Governor proposes sterilising poor men to cut birth rates
The measure, proposed on April 29, aims to control birth rates among impoverished families as a long-term strategy to reduce extreme poverty in the region.
"If someone cannot afford pregnancy and their child's education, it's better not to rush into parenthood,' he was reported as saying by local media.
However, his statement ignited heated debates involving religious leaders, community figures, academics, human rights organisations and ordinary citizens, who deemed the proposal excessive, inhumane and a violation of basic rights.
A vasectomy is a permanent male contraceptive method involving a minor surgical procedure to cut and seal the tubes carrying sperm from the testes.
This procedure prevents sperm from mixing with semen, effectively preventing pregnancy. While it does not impair male sexual function, it is typically irreversible.
Dedi's proposal offers men who agree to undergo a vasectomy an incentive of IDR 500,000 (RM 130).
Even more controversially, other aid programmes, such as food subsidies, healthcare, scholarships and housing, would also be tied to the willingness of men to undergo the procedure.
"I want men to take more responsibility in family planning, not just leave it to women,' Dedi asserted.
Indonesia's Social Affairs Minister, Saifullah Yusuf, warned against arbitrarily linking any form of assistance to medical conditions that involve bodily autonomy.
'When it comes to bodily rights and health, every aspect must be carefully considered. This is not a simple matter,' he said.
Meanwhile, Community Empowerment Coordinating Minister Muhaimin Iskandar emphasised that such conditions contradict existing regulations.
'No legal provision allows states to impose such conditions on social assistance,' he said.
The West Java branch of the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) declared that vasectomy is forbidden in Islam if performed permanently without urgent medical necessity.
'Permanent sterilisation procedures like vasectomy are not allowed unless in cases of medical emergencies. This is not about money but about Islamic law,' stated its chairman, KH Rahmat Syafei.
The Indonesian Human Rights Commission (Komnas HAM) condemned the proposal, calling it a violation of individual bodily rights and undue pressure on the poor.
'The human body is an individual's absolute right. Tying aid to medical procedures is a form of coercion,' said its chairperson, Atnike Nova Sigiro.
Amid mounting criticism, Dedi Mulyadi clarified that his proposal was not coercive but rather an incentive-based voluntary programme.
'I'm merely encouraging, not forcing. If they don't want to, there's no compulsion. But we must think about the long-term future of impoverished families,' he explained.
In a public opinion poll conducted by local media, most Indonesians viewed the proposal as inhumane, degrading to the poor and inappropriate for a diverse, multicultural and religious country like Indonesia.
Many social media users also accused Dedi of exploiting the sensitive issue as 'cheap political capital' ahead of the upcoming elections. – AGENCY
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Barnama
5 hours ago
- Barnama
Yayasan Taqwa-MAIWP Channels RM50,000 To Upgrade Surau At-Taqwa In Janda Baik
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 16 (Bernama) -- Yayasan Taqwa of the Federal Territories Islamic Religious Council (MAIWP) has channelled RM50,000 to upgrade Surau At-Taqwa in Kampung Chemperoh, Janda Baik, Pahang. Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Religious Affairs) Datuk Dr Mohd Na'im Mokhtar said the assistance would be used for repair works at the surau for the villagers' benefit. 'I personally inspected the surau and took note of the needs that will be addressed with this fund. 'Hopefully, the upgrades will make the surau more comfortable and conducive, while upholding the syiar of Islam in this village,' he said in a statement today. Earlier, he presented a mock cheque to the surau management. Mohd Naim also visited Ma'ahad An-Noer, a centre for higher Islamic and Al-Quran studies founded by Syeikh Muhammad Nuruddin Marbu Al-Banjari Al-Makki. He said the ma'ahad played a key role in producing Islamic scholars and huffaz (Quran memorisers), who are valuable assets to the ummah. In support of this noble effort, Mohd Naim also approved immediate assistance of RM20,000 to help implement the educational programmes and activities planned by the ma'ahad. 'It is hoped that this contribution will strengthen the role of Ma'ahad An-Noer in educating the younger generation in religious knowledge, fostering appreciation of the Quran, and developing leadership based on Islamic values.
