logo
‘Bizarre and wrong': Danish zoo sparks debate with plea for pets to use as food

‘Bizarre and wrong': Danish zoo sparks debate with plea for pets to use as food

The Guardian5 days ago
After a Danish zoo posted a reminder of its long-running programme allowing people to donate their healthy, small pets to be 'gently euthanised' and fed to predators, reaction poured in from across the globe.
But beyond the battleground playing out on social media – where some protested against the idea of using pets as prey and others praised the zoo's efforts to drum up a practical food supply – some were swift to point out that the zoo was simply laying bare the reality of keeping carnivores in captivity.
'If you accept the fact that you have carnivores in human care, either as a pet or as a zoo, you will agree to the fact that you feed them animal matter. Basically there is no other choice,' said Marcus Clauss, the co-director of the Clinic for Zoo Animals, Exotic Pets and Wildlife at the University of Zurich, pointing to vegan dog food as one of the few exceptions to this. 'And then the logical next step is the question, where do you source that animal product from?'
As the zoo's plea made headlines around the world, Aalborg zoo closed comments on its post, citing 'hateful and malicious rhetoric'. The zoo said it was simply aiming to mimic the natural food chain by urging those with chickens, rabbits and guinea pigs that need to be put down to instead hand them over to the zoo. 'That way, nothing goes to waste – and we ensure the natural behaviour, nutrition and wellbeing of our predators.'
Few would question the alternative, even though it came with the risk that zoo animals could end up being fed meat from animals raised in relatively poor conditions, said Clauss. 'As long as it's beef from the slaughterhouse, nobody sees it and nobody needs to think about it,' he said. 'As soon as it's an animal that is being killed at the zoo, it's in everybody's face.'
Some of the backlash was likely down to the wording of the appeal, said Dan Ashe of the Association of Zoos and Aquariums, which counts more than 200 accredited facilities spanning from the US to the UAE. 'I think the thing that people maybe see as potentially shocking is the use of the word pet,' he said.
He chalked it up to cultural differences. 'Professionally, I would not expect anything like that to happen at one of our accredited zoos, certainly not here in the US. But our accreditation policies wouldn't necessarily prohibit it.'
The plea, however, spoke to a common understanding among zoos around the world: the importance, both nutritionally and behaviourally, of mimicking nature by feeding carnivores the entire carcass of animals. 'Carcass-feeding is a regular feature of what our members do when they are available, some of our members accept donations of road-killed deer or animals,' said Ashe.
Some zoos had actively sought to spotlight this, he said, citing a recent event at Denver zoo where the public was invited – and warned appropriately beforehand – to watch as lions were fed pig carcasses. 'The lions seemed to benefit, and certainly the guests who chose to watch it – it was packed,' he said.
Others, however, found little redeeming in the Danish appeal. 'To me this was so far beyond the pale,' said Clifford Warwick, a UK-based consultant biologist and medical scientist. 'The entire thing is bizarre and wrong.'
As the zoo did not specify how the donated pets would be euthanised, Warwick worried it would be impossible to do so in a way that was both humane and ensured that the animals remained safe to be eaten by predators such as the European lynx.
'And there's no validity to their claim of needing to give animals a natural diet this way,' he said. 'Lynx don't eat guinea pigs. Where do they get guinea pigs from? Lynx would eat almost any small mammal, sure, but they can't turn around and say that's a natural behaviour.'
Aalborg zoo did not reply to a request for an interview.
At a time when animal shelters around the world are grappling with overcrowding, Warwick also bristled at what he saw as the wider implications of the zoo's message. 'It further devalues the lives of pets … It's a horrendous devaluation of animal life,' he said. 'Are you really happy saying: 'OK, well Rex or Bruno, the time has come, there's a hungry lion at the local zoo. Bye, off you go.''
The wide range of reactions hints at the many factors that play into the broader question of how to keep carnivores fed at zoos, said Alessandro Di Marzio, the science lead at Riga zoo.
'Zoos are spread across a wide range of areas, so you'll find places where certain techniques are considered acceptable and more or less normal for society, while in other areas they're not,' he said, with local laws, economic resources and culture also helping to shape these tactics. 'It depends on all these circumstances.'
The resulting clash of cultures has at times been glaring; earlier this year, Germany's Nuremberg zoo sparked protests after it confirmed it had killed six of its 12 Guinea baboons due to overcrowding and had fed the primates to lions, tigers, maned wolves and marbled polecats.
In Denmark, Copenhagen zoo was the focus of global protests in 2014 after it put down an 18-month-old giraffe, citing the risk of inbreeding, and fed some of the meat to the zoo's lions.
For Clauss, the heated debate unleashed this week recalled one of the emails sent to Copenhagen zoo after the euthanasia of the giraffe. 'It said: 'Why do you have to kill animals to feed your carnivores? Can't you just buy meat?''
While he did not think the view was representative in any way, he marvelled at how the Danish appeal had served to kickstart a global conversation. 'The amazing thing is that we learn about these things because of zoos,' he said. 'And not because of what we do at the supermarket.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Slight rise in A* and A grades achieved in A-levels in Northern Ireland
Slight rise in A* and A grades achieved in A-levels in Northern Ireland

