logo
Hakea Prison still breaching national and international human rights standards

Hakea Prison still breaching national and international human rights standards

Conditions in one of WA's busiest prisons are continuing to breach national and international human rights standards, according to the prisons watchdog.
An inspection found Hakea Prison in Canning Vale remained overcrowded, with some cells holding three prisoners despite being designed for one.
"The conditions are still in breach of international human rights," Inspector of Custodial Services Eamon Ryan told the ABC.
"The prison is full, way over capacity, and the prisoners that are being held there are not getting any sort of effective rehabilitation.
The prison is the state's main remand facility, mostly holding inmates who are yet to be sentenced.
Mr Ryan said the problem with a lack of rehabilitation went beyond individual prisoners.
"Most people who are in prison will one day be released from prison, and they'll be standing next to you in the shopping centre or on the street," he said.
"And if they don't get effective rehabilitation, they're more than likely to come out worse than they went in."
Longstanding problems came to a head in mid-2024 when Mr Ryan issued a show cause notice to the government over its running of the facility — one of the strongest warnings he can issue.
Since then, he said, there had been increased recruitment of prison officers to address staffing pressures and the creation of a task force to tackle other issues.
"Despite this, the men at Hakea are still being held in conditions that do not meet the basic level of decent treatment required under national and international human rights and standards," Mr Ryan's report reads.
"There is limited evidence available to me to show that the significant system level reform and change needed is likely to be achieved."
The report's first recommendation is for the government to hold a "formal inquiry" into problems at Hakea to work out a path forward.
"The problems in Hakea are symptomatic of the broader problems within the justice system," Mr Ryan said.
"I think we need to have a circuit breaker.
"We need to look at all options, not just how to manage prisons, not just how to have increased bed capacity.
"We need to look at diversion programs, we need to look at pre-release programs, we need to look at programs and rehabilitation within prison, and then better support once people are released from prison to help them not return to prison."
A family member of a prisoner who was recently in Hakea has described conditions as "barbaric", echoing many of Inspector Ryan's concerns.
The ABC has referred to the family member as Darren because he asked to remain anonymous due to an upcoming sentencing hearing.
"The conditions in the cells are unhygienic. There's cockroaches everywhere," he said.
"[They said] on one occasion there were 40 cockroaches overnight that they caught in one room, and three [people] to a cell.
Darren said he had tried to visit the family member six times over about two months, but half were cancelled before he could attend, which he blamed on short-staffing and lockdowns.
He said he used to believe in locking up prisoners and throwing away the key, but seeing a close family member's experience first-hand had completely changed his views.
"We should be putting money into the prisons to do rehabilitation because all we're doing in there is breeding offenders and turning them against the custodial system," he said.
The family member had recently been transferred to a different prison, Darren said, where they were doing "much better".
In a statement, the Justice Department said it was "actively implementing changes" at Hakea, including efforts to improve medical and custodial staffing.
"We remain committed to addressing issues identified by [the Inspector of Custodial Services] and delivering better conditions and outcomes for Hakea Prisoners," Director General Kylie Maj said.
Corrective Services Commissioner Brad Royce said a Hakea task force was working to improve the safety, care and welfare of prisoners and return to normal daily routines.
"Beyond Hakea, the department is also strategically managing the overall adult prisoner population across WA through a newly established adult prisoner population co-ordination working group," he said.
"This initiative demonstrates our commitment to systemic, state-wide solutions."
The department supported or supported in principle all of the recommendations it was responsible for, including allowing all prisoners access to at least one hour of fresh air each day, ensuring access to clean clothes and increasing access to social visits.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Liberal Party's climate policy a huge headache for state and federal leaders
Liberal Party's climate policy a huge headache for state and federal leaders

