Palestine activists challenge Royal Opera House over Ukraine support
Described by one audience member online as 'extraordinary scenes', a video was published online showing the performer resisted attempts to have the flag removed.
Now, Scottish activists have written to the board and said the Opera House doubling-down on their stance is "like rubbing salt into the wound".
Soon after the incident, the ROH issued a statement, writing: 'The display was a spontaneous act by the artist which was not approved by the theatre and was completely inappropriate for a curtain call'.
They added that the flag "is not in line with our commitment to political impartiality.'
Activists from the Scottish Palestinian Society wrote to the theatre's chief executive, Alex Beard, and said in 2022, following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the Opera house issued a statement in solidarity with Ukraine.
In 2022, the ROH stated: 'All of us here at the Royal Opera House are shocked and appalled by the ongoing humanitarian crisis unfolding in Ukraine."
READ MORE: Uniqlo store's historic colonial ties uncovered by Scottish university research
They added: 'As an expression of respect for all those affected by this terrible conflict, we will be lighting our building in the colours of the Ukrainian flag every night from 28 February, and in a moment of reflection playing the national anthem of Ukraine before each performance.'
Activists questioned : "We would like to ask why, despite the horrors of what we have witnessed being done to occupied Palestinians including, the widely documented mass starvation, the targeted killing, torture and imprisonment of Palestinians including doctors, academics, artists and journalists, the ROH has not once dedicated the effort and consideration to Palestinians that it has repeatedly and rightfully afforded to Ukrainians?
"This includes what appears to be not a single statement of solidarity with Palestinians, a people living under the world's longest illegal occupation and subjected to some of the worst crimes against humanity, including man-made mass starvation of an entire civilian population. Something the world has not witnessed since World War Two."
READ MORE: Pro-Palestine protest at Scottish office of 'Israeli-linked' tech company
The campaigners also claimed the artist who displayed the Palestinian flag during the performance has been barred from working for the ROH.
In response, Beard said the flag displayed at the curtain all was "not authorised and occurred outside the framework of the performance".
"Our commitment to neutrality is not a dismissal of suffering or injustice, but a reflection of our responsibility to maintain a space where audiences and artists feel welcome, regardless of background or belief," Beard replied.
Alex Beard (lef) (Image: Archant)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
3 hours ago
- STV News
Musicians head to Berlin as part of 'Brand Scotland' trade mission
Young Scottish musicians will perform in Berlin this week as part of a UK Government effort to promote Scottish culture and attract international investment. Members of the National Youth Orchestra of Scotland (NYOS) and their guest soloist, Ryan Corbett, will perform at a business and government breakfast event at the British Ambassador's residence, hosted by Scottish secretary Iain Murray and UK's ambassador to Germany, Andrew Mitchell. The event, dubbed 'Symphony and Sausages', will see guests served smoked salmon, haggis, black pudding and homemade potato scones while showcasing Scottish music. It comes as part of efforts by the Scotland Office to boost 'Brand Scotland', promoting Scottish produce and culture in a bid to help economic growth. UK Government/Lauren Hurley Secretary for Scotland Ian Murray Murray said: 'Scotland's cultural excellence is one of our greatest assets in attracting international investment and driving economic growth. The National Youth Orchestra of Scotland represents some of our most extraordinary musical talent. I'm delighted that they are able to join me in Berlin, and this performance will demonstrate Scottish culture at its finest. 'My 'Brand Scotland' campaign is about selling all that is fantastic about Scotland to the world, to encourage both exports and inward investment in Scotland, and I'm very pleased that we have been able to fund this event in Berlin.' Brand Scotland is a key part of the UK Government's Plan for Change, bringing real rewards for people in Scotland.' The visit is part of Murray's 'Brand Scotland' trade mission to 'sell the best of Scotland to the world', forming part of the UK Government's Plan For Change. The orchestra is in Berlin to perform at the Young Euro Classic festival, premiering a new accordion concerto by Scottish composer Jay Capperauld under the baton of Catherine Larsen-Maguire. During his two-day trip, Murray will also meet German officials, including Michael Meister, Minister of State for Federal-State Relations, and representatives from Germany's 16 federal states. The breakfast is funded by a £2,700 grant from the Scotland Office's Brand Scotland fund, part of a wider UK Government programme to boost Scotland's trading relationship with Europe. Murray's visit follows the signing of a new UK-Germany treaty and comes ahead of a speech in Edinburgh where he will outline the role of Scottish culture in economic growth. The minister is also set to travel to India and Sweden as part of the 'Brand Scotland' initiative. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Warmth and wit shine through in Gambler's Guide to Dying Fringe Show
Traverse Theatre **** The way Gary McNair was told it, when England beat West Germany in the final seconds of the 1966 World Cup Final, his granddad won a small fortune after betting on the result. This appears to have been much to the chagrin of his fellow drinkers in the spit and sawdust Gorbals boozer where he watched the game, but it seems to have been well worth the beating that resulted. Read More: More than three decades on, McNair's granddad makes another bet that inspires similarly grand thinking in the telling, whether he wins it or not. Inbetween, McNair is at his granddad's side, listening to stories as they grow into legend, until he starts telling his own. There is something heroic about McNair's solo play, receiving its tenth anniversary outing in this revival of Gareth Nichols' production at this year's Fringe. As he paces around the clutter of an old-school living room set, McNair is not only telling his own shaggy dog story about the man who was clearly a major influence on how he turned out. Over the play's seventy minute duration, he is giving voice to the everyday experiences of his granddad's generation that might otherwise risk being lost. Read more: The warmth and wit that shines through McNair's performance may be charming, but there is a profound insight too in his relating of matters of life and death. He has honed over the last decade to become one of the cleverest and funniest solo dramatists to ever spin a yarn on a Scottish stage. The combination makes for a poignant labour of love that gets infinitely better with age.
