Man acquitted in shooting death of 7-year-old Natalia Wallace on Fourth of July 2020
Davion Mitchell was found not guilty of murder and other felonies a week after jury selection began on April 4. In December, Cook County Judge Joanne Rosado found a co-defendant, Kevin Boyd, guilty of murder, but she acquitted the alleged getaway driver, Reginald Merrill. Charges are still pending against a fourth man, Boyd's brother, Terrell Boyd.
Wallace, called Natalie by her family, was slain while playing outside with her cousins in the South Austin neighborhood, at least the 13th child 10 years old or under to be shot that year. She was the unintended victim of a revenge shooting, prosecutors had alleged.
'The jury did the right thing with the evidence that was given to them,' Mitchell's attorney, Nathaniel Niesen, said. 'Davion is back home with his family where he belongs.'
The verdict, though, left family members reeling, especially as one defendant has already walked free.
'I don't understand what happened,' said Shelley Fulton, a great aunt of Natalie's. 'All my faith is shattered.'
Cook County prosecutors delivered opening arguments on Tuesday, telling jurors that Natalie was gunned down in a 'hail of bullets' fired by the men who sought revenge for an earlier shooting death. They hit their intended target in the legs, injuring him, prosecutors said. Natalie was struck by a stray while outside on the bright summer evening.
'She had her entire life in front of her,' Assistant Cook County State's Attorney Mary Jo Murtaugh said.
But prosecutors faced an uphill battle, contending with multiple uncooperative witnesses, including the other victim in the case, the apparent target of the shooting.
Niesen argued to the jury that the state's case was 'held together with popsicle sticks.'
'It's too tragic to really put into words,' he said. 'We're here to talk about who is responsible.'
For the family members, they are struggling with reliving the details of the shooting over the course of two separate trials.
'It's like bringing that day back over and over,' Fulton said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
an hour ago
- Newsweek
FBI Issues 4th of July Warning as Homeland Security Is 'Enhancing Security'
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is working closely with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and "enhancing security measures" to "ensure a safe and secure Independence Day across the nation," the department told Newsweek. The statement comes after ABC News reported on bulletins outlining concerns of a lone wolf attack on July 4 celebrations, similar to the car-ramming attack that killed 14 people in New Orleans on January 1. Newsweek has not seen an original copy of the bulletins. A spokesperson for DHS told Newsweek: "At this time, DHS is not aware of any specific, credible threats to Fourth of July celebrations." A spokesperson for the FBI told Newsweek: "The FBI always encourages members of the public to be vigilant and report anything they consider suspicious to law enforcement." FBI Director Kash Patel speaks during a news conference at the Manassas FBI Field Office on March 27, 2025, in Manassas, Virginia. FBI Director Kash Patel speaks during a news conference at the Manassas FBI Field Office on March 27, 2025, in Manassas, Virginia. Rod Lamkey, File/AP Photo Why It Matters The U.S. has experienced several attacks by lone actors in 2025: the New Year's attack in New Orleans, the shooting of two Israeli Embassy officials in Washington, D.C., the firebombing of a march for Israeli hostages in Boulder, Colorado, and the killing of two Minnesota lawmakers and the shooting of two others. Since President Donald Trump took office, he has removed funding and most personnel from the DHS Center for Prevention Programs and Partnerships (CP3), the group tasked with countering violent extremism, and hired a 22-year-old former Heritage Foundation intern with no known counterterrorism or national security experience to lead it. This has created concerns over the White House's preparedness to deal with violent extremism. The FBI investigates the area of Orleans Street and Bourbon Street by St. Louis Cathedral in the French Quarter where a suspicious package was detonated after a person drove a truck into a crowd, on... The FBI investigates the area of Orleans Street and Bourbon Street by St. Louis Cathedral in the French Quarter where a suspicious package was detonated after a person drove a truck into a crowd, on January 1, 2025. More Matthew Hinton, File/AP Photo What To Know The bulletins obtained by ABC state: "We are concerned about the potential threat of copycat attacks inspired by the 2025 New Year's Day vehicle-ramming attack in New Orleans and continued [foreign terrorist organizations] messaging calling for attacks against Western targets." The bulletins come after DHS issued a warning on June 22 over Iranian threats to the U.S. following the U.S. bombing Iran's nuclear infrastructure. According to the bulletins, U.S.-based extremists and lone actors represent the largest threat to crowds gathering for Independence Day celebrations over the weekend. Authorities have said they are concerned about chemicals being used on crowds in an attack similar to the one in Boulder, where one person died and 13 were injured after a man threw Molotov cocktails into the crowd. Since taking office, Trump has not only slashed the budget for CP3 but pivoted the nation's terrorism focus away from white supremacy and labelled drug cartels as terrorist organizations. Abigail Jackson, a White House spokesperson, spoke with ProPublica regarding the changes at CP3, saying: "The notion that this single office is responsible for preventing terrorism is not only incorrect, it's ignorant." Members of law enforcement agencies search for shooting suspect at a house on June 15, 2025, in Belle Plaine, Minnesota. Members of law enforcement agencies search for shooting suspect at a house on June 15, 2025, in Belle Plaine, Minnesota. George Walker IV/AP Photo What People Are Saying A spokesperson for DHS told Newsweek: "The Department of Homeland Security is working closely with the FBI and other federal, state, and local law enforcement partners to ensure a safe and secure Independence Day across the nation. We are enhancing security measures and coordinating intelligence-sharing to proactively address potential risks, including those from lone wolf actors. At this time, DHS is not aware of any specific, credible threats to Fourth of July celebrations." A spokesperson for the FBI told Newsweek: "While our standard practice is to not comment on specific intelligence products, the FBI regularly shares information with our law enforcement partners to assist in protecting the communities they serve, as well as with our private sector partners for awareness. The FBI always encourages members of the public to be vigilant and report anything they consider suspicious to law enforcement." What Happens Next Officials in New York told ABC that they are concerned about lone attackers over the holiday weekend who are "motivated by a broad range of racial, ethnic, political, religious, anti-government, societal or personal grievances."
