Intel spars with EU regulators over $421.4 million antitrust fine
FILE PHOTO: The Intel Corporation logo is seen at a temporary office during the World Economic Forum 2022 (WEF) in the Alpine resort of Davos, Switzerland May 25, 2022. REUTERS/Arnd Wiegmann/File photo
LUXEMBOURG (Reuters) -U.S. chipmaker Intel on Friday sparred with EU antitrust regulators over a 376 million euro ($421.4 million) fine levied nearly two years ago for excluding rivals from the market, arguing that it was disproportionate and unfair.
The case dated to 2009 when the European Commission slapped a then-record 1.06 billion euro fine on Intel for blocking rival Advanced Micro Devices.
The tech giant managed to convince the General Court, Europe's second-highest, to scrap the penalty in 2022.
Judges however agreed with one part of the Commission's 2009 decision, prompting the EU competition watchdog to re-impose a 376 million euro fine for payments made by Intel to HP, Acer and Lenovo to halt or delay rival products between November 2002 and December 2006.
Such practices are known as naked restrictions and are frowned on by antitrust regulators. Intel then took its case back to the General Court, asking for the new EU decision and penalty to be annulled.
Intel's lawyer said the EU competition enforcer had not taken into account the limited scope of the violations related to HP, Acer and Lenovo.
"The Commission cannot sustain a finding that there was an overall strategy to foreclose competitors from the entire x86 chips market. These were narrow, tactical moves," Daniel Beard told the panel of five judges.
"The naked restrictions can't be treated as in effect of equal weight to each of the pricing practices which were overturned. Nor do they have the same sort of cumulative effect or strategic weight. They, on their own, don't sustain an overall, market-wide strategy finding," he said.
Beard said the Commission had imposed "a wholly disproportionate and unfair" fine.
The EU watchdog rejected Intel's arguments.
"The Commission correctly applied the finding guidelines, and when in doubt, opted in Intel's favour," its lawyer Pedro Caro de Sousa said.
"The fine is clearly not disproportionate to the seriousness of Intel's conduct, amounting to 1% of its turnover on the last year of the infringement, and about 0.5% of its turnover today," he said.
Both Intel and the Commission called on the court to resolve the issue by setting the size of the fine. A ruling is expected in the coming months.
The case is 09:30 T-1129/23 Intel Corporation v Commission.
($1 = 0.8922 euros)
(Reporting by Foo Yun Chee; Editing by Jan Harvey)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Apple challenges 'unreasonable' EU order to open up to rivals
People walk by the Apple store on Fifth Avenue in New York City, U.S., May 1, 2025. REUTERS/Kylie Cooper/File Photo (Reuters) - Apple has submitted a legal challenge to an EU order to open up its closed ecosystem to rivals such as Meta and Alphabet's Google, saying the demands are unreasonable and hamper innovation. The European Commission had in March detailed how Apple must comply with the Digital Markets Act, which aims to rein in the power of Big Tech. Apple said the EU's interoperability requirements create "a process that is unreasonable, costly, and stifles innovation". "These requirements will also hand data-hungry companies sensitive information, which poses massive privacy and security risks to our EU users," it said in a statement. "These deeply flawed rules that only target Apple - and no other company - will severely limit our ability to deliver innovative products and features to Europe, leading to an inferior user experience for our European customers." Meta, Google, Spotify and Garmin are among companies that have requested access to Apple users' data. The legal fight will likely take years to play out in court. Until then, Apple will have to comply with the EU order. The Commission ordered Apple to give rival makers of smartphones, headphones and virtual reality headsets access to its technology and mobile operating system so they can connect with Apple's iPhones and iPad tablets. It also set out a detailed process and timeline for Apple to respond to interoperability requests from app developers. (Editing by Kevin Liffey)
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Analysis-Polish nationalist's election victory deepens fiscal uncertainty
WARSAW/LONDON (Reuters) -Poland's path to narrowing its fiscal deficit, maintaining its credit ratings and keeping investors on board looks more difficult following conservative nationalist Karol Nawrocki's presidential election triumph. Nawrocki's victory in Sunday's election could deal a blow to the centrist government's efforts to cement the European Union and NATO member state's pro-European orientation. Poland faces big spending demands, including a rise in defence outlays after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and is grappling with the EU's second-highest fiscal deficit, driven in part by what are widely seen as generous social policies. Prime Minister Donald Tusk, who returned to power in 2023, has struggled to fulfil electoral promises that could strain public finances and the outgoing president, Andrzej Duda, has used his presidential veto powers to block some of Tusk's political agenda. Nawrocki, who like Duda is aligned with the opposition, could employ similar tactics, possibly delaying reforms and increasing the