Cardinal democracy: Conclave and the politics of the election of the Pope
Mention thrillers and the politics of the Pope and many will immediately think you are referring to Angels & Demons by Dan 'Da Vinci Code' Brown, which—like Conclave—was given an extra dollop of publicity by a Hollywood film avatar starring Tom Hanks as Robert Langdon. But while that book/film did make millions of people realize the importance of the color of smoke coming out of a chimney in the Sistine Chapel, it was really more about suspense and drama. Conclave is a very different book—the equivalent of a five-course meal to a McDonald's burger.
Harris' gift lies in making history interesting without being cumbersome, something he has displayed in his books on Pompeii and Cicero. Conclave is not an overly long book. It is about 400 pages in length and can be easily read in 3–4 days. It revolves around the three days that follow the death of a Pope, and how the College of Cardinals selects his successor through a meeting known as a Conclave. The story is told mainly from the perspective of the Dean of the College of Cardinals, Cardinal Jacopo Lomelli (who is made British in the film, renamed Thomas Lawrence, and is played memorably by Ralph Fiennes). Entrusted with the task of organizing the election of the new Pope, Lomelli finds himself having to deal with 117 Cardinals from different parts of the world, each with their own agendas and ambitions. Things are not helped when a 118th Cardinal turns up at the last minute, claiming to have been made a Cardinal in pectore ('in the heart') by the recently deceased Pope.
'I would say that this is a pretty fair vision of hell,' the secretary of the College says, looking at the hectic preparations for the selection. 'Don't be blasphemous,' Lomelli rebukes him, and then adds, 'Hell arrives tomorrow, when we bring in the cardinals.' He is proved right.
As the Cardinals arrive at a special building, the Casa Santa Marta, that is totally sequestered from the rest of the world to discuss candidates, different groups and cliques form. The elite collection of deeply religious people begins to argue and lobby. Prejudices surface even among the pious—some believe women should never be ordained, others insist on Latin being used more frequently, and still others believe it is time the Pope was an Italian. And even as this is going on, Lomelli gets disturbing information about one of the frontrunners for the post.
Tension builds up as one round of ballots follows another, and candidates campaign—subtly and brazenly—for votes, and cardinals no one had considered suddenly emerge as contenders. And at the cost of being spoilsports, we need to add that there is a twist at the end. Harris narrates it all brilliantly, without ever being overdramatic, proving that you don't need puzzles, violence, or sex to keep a reader riveted. And he garnishes the story with Biblical references and some treasures of trivia—the papal robes are made by Gammarelli and the cassocks worn by the Cardinals have 33 buttons, each representing a year in the life of Christ.
There are intense debates between the Cardinals on issues of personal and spiritual integrity and also on theological issues, but Harris' simple, smooth narration ensures that the reading never gets too heavy. There is also an undercurrent of wry, often dark humour which lightens matters when the mood gets too somber—Lomelli tries to go to sleep trying to count the snores of a Cardinal in the next room and gives up after reaching five hundred! There are flashes of wit too: 'His beliefs are sincere. But they are sincere nonsense,' a Papal candidate snaps about another.
At the end of it all, you will find yourself shaking your head in amazement, and understanding why Cardinal Aldo Bellini, one of the favourites to become Pope, says at the beginning of the book:
'No sane man could possibly want the papacy.'
Every sane person, however, would love reading Conclave. To know more about the Pope and his election. Or about the politics of faith. Or simply to be enthralled by an amazing tale, narrated by a master. Yes, it is better than the film. In spite of Ralph Fiennes. Books almost always are, aren't they?
