Competing Otago Port proposals 'frustrating', Minister says
Photo:
123RF
Clutha's mayor says newly announced
funding for an inland port
proposal came out of the blue, despite his efforts to be transparent about a similar project just down the road.
Calder Stewart debuted plans to develop a privately-funded inland port in Milburn just days before the
government announced a multi-million dollar loan
to develop a rail connection between Port Chalmers and a proposed Southern Link Logistics Park in Mosgiel last week.
The Associate Regional Development Minister said local leaders should have created a coordinated regional plan instead of having two nearby competing inland port proposals - Mosgiel and Milburn are less than 50 kilometres away from each other.
Dunedin mayor Jules Radich said he had repeatedly discussed the Mosgiel plan when Clutha's mayor was present.
But Clutha district mayor Bryan Cadogan said he was caught off guard by Friday's Port Otago funding announcement, which was frustrating as his district had been upfront and transparent about the Milburn proposal.
Photo:
Supplied by Calder Stewart
The Calder Stewart proposal was the district's "once in a lifetime project" and had been in the pipeline for at least a decade.
Local leaders including Dunedin's mayor had discussed the project last year, he said.
The Regional Development Minister hadn't been briefed about the Milburn proposal which could have impacted the government's funding decision as it didn't have the whole picture for the region, he said.
Cadogan didn't have any issue with the Port Otago project and didn't believe Calder Stewart intended to seek government funding, instead he was concerned that those local leaders didn't disclose a competing proposal despite his efforts to keep them informed.
He wanted the South to start working in unison.
"If there is a conflict like this, just be transparent. If I put my cards on the table, could you put cards on the table the same way," Cadogan said
Dunedin mayor Jules Radich agreed that it was important for regions to work together, but said he had talked about the Port Otago-Mosgiel plan repeatedly in the Clutha mayor's presence including at the Otago mayoral forum in Queenstown last year.
"I asked for government support of a heavy traffic bypass for Mosgiel to complement the project," Radich said.
"I also think the Mosgiel logistics hub would be a great asset to the meatworks in Balclutha and Ōamaru."
The up to $8.2 million loan for the Port Otago rail connection was earmarked from the Regional Infrastructure Fund, which is run by the government's Regional Economic Development and Investment Unit, Kānoa.
Associate Regional Development Minister and local List MP Mark Patterson said only one project was formally proposed to the government in the end.
It was frustrating there were two competing proposals when they could have worked together to create a cohesive proposal, he said.
He described collaboration in the regions as "absolutely critical", and said the government was expecting that regions would coalesce around an agreed set of projects and priorities.
The Port Otago option also had backing from Fonterra, Silver Fern Farms and KiwiRail so they were confident in their processes and in making the investment, he said.
He believed they could be complementary projects, and said last week's funding announcement wouldn't prevent Calder Stewart from making a funding application in the future if it chose to.
The Regional Development Minister has been contacted for comment.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
How drones could cut Aucklanders' power bills
A partnership between Auckland and Silicon Valley could potentially make Aucklanders' power bills cheaper, or at least help make power lines stronger and repairs after storms faster. Linesmen will still go up the poles, but before they need to, inspectors will be able to do a 45-minute check on what is needed five or six times faster because of a new high-tech eyes on the problem - drones. The drones sport a camera so smart it can ping using a laser to feed maps, listen in with an acoustic tracker for crackling that could presage problems, do thermal imaging and even spot any loose nuts. "I'm not allowed to play with these toys," Vector's chief engineer Andre Botha said. "I'd love to do it. But you know these things are quite complex to fly. You get the experts to do that." The old way - inspectors in their utes, taking photos from the ground of problems 11m in the air - is versus the new way: hovering drones that see from above, then feed all the images back into a machine-learning image analyser GridAware. The system could even tap satellite imagery. Aerial survey technology from drones captures precision images of electrical assets. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ "That is how you drive lower-cost energy delivery without compromising reliability," general manager of US-based company Tapestry, Page Crahan, told RNZ from Silicon Valley. Tapestry was an offshoot of Google/Alphabet's so-called 'moonshot' programme, that five years back began looking at how to use AI to relieve aching pressure on electricity grids. It chose New Zealand for its self-contained island power grid and generation. "Vector and New Zealand have been the first place... hopefully showing folks all around the world what artificial intelligence and great technology can do to drive more reliability," Crahan said. A short case study the partners released on Thursday suggested it worked. It found Vector had doubled its "visibility" of network problems across 150,000 poles from Warkworth to Papakura. In the field, it was even more dramatic. On Kawau Island, inspections that once took 320 hours of "strenuous onsite" work for a team of eight now took about 12 hours, Tapestry said. "In the 35 years that I've been in this industry, this is the biggest advancement in how we will manage our overhead assets," Botha said. Vector will use drones to check on what work is needed before repair crews climb power poles. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi Crahan believed it would make a difference to escalating household power bills . Everyone around the world had this "trifecta" of questions, about price, reliability and increasing electricity supplies, she added. "On the price of power, the way we think about this... is, how can we deliver insights that help the decisionmakers who, you know, are driving their trucks every day, invest[ing] in new equipment, be as efficient as they possibly can?" Of course, she hoped this could change how grids work worldwide; Botha, for his part, said it should at least change how the whole of New Zealand does things. "The quality of the images, the clarity with what we can see, it will help us to forecast the condition and to predict the condition and the future asset health of that asset so much better. "That benefit will flow to customers not only in terms of that we are more efficient as a business, but also that [it] helps with resilience." Vector will use drones to check on what work is needed before repair crews climb power poles. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi It would have made a "huge difference" had Vector had this in the wake of the Auckland anniversary storms and Cyclone Gabrielle two years ago. "It's much faster to send our drones to assess the damage than it is to send out vehicles to drive from pole to pole." The electric AI would bring change to jobs, Botha said. Inspectors once out in utes would more often be in the back-office evaluating the pictures, or redeployed to other tasks. Assets on the ground were a different story. "People are still driving around to look at our transformers, our pillars and our switchgear next to the road," Botha said. And they would still need expert linespeople to straighten up the poles and fix the wires. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Ōtara Flea Market secures five-year licence with longer hours and new conditions
Shoppers and stallholders fill the Ōtara Flea Market, a South Auckland icon now set for longer hours under a new five-year licence. Photo: Supplied / Auckland Council As a beloved South Auckland landmark, the Ōtara Flea Market is known for being rich in Pacific culture and vibrancy, offering food, music, crafts and art. The future of the market looks bright after the Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board approved a new five-year commercial licence during its monthly business meeting on Tuesday. The licence allows Ōtara Markets Limited Partnership to run the Saturday market at 1R Newbury Street, Ōtara, from 5am until 2pm, two hours longer than before. The area will also expand by one row of car parks, allowing for more stallholders. Key conditions of the licence include strict monitoring and reporting on social returns. The operator is expected to promote access for local performing arts groups, ensuring that the market area can also serve as a stage for cultural performances and community expression. Board members also supported a new clause related to corporate social responsibility, which clearly states that the operator is expected to support and enable Māori and Pasifika businesses whenever possible and to align with Auckland Council's zero-waste vision. This includes implementing strategies to reduce carbon emissions in the market's operations and providing regular updates on progress. While there is no direct financial impact on the local board, members recognise that the expansion could positively influence rent when the licensed area is reviewed in the future. They have also requested periodic updates on the annual revenue generated for the Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board. Board members described the new licence as a major step towards ensuring the market continues to deliver both economic and cultural value. The market, first established in the 1970s, is one of Auckland's longest-running open-air community spaces and remains a key hub for Pacific and Māori enterprises. It continues to attract locals and visitors with its multicultural food offerings, fresh produce, and its role as a cultural hub for music and arts. The five-year licence paves the way for stallholders and visitors to enjoy longer hours, more stalls, and a renewed focus on social and environmental initiatives. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Young and vulnerable people more likely be radicalised online
A report out the morning from the Security Intelligence Service has found young and vulnerable people are more likely be radicalised by extremist material online. The third annual Security Threat Environment report says New Zealand is facing the most challenging national security environment of recent times, with foreign interference, espionage, and online radicalisation all highlighted as threats. Much of the report contained similar analysis and threats to the two previously released reports, though the NZSIS noted further deterioration since last year's report. This was largely driven by less stable relationships between states, and increasing levels of polarisation and grievance. Young and more vulnerable people were seen as being particularly at risk of becoming radicalised, with ease of access being a key contributor to the cases brought to NZSIS attention. The Service says the most plausible violent extremist scenario remains a lone actor who has been radicalised online. Chris Wilson is senior lecturer at University of Auckland, and is the programme director of the Master of Conflict and Terrorism Studies. Before joining the university he held professional roles in conflict analysis and prevention with the World Bank and United Nations. Photo: 123rf
