Peter van Onselen: Australia can breathe easy after Greens go for the blandest option in Larissa 'Still' Waters
The country has dodged a bullet, thanks to the Greens. While that's not a sentence you'll hear very often, this week it's true.
The party room of 12 wise disciples representing the minor party in federal parliament has shunned the firebrand deputy leader Mehreen Faruqi.
Instead, they favoured Queensland Senator Larissa Waters as its new leader, to replace Adam Bandt who lost his seat of Melbourne at the election.
While the Greens would have been wiser to pick Sarah Hanson Young for the role, Waters is a comfortable lesser of evils compared with Faruqi who as deputy leader was in the box seat to take over from Bandt.
She's a radical who would have dragged the activist minor party even further to the left, taking it further away from its environmental roots to advocate for issues appealing to only a very narrow band of the Australian population.
Prior to Thursday's partyroom decision on its new leader, I flagged the litany of the extreme policy positions Faruqi has spruiked over the years.
She's backed everything from refusing to agree terrorist group Hamas should be disbanded, to claiming in 2024 that the Labor government was 'complicit in Israel's genocide', to wanting the Lord's Prayer removed from parliamentary proceedings.
When the Queen passed away she even pointedly noted: 'I cannot mourn the leader of a racist empire built on stolen lives, land and wealth of colonised peoples'.
Now that the Greens hold the balance of power in the senate all in their own right, a period of Faruqi leading the minor party would have made it near impossible for Labor to govern from the centre.
Waters is unlikely to follow a similar path. She's shown a willingness during her career to negotiate with colleagues from the major parties. Just as importantly she's been prepared to enter those negotiations with an air of civility.
The fact that the Greens partyroom struggled to build consensus around its choice of a new leader speaks to how divisive Faruqi can be.
Even her own partyroom was divided about her penchant for extremism and what it might do to the Greens' brand after an election result which saw its primary vote slip and a host of lower house seats be lost.
And that was under Bandt's leadership - a less radical version of Faruqi.
The challenge for Waters will now be to keep her partyroom together and avoid Faruqi and her supporters going rouge.
The minor party encourages free votes from time to time and its entirely possible defections follow Thursday's announcement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
15 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Matildas usher in new era after key interim role is filled perfectly by Tom Sermanni
One of the key themes of the past week for the Matildas has been a sense of serendipity. On Friday, Tom Sermanni's 150th fixture in charge of the national team was marked by Kahli Johnson's goal in a 2-0 win over Argentina, as the debutante became the latest in the long line of players whose international journey has started with the veteran coach. On Monday, the final game of Sermanni's tenure was played hours after Joe Montemurro was formally unveiled as the team's next full-time coach. Montemurro watched on from the stands of GIO Stadium as he begun preparations for the first games of his reign later this month. After coaching the Matildas across four separate decades, his final hitout in charge came in the same city where his coaching career began back in the 1980s. As one era ended, a player hoping to play a key role in the next demanded the attention of the incoming boss during the second game against Argentina. In her first start for 549 days, Amy Sayer grabbed a first-half brace to help steer the Matildas towards a 4-1 win in Canberra, before Emily van Egmond and hometown hero Michelle Heyman put the result beyond doubt. With Sermanni's third stint in charge of the Matildas now over, focus now turns to what comes next. As the 70-year-old himself reflected, his three stints in charge have intersected with the major eras of this team, and while he is too self-effacing to acknowledge it, that means stories of the Matildas cannot be told without him. He was there when the modern Matildas program was being established in 1993, and when Australian football made its move to Asia, before laying down a marker of what was to come with a continental crown in 2010. During his latest stint in charge, he was offered a chance to experience a team he had been so instrumental in building, after it had ascended to being something more. The 25,125 fans in Canberra – a record for a women's sporting event in the Australian capital – was testament to this. 'Back in the days when you'd essentially get family and friends to come to games, you dreamt of stuff like this' Sermanni told Paramount. 'It's just a dream come true.' It's this history that made his appointment as an interim such a key one. Not just because he deserved an opportunity to bask in the glow that exists around the side, but also because his willingness to do whatever is in the team's best interests – demonstrated across multiple decades – is indisputable. When he walked back in the door last October, he described the atmosphere that greeted him as being akin to 'turning up at a funeral' following a disastrous Paris Olympics. Combining an existing relationship with much of the squad and an unimpeachable record of service with a humble lack of ambition to make this anything permanent, he filled the temporary role perfectly. Yet, the results against the biggest nations weren't there. And the effects of an extended period of limbo as Football Australia's search for a permanent coach continued were clear to everyone during three games in February. While he