The Independent

timean hour ago

  • The Independent

Slight rise in A* and A grades achieved in A-levels in Northern Ireland

The number of A* and A grades awarded at A-level in Northern Ireland has risen slightly. More than 25,000 students across the region received their AS and A-level examination results on Thursday. In A-levels, 8.7% of entries achieved the A* grade, compared to 8.2% in 2024, while 30.4% of entries achieved grades A*- A, compared to 30.3% in 2024. Overall, 98.7% of students in Northern Ireland achieved A*- E grades, compared to 98.5% in 2024. More than one third (37.3%) of A-level entries in Northern Ireland continue to be in Stem subjects (science, technology, engineering and mathematics). Mathematics remains the most popular A-level subject, accounting for one in 10 entries. Boys have achieved a slightly higher rate of A* grades but girls have a higher rate in achieving overall grades A*-E. The total number of A-level entries in Northern Ireland has remained stable with 32,275 entries this year. This year, AS level entries are up from 41,180 in 2024 to 43,362, an increase of 5.3%. The results show that 27.2% of students achieved grade A, compared to 26.7% in 2024. Overall, 96.7% achieved A – E grades, compared to 96.4% in 2024. The majority of A-level and AS-level qualifications are taken through the Northern Ireland exams board CCEA, though some students will also receive grades from English and Welsh exam boards. Most students can get their A and AS-level results online, but some still go to their school to receive their results in person. Gerry Campbell, chief executive of CCEA, said: 'Congratulations to all the students receiving their results today. 'This marks a significant step in your personal and educational journey, and everyone at CCEA recognises the dedication and effort that brought you to this point. 'Your results reflect your resilience, hard work and growth and you should be incredibly proud of what you've achieved. 'I would also like to thank the teachers, school leaders and support staff whose commitment and guidance have played a crucial role in helping students reach their potential. 'To every student receiving results today, well done and best of luck as you take your next steps, wherever they may lead. 'The results you received today are stepping stones to your future, whether that be further education, entering the world of work, or something else.' John Trueman, director of the Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL) Northern Ireland, said: 'The 2025 summer series went well in Northern Ireland and we must congratulate CCEA for clear communication and management of the examinations, marking, awarding and issue of results. 'We welcome the fact that results this year are broadly similar to those issued in summer 2024.'

A-level results 2025 loom as pupils in Wales wait for their grades
A-level results 2025 loom as pupils in Wales wait for their grades

BBC News

time12 hours ago

  • BBC News

A-level results 2025 loom as pupils in Wales wait for their grades

Thousands of A-level and AS students across Wales are set to find out their results on Thursday morning, following a drop in top grades in year most extra support measures for students were dropped as part of a move away from previous changes to exams to reflect the disruption caused by the Covid-19 2024, 29.9% of pupils got A* and A grades, down from 34% in 2023, but ministers said that was to be can be shared with students from 08:00 BST, but arrangements vary depending on the school or college. Results for the Advanced Skills Baccalaureate Wales and some vocational qualifications, including BTecs, will also be released on students will need confirmation of grades to secure university offers and can usually get updated information about their places from 08:00. Identical twins Adrian and Łukasz Kolman from Newport have always had similar interests - taking the same A-level subjects and studying together for they are both waiting for results in maths, further maths, computer science and exams were "stressful", according to Adrian. "We were studying the same things so at least we had each other to help out on what we didn't know and what we didn't understand sometimes."Ahead of results Łukasz said he felt "nervous but also kind of excited". "I'm really looking forward to seeing what I get but also I need to make sure that I have the results I need for my university," he have been offered places to study electronics and electrical engineering - Adrian at Bristol University and Łukasz a short distance away at Bath University."We spend a lot of time together since we've shared the same room for all our lives pretty much. It's nice to go out there and be a bit more individual," said Łukasz. Some BTec students will also get confirmation of their final results - though some have already been published, depending on the Gape, 19, from Cardiff, already has a clear idea of how she has done in her art and design BTec, and has secured a place to study performance design at the Royal Welsh College of Music and said she enjoyed studying the more practical, coursework-based qualification."I've really thrived with being able to do a BTec and it's let me explore things that I don't think I would have if I'd stayed on in school," Ngaire is now looking forward to her degree which will include working on set costumes, props and puppetry. After disruption to exams due to Covid, lasting until 2024 when all extra support measures were dropped, Qualifications Wales kept a "safety net" when setting grade boundaries if performance in a subject was far lower than pre-pandemic year, that has been removed and grade boundaries in some subjects are likely to be exams watchdog has said "outcomes should be broadly similar" to those before the pandemic, if performance continues to improve after the disruption caused by Covid. The head of Universities and Colleges Admissions Service (Ucas) has said a record number of 18-year-olds are likely to get in to their first choice of university this year, even if they narrowly miss their Jo Saxton said universities were keen to enrol UK undergraduates because there was more "uncertainty" around international student clearing process, offering places on courses which still have space, is also available for students who do not get their grades or who change their latest Ucas data said 32.5% of Welsh 18-year-olds had applied to university by the end of June, compared to 41.2% across the UK. On a visit to engineering and manufacturing company Boccard on Deeside, Wales' Skills Minister Jack Sargeant spoke to apprentices about other education Tattersall, 19, said he started his apprenticeship "with no experience at all"."I've been learning to weld and fabricate and everything I need to do in a workshop."I did two years in college back in Pembrokeshire but I decided I wanted to be earning and learning at the same time so that's why I went for apprenticeship. It's going really well," he said. Lawrence Coleman, 20, said there had already been "a few stressful moments" in his career so far."This wasn't actually my first option... but I came through and ended up signing up in college. You've got to have an open mind to it all."Careers Wales said there were plenty of options available to young people who may be unsure about what to do Catrin Owen said alternatives to university were to "take a break, go into work or you can look at things like apprenticeships". She added: "We are seeing more higher level apprenticeships now - degree-level apprenticeships, which are great options for some young people."It's really important that you sit down with a professional who can go through everything with you to make sure you're making the best decision that suits you."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store