Eskom faces R1 billion penalty in high-stakes Koeberg steam generator dispute
Image: Supplied
Power utility Eskom must pay French nuclear power company Framatome nearly R1 billion in a contractual dispute over the replacement of steam generators at the Koeberg Power Station.
Eskom hauled the company formerly known as Areva to the Western Cape High Court to challenge adjudicator Peter Ramsden's decisions on the merits and the quantum delivered in December 2022 and March 2023, respectively.
The entity's contention was that both decisions were beyond his jurisdiction and failed to apply the rules of natural justice.
On the merits, Eskom complained that Ramsden failed to take into account its submissions, issue a reasoned decision and decide the issues that he was required to decide.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
In addition, Eskom also stated that the adjudicator failed to receive and take into account its response to Framatome's amended claim as well as its submissions when determining the quantum.
Eskom was also unhappy that the adjudicator accepted the amounts in the company's amended claim without having enquired into the supporting documents or the details of the claim, failed to issue a reasoned decision and/or follow the procedure he laid down by himself.
The dispute dates back to 2014 when the parties concluded an agreement to replace the steam generators at Koeberg.
In terms of the contract, Framatome work included the supply and installation of two sets of three replacement steam generators, with one set to be installed in each of the reactor buildings at units one and two at Koeberg during their separate planned outages.
The work of replacing the steam generators can only be performed during maintenance and refuelling outages when the power station is offline and the outages are planned in advance and around Eskom's operational requirements.
Eskom had scheduled the outage dates and planned to replace the steam generators but then twice postponed for a later date.
The power utility then informed Framatome that it would not be continuing with the steam generator replacement work during one of the outages.
However, the company notified Eskom of an event which required it to notify the power supplier of such an event and that it required compensation after the postponement. This was acknowledged by the project manager.
Eskom then unsuccessfully approached the adjudicator, claiming that both decisions were unenforceable as contractual obligations and need not be complied with as he exceeded his powers.
It later filed an application for several declarators, which acting Judge Renata Williams dismissed with costs on Thursday.
Framatome succeeded in its counter-application and Eskom was ordered to pay the company €35,288,582 (about R729 million) exclusive of value-added tax (VAT) and subject to the price adjustment for inflation pursuant to secondary option clause of the contract.
Payment is also pursuant to certain clauses of the contract, interest thereon calculated at the London Interbank Offered Rate applicable at the time for amounts due in other currencies
Additionally, Eskom must pay Framatome more than R256.6m exclusive of VAT and subject to the price adjustment for inflation pursuant to secondary option clause of the contract and pursuant to certain clauses including interest.
The power utility was also ordered to pay the costs of Framatome's counter application including the costs of the company's France-based attorneys.
'There is no basis to set aside the decisions of the adjudicator which are valid and binding. In terms of the parties' contract Eskom was obliged to comply therewith,' acting Judge Williams ruled.
Eskom spokesperson Daphney Mokwena did not respond to requests for comment on Saturday.
loyiso.sidimba@inl.co.za
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
7 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Who will steer the R55bn marriage of MultiChoice and Canal+?
There's a new power couple in African media. After nearly five years of courting, Canal+ has finally put a ring on MultiChoice to form a pan-African content colossus with global ambitions. French media titan Canal+ has secured the final go-ahead to acquire MultiChoice in a landmark R55-billion deal. After years of quiet manoeuvring and regulatory hurdles, the merger is now a question of who controls what. The Competition Tribunal's conditional approval, granted late last week, closes the chapter on a five-year 'creeping takeover' and opens a new era in African broadcasting. Now it's a balancing act weighing foreign capital with national sovereignty on a digital scale with local content. Enter the media monarchy In return for its princely sum, Canal+, owned by the French conglomerate Vivendi, gets access to MultiChoice's 14.5 million Anglophone and Lusophone subscribers, the DStv powerhouse, sports juggernaut SuperSport, and a foothold in streaming via Showmax. MultiChoice, facing rising costs and subscriber declines, finds itself rescued by a suitor with deep pockets and pan-African ambition. Combined, the merged entity will serve more than 24 million subscribers across 50 countries — instantly becoming the largest pay-TV and streaming provider on the continent. However, if Canal+ was hoping for free access, South African regulators had other plans. The deal's approval came wrapped in layers of red tape — not as a deterrent, but as a deliberate design feature. Transformation goals Central to the regulatory conditions is the creation of LicenceCo, an independent company that will hold MultiChoice South Africa's