did his best to bring through new talent and prepare the side for what was to come, as a caretaker there was a limit to his authority. Outside of the retired Clare Polkinghorne, much of the established squad looks set to still be in place come next year's Asian Cup, and it wasn't Sermanni's place to say otherwise. That is Montemurro's responsibility. Sign up to Moving the Goalposts No topic is too small or too big for us to cover as we deliver a twice-weekly roundup of the wonderful world of women's football after newsletter promotion But Sermanni cannot be blamed for the maladroit hunt for a full-time replacement. Back-to-back losses to Brazil and a winless SheBelieves Cup weren't part of the plan, but neither was him being in an interim role for nearly a year. He came in and did his job in getting the team back on its feet, and then the federation turned around and asked him to keep doing it. He would have been well within his rights to put decision-makers on blast, but doing what was best for the Matildas came first. Starting with Daniela Galic and ending with Isabel Gomez, nine players have made their international debuts during his brief tenure, while others such as Sayer, Holly McNamara, and Clare Wheeler have grown in prominence. Fittingly, Sermanni used one of his final appearances as coach of the Matildas to call for improvements to resourcing and staffing in the A-League Women, attempting to spur even more progress for the game, even after his exit. If some of the recent results have damaged Sermanni's standing in the eyes of a new generation of fans who have rallied around the Matildas, they shouldn't. He has played an irreplaceable role since before many of them were born. And now, with the Montemurro era looming, he can kick back.
The Guardian
19 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘Witch hunt': two students expelled from University of Melbourne after pro-Palestine protest in academic's office
The Greens deputy leader, Mehreen Faruqi, has accused the University of Melbourne of a 'witch hunt' after the first formal expulsion of pro-Palestine student activists since waves of campus demonstrations began in 2023. On Monday, letters were sent from the university's vice-chancellor, Emma Johnston, to four students, informing two that they had been terminated and two that they were suspended until March next year after taking part in a pro-Palestine demonstration at an academic's office last October. The students were given 20 business days to lodge an appeal, however Johnston's decision, which upheld recommendations made by the university's student discipline committee, will remain in place until the process is completed. 'In the interest of maintaining good order and discipline, I direct you to only attend campus for the purpose of study or assessment … until your expulsion takes effect,' Johnston wrote in a letter seen by Guardian Australia. 'You were found to have engaged in improper conduct and in doing so breached sections of the vice-chancellor regulation, and the student conduct policy.' The students were referred to the disciplinary committee after reports they were part of a group of about 20 who, on 9 October 2024, occupied the office of an academic who oversees the university's joint PhD program with the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. The protesters were calling on the university to disband its joint programs with Israeli universities, which have been a target of the global boycott, divestment and sanctions movement since 2004. Faruqi, who is also the Greens' higher education spokesperson, said the university was on the 'wrong side of history'. 'Universities like the University of Melbourne should cease the disciplinary witch hunts on brave student activists and issue a public apology for the McCarthyist crackdown on staff and students speaking out for a free Palestine,' she said. 'From draconian anti-protest policies and police interventions to surveillance, suspensions and disciplinary actions, university management have used every trick in the book to stifle activism. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email 'Students and staff at universities have led the way in rallying against Israel's atrocities, and they continue to pay the price.' Johnston told Guardian Australia the university respected the rights of individuals to protest, reiterating 'this has not changed'. 'Universities are places where free and open debate must take place, but the safety of our students and staff must also be protected as this is integral to enabling free and open debate,' she said. 'It's our responsibility to respond to any actions that may intimidate or threaten the safety of students and staff on our campuses. These matters are taken seriously and addressed under the appropriate policy which may include disciplinary procedures.' Alex Ryvchin, the co-CEO of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, said there was a right to protest, but there was no right to target individuals and make them 'fearful for their safety'. 'The targeting … was dangerous and completely unacceptable and such behaviour has no place anywhere, let alone at a centre of education and the professor's workplace,' he said. 'The university was right to take decisive action.' Ryvchin said universities had allowed 'extreme elements' of the anti-Israel movement to develop on campuses in the past academic year which had subordinated the freedoms of the 'vast majority' of students and staff. 