Trebilcock, a retired academic and co-author of two books on immigration policy. 'So it's basically research-free.' As the premiers and territorial leaders were wrapping up their three-day meeting in Huntsville, Ont., late last month, they called for an increase to economic immigration levels to fill local labour gaps and said they would use their constitutional powers to seize more control over immigration and issue work permits. Ontario Premier Doug Ford later walked back his vow to issue work permits to asylum seekers. 'Do I want the whole immigration system on the shoulder of the province? No. Would I like to be treated the same way as Quebec? Yes, and so would every other province and territory,' Ford said last Monday. Quebec has its own distinct immigration system through an agreement with the federal government. The province is able to choose who can immigrate to Quebec based on its own criteria, with French language skills being a significant factor. David Piccini, Ontario's immigration minister, said last Monday that the province also wants to see more financial support from Ottawa to help pay for social services strained by a high number of asylum seekers landing in Ontario. Ninette Kelley, a former United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees official and a former member of Canada's Immigration and Refugee Board, said that provincial control over immigration has grown significantly over the last two decades. 'They know what their provinces need today, and they want to make sure they get the labour in that is required to meet those demands,' she said. 'But at the same time, there's been absolutely no evaluation that I can see of how those programs are implemented or what effect they're having.' Trebilcock said the premiers' concerns need to be taken seriously because increased immigration boosts demand for health care and other provincial services. He said that it's 'disturbing' to see Canadians' support for immigration decline in multiple public opinion polls. He said current immigration policies lack broad support and he believes a comprehensive, public review is needed to rebuild that support through evidence-based policies. 'What we see at present is often piecemeal, on-the-fly changes in reaction to particular concerns that have surfaced in the media ... international students, temporary foreign workers,' he said. Kelley said that, instead of a multi-year exercise like a national inquiry, a top-to-bottom immigration system review could be conducted quickly with 'the right people at the table.' Saskatchewan Immigration Minister Jim Reiter told The Canadian Press that he and the other subnational immigration ministers have told Ottawa they want to be seen more as partners in immigration, not stakeholders. 'We need more influence in the decision-making of this because so much of the economic stream needs to be targeted depending on the specific needs of each province,' Reiter said. The federal government last year slashed the number of slots in the Provincial Nominee Program from 110,000 to 55,000 as part of broader efforts to rein in immigration. The program allows provinces and territories to nominate individuals for permanent residence based on their skills and ability to contribute to the economy. Each province and territory has its own set of program streams targeting different types of immigrants based on factors like skills or business experience. Reiter said provincial immigration ministers want to see the Provincial Nominee Program return to its previous levels. He said that while he understands the need to reduce the number of temporary visas, that shouldn't come at the expense of economic immigrants. 'We've had to restrict (the Saskatchewan Immigrant Nominee Program) down to three streams now to a large degree because we just don't have enough spots anymore,' Reiter said. Reiter said that of the 3,600 spots Saskatchewan has for its immigrant nominee program, three-quarters have to go to temporary workers, so the province is prioritizing nominees who work in health care and skilled trades. 'We've got the largest potash mine in the world being built ... just outside of Saskatoon and that company, BHP, every time we meet with them they raise the issue that skilled trades are an issue. So this is having a detrimental effect on economic growth,' he said. Trebilcock said that if provinces are focused on using immigration to strengthen their local labour markets, steps could be taken to make it easier to recognize immigrants' foreign credentials in fields like law and medicine. With federal immigration decisions having provincial consequences, Kelley said, running an effective immigration system requires close collaboration between all levels of government. 'So that speaks to the need for really tight co-operation between the federal government and the provincial government and municipalities, both in the setting of levels and in the housing and medical policies that are currently in place so that we can accommodate those who we're letting in,' she said. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 4, 2025. David Baxter, The Canadian Press
