logo
Sydney doctor Semir Farhan denies abusing six patients

Sydney doctor Semir Farhan denies abusing six patients

News.com.au22-07-2025
A Sydney doctor charged with allegedly sexually touching or raping patients has been granted bail after a court heard some of the incidents 'simply could not have occurred'.
Semir Farhan, 42, was arrested at his Casula home in April and charged with 14 offences allegedly committed against two men under his care at clinics in Narellan and Auburn.
The NSW Supreme Court heard on Tuesday he now faced 32 charges after a further four complainants were identified as part of the ongoing investigation.
Among the charges are 28 counts of aggravated sexual touching under authority, two counts of aggravated sexual intercourse without consent and one of aggravated indecent assault.
The GP's barrister Matthew Johnston SC, however, told the court there were serious concerns over the police probe which he described as 'in my submission, poor'.
Some of the charges 'simply could not have occurred', Mr Johnston said, owing to issues with the dates identified or the evidence from alleged victims.
The court heard Mr Farhan had previously faced trial over similar allegations made by two separate complainants last year.
He was found not guilty and acquitted of all charges after the trial in May 2024.
Those proceedings meant Mr Farhan was supervised at work by practice monitors who Mr Johnston said had still not been interviewed by police.
That was despite Mr Farhan's legal team advancing that a monitor was present at the time some of the alleged offences were said to have taken place.
Mr Johnston said the failure 'to properly investigate is a significant factor' and foreshadowed the claims would be defended at a 'hotly contested trial'.
The Crown prosecutor conceded the case against Mr Farhan was 'not without issue' but said 'this investigation is in its rudimentary stages'.
'The Crown accepts there are some issues … but the Crown would say not all of the offences with which Mr Farhan has been charged suffer the evidentiary issue that's been brought to light,' she said.
She argued some of the complainants may have given the wrong date to investigators when recalling the alleged incidents, and that some of the claims predated Mr Farhan's previous trial.
'It is not the entirety of the allegations that are put in issue or (over which) there has been significant doubt raised by the applicant,' the prosecutor said.
'The Crown would raise there are ongoing investigations.
'The Crown would submit the nature of the offending is similar among six unrelated victims, and that is compelling.'
In granting bail, Acting Justice Derek Price said it was clear 'there are issues with not only the timing of some of the charges but also the applicant's capacity to commit some of the offences'.
The two practice monitors who supervised Mr Farhan 'never saw anything inappropriate while monitoring the applicant', he told the court.
Justice Price said that on his review of the documents before the court 'there is a reasonable possibility the Crown case against the applicant will not be proven beyond reasonable doubt'.
Mr Farhan was granted bail after a family member offered to forfeit $500,000 if the doctor failed to appear at future court dates.
Under his bail conditions he must also not practice as a medical practitioner, not approach his previous workplaces in Auburn and Narellan, and can only enter a medical facility if he is a patient himself.
Justice Price ordered Mr Farhan turn in his passport and report daily to police while on bail.
He asked the doctor if he understood the stringent conditions that had been imposed on him.
'Understood, Your Honour,' the GP replied. 'Thank you, Your Honour.'
Mr Farhan is next due to face Burwood Local Court on July 30.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Pilot, 56, killed after light plane crashes into wheat field near Toowoomba
Pilot, 56, killed after light plane crashes into wheat field near Toowoomba

News.com.au

timean hour ago

  • News.com.au

Pilot, 56, killed after light plane crashes into wheat field near Toowoomba

A man has died after a light plane crashed into a wheat field near Toowoomba. A 56-year-old man flying a glider plane was reported missing after failing to return from his flight. About 6.30pm on Wednesday, officers were called to a wheat field near Wainui Soldiers Rd in Bowenville after reports of a light plane crash. Upon arrival, emergency services found the man, the sole occupant of the plane, who was declared dead at the scene. The fatal crash comes only two weeks after two experienced pilots were killed in a similar crash in the same region. Robert 'Bob' Molony and Wayne Saunders, an experienced Aero Logistics pilot and flight examiner, were killed on July 20 after a light plane crashed into a field and burst into flames.