BusinessToday
7 hours ago
- BusinessToday
RM20 Million For TH Rebranding? Shocking, Says Former Staff
Letter to editor: I write not merely as an observer, but as a former employee of Lembaga Tabung Haji (TH), having served the institution for years and witnessed its rise as a globally respected symbol of Islamic fund management and faith. The name 'Tabung Haji' carries weight — synonymous with the sacred pilgrimage, with discipline in Islamic finance, with trust, and with blessings. So imagine my shock reading about the debate in Parliament on a potential spending of up to RM20 million on a 'rebranding exercise.' One cannot help but ask: is the TH brand so obscure, so forgotten, that Malaysians — or the Muslim world — no longer recognise it? Will a new logo or 'brand' miraculously bring pilgrims closer to the Kaabah? Or will it merely distance depositors from the very essence of their ibadah? As a former staff member, as a depositor, and as a Muslim, I fail to see the logic. This is happening when depositors await higher 'Hibah', subsidies remain limited, and TH itself is still regaining footing after years of political interference. Despite those challenges, TH's name endures with global respect. So why the obsession with a superficial facelift when what TH truly needs is an internal rebranding — strengthening integrity, building staff and depositor confidence, and recommitting to its sacred mission? But what truly stings is this: the rebranding job has been awarded to three companies — yes, not one, not two, but three — and every single one is owned and led by non-Muslims. Out of the hundreds of capable Bumiputera and Muslim-led and owned agencies in Malaysia, not a single one has been deemed 'worthy' by TH? I recall the era of Tan Sri Ismee Ismail's leadership, when TH worked with a Bumiputera and Muslim-owned communications agency of proven credibility. I had the privilege of working with them. They helped navigate crises, preserve TH's reputation, and their work even won industry awards for TH, three years in a row. Yet today, such homegrown expertise is dismissed in favour of outsiders with little understanding of Islamic values or the spiritual sensitivities underpinning this institution. Why? Yes, professionalism can come from anywhere. But let's be honest: this is not just a technical project. It is about identity, amanah, and faith. And the decision to entrust it to non-Muslim agencies sends a painful message: that TH trusts outsiders more to 'market' Islam than it does its own ummah. As a former staff member, I am both saddened and embarrassed. As a depositor, I am compelled to ask: how was this selection made? Was it transparent? Why were proven Muslim agencies overlooked? And above all — why should RM20 million be squandered on 'rebranding' an institution already recognised and respected across the globe? The only 'rebranding' TH truly needs is internal: rebuild governance, restore depositor trust, and recommit to the sacred duty of helping Muslims fulfil the fifth pillar of Islam. A logo or 'brand' change will not bring us closer to Allah SWT. Integrity, honesty, and sound management will. TH must explain itself — openly, transparently — to depositors and to the ummah. Why was this project approved? Why were Muslim agencies with proven capabilities ignored? Why the obsession with changing appearances when it is the soul of the institution that needs strengthening? If TH wishes to remain relevant and trusted, it must immediately halt this project and restart the process — fairly, transparently, and with rightful consideration for capable Muslim-led firms. And finally, let me pose the conscience test to TH's management: would any other faith-based institution in the world do what you have done? Has the Vatican ever hired a Muslim firm to redesign its identity? Has a Hindu temple in India or a Buddhist centre in Thailand ever entrusted such sacred representation to outsiders of another faith? Of course not — because they understand that identity, symbols, and communication tied to religion are sacred trusts, not corporate experiments. So I ask: where is your sense of duty? Where is your fidelity to Islam, to Muslims, and to the millions of depositors who entrust not only their savings, but their prayers, confidence, and hopes to TH? If the management cannot uphold this principle, what then remains to defend the dignity of this institution? -FORMER TH STAFF-
Borneo Post
8 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Sarawak Premier calls for spiritually-grounded, digitally-ready Muslim leaders
Abang Johari speaking at the opening ceremony of the RISEAP International Youth Leadership Training 2025 at the Sabah International Convention Centre on Saturday. KOTA KINABALU (Aug 16): Muslim leaders must be spiritually grounded and digitally empowered to meet the challenges of a fast-changing world, said the Premier of Sarawak, Datuk Patinggi Tan Sri Abang Johari Tun Openg. Abang Johari. 'In an age of Artificial Intelligence, digital communication and automation, Muslims must not be left behind. We must be equipped with the tools, literacy and mindset needed to serve the ummah effectively, both on the ground and online,' he said at the opening ceremony of the RISEAP International Youth Leadership Training 2025 at the Sabah International Convention Centre (SICC) here on Saturday. Abang Johari,who is also the president of the Regional Islamic Da'wah Council of Southeast Asia and the Pacific (RISEAP), urged the participants to embrace technology without compromising Islamic values. He emphasised that RISEAP envisions a future where traditional Islamic values are amplified through smart technology, and where da'i are empowered to lead with wisdom, integrity and purpose in both real and digital spaces. A total of 22 young participants from 14 countries including Malaysia, Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam, Myanmar, the Philippines, Taiwan, Japan, South Korea, Sri Lanka, Papua New Guinea, Vanuatu and Samoa are attending the week-long training. The programme builds upon the International Da'i Training held earlier in Kuala Lumpur in February, co-organised by RISEAP and the International Da'wah Institute of Putrajaya (IDIPKL). It aims to strengthen capacities of emerging Muslim leaders through intensive workshops, cross-cultural engagement and field exposure. 'This training is more than learning how to speak or organise. It is about developing the heart and mind of a true leader, one who serves, who uplifts, and who walks in the footsteps of the Prophet Muhammad,' he added said. In his address, Abang Johari reflected on RISEAP's founding on November 11, 1980 by Malaysia's first Prime Minister, Tunku Abdul Rahman Putra al-Haj, who envisioned a platform that would unite Muslims living as minorities across the Asia-Pacific region. 'He wanted RISEAP to bring together Muslim-minority communities to pursue collective ambitions and remain fired with enthusiasm for the Islamic cause,' he said, adding that the organisation's slogan, In Service of Muslim Minorities, still resonates strongly today. He also paid tribute to the late Tun Abdul Taib Mahmud, who served as RISEAP president from 1988 until 2023 and helped shape the direction of the movement with his passion for youth empowerment and institutional development. With 52 member organisations from 24 countries and territories, RISEAP has grown into a vital network promoting Islamic education, leadership and da'wah. Abang Johari encouraged member organisations to take ownership in designing Islamic education curricula suited to their local contexts. 'Education is central to our agenda, not just in content, but in building character and resilience among Muslim youth,' he said. He also highlighted RISEAP's commitment to reviving Islamic social finance instruments such as baitulmal and waqf, calling them essential tools in addressing poverty, supporting da'wah and sustaining long-term community development. The Sarawak Premier reiterated that the leadership training serves as more than a classroom for young da'i. It is also a space for fostering interfaith understanding, strengthening regional bonds, and preparing youth to be responsible, confident representatives of Islam. 'At RISEAP, one of our primary objectives is to demonstrate our willingness to collaborate with other communities for the advancement of society,' he said.