broadcast licence. It will be majority-owned and controlled by historically disadvantaged South Africans and employees. Crucially, Canal+ has no control and no board seats. This structural firewall protects South Africa's legal requirements around media ownership, ensures transformation goals are met and serves as a template for foreign investment in other sensitive sectors. Phuthuma Nathi, the B-BBEE shareholder darling, increases its economic interest in LicenceCo to 27%, with a new employee trust added. The licence, and the local airwaves it governs, stay South African. The R30bn lobola The Competition Tribunal didn't just demand structural separation; it also extracted a commitment package valued at more than R30-billion. This includes: A three-year moratorium on retrenchments linked to the merger; Significant investment in local content production, sports broadcasting, SMME procurement and Corporate Social Investment programmes; Ongoing free-to-air broadcast access for key sporting events, safeguarding the public's ability to view major matches without a subscription; and Local skills development through Canal+'s 'University Programme', to train historically disadvantaged individuals in broadcasting and production. In a media environment where Netflix and Amazon Prime are increasingly dominant, this local-first approach is designed to future-proof South African media. Showmax, SuperSport and scale Behind the regulatory muscle lies a clear commercial imperative. MultiChoice has struggled in recent years, shedding 2.8 million linear subscribers and burning cash to prop up Showmax 2.0, its streaming reboot built on Comcast tech and bolstered by NBC Universal's 30% equity stake. Canal+ brings financial stability and scale. It also inherits Irdeto, MultiChoice's profitable cybersecurity unit, and Showmax's potential to become Africa's answer to global streamers. Vivendi, Canal+'s parent company, views this merger as critical to its own transformation and part of a plan to split into three listed entities, with Canal+ as its global growth engine. Listing Canal+ on the JSE within nine months of deal completion is a further nod to local inclusion, visibility, and capital market confidence. The shiny ring can't cover controversial holes While South Africa celebrates a structurally sound deal with tangible local benefits, not all observers are convinced. Critics warn that Canal+'s track record and the Bolloré Group's 30.4% stake in it come with baggage. Vivendi's past includes one of the largest corporate losses in history and regulatory infractions that still cast a shadow. Vincent Bolloré, the billionaire behind the curtain, faces corruption charges in France and has been accused of turning Canal+'s French media outlets into right-wing political mouthpieces. With Canal+ now embedded in South Africa's broadcasting ecosystem, some fear creeping influence over editorial independence, particularly if there are future attempts to deepen ownership or control beyond the current firewall. Marriage isn't buying a horse Mergers are easy to announce but hard to manage. However, the competition bodies have played their hand cleverly — extracting commitments, safeguarding jobs and setting a precedent for how global capital must behave when it enters South Africa's strategic sectors. The long-term test lies ahead. Can Showmax truly compete with Netflix? Can SuperSport keep its sports crown as global streamers outbid for rights? Will LicenceCo be a transformative force or a regulatory box-ticker? Will Canal+ respect the firewall, or try to chip away at it over time? The merged entity is now king of the hill in African broadcasting, but it's a kingdom that won't run on size alone. Trust, execution and transformation will be the currencies of success. DM
Daily Maverick
7 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Mozambique's Cahora Bassa Dam expansion plan offers Eskom a fresh clean energy option
The Mozambican government-owned hydroelectric power company is looking at Eskom as a potential customer for the additional 1,245MW generation capacity that it plans to add to its existing plant at the Cahora Bassa Dam. Eskom is already the biggest client of the Hidroeléctrica de Cahora Bassa (HCB), the company that operates the Cahora Bassa Dam plant, with about 60% of the power generated at the dam travelling more than 1,400km on two parallel power lines between Cahora Bassa in Songo, northern Mozambique and the Apollo substation near Pretoria. Cahora Bassa has a 2,075MW generation capacity, and the Mozambican government is in discussions with the World Bank to raise money for the expansion of the dam's northern bank and the construction of a new hydropower plant at the Mphanda Nkuwa Dam. The latter dam is downstream from Cahora Bassa, also along the same Zambezi River, and is expected to generate 1,500MW of clean energy. The expansion of the Cahora Bassa Dam scheme has received the backing of the World Bank and will increase generation capacity through the installation of three turning turbines – each generating 415MW. The projects are estimated to cost more than $6-billion. With Eskom under pressure to keep the grid stable while trying to meet obligations to use cleaner energy sources, the power utility's spokesperson Daphne Mokwena told Daily Maverick that HCB's plans were in line with Eskom's mandate. 