Edmonton city council approves reallocating $5M for more transit peace officers

CBC

10-04-2025

City council will redirect $5 million to place more transit peace officers at LRT stations throughout Edmonton, to try to address social disorder and crime.
Council had asked city administration to further analyze the implications of reallocating portions of the existing, ongoing funding for commissionaires. In a report, administration outlined five options, the default being that council redirect spending for more officers.
But Wednesday's council meeting saw robust debate, after Coun. Anne Stevenson proposed a motion that, if it had passed, would have split funding between deploying more officers and implementing a safety attendant program — another option administration raised that could improve safety and the public's perception of safety.
The program would offer "a consistent presence in stations, a friendly helping hand when needed, and increased cleanliness — which has a huge impact on perception of safety," Stevenson said.
Over the past several years, council and city administration have focused on transit safety and security through measures like adding more uniformed security, joint deployment and community outreach teams, better cleaning, facility upgrades and esthetic changes like murals and other art.
Edmonton Police Service data shows the average crime severity at LRT stations and transit centres decreased by six per cent last year, although calls for services at those locations rose by 12 percent.
A March report from city administration found many Edmontonians still don't feel safe taking transit, despite ridership growing by 15 per cent in 2024.
Commissionaires, who do security work, don't have enforcement authority transit peace officers do, but they can administer naloxone in the event of a drug overdose. Commissionaires reported security incidents most at several Capital Line LRT stations — including Central, Churchill and Southgate — and the Kingsway/Royal Alex Station.
In the report, administration suggested redirecting funding to hire 30 more transit peace officers, which would increase the total deployed throughout Edmonton to 126.
During Wednesday's meeting, councillors discussed how officers could be used to address safety and the public's perception of safety.
WATCH | Do Edmontonians feel safe taking transit?
Do Edmontonians feel safe taking transit?
1 month ago
Duration 2:31
Stevenson's motion was defeated 4-8. Some councillors argued that splitting funding between two initiatives would be less effective.
When asked by the city in an online survey in 2024, about 61 per cent of respondents said they felt safe using transit — about the same as in the 2023 survey, that suggested 60 per cent of respondents felt safe.
Coun. Aaron Paquette voted in favour, saying it could address safety immediately.
"It takes time to train [transit peace officers], and it doesn't take as much time for a safety attendant program. So if we want to see some immediate action, that's how we do it," Paquette said.
But Coun. Andrew Knack, who voted against the motion, said the additional 30 officers wouldn't help people feel safer.
"We're sort of kidding ourselves, right now, if that's going to be the big factor, " Knack said, adding that the city would still be short officers.
"All we're talking about is reallocating $5 million. In a scenario like what we're facing, instead of doing either job somewhat OK, I'd rather do one of them relatively more OK."
Coun. Karen Tang also voted down the motion, despite noting that council has frequently discussed transit safety and that it is "very prominent" in her ward of Karhiio, through which runs the Valley Line Southeast LRT.
"The data doesn't really show a lot of those stations as a hotspot just yet — and I will worry, without proactive measures, that one day, they will become a hot spot," Tang said.
"But I really don't want us to get there."
Tang put forward a subsequent motion, asking administration to gather information tied to measuring how implementing transit peace officers would impact safety and the perception of it.
The motion passed.