Eskom faces R1 billion penalty in high-stakes Koeberg steam generator dispute
Image: Supplied
Power utility Eskom must pay French nuclear power company Framatome nearly R1 billion in a contractual dispute over the replacement of steam generators at the Koeberg Power Station.
Eskom hauled the company formerly known as Areva to the Western Cape High Court to challenge adjudicator Peter Ramsden's decisions on the merits and the quantum delivered in December 2022 and March 2023, respectively.
The entity's contention was that both decisions were beyond his jurisdiction and failed to apply the rules of natural justice.
On the merits, Eskom complained that Ramsden failed to take into account its submissions, issue a reasoned decision and decide the issues that he was required to decide.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
In addition, Eskom also stated that the adjudicator failed to receive and take into account its response to Framatome's amended claim as well as its submissions when determining the quantum.
Eskom was also unhappy that the adjudicator accepted the amounts in the company's amended claim without having enquired into the supporting documents or the details of the claim, failed to issue a reasoned decision and/or follow the procedure he laid down by himself.
The dispute dates back to 2014 when the parties concluded an agreement to replace the steam generators at Koeberg.
In terms of the contract, Framatome work included the supply and installation of two sets of three replacement steam generators, with one set to be installed in each of the reactor buildings at units one and two at Koeberg during their separate planned outages.
The work of replacing the steam generators can only be performed during maintenance and refuelling outages when the power station is offline and the outages are planned in advance and around Eskom's operational requirements.
Eskom had scheduled the outage dates and planned to replace the steam generators but then twice postponed for a later date.
The power utility then informed Framatome that it would not be continuing with the steam generator replacement work during one of the outages.
However, the company notified Eskom of an event which required it to notify the power supplier of such an event and that it required compensation after the postponement. This was acknowledged by the project manager.
Eskom then unsuccessfully approached the adjudicator, claiming that both decisions were unenforceable as contractual obligations and need not be complied with as he exceeded his powers.
It later filed an application for several declarators, which acting Judge Renata Williams dismissed with costs on Thursday.
Framatome succeeded in its counter-application and Eskom was ordered to pay the company €35,288,582 (about R729 million) exclusive of value-added tax (VAT) and subject to the price adjustment for inflation pursuant to secondary option clause of the contract.
Payment is also pursuant to certain clauses of the contract, interest thereon calculated at the London Interbank Offered Rate applicable at the time for amounts due in other currencies
Additionally, Eskom must pay Framatome more than R256.6m exclusive of VAT and subject to the price adjustment for inflation pursuant to secondary option clause of the contract and pursuant to certain clauses including interest.
The power utility was also ordered to pay the costs of Framatome's counter application including the costs of the company's France-based attorneys.
'There is no basis to set aside the decisions of the adjudicator which are valid and binding. In terms of the parties' contract Eskom was obliged to comply therewith,' acting Judge Williams ruled.
Eskom spokesperson Daphney Mokwena did not respond to requests for comment on Saturday.
loyiso.sidimba@inl.co.za
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
an hour ago
- The South African
Bye bye MultiChoice: R53 billion takeover by French media giant Canal+ approved
French media giant Canal+ has received regulatory approval from South Africa's Competition Tribunal to proceed with its multibillion-rand takeover of MultiChoice, paving the way for one of the most significant media mergers on the African continent. The deal, valued at around R53 billion, will see Canal+ acquire full control of MultiChoice, best known for its DStv and Showmax platforms. While the approval from the Competition Tribunal is a major milestone, the merger still needs clearance from other regulatory bodies, including Icasa, the JSE, the Takeover Regulation Panel, and the Financial Surveillance Department. 'It is a hugely positive step forward in our journey to bring together two iconic media and entertainment companies,' said Canal+ in a statement. As part of the approval, the Tribunal imposed conditions designed to protect South African interests: Ongoing investment in local sports and general entertainment content. Measures to support Historically Disadvantaged Persons (HDPs) and SMEs in the local broadcasting sector. Guarantees to maintain South Africa's influence over content and access decisions through the continued independence of MultiChoice (Pty) Ltd, which services local subscribers. 'We look forward to executing the remaining processes and to building something extraordinary – a global media and entertainment company with Africa at its heart,' said Calvo Mawela, CEO of MultiChoice Group. Despite the approval, Canal+ and MultiChoice must still navigate legal and policy hurdles, including South Africa's laws on foreign ownership of broadcasters. As part of the transaction structure, MultiChoice's South African business will be carved out and maintained independently to comply with these restrictions. Customers and viewers are not expected to be affected during the ongoing approval process, and both companies have committed to maintaining current services. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