'One of Eskom's mandates is to ensure a reliable, sustainable and clean energy grid for the country. Eskom will review all HCB plans for future growth and give feedback once all the relevant details have been presented,' she said. Mozambique has its own challenges as it has to meet its domestic electricity demand and has set a target of 2030 to meet this need. According to the World Bank 2023 figures, only 36% of the Mozambican population had access to electricity, compared with 87.7% in South Africa. In February 2024, Bloomberg reported – based on an unpublished energy transition strategy – that the Mozambican government intended to end the partnership with Eskom when the contract expired in December 2030. Eskom said talks on the matter were yet to be concluded. Said Mokwena: 'As the discussions are ongoing, there has been no conclusion on this matter. Eskom is therefore not able to comment on this question at this stage'. However, Mokwena stressed that while Eskom continues to buy power from HCB, the utility 'will continue to rely on its own generation fleet'. 'Notably, the returned 800MW from Medupi Unit 4, the additional new 800MW capacity from Kusile Unit 6, and the planned return of 930MW from Koeberg Unit 1 by August 2025 will significantly boost available capacity,' she said. The 50-year-old Cahora Bassa Dam scheme is a Mozambican government flagship and was showcased to World Bank President Ajay Banga, who visited Mozambique last week. Banga was the guest of Mozambican President Daniel Chapo, who is driving the development of Mozambique's untapped energy sources. The 48-year-old Chapo (the governing party, Frelimo's, candidate) was elected president following the disputed October 2024 elections. The development of the war-ravaged country is at the centre of his plans. Ambitious renewable energy plans Chapo said the main objective of the World Bank's visit was to identify areas of possible investment in the country's energy plans. 'Mozambique has a geographic location that allows for wind farms, so we are currently working with the World Bank Group, through the IFC (International Finance Corporation) which is part of the World Bank Group. 'We can have a public-private partnership, who can come and invest in this entire energy matrix we're talking about – producing electricity through hydroelectric plants, solar plants, gas plants, and also wind farms,' said Chapo. Speaking after a tour of Cahora Bassa, Banga said Mozambique had the potential of becoming the 'energy powerhouse' of southern Africa. 'Frankly, in this part of Africa, nobody has the capacity or capability to do what can be done with the assets of this country. 'We are discussing with the government of Mozambique the idea of investing in another 1,500MW downstream from (Cahora Bassa). 'And then in the meantime, we're also doing some investing in solar capacity, 400MW. And then (Chapo) has some master plans, which I think are even more interesting in terms of adding more capacity (at Cahora Bassa) and renovating this plant and then adding further downstream,' said Banga. Cahora Bassa is a major contributor to the Mozambican economy. It generated $547-million in revenue in 2024 and contributed $302-million to the southern African country's fiscus in the same year. HCB CEO Tomás Matola said that while they continued to make a major contribution to the Mozambican economy, the age of the plant was a threat to its revenue plans. He told the World Bank's Banga that they needed to refurbish Cahora Bassa's generators to future-proof the plant. Said Matola: 'From the supply side, our big challenge is because of the age of our equipment. It is 50 years old, so all our equipment is obsolete, so now we need to do a deep rehabilitation of our power plant and substations.' Southern Africa presently has a shortage of 10,000MW, while Mozambique plans to increase its power generation for the benefit of the domestic and the regional market. 'In Mozambique, we do have a challenge of electrification of all the country… So we have increasing demand from the domestic market, but also the regional market,' said Matola. 'As we need to diversify our power matrix, we have a project for producing 400MW of photovoltaic power. We believe that by 2027, we can start building this project,' said Matola, adding that HCB's vision was to generate 4,000MW of clean energy by 2034. The plans for the 400MW solar power plant include the construction of two solar farms with 200MW generation capacity each. Climate change threat to cleaner energy projects While there is a global drive towards renewable energy and less reliance on fossil fuel energy sources, such as coal, cleaner energy sources are not without challenges. For instance, Cahora Bassa's generation capacity has been adversely affected by the drought that has gripped countries along the Zambezi River. The dam's levels are currently at 25%, meaning that water management techniques have to be applied to maintain the flow through the five generators – thus reducing power generation. According to engineers at HCB, that is the lowest level the dam has reached in its 50-year history. That means Eskom has been getting less power from the plant. This was confirmed by Eskom spokesperson Daphne Mokwena, who said that the power utility had received 45% less electricity from Cahora Bassa than the previous year. 'Cyclically, southern Africa is affected by droughts, and Eskom's supply from HCB has been affected. During the droughts, Eskom relies on its own generation fleet. 