(Conclave By Robert Harris, 400 pages, Penguin, Rs 599)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
Celebrating Freedom with Reforms
Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced a 'Diwali gift' for the people two months ahead of the festival, declaring that the next set of goods and services tax (GST) reforms will be in place by October, besides underscoring a renewed reforms push, emphasising Atmanirbhar (self-reliant) Bharat as the bedrock on which Viksit Bharat will be built by 2047, and unveiling a ₹1-lakh crore jobs programme, among other initiatives. Independence Day 2025 Modi signals new push for tech independence with local chips Before Trump, British used tariffs to kill Indian textile Bank of Azad Hind: When Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose gave India its own currency In his 12th Independence Day speech that lasted 103 minutes, the Prime Minister also assured the nation he will soon declare from the Red Fort that India has become the third-largest economy in the world. Countering the Opposition's charge of high unemployment, Modi also said the PM Viksit Bharat Rozgar Yojana being launched on Independence Day will facilitate the creation of 35 million jobs. On Friday, he said, 'This Diwali, you are going to get a big gift. We are coming with the next generation of GST reforms.' The announcement comes close on the heels of parliamentary approval for two key items of legislation — the Income Tax (No 2) Bill and the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill — earlier this week. A total of 280 sections have been abolished in the Income Tax Act. The Prime Minister said the government has decided to constitute a task force to look into the prospects of next-generation economic reforms within a set time frame. 'Current rules, laws, policies, and procedures must be redrafted to suit the 21st century, to fit the global environment and to align with the vision of making Bharat a developed nation by 2047,' he said. The PM said the policy changes will reduce compliance costs, besides boosting startups and small and cottage industries. Other benefits will include a smoother export process, improved logistics and systems, and the abolition of archaic laws that led to imprisonment for minor matters. Modi urged all sections, including political parties, his rivals and fellow leaders, to take part in the efforts to build a bright future. 'I wish to tell my countrymen, everything I am doing, I am doing for the country, not for myself, not to harm anyone,' he said. 'Whether it is structural reforms, regulatory, policy or process reforms, or the need for constitutional reforms, we have made every kind of reform our mission today.' Atmanirbhar Bharat is the bedrock on which Viksit Bharat will be built, he said. The Prime Minister asserted that Operation Sindoor, the Gaganyaan mission and the manufacture of indigenous semiconductors has proved the power of self-reliance. 'The greater a nation's reliance on others, the more its freedom comes into question,' he said. 'Misfortune arises when dependency becomes a habit, when we do not even realise it, when we abandon self-reliance and become dependent on others. This habit is fraught with danger and hence, one must remain vigilant every moment to be self-reliant.' Made in India weapons and defence systems helped India during Operation Sindoor, he asserted. 'The enemy had no inkling of what weapons and capabilities we possessed, what power was destroying them in the blink of an eye,' he said. 'Imagine if we were not self-reliant, could we have executed Operation Sindoor with such swiftness? We would have been plagued by worries over who might supply us, whether we would get the required equipment, and so on.' Modi also announced the Sudarshan Chakra Mission for creating a complete security cover for all civilian installations in the near future. Since the 21st century is a 'technology-driven century,' it is imperative that India does not lag behind, the PM said, adding that every nation that mastered technology scaled the heights of development and attained new dimensions of economic power. He lamented that although India began the process of building infrastructure for semiconductor manufacturing six decades ago, the plan was stalled, delayed and shelved, while other countries mastered the technology and strengthened their position. 'Today, we have freed ourselves from that burden and advanced the work on semiconductors in mission mode,' Modi said. 'Six different semiconductor units are taking shape on the ground, and we have already given the green signal to four new units.' India is becoming self-reliant in space technology as well, he stated. 'We are also preparing for Atmanirbhar Bharat Gaganyaan on our own in space,' the Prime Minister said. 'We are working towards building our own space station. And I am very proud of the reforms done in space recently. More than 300 startups in my country are now working only in the space sector and thousands of youth are working with full potential in those 300 startups.' He also expressed satisfaction at the pace with which the National Manufacturing Mission was progressing and reiterated the importance of the 'vocal for local,' 'zero defect, zero effect' and 'lower price, higher value' themes. Underlining the need for promoting indigenous products, Modi urged all traders and shopkeepers to put up boards, saying 'Swadeshi goods sold here.' 'Today, on August 15th, we are launching and implementing a scheme worth Rs 1 lakh crore for the youth of my country,' he said. 