'It appears that most universities are determined not to allow this to happen again but the proof will be in their handling of incidents like this,' he said. Dr Elizabeth Strakosch, a member of the University of Melbourne's National Tertiary Education Union branch and a political science lecturer, said the union was 'deeply concerned' about the implication of the disciplinary proceedings on the wider community given widespread protest crackdowns across institutions. The University of Sydney's vice-chancellor, Mark Scott, on Monday confirmed staff and students would be banned from holding banners on campus without prior permission and staff would be unable to send political emails unless prior interest has been expressed, as part of five revised policies adopted by the institution. It followed a suite of rules against protests implemented at the University of Melbourne in March, including that they may not be held indoors and must not obstruct entries or exits of university buildings. 'We're definitely seeing an intensification of surveillance, a crackdown on dissent, and there's a widespread feeling amongst our membership that academic freedom is on the line,' Strakosch said. 'Sit-ins and protests are often disruptive. That's the way that they function. They're one of the most important tools that students and staff have for getting concerns that are not being registered on to the agenda. 'It's pretty clear that there is a change in atmosphere and temperature on campuses for both staff and students. If upheld, this will be the first [Australian] university to expel students over protests around Gaza, and that sets a really dangerous precedent for other universities.' Dr Jordana Silverstein, a cultural historian at the University of Melbourne, said it was 'frustrating' to see the university and vice-chancellor 'so severely discipline' the students for their actions. 'This is not about the occupation of an office,' she said. 'This is about what kind of university we want to study and work at and society we want to live in. These students are calling for the university to divest of its financial and political ties with genocide, an eminently reasonable request.' Prof Joo-Cheong Tham, a researcher at the University of Melbourne's law school and an assistant secretary at the National Tertiary Education Union, said disciplinary proceedings should only be taken in 'the gravest of situations' given the 'profound consequences it has on the student's life and career'. He said proportionate regulation of protests was justified, but workplace, health and safety laws already showed how to 'strike a good balance' between freedom to protest and campus safety, adding that protest had been an established tradition at Australian universities since the 1960s. 'Most of the protest restrictions introduced at the University of Melbourne are an overreach because they fail to distinguish between peaceful protests and those that pose a real threat to safety,' he said. 'The ham-fisted approach of the recent protest restrictions reflect a loss of faith in the University of Melbourne as an institution of dialogue, debate and disagreement.' Last year an Australian National University student who was expelled and a Deakin University student who was suspended for Palestine-related activism had those decisions overturned on appeal.
Daily Mail
21 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Shock twist after father was allegedly stabbed to death
Another man is being sought by police over a 'gruesome' homicide on a suburban street, which is believed to be the outcome of a drug deal gone wrong. Detectives continued to scour the scene in Sydney's inner west on Tuesday after officers found a man aged in his 50s stabbed to death about 5pm on Monday in Croydon Park. A 32-year-old man arrested at the scene is assisting police with their inquiries and has not been charged. Another man, believed to be a 29-year-old Malaysian national, is wanted for questioning. Police released images of this man on Tuesday, saying he was last seen on the street where the stabbing occurred on Monday afternoon. The man already in custody was taken to hospital for assessment under police guard. He had attempted to flee the crime scene when police attended but was quickly apprehended, Superintendent Christine McDonald said. 'This is a gruesome crime,' she told reporters on Monday evening. Another man is being sought by police over a 'gruesome' homicide on a suburban street, which is believed to be the outcome of a drug deal gone wrong 'The man's injuries are horrific, and what we know from very preliminary investigations is that ... we believe this is a drug deal gone horribly wrong. 'We didn't give him any time to run away, we were here too quick.' On Tuesday morning, police were crawling over the quiet street as they attempted to piece together what happened. The dead man was found with multiple stab wounds to his neck and police are treating the investigation as a homicide. Speaking on Monday night, Supt McDonald said police were unsure of who lived at the house, who had attended before the fatal incident and the reason they were meeting. 'We don't believe it to be domestic-related, we don't believe it to be gang-related, but we need to work through all those steps of the investigation,' she said. 'The community down here would be shocked that something so brutal has happened in their street.' The man in his 50s who died has not yet been formally identified. Detectives continued to scour the scene in Sydney 's inner west on Tuesday after officers found a man aged in his 50s stabbed to death about 5pm on Monday in Croydon Park Supt McDonald did not detail why she believed the incident had stemmed from a drug deal. A neighbour told Daily Mail Australia on Tuesday the dead man lived with his wife and children at the Croydon Park home for just a few months before the alleged attack. 'The neighbourhood is feeling very unsettled. This is a really, really lovely quiet street,' she said. 'We do all know each other. Pretty much, we all know each other except for this particular house. 'They haven't lived here that long so we don't know much about them.'