'Eskom is receiving less power from HCB as compared to the previous year, due to the drought currently affecting the SADC region. The average loss of power is 45% when compared to last year,' said Mokwena. Cahora Bassa Dam is built on the Zambezi River, which flows through six countries – namely Zambia, Angola, Namibia, Botswana, Zimbabwe and then joins the Indian Ocean in Beira, northern Mozambique. The drought in the SADC region has seen levels at Kariba Dam – between Zimbabwe and Zambia – reach an alarming level of about 11% last year. According to the Zambezi River Authority, the Lake Kariba water levels were sitting at 24.3% on 14 July 2025, compared with 11.5% recorded on the same date in 2025. In July 2023, Kariba's levels were at 31%. However, while the levels have improved at Kariba, the benefits have yet to be realised downstream at Cahora Bassa, as the former is not releasing much water as it is still recovering from the lower levels. Fast facts on Cahora Bassa The construction of the dam took place between 1969 and 1974, resulting in the biggest hydroelectric power plant in southern Africa. Power is generated by water passing through five vertical generator units – each producing 415MW and a total of 2,075MW. Eskom is HCB's biggest client, buying 58% of the power generated at the plant, while 39% goes to the Mozambican state-owned energy company – 3% is sold to the Zimbabwean power utility. The staff complement at HCB consists of Mozambican citizens, with 741 permanent workers and 685 seasonal workers. Another 2,000 indirect workers benefit from the plant, through its suppliers. *Source: Hidroeléctrica de Cahora Bassa (HCB) World Bank Group structure The World Bank Group comprises five organisations that specialise in differing areas, namely: The World Bank, whose official name is the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, which lends to low- and middle-income countries; The International Development Association, which also lends to low-income countries The International Finance Corporation, which lends to the private sector; The Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency, which 'encourages' private companies to invest in foreign countries; and The International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes, which mediates disputes between private investors and foreign countries. DM Sibusiso Ngalwa is a journalist, a cabbage farmer and a breeder of boer goats. His trip was sponsored by the Hidroeléctrica de Cahora Bassa (HCB), the company that operates the Cahora Bassa plant.
IOL News
8 hours ago
- IOL News
Leaked affidavit exposing Landiwe Ntlokwana's involvement in a multi-million rand scheme
According to the affidavit, Ntlokwana managed investor data, tracked payments, and even used her company's bank account — GTT Wealth (Pty) Ltd — to receive millions of rands from individuals drawn into Bushiri's now-notorious commodities investment platform. Image: Supplied A leaked affidavit has exposed Landiwe Ntlokwana, a former auditor and financial coordinator for Prophet Shepherd Bushiri, as a key figure in a multi-million rand investment scheme — and strongly suggests she is using her testimony under Section 204 of the Criminal Procedure Act in a strategic bid to escape prosecution. According to the affidavit, Ntlokwana managed investor data, tracked payments, and even used her company's bank account — GTT Wealth (Pty) Ltd — to receive millions of rands from individuals drawn into Bushiri's now-notorious commodities investment platform. Her phone, she claims, was used by multiple committee members as the central point of contact for investor communication. 'The committee and I continued our administrative duties as described previously. My phone continued being passed around for whoever wanted to focus on that function,' she said. With a strong background in Microsoft Excel, Ntlokwana took responsibility for consolidating all investor information into a single master file, which she says was used by the IT team for internal reporting and to generate investor statements. The affidavit details the rapid expansion of the scheme and growing unrest within the church community. Ntlokwana describes how popularity surged beyond South Africa's borders, leading to complaints from international followers of Bushiri's Enlightened Christian Gathering Church who felt excluded from the opportunity. 'They started saying what was the point of belonging to a community where only a select few can participate in empowerment initiatives,' she said. These concerns, she claims, were taken directly to response, Ntlokwana says Bushiri called a closed-door meeting with her and five other women in his inner circle — Gladness, Rosemary, Shirley, Jumoke, and Memory. During the meeting, Bushiri announced the launch of a new investment round: Commodities Trade Cycle 3. This phase, however, was exclusive to high-net-worth individuals, with a minimum investment of R1 million. Despite her corporate background at firms like Grant Thornton and Allan Gray, Ntlokwana admits there were no formal contracts governing her role. Legal experts find this highly questionable. 'She's not an amateur. She knows how finance works,' said a senior investigator. 'The absence of contracts and the use of her company account are not rookie mistakes — they point to direct involvement.'Under Section 204, an accused may be granted immunity in exchange for full and truthful testimony. ''But such a deal hinges on credibility — something that could be Ntlokwana's biggest hurdle.'She handled the money, the records, and the investor lists,' the investigator continued. 'Now she's trying to claim she was just assisting — but this affidavit proves she was in control.' With Bushiri still in Malawi and his extradition proceedings stalled, Ntlokwana's testimony could close the case but she if found to be self-serving or unreliable, the prosecution could be left with little to stand on
