Artist pulls show from National Portrait Gallery over censorship concerns
Why it matters: Artist Amy Sherald alleged the Smithsonian-owned art museum, which confirmed the show's removal, considered excluding one work in Sherald's show that depicts the Statue of Liberty as a transgender woman.
The big picture: The complete show, "American Sublime," was slated to debut in September and would have been the museum's first show by a Black contemporary artist. The piece in question was "Trans Forming Liberty."
"While we understand Amy's decision to withdraw her show from the National Portrait Gallery, we are disappointed that Smithsonian audiences will not have an opportunity to experience American Sublime," the Smithsonian said on Thursday in a statement to Axios.
Zoom in: Sherald, who didn't immediately respond to Axios' request for comment, told The New York Times the museum feared backlash from President Trump. She said she had been "informed that internal concerns had been raised" at the Portrait Gallery regarding the painting.
"These concerns led to discussions about removing the work from the exhibition," she said.
"I entered into this collaboration in good faith, believing that the institution shared a commitment to presenting work that reflects the full, complex truth of American life," Sherald wrote in a letter to Smithsonian secretary Lonnie G. Bunch III on Wednesday, per the Times.
A Smithsonian spokesperson told Axios the museum never wanted to remove Sherald's painting, but include an additional video to "contextualize the piece."
"The Smithsonian strives to foster a greater and shared understanding," the spokesperson said.
"By presenting and contextualizing art, the Smithsonian aims to inspire, challenge and impact audiences in meaningful and thoughtful ways. Unfortunately, we could not come to an agreement with the artist."
Sherald said, per the Times:"The video would have opened up for debate the value of trans visibility and I was opposed to that being a part of the 'American Sublime' narrative."
Context: The Trump administration has threatened to pull funding from a wide range of institutions — from hospitals to Harvard — if they acknowledge, let alone protect, LGBTQ+ people or people of color.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
24 minutes ago
- USA Today
Justice Department files complaint against judge who blocked deportations
In a social media post, the attorney general accused District Court Chief Judge James Boasberg of making "improper public comments about President Trump and his Administration." The U.S. Department of Justice has intensified its scrutiny of the judiciary by filing a formal misconduct complaint against one of President Donald Trump's least-favorite federal judges. Attorney General Pam Bondi said on July 28 that she directed her agency to file the grievance because James Boasberg, the 62-year-old chief judge for the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, made "improper public comments about President Trump and his Administration" in March. "These comments have undermined the integrity of the judiciary, and we will not stand for that," Bondi wrote on X. Boasberg is the judge who initially blocked the deportation flights of hundreds of alleged Venezuelan gang members the Trump administration carried out under the Alien Enemies Act. When the administration ignored his order to bring the flights back, Boasberg began contempt proceedings, which were later halted by an appeals court. The Supreme Court eventually vacated the temporary ban on the deportations. Read more: Trump shipped them to El Salvador. Their families say their only crime was a tattoo. President Donald Trump said on social media in March that Boasberg was a "Radical Left Lunatic" and called for his impeachment. John Roberts, the chief justice of the Supreme Court, intervened, issuing a rare public statement that said in part: "For more than two centuries, it has been established that impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreement concerning a judicial decision." Read more: Chief Justice John Roberts rebukes Trump after president calls for judge's impeachment In Bondi's complaint, Chad Mizelle, her chief of staff, accused Boasberg of attempting to improperly influence Roberts and other judges during a conference on March 11. Mizelle said that Boasberg expressed concerns about the Trump administration disregarding federal court rulings, and those alleged remarks violated rules that judges have to follow about not discussing pending cases in public. Then-President George W. Bush first nominated Boasberg in 2002 to serve on the primary trial court for Washington, D.C. Boasberg advanced to the federal bench in 2011 thanks to a lifetime appointment from then-President Barack Obama. An assistant to Boasberg declined to comment. Contributing: Reuters
The Hill
24 minutes ago
- The Hill
Press freedom group files ethics complaint against FCC chair
The Freedom of the Press Foundation has filed an ethics complaint against Brendan Carr, the chairman of the FCC, arguing the close of ally of President Trump has 'engaged in egregious misconduct,' and calling for him to be disbarred. In the organization's complaint, filed with the District of Columbia Court of Appeals' Office of Disciplinary Counsel on Monday, cites Carr's public statements and actions in the weeks leading up to the agency's recent approval of the Paramount, Skydance merger. 'Everyone from U.S. senators to CBS employees to a dissenting FCC commissioner has said the settlement appears to have been a bribe to grease the wheels for Carr's FCC to approve the merger,' the complaint reads. 'Even putting Paramount aside, Carr has pursued numerous other frivolous and unconstitutional legal proceedings and threatened more of them in furtherance in his efforts to intimidate broadcast licensees to censor themselves and fall in line with Trump's agenda.' The organization's complaint was first reported in journalist Oliver Darcy's media newsletter Status. Carr had in the weeks leading up to the merger publicly blasted CBS News over its coverage of the Trump administration and indicated he believed the '60 Minutes' interview that sparked a lawsuit against the network from President Trump could hold up FCC approval of the $8 billion deal. Paramount, CBS's parent company, earlier this month agreed to pay Trump's foundation $16 million and its new parent company made several concessions as part of its merger agreement with Skydance. Carr praised those promises, including the appointing of an ombudsman to monitor CBS coverage for objectivity, in announcing the agency had approved the deal last week, saying 'Americans no longer trust the legacy national news media to report fully, accurately, and fairly. It is time for a change.' 'Carr's actions brazenly violate legal and ethical standards that govern the practice of law and public officials, undermining the First Amendment, the FCC's credibility and the laws he is trusted to administer,' the complaint said. 'His abuse of his office to force an unwarranted settlement of a private lawsuit, is shameful and warrants disbarment.'
