Tobacco companies called on government to age restrict nicotine pouches
A vaping company labelled proposed regulation for the sector as 'draconian, excessive and unnecessary' at the same time as the tobacco industry was calling for tighter rules on nicotine pouches.
Corporate lobbying documents released to The Irish Times under the Freedom of Information Act reveal that two of the largest tobacco companies in the world called on the Irish government to regulate nicotine pouches and to add age restrictions to the product.
Japan Tobacco International
(JTI), the company behind Nordic Spirit-branded nicotine pouches, wrote to then minister for health
Stephen Donnelly
in May last year, calling for the product to be 'robustly regulated'.
'Nicotine pouches should not be sold to individuals under 18 years of age,' the company said, recommending against packaging that would target children and calling for the addition of a health warning of nicotine content and a strength indicator.
READ MORE
Shortly after, in a separate communication, a representative for JTI said there had been 'an influx of disposable e-vapour products' into Ireland with 'packaging and flavour descriptors that appealed particularly to young people'. It noted that youth uptake of the products had 'increased significantly' due to the lack of regulation in marketing.
JTI Ireland said it would like to 'avoid a similar situation with the nicotine pouch category'.
In August 2024
British American Tobacco
(BAT) also wrote to Mr Donnelly to raise 'concerns regarding the sale and retail of high strength nicotine pouches' in Ireland and calling for regulation on these products.
BAT, which sells these products under the Velo brand, said it was 'concerned' by reports of pouches with 'concentrations of nicotine as high as 50mg, 75mg and even 150mg', which it said could be acutely toxic in the highest of these doses.
The company called for the implementation of a maximum nicotine limit of 20mg, as well as further regulation regarding the packaging of these products.
BAT said with 'appropriate regulation' nicotine pouches would be an alternative to smoking for adults 'without the risk of products being retailed that are misleading, potentially appealing to underage or which contain excessively high levels of nicotine'.
A representative for the minister acknowledged the letter but said it would not meet the company citing an article of the
World Health Organisation
Framework Convention on Tobacco Control under which they must 'act to protect [the convention's] policies from commercial and other vested interests'.
The company reiterated its concerns to the Minister for Health
Jennifer Carroll MacNeill
in January 2025 after she had been appointed to the role, saying there is a 'clear need to act now and regulate nicotine pouches and introduce requirements to prevent the sale of these products to under 18s'.
Separately, one of Ireland largest vaping product retailers labelled measures outlined by Mr Donnelly to regulate the vaping products as 'draconian, excessive and unnecessary'.
In an email to Mr Donnelly in August 2024 the director of retailer and manufacturer Hale Vaping, Joe Dunne, said, 'your objective appears to be to apply the same – or even greater – regulation to a category of products' that he claimed 'are significantly less harmful than cigarettes' and offers a 'gateway for thousands of Irish smokers out of smoking'.
The company's director said 'recent and existing regulations are not being enforced' and said the inspections of retail premises are 'almost non-existent'.
Mr Dunne suggested the government implement a deposit and return scheme for disposable vaping devices, among a series of policy suggestions.
Earlier in 2024, as part of the public consultation period on the Further Regulation of Tobacco and Nicotine Inhaling Products, Mr Dunne said: 'It is hard to think of a more draconian or retrograde policy decision from a public health perspective' than raising the price of vaping products.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
What are the new rules around organ donation in Ireland and what if I want to opt out?
What is happening from today? The Human Tissue Act 2024 introduces a presumption that your organs will be available for donation after you die. Previously, people had to actively opt in to the process. Now, the presumption has shifted, and adults – other than those in an excluded group – will be considered to have agreed to donate unless they actively opt out. If someone does not want to donate, they should note this via the national organ donation opt-out register. Even if a deceased person is not on the opt-out register, their next of kin will still be contacted to seek consent. The HSE says people who have registered to opt out 'will have their wishes respected', and their family will not be approached on the issue after death. READ MORE Excluded from this change are children under the age of 18, people who do not normally live in Ireland or who have lived in Ireland for less than a year and people who may not have had the capacity to decide to opt out of organ donation. What is the process of organ donation? If you do not opt out, you will be presumed to have opted in to the process. In that case your next of kin will be contacted for permission to use one of your organs for transplant . It is not possible to opt out of donation of individual relevant organs. You cannot, for instance, say you are happy to posthumously donate your kidney and not your lungs. The deemed organs covered by the Act are the heart, lungs, liver, pancreas and kidneys. The Act provides for non-directed altruistic donation by adults only, with additional protections and safeguards for donors. This covers the donation of an organ to somebody who is not known to the donor. [ Waiting for an organ donor: 'It was the beginning of the hardest chapter in our family's life' Opens in new window ] The legislation forbids pressurising a living donor. It prohibits any payment or reward for donating organs, tissues or cells. The Act also provides a framework for donation while alive and will, for the first time, provide a way for people to donate a kidney to someone they do not personally know if they wish to. Why is this legislation being brought in? Similar legislation is already in place in the UK and in many other EU countries. Ireland was an outlier in not having such a law. At any given time, there are hundreds of people in Ireland who are on waiting lists for organ transplants, according to the HSE. Dr Brian O'Brien, national director of the HSE's Organ Donation Transplant Ireland, said not everyone who dies is a potential organ donor. A donor needs to be in hospital and on a life-support machine. All organs donated go to people most in need of a transplant. 'Consent is at the heart of this change,' he says. 'When someone dies, their family must agree to donate their organs. It is important to inform your family and friends about your decision regarding organ donation, as they will always be consulted and your wishes should be central to any decision.' What difference will it make to those in need of an organ donation? There were 263 organ transplants last year from 84 deceased and 30 living organ donors. At any time, there are between 500 and 600 people on the transplant waiting lists. It is hoped that waiting lists will come down as a result of this initiative and lives will be saved. HSE chief clinical officer Dr Colm Henry said: 'The opt-out organ donation system will bring us in line with international best practice. Organ transplantation is one of the great advances in modern medicine.'
