Matt Hancock gives verdict on botched Covid 'test and trace' operation
Former health secretary Matt Hancock is grilled at the Covid-19 Inquiry about setting up a privatised "test and trace" service which failed to prevent repeated lockdowns
Matt Hancock has defended Britain's botched pandemic 'test and trace' operation at the Covid-19 Inquiry which failed to prevent repeated lockdowns.
The former Health Secretary outsourced the nation's vital contact tracing rather than beefing up existing NHS and local public health laboratories and its failure contributed to the need for further lockdown measures. The disgraced ex-minister blamed health leaders for being unable to scale up testing laboratories, insisting 'Public Health England didn't have the operational capacity to scale [up]'
The Tories' privatised 'NHS Test and Trace' operation was set up in May 2020 costing £37 billion and led by Mr Hancock's friend, Tory Peer Baroness Dido Harding.
Outsourcing firms like Serco were paid millions to call people and advise them to self-isolate but used agency call centre staff paid the minimum wage who were largely not medically trained.
The former I'm a Celebrity Get Me Out of Here contestant said: 'The critical thing is that we absolutely must, as a nation, be ready to expand and radically expand testing capacity. Once the test is developed, I had to do that.
'And there are critics who said that it was done in the wrong way. What matters is that it's done and it is planned for next time to be ready to be done.'
PM Boris Johnson promised a " world beating" system but the Public Accounts Committee later found NHS Test and Trace failed in its main objective of breaking chains of COVID-19 transmission. A BBC investigation at the time showed only half of close contacts were being reached in some areas.
Mr Hancock said Public Health England (PHE) 'proved entirely incapable of expanding that testing capacity', adding: 'It was a cottage industry and we needed industrial scale capacity'.
The inquiry heard how Mr Hancock set up a contract tracing system 'from scratch' rather than providing the funding to upgrade local authority labs and facilities run by PHE.
The barrister questioning Mr Hancock on behalf of the inquiry asked whether he was aware that local contact tracing systems already existed.
Sophie Cartright KC said: 'Did you appreciate that, that the directors of public health within local authority is discharged and performed the role of contact tracing? There was this resource in every local authority across the United Kingdom that had the resources.'
Mr Hancock responded: 'Of course I appreciated that. There was one person in each of the upper tier local authorities and therefore, around 100 people, brilliant people, I engaged with a huge number of them throughout the pandemic. But the idea that they alone could have solved this problem was, unfortunately, the wrong attitude.'
Mr Hancock resigned as health secretary in 2021 after admitting breaching social distancing guidance after photos showed him in a romantic embrace with colleague Gina Coladangelo.
Lack of NHS testing capacity meant testing everyone who had Covid symptoms had to be abandoned early in the pandemic once 'community transmission' was established in the UK.
Mr Hancock told the inquiry: 'The doctrine that we had going into the pandemic, that was shared by most of the Western world and the World Health Organisation, was wrong.
'The advice I received from Public Health England was that we should not need or try to test at scale or contact trace at scale as soon as there was community based transmission. There was no point in testing and contact tracing any further outside of hospitals because, effectively, everybody was going to get infected.
'That was the wrong attitude and it is absolutely critical that next time there's a pandemic… we are ready to take the actions to stop it spreading and protect the most vulnerable first.'
He concluded: 'The single most important thing is to conclude that the industrial scale, expansion of testing is necessary and we need to be ready to do it.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
14 minutes ago
- BBC News
'Our honeymoon money paid for my husband's funeral'
Two young widows who lost their husbands to heart conditions have launched a podcast about their Burr, 31, from Banbury, Oxfordshire, and Gabby Evans, 32, from Burnley, have previously campaigned to lower the age of NHS health Burr, whose husband died six months after their wedding, said the weekly podcast would deal with "raw emotions and real lives".She told the first episode: "I literally had to spend the money me and Ed had earmarked for a honeymoon on his funeral." Her husband fell ill on the day after their wedding in April 2024 and was diagnosed shortly afterwards with dilated cardiomyopathy, which inhibits blood died in October at the age of 32 while waiting for a heart Evans' partner Tom Brakewell, who was 34, died suddenly at home in January 2025 with an undiagnosed heart widows, who have never met in person, previously joined forces to launch an online petition to lower the age - currently 40 - at which the NHS starts to invite patients for full health screening. Mrs Burr said: "I fully believe if health checks were mandatory and Edward had gone for a health MOT between 25 and 30 his heart issue would have been flagged and he would still be here."The pair released The Podcast That Shouldn't Exist on the first episode, Mrs Burr told how she walked down the aisle at the wedding and the funeral to the same music, from her husband's favourite film series Lord Of The Evans described her fantasy that her partner would leap up and "jump scare" her at the chapel of rest. The pair said the podcast was "a space we never asked to create about a club no-one wants to join".In response to the widows' campaign, the Department of Health and Social Care said: "Our deepest sympathies are with the families of Edward and Tom."The NHS's life-saving health checks are targeted towards those at higher risk, preventing around 500 heart attacks and strokes every year and stopping people developing a range of diseases."To increase availability and uptake of the checks, we are developing a new online service that eligible people can use at home to understand their risk of cardiovascular disease and diabetes." You can follow BBC Oxfordshire on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.