government's reliance on fiscal measures in the run-up to a 2027 national election. "The Nawrocki presidency will fuel domestic political instability. Tusk's reform agenda will be paralysed," Eurasia group analyst Orsolya Raczova said in a note, adding that Nawrocki could "actively stoke tension among coalition partners." S&P Global said that, at a minimum, Tusk could during Nawrocki's presidency expect similarly "uneasy relations" between the president and the government, and that Poland's economic strength and medium-term fiscal policies would remain the most important factors for Poland's credit rating. Poland has pledged to bring its budget deficit below 3% of gross domestic product by 2028, but, given the high-stakes election calendar, Tusk's government has ramped up borrowing to record levels ahead of the presidential ballot. UNDER PRESSURE Polish stocks fell on Monday from near 14-year-highs, underperforming central European peers, and Poland's international bonds also came under pressure, with longer-dated maturities down between 0.5-0.7 cents on the euro, Tradeweb data showed. Hasnain Malik, managing director with Tellimer, said the result was a "jolt" to investors. Before Monday, the zloty had been up 11% versus the dollar this year and the local equity index had been up 40% in total U.S. dollar return terms. The International Monetary Fund projected in April that Poland's economy would grow 3.2% this year and 3.1% in 2026, and slow to 2.7% by 2030. But last month the European Commission forecast that the deficit would be more than 6% of GDP this year and next, nearly double the average for the 27-member EU and the bloc's second-highest behind Romania. The yield on Poland's 10-year domestic government bond - a key benchmark for borrowing costs - is currently at around 5.5% - below the 6% mark it hovered around for much of the first three months of the year. "Poland is likely to face continued political polarisation in the coming years, with the next general elections scheduled for 2027, potentially increasing reliance on expansionary fiscal policies and delaying fiscal consolidation," Scope Ratings said. S&P warned last week that while it was "not in a rush" to adjust Poland's 'A-' credit rating, the deep polarisation in Polish politics made lowering deficits potentially risky. Poland has a narrow window before the next election to craft a medium-term fiscal adjustment. Some economic analysts say its ability to do so now looks more uncertain. "It is likely to be increasingly more challenging to implement fiscal tightening measures after the loss by the ruling coalition in the presidential election," Ercan Erguzel, an economist at Barclays, wrote in a note. One of Tusk's main unfulfilled electoral promises is a doubling of the income tax free threshold, with an estimated price tag of some 55 billion zloty ($14.76 billion), coming on top of social benefits already widely viewed as generous. Aleks Szczerbiak, politics professor at the University of Sussex, said Tusk's government was hostage to its income tax pledge, with cost-of-living issues still weighing on Poles despite inflation retreating. "If they get to the next election, and there's no road map and they haven't started implementing it, that tax free allowance thing is very, very difficult," he said, adding that the political demand was directly at odds with the economic imperative. "And I'm not quite sure how they're going to square that circle." ($1 = 3.7264 zlotys) (Additional reporting by Paweł Florkiewicz, Editing by Libby George and Timothy Heritage)
Free Malaysia Today
5 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
EU says it will make strong case for US tariff cuts this week
The EU has said it strongly regrets the planned doubling of steel tariffs. (EPA Images pic) BRUSSELS : The European Commission said today it would make a strong case this week for the US to reduce or eliminate tariffs, even after Donald Trump said he would double import duties on steel and aluminium to 50%. European trade commissioner Maros Sefcovic will meet US trade representative Jamieson Greer at an OECD gathering in Paris on Wednesday, while commission technical teams will be in discussions with counterparts in Washington this week. The commission, which oversees trade policy for the 27-nation EU, said it was prioritising negotiations to resolve the conflict. 'We don't want to go down the route of tariffs. Rather than have them increase, we want them to decrease and, where possible eliminate them,' a commission spokesman told a press conference today. 'That remains the case, that remains our priority. We will be making that case strongly both at technical level and at political level this week,' the spokesman said. The EU has said it strongly regrets the planned doubling of steel tariffs. The EU currently faces 25% tariffs on steel and cars and for Trump and 'reciprocal' tariffs on most EU goods, which were provisionally set at 20% for the EU but is being held at 10% during a 90-day pause until July. The EU imposed, but immediately suspended, a first set of counter tariffs on €21 billion (US$24 billion) of annual US imports package in response to US metals duties. It is also weighing a response to the US car and broader tariffs that would hit up to €95 billion of US imports. The commission said that, in the absence of a mutually acceptable solution, these countermeasures would take effect automatically on July 14, or earlier if circumstances require.