SMME focus: Why storytelling is the secret weapon of SA's small businesses
South Africa's small businesses face a market obsessed with speed and scale, yet some are thriving by leaning into craft, storytelling, and human connection. In a studio in Woodstock, Cape Town, a group of women crochet hats from hemp and cotton, their movements slow and deliberate. Months later, those same hats sit in a Dior lookbook, worn by models striding Paris runways. This is the improbable story of Earth Age, a business that began with three friends during lockdown and ended up collaborating with one of the most recognisable names in fashion. Their story is also a blueprint for small business in South Africa trying to make sense of a market that rewards sameness and speed over meaning and craft. The fight for value The 'never say die' spirit of a small business is often romanticised. The reality is that the market is tough and only getting tougher. Consultancy company Kantar's annual Mzansi Consumer Barometer tracks national consumer behaviour. Its latest findings show that South Africans are concerned about unemployment, corruption, crime, spiralling living costs, and load shedding. The survey also found that household income was unpredictable in our country, as the sources of income varied from month to month, making it difficult for businesses to plan sales, said Stacey Saggers, commercial growth director at Kantar. When the money does come in, it doesn't stretch far. South Africans are consuming less essential items, Saggers added. Consumers are cutting back on things like luxury food items, alcohol, entertainment, going out and clothing. Lurking in the background are juggernauts like Shein and Temu, peddling fast fashion at prices local makers can't dream of matching. According to Saggers, 75% of South Africans surveyed have shopped on these platforms, and 48% admitted to doing so more in the last year than the one before. Against this backdrop selling a R1,500 handmade jacket feels almost reckless, until you understand the industry shift that's modifying perceptions of value. Story as currency 'People want to purchase something more than just a piece of product. I think it adds value to it when they understand that it comes with so much meaning.' These are the words of Harmonie Mbunga, founder of apparel and accessory brand Udo & Harmony. She observed that customers were initially drawn to the beauty and craftsmanship of her products, and upon learning the story behind them, discovered 'so much more meaning'. This wasn't always the case. Erica Elk, CEO of the Craft and Design Institute (CDI), recalled that 24 years ago, when the CDI was established, there was an expectation that craft products should be cheap because they were made by hand. 'What we tried to do as an organisation with the businesses that we supported was actually to shift that narrative,' she said. 'To say that because they're made by hand, and because they're an expression of an individual person and their creativity, you should be paying more.' The market would respond, she argued. 'Somebody is going to come in and they're not going to want to pay the price, but there will be customers that will come and they will appreciate the quality and the position and the value.' Elk said this was because craft and design weren't products, but rather the 'process of making'. 'When you understand that it's a process of making, then you're opening up market opportunities.' Lessons from the frontlines Brands like Hannah Lavery know this firsthand. In the early days, Lavery's clothes hung on racks in the V&A's Watershed, a Cape Town craft and design marketplace. Their first year was challenging, Lavery said, as the Watershed was a new space and their product 'wasn't that cheap'. Her persistence, however, paid off. 'We gradually got traction and we figured out our product and our messaging,' she said. Before Covid-19, Lavery's online store was an afterthought. 'We knew it was important to have one,' Lavery said, 'but we never actually had any sales come through.' Sometimes it was only one order every three months. Lockdown forced a pivot to online, and with it, a new approach. Lavery stepped in front of the camera. 'I got in front of the camera and, through our social media channels, told the story of what we are and what we do and who my team is.' That human connection led to the growth of her brand and its sales. Luck, strategy and a Dior email Earth Age's founders, Elektra Georgiadis, Ashley Wagner and Amy Kunz, began with restless ambition, dabbling in everything from apparel to homeware before finding their lane. 'We realised, hold on a second, this is impossible! We need to hone in on one product and figure that out,' Georgiadis explained. They chose sustainability as their anchor, reaching for hemp and cotton and making hats their hero product. The hats are crafted by a team of Zimbabwean women using techniques passed down through generations. Then came an email that looked a lot like spam: Dior wanted to collaborate. 'We got this message from someone saying they're from Dior… We all thought we were being scammed,' Georgiadis recalled. The collaboration has propelled Earth Age to explore international markets, now selling their products in London. Winning in a digital world Today, countless small brands are lost in an algorithm-fed blur of sameness. This is because online engagement is exploding. 'Instant messaging and email as well as online video and social networks are absolutely ridiculously getting bigger and bigger every single year,' Saggers said. Podcasts are booming too. In South Africa, one in four people listened to a podcast daily, Saggers said, and 55% listened to a podcast weekly. For small businesses, this could translate into opportunity. 