Axios
an hour ago
- Axios
River North mass shooting: 4 killed, 14 injured outside Chicago club
A mass shooting in Chicago's River North neighborhood Wednesday night has left four people dead and at least 14 wounded, according to police. The latest: The shootings happened just outside Artis Restaurant on West Chicago Avenue, during a record-release party for rapper Mello Buckzz. Police say a large group of people were gathered outside when an SUV drove by and opened fire around 11pm. The four killed were two men and two women. Four others are listed in critical to serious conditions at local hospitals. The victims injured in the shooting range in age from 21 to 32 years old. The mass shooting comes as the city gears up for a traditionally violent weekend. Last year, 109 people were shot and 19 killed over the Fourth of July weekend. No arrests have been made as of Thursday morning. Flashback: This block in River North was also the site of a shooting in 2022, when the nightclub was called Hush Lounge. Zoom out: So far, 2025 has seen steep declines in homicides and shootings in the city, with some of the lowest levels in decades. Chicago had remarkably low numbers for Memorial Day weekend, and officials were hoping to see the same this weekend. There were 192 homicides in Chicago through June 30 this year, compared to 289 over the same period last year. What they're saying: "The goal is, obviously, to not have any homicides this weekend," deputy mayor of community safety Garien Gatewood told Axios this week. "But historically, the Fourth of July has been one of the hardest holidays in the history of the city of Chicago."
Axios
3 hours ago
- Axios
Chicago's safety plan faces crucial test this Fourth of July
The Fourth of July weekend is traditionally a time for families to come together for food, fun and fireworks. Unfortunately, the holiday weekend is also historically a violent time. Why it matters: Last year, 109 people were shot and 19 killed over the holiday weekend. 50 people were killed in the first half of July. The big picture: So far, 2025 has seen steep declines in homicides and shootings in the city, with some of the lowest levels in decades. Chicago had remarkably low numbers for Memorial Day weekend and officials are hoping to see the same this weekend. There were 192 homicides in Chicago through June 30 this year, compared to 289 over the same period last year. What they're saying:"The goal is, obviously, to not have any homicides this weekend," deputy mayor of community safety Garien Gatewood tells Axios. "But historically, the Fourth of July has been one of the hardest holidays in the history of the city of Chicago." Zoom in: Mayor Brandon Johnson has been touting his community safety plan as the reason why homicides are dropping. The center of that plan was hiring Gatewood as the first-ever deputy mayor of community safety in 2023. Gatewood says success is all about communication between all the stakeholders. "I think the big difference is everybody is actually working together," Gatewood says. "Back in other administrations, you had too many folks working in silos. You'd have street outreach contracts, but no relationship with the police department. You would have deputy mayors who weren't out on the ground as much as we are." "I can't tell you the last day I haven't talked to either the superintendent or the chief of patrol." State of play: Gatewood says the entire menu of resources will be used this weekend, including activating the city's emergency operations center and flooding the streets with more police officers and the skies with more helicopters. Officers will work overtime in certain high-crime areas. He also says the city has expanded contracts for community organizations to stay out until 2 or 3am. Last year, they were only out until midnight. The city will also feature more late-night basketball events with free food, designed to attract teens from the South and West sides. Zoom out: While violent crime is dropping across the country, including in big cities like New York and LA, Gatewood points out that Chicago's levels are dropping even faster, which is a stark contrast to years past. Reality check: Even though Johnson's plan seems to be working, Gatewood is well aware of the challenges this weekend, thanks to the combination of late-night outdoor celebrations and the heat. Last year, he spent his holiday weekend visiting crime scenes and consoling family members. "It's important we show up and put in the work," Gatewood says. "Because in a lot of situations, when people see me on their block, it could be the worst day of their lives. So we must show up in the good times and in the bad times." What's next: After this weekend, Gatewood says the city will continue its "take back the block" events that flood one particular violent hotspot neighborhood with police, other city departments and community organizers.
