High Court dismisses Dzulkefly's bid to recuse JC Arziah in Najib defamation suit
The case revolves around a Facebook post alleging cronyism.
JC Arziah ruled that Dzulkefly failed to prove any real risk of bias, stating, 'The relationship is between my father and the defendant (Najib), not between myself and any party. There is no evidence of any continuing relationship between my father and the defendant beyond a brief court appearance as a witness in 2019.'
She added that her father, former Attorney General Tan Sri Mohamed Apandi Ali, left office in 2018, making any connection to the case 'tenuous and historical.'
Dzulkefly had sought Arziah's recusal, citing alleged bias from her remarks during case management hearings on March 7 and April 7.
He argued that her comments on potentially striking out the case indicated bias.
Additionally, he raised concerns over her familial ties to Apandi, who was appointed by Najib in 2016.
Representing Dzulkefly, counsel Stanley Sabastien Sinnappen argued that these factors created a reasonable apprehension of bias.
However, JC Arziah found no evidence of actual bias, stating, 'The application is accordingly dismissed.'
The defamation suit, filed by Dzulkefly in January 2022, stems from a Facebook post by Najib on August 24, 2020, which included a screenshot of a Sinar Harian article.
Dzulkefly claims the post implied he engaged in cronyism by awarding positions to relatives without merit.
Najib, in his defence, argued the post targeted the Pakatan Harapan coalition, not Dzulkefly personally. – Bernama
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
5 hours ago
- The Star
Animal crossing remark sparks verbal jibe in Dewan Rakyat
KUALA LUMPUR: Tensions rose sharply in the Dewan Rakyat after Hulu Langat MP Mohd Sany Hamzan made remarks aimed at Pasir Mas MP Ahmad Fadhli Shaari during the debate on the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP). The exchange on Monday (Aug 4) began when Ahmad Fadhli called on the government to consider building a new highway linking Gerik in Perak to Jeli in Kelantan under a public-private partnership (PPP) model. He said the current route, Federal Route 4, also known as the East-West Highway, was a narrow two-lane road without a divider, prone to accidents and often used by roaming elephants. Mohd Sany then stood up to ask why the project was not pursued when Perikatan Nasional (PN) was in power. 'I just want to ask Pasir Mas, earlier you mentioned elephants, but you didn't mention apes and goats. 'Also, didn't you ask for this highway when your coalition was in government?' he said. The remarks came amid ongoing controversy surrounding Ahmad Fadhli's recent Facebook post, which depicted Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim and two regional leaders as caricatures of animals. He has been urged to apologise for allegedly mocking Malaysia's efforts to broker peace between Thailand and Cambodia. Ahmad Fadhli responded by saying the question matched the person asking it. 'Those animal names are quite fitting. You can include them in Hulu Langat's speech next time. Sometimes, the question really does reflect the person asking it,' he said. The comment triggered a row, with Mohd Sany demanding a retraction. 'I asked respectfully. We're friends. You're from PAS, an Islamic party. That comment was rude and inappropriate,' he said. Dewan Rakyat Speaker Tan Sri Johari Abdul then stepped in, saying that: 'There's no need to talk about goats, camels, monkeys or cows. Everyone, sit down and carry on with the debate.' Ahmad Fadhli then resumed his speech, criticising the lack of clear allocations for Kelantan in the 13MP. He said that while the state was mentioned in several strategic sectors, there were no figures or firm financial commitments.