'The Pradhan Mantri Viksit Bharat Rozgar Yojana is being implemented today… Under this scheme, the government will give Rs 15,000 to the youth, to every son or daughter who gets a job in the private sector.' The new jobs programme is expected to create new employment opportunities for approximately 35 million youth. Companies that generate more jobs will also be given incentives under the scheme. The Weight of Eight On the 79th Independence Day, Prime Minister Narendra Modi turned the Red Fort into a launchpad for the next chapter of India's rise. His bold announcements signal a nation ready to leap, not just step, into the future. From making India's first chip to building jet engines, his message was unambiguous: Bharat will set its own terms and aim to become a developed nation by 2047. Eight key announcements include… SEMICON: FROM LOST DECADES TO MISSION MODE Recalling how attempts to set up semiconductor factories 50–60 years ago were 'killed at birth,' the PM said India is now in mission mode. The first Made in India chip will roll out by year-end 10x Nuclear Energy Capacity by 2047 Work is underway on 10 new nuclear reactors as part of India's mission to increase nuclear power generation capacity by over ten times in the next two decades GST Reforms – A Diwali Gift Next-generation GST reforms will be unveiled on Diwali, reducing taxes on essential goods and providing relief to MSMEs, local vendors and consumers Bharat@$10 Trillion The PM said a dedicated Reform Task Force will be set up to drive nextgeneration reforms. Its mandate is to accelerate economic growth, cut red tape, modernise governance, and prepare the country for the demands of a $10-trillion economy by 2047 PM Viksit Bharat Rozgar Yojana A major employment scheme worth Rs 1 lakh cr was launched, under which newly employed youth will receive Rs 15,000. It aims to benefit 3 crore young Indians, making stronger the bridge between Swatantra Bharat and Samriddha Bharat Energy Independence – Samudra Manthan A large share of India's budget still goes toward importing fuel. A National Deepwater Exploration Mission was announced to tap ocean resources, alongside major expansions in solar, hydrogen, hydro and nuclear power High-Powered Demography Mission Highlighting dangers of infiltration and illegal migration, the PM launched a High-Powered Demography Mission to address this national security challenge Made in India Jet Engines – A National Challenge Modi made a dramatic announcement — for India to build its own jet plane engines, just like vaccines and UPI. He asked scientists & youth to take it up as a direct challenge
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
City mustard oil mill preserves Gandhian ideals
1 2 Ranchi: A shop-cum-mustard oil mill in capital's bustling Main Road area, which might be easily overlooked due to its modest appearance, stands as a living testament to India's freedom movement. Shyam Kishor Sahu established Gramudyog Bhandar in 1938 in response to Mahatma Gandhi's call to revive small-scale industries and promote self-reliance. At a time when imported goods dominated Indian markets, the mill churned out mustard oil, becoming both a source of livelihood and a symbol of the Swadeshi movement. Shyam ran the shop for 61 years, until his death in 1999. Since then, Shyam's son Narayan Prasad Sahu has been running the shop. "In 1934, Gandhiji called for re-establishing small industries across the country so that Indians get an opportunity to earn their livelihood. He set up a mustard oil mill in Wardha as an example. Disciples of Gandhi, my parents stayed at his Wardha ashram for years. My father returned to Ranchi and established the mill in 1938. As India celebrated its 79th Independence Day on Friday, the shop stands tall as a symbol of courage, patriotism, and ideals that dreamt of a free nation," septuagenarian Narayan, who is a physician, said. A plaque bearing Gandhi's wishes adorns the walls of the shop. During his visit to present-day Jharkhand to attend the 1940 session of the Indian National Congress held in Ramgarh, Gandhi stopped by the store and penned on a piece of paper, 'Iss Bhandar ki unnati ho' (May this store prosper), a message that continues to echo the shop's golden past. Shyam was jailed several times by the British, but his commitment to serve the country remained undeterred. "The shop was never just about selling oil. My father used the profits to support the movement, funding meetings, rallies, and helping fellow freedom fighters. Steeped in history, our shop aims to uphold and nurture Gandhi's ideals. I strive to preserve my father's legacy without altering its essence. The only change is that where bulls once churned the oil, machines have taken their place," Narayan said. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Kerala CM slams PM Modi for praising RSS in I-Day speech
T'puram: Chief minister Pinarayi Vijayan has criticized Prime Minister Narendra Modi for praising RSS in his Independence Day speech. He stated that giving credit to RSS and V D Savarkar for Indian independence was a denial of history. Vijayan said it was a dishonour to the independence struggle that the Prime Minister chose Independence Day itself to eulogize those who worshipped the British. RSS was banned in connection with the assassination of Mahatma Gandhi, and Savarkar faced conspiracy charges related to the murder, the chief minister said. Any amount of ridiculous efforts to whitewash an organization like RSS would not work. The conspiracy behind such an exercise was clearer in the Union petroleum ministry's Independence Day poster, featuring Savarkar above Gandhiji, he added. "It shows the panic of those who fear the history of the freedom struggle," Vijayan said in a statement. "Indians joined the national independence movement beyond caste, religion, dress and language differences. RSS played the role of bystanders then. They openly opposed the fundamental ideological concepts of the freedom movement. Instead of the unity in diversity that Indian nationalism upholds, they promoted a Hindutva nationalism based on majority communalism. On Nov 26, 1949, when the Constituent Assembly gave final approval to India's Constitution, the RSS mouthpiece, Organizer, editorialized that Manusmriti should be upheld instead of the Constitution," the chief minister said. Vijayan said Savarkar boycotted the Independence Day celebrations on Aug 15, 1947. It was this same Savarkar whom the Sangh Parivar is now projecting as a leader of the freedom struggle. RSS, which stood aloof throughout the phases of the freedom struggle, is now engaged in creating false narratives to claim a role in the national movement. "What respect do those who called for observing Aug 14 as a day of Partition horror have for Independence Day?" he asked. The nation must stand united against any attempt to bury the history of humanity and mutual respect and replace it with hatred, he added. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