New York Post
24 minutes ago
- New York Post
Pope Leo XIV receives a rock star's welcome at Catholic influencer festival
Pope Leo XIV on Tuesday received a rock star's welcome at the Vatican's festival of Catholic influencers — priests, nuns and ordinary faithful who use their social media presence to preach and teach the faith — as he urged them to ensure that human relations don't suffer with the spread of digital ecosystems and artificial intelligence. History's first American pope was mobbed by hundreds of influencers, their cellphones hoisted high to stream the encounter, when he arrived in St. Peter's Basilica after a special Mass. The pilgrims have descended on Rome for a special Holy Year celebration of so-called 'digital missionaries,' part of the Vatican's weeklong Jubilee for young people that culminates this weekend with a vigil and Mass in a vast field on Rome's outskirts. 6 History's first American pope was mobbed by hundreds of influencers, their cellphones hoisted high to stream the encounter. AP Leo thanked the young people for using their digital platforms to spread the faith, and he gamely posed for selfies. But he warned them about neglecting human relationships in their pursuit of clicks and followers, and cautioned them to not fall prey to fake news and the 'frivolity' of online encounters. 'It is not simply a matter of generating content, but of creating an encounter between hearts,' Leo said in a speech that showed his ease switching from Italian to Spanish to English. 'Be agents of communion, capable of breaking down the logic of division and polarization, of individualism and egocentrism.' 'It is up to us – to each one of you – to ensure that this culture remains human,' he said. 'Our mission – your mission – is to nurture a culture of Christian humanism, and to do so together' in what he called the only networks that really matter: of friendship, love and the 'network of God.' Warnings against going off-message 6 The pilgrims have descended on Rome for a special Holy Year celebration of so-called 'digital missionaries.' REUTERS For the past two days, the Vatican's message to the young influencers has been one of thanks for their social media evangelizing, but also a warning to not allow their posting to go off-message or to neglect the human dimension of all encounters. For Leo, the issue is particularly heartfelt since he has said that addressing the threat to humanity posed by AI will be a priority of his pontificate. 6 Leo thanked the young people for using their digital platforms to spread the faith, and he gamely posed for selfies. IPA / The Rev. David McCallum, an American Jesuit who heads a leadership development program and spoke to the influencers at a conference Monday, held periodic breaks in his presentation with instructions for those in the audience to actually speak with the person next to them, for up to 10 minutes at a time. Cardinal Antonio Tagle, the head of the Vatican's evangelization office, urged the influencers to avoid anything that smacks of false advertising, coercion or brainwashing in their posting, or to use their platform to make money. He noted that he himself had been a victim of a fake video advertising arthritis medicine. 'Brothers and sisters, be discerning,' Tagle told the influencers in his homily at Tuesday's Mass. A mini World Youth Day in Rome 6 The pope warned them about neglecting human relationships in their pursuit of clicks and followers, and cautioned them to not fall prey to fake news. AP Tuesday began with groups of influencers and young pilgrims passing through the basilica's Holy Door, a rite of passage for the estimated 32 million people participating in the Vatican's 2025 Holy Year celebrations. This week, downtown Rome swarmed with energetic, singing and dancing masses of teenage Catholic scouts, church and Catholic school groups. It all had the vibe of a scaled-down World Youth Day, the once-every-three-year Catholic Woodstock festival that was inaugurated by St. John Paul II. 6 For Leo, the issue is particularly heartfelt since he has said that addressing the threat to humanity posed by AI will be a priority of his pontificate. AP The most recent one in Lisbon, Portugal, went viral thanks to the Rev. Guilherme Peixoto, a village priest in northern Portugal who also happens to be a DJ. He's in Rome this week, though it's not clear if he will reprise his now-famous set that woke young people up before Pope Francis' final Mass in Lisbon. In it, as he jammed to house music behind his console in full clerical collar, Peixoto spliced into the set both St. John Paul II's exhortation to young people to 'be not afraid' and Francis' insistence in Lisbon that the church had room for everyone, 'todos, todos, todos.' 6 This week, downtown Rome swarmed with energetic, singing and dancing masses of teenage Catholic scouts, church and Catholic school groups. AP That mantra has become something of the refrain for this year's youth Jubilee, with #todostodostodos being used across platforms by pilgrims posting about their time in Rome. Pablo Licheri, who founded the Catholic Mass Times app, which provides locations and times for Catholic liturgies around the world and has registered 2 million downloads, said he has been heartened by both Leo's message of unity and the enthusiasm of social media-savvy Catholics like him. 'I was especially moved to meet so many fellow Catholic influencers in person and to pray together with others who share the same passion for spreading the joy of God's love,' he said after Tuesday's Mass.