Little has changed since disability royal commission exposed deep institutional failings
Little has changed since disability royal commission exposed deep institutional failings

ABC News

timean hour ago

  • ABC News

Little has changed since disability royal commission exposed deep institutional failings

"Devastated." "An insult." "A failure of leadership." That's what the disability community said a year ago when the federal government released its initial response to the $600 million Royal Commission into Violence, Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation of People with Disability. It came after four and a half years of shocking evidence that revealed to the wider public how people with disability had been sexually assaulted, forcibly restrained and sterilised, and ripped off by people and institutions meant to help them. People with disability fought for years to get a royal commission and agreed to relive their biggest traumas in the hope it would finally bring about change. But the overwhelming feeling last July, after the initial response to the commission's 222 recommendations, was that measures to address them were being kicked down the road. Twelve months on, advocates are concerned the inquiry has vanished from public view, with many wondering where the progress is at from this once-in-a-generation opportunity for change. "Many of the issues identified remain unresolved, without clarity on what action is being taken and when," Women with Disabilities Australia CEO Sophie Cusworth said. Simply put, the royal commission has led to very little real-world change so far. Per the Commonwealth's last progress update — released just days before Christmas last year — one of the biggest shifts has been the amendment of a contentious migration law. The rest of the update mostly revolves around administrative work — things like reviews of various strategies and plans, establishing employment targets for the public sector and creating a "disability-inclusive" definition of family violence. Greens senator Jordon Steele-John — who was instrumental in getting the inquiry set up in 2019 — said governments "not only kicked the can down the road" last year — they "crushed it". Those governments — which missed the original response deadline by four months — agreed to start biannual progress reporting against all 222 recommendations from June 2025. However, that's yet to start, with the government confirming it's been delayed until at least mid-August. Commitments to bigger ticket recommendations — such as the phasing out of segregated education, housing and employment; creating a disability rights act; and changes to guardianship laws across the country — have been largely absent from progress reports, as well as from federal and state budgets. When they have appeared in budgets, they've sometimes been in opposition to the commissioners' recommendations — for example, Queensland's recently announced plan to open half a dozen new special schools. Many items from the initial response were listed as needing "further consideration", but exactly how far along that consideration has come remains unclear. The federal government noted last year that responding to the royal commission wouldn't be easy, saying recommendations straddled several jurisdictions and the six commissioners themselves didn't agree on everything. In a statement, a federal government spokesperson said it was taking the royal commission's recommendations "very seriously". They said the government remained committed to working with the disability community and state and territory ministers to "implement meaningful change". Senator Steele-John said that needed to be a matter of urgency. "We need the government to take the opportunity of this new parliament to actually look at the recommendations with fresh eyes and to decide to join the disability community in the work," he said. Governments have had the royal commission's recommendations since September 2023 but the systemic change it has demanded is clearly a long way off. That change was never going to happen overnight. Genuine co-design with people with disability takes time, too. Ms Cusworth understands that but she says the lives and safety of people with disability can't wait. Sally Robinson, a professor of disability and community inclusion at Flinders University, has some sympathy for governments because of how complex the situation is. "But I really do wish they would be more transparent so that we all had an idea about where that work was up to and why it's taking time," she said. People with disability are used to feeling sidelined, but the royal commission was supposed to be different. Two years ago, my colleague Nas Campanella wrote that, without change, the trauma of the inquiry would have been for nothing. And as we sit here in the second half of 2025, many of those who poured their hearts into this huge opportunity for reform fear that's how things are shaping up.

Men to face court after $1m worth of cocaine seized by NSW Police
Men to face court after $1m worth of cocaine seized by NSW Police

ABC News

timean hour ago

  • ABC News

Men to face court after $1m worth of cocaine seized by NSW Police

Two men will appear in court today after New South Wales Police seized more than $1 million worth of cocaine, cash and items alleged to be the proceeds of crime. In April officers from the Murray River Police District established Strike Force Whitecourt to target the supply of cocaine, ketamine and MDMA in the area. At 6am yesterday two search warrants were executed in Howlong and Wodonga, Victoria. Police say they seized five kilograms of cocaine with an estimated street value of more than $1m, MDMA valued at $30,000 and ketamine with an estimated street value of $15,000. Police say they also seized $50,000 in cash, two vehicles and $100,000 worth of goods that they allege are the proceeds of crime. Two men aged 29 and 31 have been charged with more than 30 offences, including the supply of a commercial quantity of drugs.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store