Metro
3 hours ago
- Metro
Vanessa Redgrave, 88, hailed as ‘national treasure' after rare appearance
Vanessa Redgrave has been praised for turning up to a protest addressing the ongoing starvation crisis in Gaza. In recent weeks there has been increased international attention on the suffering of civilians in Gaza, with photos of starving Palestinians, including babies, emerging. With aid agencies issuing stark warnings about the desperate situation on the ground, there's been a public outcry for intervention in the conflict, which is about to enter its third year. Although Israel has denied any responsibility for what experts have now called a famine, it controls the flow of all aid into the enclave and has been blamed by agencies, including Doctors Without Borders and Oxfam International, for 'restrictions, delays and fragmentation' for 'chaos, starvation and death'. Over the weekend, more protests occurred across the world calling for action, including in London, where Redgrave, a long-time supporter of Palestine, was spotted. On Friday evening the Pots and pans for Palestine protest was held at the Lambeth Town Hall in Brixton, with attendees asked to 'bang pots and pans to echo the hunger faced by Palestinians trapped under blockade'. The demonstration – organised by Lambeth and Southwark for Palestine and West Norwood 4 Palestine – was part of a UK-wide day of action, with the acclaimed actress photographed taking part. Photos taken at the event show the 88-year-old in a wheelchair holding a spoon and pan. Sharing it on social media, photographer Misan Harriman wrote: 'I burst into tears when I saw this image of our national treasure, Vanessa Redgrave, still fighting for us to recognise the humanity of Palestinians 46 years after her Oscars speech. She has endured so much for this cause, but she still shows her solidarity in London today! 'Unfiltered humanity, perseverance, and empathy in one soul. 'Thank you sincerely, Vanessa; you are a real one!' he added, also tagging her daughter Joely Richardson. 'Oh!!!! THIS is phenomenal!!!!!!!' Annie Lennox commented. 'Stunning! Thank you Vanessa,' Paloma Faith wrote. 'She is an amazing human being,' Rosie O'Donnell added. Many others praised Redgrave's long-standing activism and 'moral backbone to speak truth to power'. In 1977, Redgrave produced and starred in a controversial documentary film, The Palestinian, about the activities of the Palestine Liberation Organization. She funded the film by selling her house, but faced fierce backlash from some, with one screening of the film even being hit by a bomb. The following year Redgrave, whose career has spanned six decades and seen her win an Academy Award, a Tony Award, two Primetime Emmy Awards and an Olivier Award, won the Oscar for best actress in a supporting role for her part in the drama Julia. After she paid tribute to the film's writer, she ended her speech with a message directed to the Palestinian people: 'And I salute you, and I pay tribute to you, and I think you should be very proud that in the last few weeks you've stood firm, and you have refused to be intimidated by the threats of a small bunch of Zionist hoodlums. 'I salute you and I thank you and I pledge to you that I will continue to fight against anti-Semitism and fascism.' More Trending Redgrave had been referring to the extremists of the Jewish Defense League who had offered a bounty to have her killed. Throughout her career Vanessa has also participated in anti-Vietnam War protests, served as a UNICEF Goodwill Ambassador, launched the Peace and Progress Party and in 2017 made her directorial debut with the movie Sea Sorrow, a documentary about the European migrant crisis and the plight of migrants encamped outside Calais, France, trying to reach Britain. In 2018 she told The Hollywood Reporter: 'I had to do my bit. Everybody had to do their bit, to try and change things for the better. To advocate for what's right and not be dismayed if immediately you don't see results.' Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: What does recognising Palestine as a state really mean? MORE: What's stopping Keir Starmer from recognising Palestine as a state? MORE: Freed Hamas hostage says Starmer 'on wrong side of history' over Palestine