'If you can find a podcast that mirrors what you do with your brand, you have a very big opportunity to amplify awareness of your brand and position yourself as an expert,' she said. The opportunity here was agility. Big brands couldn't do what smaller businesses could, Sagger said. 'They will nod and nod… but none of them change their behaviour. They can't do it because there are too many sign-offs that need to happen, and there's too much risk to their brands to do anything adventurous or entertaining.' Where the opportunities lie Nearly half of South Africans believe the country will be in better shape in five years, Kantar's survey found. Two-thirds expect their personal finances to improve within the next 12 months. That optimism creates a window for the brands that can articulate why they matter. 'There's a juggling act,' Saggers noted as consumers balanced essentials with small indulgences. They would down-trade in some categories to spend on what they truly loved. According to her, the solution was to provide a 'meaningful difference'. In a hyperinflationary environment, consumers would pay up to 14% more for brands they believed in, Saggers added. In South Africa, local mattered. Unlike some African markets, Saggers said, 'Made in South Africa' signalled artisanal, sustainable and something to be proud of. Paired with meaning and digital fluency, it was a potent differentiator. DM
The Citizen
5 hours ago
- The Citizen
No fines or penalties over Koeberg delays, Eskom says
The two disputes stem from the Steam Generator Replacement Project of Unit 2 at Koeberg Nuclear Power Station. Eskom has sought to clarify that two contractual disputes with Framatome, the contractor for the Steam Generator Replacement Project at the Koeberg nuclear power station, are being addressed through agreed resolution processes. The two disputes stem from the Steam Generator Replacement Project of Unit 2 at Koeberg Nuclear Power Station, which has now seen significant progress, following problems that contributed to a bout of stage 3 load shedding in March. Steam generators Framatome had taken over the contract to supply and install replacement generators at the power plant's two reactor buildings from Areva NP in 2018. The recent Long-Term Operation (LTO) programme for Unit 2 included the replacement of three steam generators, extensive inspections, and refuelling activities, ensuring continued safe and efficient performance. ALSO READ: Koeberg Unit 2 back online, but what caused the 'unplanned' trip? Eskom needed to replace the plant's six steam generators – three in each of its two units – to prolong its life by another 20 years. Media reports Eskom issued a statement on 21 July, following media reports, that the utility had been ordered by the high court to pay more than R1 Billion to Framatome over delays to the Steam Generator Replacement Project at Koeberg. According to reports, the Western Cape High Court agreed with the findings of an adjudicator who investigated the delays two and a half years ago, ruling that Eskom was at fault for the stoppage of work and had to pay for breaching its contract. Disputes The utility's spokesperson, Daphne Mokwena, said the two disputes were adjudicated between December 2022 and February 2023. Mokwena said in accordance with the contract, disputes are first referred to adjudication and, if not resolved, to arbitration. 'As Eskom was not satisfied with the adjudicator's decisions, the two matters were escalated to arbitration as per the agreed process. The arbitration was held from June to July 2025, and a decision is expected in the last quarter of Eskom's financial year. ALSO READ: Load shedding: Hiccup in Eskom's power plans 'Recent media reports appear to have mixed separate legal processes. To clarify, no new payments are currently due, and all actions taken by Eskom have been in line with the applicable legal and contractual procedures,' Mokwena said. Disagreement Mokwena added that although Eskom disagreed with the adjudicator's decisions, the utility complied with the requirement to implement the outcome and made payments in the interim. 'All payments had been made by March 2024 as part of standard contract processes—not as penalties or fines. At the same time, in March 2023, Eskom approached the Cape High Court to have the adjudicator's decisions set aside due to procedural irregularities.' Mokwena said the court only delivered its judgment on 17 July 2025, over a year late. 'Eskom is currently reviewing the judgment to determine the appropriate next steps. We encourage the public and media to trust the integrity of this process. Eskom is following the proper legal channels to resolve these matters responsibly, and we remain committed to transparency and accountability throughout. 'Most importantly, despite these disputes, the core technical work, replacing the steam generators on Koeberg Unit 2, has been completed. This is a major milestone that contributes to the safe and extended operation of the power station, helping to ensure energy security for the country,' Mkowena said. Eskom stated that it anticipates a decision on the arbitration hearing in the last quarter of its financial year. Koeberg Koeberg's units 1 and 2 have undergone life extension exercises. In July last year, the National Nuclear Regulator (NNR) granted Eskom a licence to continue operating Koeberg Nuclear Power Station Unit 1 until 21 July 2044. As a result, Koeberg Unit 1 is expected to contribute over 930MW to the grid for another 20 years,' Mokwena said. ALSO READ: Eskom takes action after breach of online vending system