New Straits Times
9 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Lump sum EPF payout scheme for retirees not feasible, says economist
KUALA LUMPUR: Putrajaya may encounter a hurdle if it implements a payout scheme to provide lump-sum access and regular income to retirees via the Employees Provident Fund (EPF). Economist Dr Geoffrey Williams said that most Malaysians have low savings and low income, which may halt the government's plan due to the lack of funds. "The real problem is coverage. Currently, EPF only has 8.8 million active members, and these have very low savings. "So, even with the new scheme, there is still a pensions adequacy crisis. Millions have no retirement scheme, and those that do have savings are too low to be meaningful," he said. Williams added that pension adequacy cannot be addressed quickly because it requires retirees to have higher savings. "With incomes being low, higher savings are not possible, and actually, people are already working beyond the official retirement age anyway," he said. He suggested that the government establish a non-contributory pensions scheme to top-up the existing funds. He said that the non-contributory pension could be funded by current spending, taxes, a "superfund", or a combination of all of these measures to top up whatever savings people already have. Under the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP), the government is considering implementing a monthly pension scheme under the EPF as part of its efforts to ensure a steady income after retirement. In a Facebook post, Deputy Finance Minister Lim Hui Ying yesterday said that the proposed new structure will split the savings into two accounts — a Flexible Savings account, allowing members to withdraw anytime, and an Income Savings account, a periodic payment until funds are exhausted. However, she said that the proposed changes will not affect existing withdrawal rights of current members and will only apply to new members after it is implemented. Currently, there are three funds under every member's name — Account 1, which are meant to be a retirement fund, Account 2 for selected pre-retirement needs, and Account 3, which was only implemented last year for flexible withdrawals. Meanwhile, the Malaysian Employers Federation objected to any compulsory pension payout mechanism under EPF and urged the government to approach the matter with great caution. Its president, Datuk Dr Syed Hussain Syed Husman, said that the monthly pension payout model must be implemented on a voluntary opt-in basis, and not as a mandatory mechanism. "EPF members should be allowed to choose the proportion of savings they wish to convert into a monthly payout, if any. "A rigid, compulsory payout model may increase financial stress among retirees who need a lump-sum cash flow. "Concerns over restricted access to retirement funds can lead to financial stress, particularly if workers need liquidity for medical emergencies, education, or caregiving responsibilities," he said. He added that any compulsory structure may also increase the demand for salary advances, loans or early retirement which will in turn put pressure on employers and the system. "Younger workers may begin to question the value of contributing to EPF if the system evolves into a rigid payout structure. This could reduce enthusiasm for formal sector employment, encouraging some to shift into the gig or informal economy where contributions are voluntary," he said. He suggested that the government begin with a pilot scheme for low-income earners and conduct extensive consultations with employers, employees and retirement experts to ensure the design meets practical needs. He added that any new model must preserve members' rights to full or partial withdrawal at retirement. "If the government wishes to introduce a separate, government-funded pension fund for the people, especially one with government contributions, then clear conditions for withdrawal and payout structures can be designed accordingly," Syed Hussain said.
Sinar Daily
11 hours ago
- Sinar Daily
DAP Veterans protest ‘outsider' senator appointment with sanitary pad masks
Members wore custom-made face masks made from sanitary pads to symbolise their frustration with the state DAP leadership's silence on the issue. By SINAR DAILY REPORTER 04 Aug 2025 01:08pm Wanita DAP chief and Deputy Communications Minister Teo Nie Ching - BERNAMA FILE PIX SHAH ALAM - The Negeri Sembilan DAP Veterans Club has publicly protested the appointment of Johor native Vincent Wu as senator, accusing the party leadership of sidelining local interests in favour of an 'outsider.' According to online news portal Malaysiakini, the protest was staged yesterday, with members wearing custom-made face masks made from sanitary pads to symbolise their frustration with the state DAP leadership's silence on the issue. The club's chairman Lee Kong Hing reportedly described the masks as 'thick, dense, highly absorbent and soundproof' which were qualities he claimed 'perfectly symbolise how seamlessly silent the state leadership is.' The club also slammed the state party committee, accusing it of 'selling out' the people of Negeri Sembilan by awarding a senator post to an 'outsider.' The protest has drawn sharp criticism from Wanita DAP, who condemned the use of sanitary pads as protest props. It was reported that the wing's chief Teo Nie Ching said using sanitary pads as gimmicks during a protest against the party's leadership was inappropriate and disrespectful to women. Teo, who is also Deputy Communications Minister said the act was unacceptable and reinforced negative stigma around menstruation. 'Using sanitary pads as tools of attack or ridicule only reinforces the shame and stigma long associated with menstruation,' she was quoted as saying. She also raised concerns about period poverty, noting that some students in the country were forced to skip school due to the inability to afford menstrual products. 'And yet, here they are wasting large quantities of sanitary pads just to mock their political rivals,' she reportedly said. The Federal Territories chapter of Wanita DAP also condemned the protest in a Facebook post, urging party members to uphold dignity and engage in respectful discourse. 'The menstrual pad is not a tool for personal gain or internal protest. 'It represents the lived experiences of millions of women and should not be exploited to make a political point, especially within our own party,' it wrote in the post.