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
Neurent Medical to create 125 jobs at new manufacturing facility in Galway
Galway medtech company Neurent Medical is to create 125 jobs at its new manufacturing facility. The jobs, which will be in engineering, quality control, operations, supply chain, and sales and marketing, will be created by the end of 2028. Neurent Medical has developed a minimally invasive device that helps deal with the inflammatory response that leads to rhinitis, or chronic runny nose. It will be manufactured at the new facility, which was officially opened on Tuesday at Westlink Commercial Park in Oranmore, Co Galway. READ MORE The move follows the recent FDA clearance for the next-generation Neuromark system, which opens the way for further commercialisation in the US. 'We're proud to scale our operations in Galway, where the MedTech ecosystem continues to thrive. Our new Westlink facility gives us the manufacturing capacity to meet growing demand for Neuromark, while creating high skilled employment opportunities and contributing to economic vitality in the west of Ireland,' said Brian Shields, CEO of Neurent Medical. 'As an Irish-founded company, we're excited to manufacture our product locally with the exceptional skills available and deliver Irish-engineered MedTech innovation to the world.' It also expands the growing medtech ecosystem in Galway. Neurent Medical has its roots in the Enterprise Ireland-supported BioInnovate Ireland Programme, founded by Mr Shields and chief technology officer David Townley as a spin-out, and has grown from concept to commercialisation within a decade. 'Today's announcement of new jobs based here in Oranmore shows that Ireland is leading in research and development within the medical device space,' said chief executive designate of Enterprise Ireland Jenny Melia. 'Supporting Irish companies with the ambition to scale globally is a key priority for Enterprise Ireland and we will continue to work closely with Brian and the team at Neurent Medical to optimise their full international growth potential, creating and sustaining jobs here in the Galway region.' The opening was attended by Minister of State at the Department of Children, Disability and Equalit yHildegarde Naughton. 'Galway is known as a major player in Medical Technology, being home to eight of the world's top 10 MedTech companies,' she said. 'Today's announcement is further evidence of that and, as a native myself, I am particularly proud to see 125 new highly skilled jobs being created by a company based in Oranmore. It is also highly notable that this is an Irish company, supported by Enterprise Ireland, and selling into the US market.'
Irish Times
13 hours ago
- Irish Times
Up in smoke: Minister for Health snubs tobacco industry
The tobacco industry's hopes of meeting the Minister for Health went up in smoke recently when requests were snubbed citing commitments to World Health Organisation (WHO) articles on tobacco regulation. Two of the largest tobacco companies in the world have urged the Irish Government to regulate nicotine pouches and to add age restrictions to the product, according to documents released to The Irish Times under the Freedom of Information Act. Concerns around vaping and nicotine pouches are very much the issues of the day, so to hear Japan Tobacco International (JTI) and British American Tobacco (BAT) lobbying for these changes is perhaps not surprising. Will rent reform make building apartments viable? Listen | 40:12 Notably, though, tobacco companies are blowing the whistle on nicotine-inhaling products which are targeting young people. READ MORE 'We have seen products with 'Gummy Bear', 'Jolly Ranger', 'Skittels' and 'Slushee' flavour descriptions. Products which are shaped like toy guns and 'fidget spinner' toys,' JTI said in a consultative submission on the Further Regulation of Tobacco and Nicotine Inhaling Products. Owning Nordic Spirit- and Velo-branded pouches respectively, JTI and BAT are seeking to get ahead of and shape the regulation of their products. These attempts, however, were not hugely successful. Representatives of both then minister for health Stephen Donnelly, and current Minister, Jennifer Carroll MacNeill, responded identically to the two companies, citing Article 5.3 of the WHO's Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, to which Ireland is a signatory. 'In setting and implementing their public health policies with respect to tobacco control, Parties shall act to protect these policies from commercial and other vested interests of the tobacco industry in accordance with national law,' their representatives said. 'In this context, it would not be appropriate for the Minister to engage on the topics posed in your letter.' Conveniently for any journalists sniffing around the topic, the representative reminded JTI that the company must include their letter and attempt at shaping the sector's regulation to the Standards Commission under lobbying regulations. Ironically, it was pointed out that the 'correspondence may be made available to the public under a Freedom of Information request'. Put that in your pipe and smoke it.