STV News
15 minutes ago
- STV News
Voters urged to ‘call time on SNP failure' as by-election looms
Voters in Lanarkshire have been urged to 'call time on SNP failure' as a Holyrood by-election campaign enters its final days. Voters will go to the polls in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election on Thursday with the SNP, Labour and Reform hoping to win the seat vacated by former government minister Christina McKelvie. The SNP and Labour were initially seen as the frontrunners but a surge by Nigel Farage's party has made a second place finish seem possible, though leaders have publicly said they believe they can win. As the final week of campaigning begins, Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie urged voters in the seat to 'chart a new direction for the whole of Scotland'. 'After almost two decades in charge, the SNP has left public services at breaking point – almost one in six Scots are on an NHS waiting list, violence is rife in our schools, and high streets across Scotland are struggling,' she said. 'We cannot risk a third decade of SNP government and only Scottish Labour can beat them. 'Ignore the desperate spin of Reform and the SNP – this by-election is a direct fight between Scottish Labour and the SNP. 'We have three days to put this failing SNP government on notice and start the journey towards a better future for Scotland.' Baillie added that the Labour Government had spent its first year in office 'working to clean up the mess left behind by 14 years of Tory chaos'. But Scots are 'still not feeling the benefit of these changes' because of the Scottish Government. 'SNP inaction means we still have sky-high NHS waiting lists, a low-pay, low-growth economy, and a devastating housing emergency,' she said. 'It's time for John Swinney and the SNP to take responsibility for their failures and admit that the blame for Scotland's biggest challenges lies squarely at the door of Bute House.' An SNP spokesperson said: 'The SNP is taking action on what matters to people – creating 100,000 additional GP appointments, 150,000 extra NHS appointments and procedures, scrapping peak rail fares, investing £186.5 million to increase teacher numbers and keeping key costs like water bills lower. 'That's what it means to put Scotland first. We recognise that times are still too tough for too many, and we are doing something about it. 'Meanwhile, Labour are letting down Scots – taking away the winter fuel payment from 900,000 Scottish pensioners, cutting £5 billion of support for disabled people and presiding over a £150 increase in energy bills. 'That's the reality of Labour in power – broken promises and Scotland treated as an afterthought – and even they know they've lost with a candidate who is running scared of hustings and debates. 'This contest is a straightforward fight between the SNP and Nigel Farage's Reform UK, and the only way to stop Farage on June 5 is by voting for Katy Loudon.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Western Telegraph
28 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Thousands in west Wales waiting too long for eye care
Nearly half of those patients have already waited more than 36 weeks, raising fears of avoidable, permanent vision loss. The latest figures come during Cataract Awareness Month and highlight what health professionals are calling a growing crisis in eye care across South Wales. Of the total waiting, more than 8,000 patients in the Hywel Dda University Health Board area are breaching target treatment times. Sam Evans, a consultant ophthalmologist in west Wales, said: "I'm frustrated. "We're seeing avoidable sight loss because people simply cannot get seen in time. "Cataracts are treatable, but patients don't need to wait as long as they are, and are coming to harm with these long waits." Mr Evans runs a private 'see and treat' cataract service in west Wales, working with optometrists who provide clinical referrals. His model offers telephone consultations and surgery within two to four weeks of referral, often requiring just a single hospital visit. He has also performed same-day bilateral cataract surgery for five years and believes the approach is both safe and efficient. Mr Evans said: "In many cases patients only need to come to the hospital once – for surgery on both eyes, and need no further visits. "This approach is fantastic for older patients who struggle to get to the hospital for repeated visits." The service has proven especially valuable in rural areas like Carmarthenshire, Pembrokeshire, and Ceredigion, where travel to hospital can be a major barrier. One patient, Ron Jenkins, waited more than two and a half years for NHS surgery before opting for Mr Evans' service. He said: "After waiting over two years on the NHS list, I was hesitant to go private but my vision was getting worse and affecting my daily life. "I wasn't sure about having a phone assessment at first, but it worked brilliantly. "I was offered a one-stop visit for assessment and surgery, saving me a 55-mile round trip. "The care was excellent, the surgery painless, and I'm now driving at night and reading fine measurements again, life back to normal." Optometrist Rachel Brady said: "Embracing the convenience of telephone consultations and the innovative 'see and treat' approach in cataract surgery transforms the patient experience, eliminating the need for multiple, time-consuming exams and logistical hurdles." Mr Evans believes June's Cataract Awareness Month should lead to real change. He said: "Awareness campaigns matter — but awareness alone isn't enough. "We need real action. "The solutions exist, but need to be put into place at scale."