ABC News

time10 minutes ago

  • ABC News

Liberal Party's climate policy a huge headache for state and federal leaders

Political parties are funny beasts, as the Liberals were reminded on the weekend. To win elections they need to appeal to broad sections of the community, many of whom only have a passing interest in politics once every few years. Former Liberal Prime Minister John Howard famously referred to the party as a "broad church" for voters. And yet the heart of the parties — the kind of people who, for example, show up to Saturday morning meetings years out from an election — are not always representative of broader society. Both Labor and the Liberals can struggle at times because it is those very people who help shape policies — and more importantly, party brands in the eyes of ordinary voters. It can create headaches when, for example, that core group votes to abandon a commitment to net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, continuing a debate which has dogged the party for years, as the WA Liberals' State Council did on Saturday. The group also voted to remove the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Island flags behind the prime minister at press conferences and cut back on Welcome to Country ceremonies. The net zero issue has dogged the Liberals for years, with federal leader Sussan Ley setting up a working group to review the party's policy after its federal election drubbing. But the WA Liberals' State Council was not waiting for that review, nor was one of its most prominent voices who supported the motion. "We're part of a process," frontbencher Andrew Hastie, acknowledged on Saturday. "But I think it's pretty clear the South Australian division, the WA division, the Northern Territory division have adopted this position. "We'll see how the LNP goes in future weeks." The debate is shaping up as a thorny issue for Ley, who faces not only division between the party's membership and its elected members, but among its own MPs. In a sign of just how thorny the issue is, WA Leader Basil Zempilas had to spend part of his Monday morning defending his different position after attending the council meeting, but leaving before votes were taken. "The WA Parliamentary Liberal Party supports the status quo," he told reporters. "We are very comfortable with standing in front of the Aboriginal flag, we are very comfortable with the Welcome to Country and we support the status quo on the net zero targets." Party members who spoke to the ABC on the condition of anonymity to speak freely pointed out there was not necessarily anything unusual with that position. The views of the lay party — ordinary members who voted on Saturday — are not binding on elected MPs, who have the final say on the party's policies. Lay party motions are just one viewpoint to consider, they said. Also, they added, the motions were focused on the federal party, not the state. Which is all well and good, and gives Zempilas the ability to freely offer his own position without creating an even bigger storm. But it does little to solve the Liberals' key problem: the effect this splintering can have on public perception at both state and federal levels. Because the potential cost of this position is making it harder to win back the very voters who have deserted the party in recent years. At a state level, the party had bled voters to a more centrist Labor Party for a range of reasons, including it would seem the Liberals' drift further to the right on some issues. Federally, the cost has been even more clearly seen in seats taken by teal independents. The seat of Curtin, taking in Perth's leafy Western suburbs, had been as Liberal as they come until independent Kate Chaney swung the electorate in 2019 with a campaign heavily focused on climate. "I got the biggest swing in WA, five-and-a-half per cent. Pretty sure I got a strong endorsement," was Hastie's alternative view. For some though, there is also a view this issue is about more than just net zero, but ultimately the leadership of the party. While far from a universal view, there is little doubt having such a public show of disunity so early into Ley's leadership will only work against her prospects of staying in the job long-term. Hastie had been touted as a possible leadership contender after the May federal election, but bowed out early before Ley was installed. "I'd be foolish to say I don't have a desire to lead, I do have a desire to lead," he told the Curtin's Cast podcast at the time. "But the timing was all out for personal reasons." Politics is a game where little is done without an eye to the future prospects of each decision. Hastie, and others, clearly see some benefit in creating a clear point of difference with Labor over future climate policy. The question voters will decide in a few years' time is whether that is of benefit only among the party's core base, or helps win over electors more widely.

A social media threat to Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin will go unpunished after an AFL investigation
A social media threat to Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin will go unpunished after an AFL investigation

News.com.au

time10 minutes ago

  • News.com.au

A social media threat to Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin will go unpunished after an AFL investigation

Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin opted against the AFL taking any further action after the league's Integrity Unit investigated an online threat made in the wake of the Demons last quarter capitulation against St Kilda on Sunday. Two goals in the final 60 seconds to Saint Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera, including one after the siren, sealed the biggest three-quarter-time comeback in AFL history and consigned the Demons to a famous defeat. As he was conducting his post-match press conference, a post from an anonymous account on X included an image of a ute in a car park and a chilling caption. 'I'm currently waiting outside Simon Goodwin's car: Don't fret, Melbourne fans you won't need to worry any further,' the post read. It came after a Collingwood member was banned from the AFL, and MCG, for five years after posting a message on the ground's anti-social behaviour hotline about Carlton coach Michael Voss. Melbourne made the AFL Integrity Unit aware of the post but confirmed on Monday there would be no further action, confirming the car in the photo did not belong to Goodwin and it wasn't taken in the Marvel Stadium car park. 'The AFL Integrity Unit has investigated the reported tweet regarding Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin post-game,' the league said in a statement. 'The image posted was not Goodwin's car, nor was it from Marvel Stadium. 'Goodwin has been consulted and does not wish to take the matter further, and there is currently no further action from Victoria Police. 'The AFL is currently working with the platform 'X' to help identify the owner of the account.' Melbourne captain Max Gawn defended Goodwin, who is now in the spotlight after the loss, and said the players were to blame to the chaotic finish. He also said Goodwin, the 2021 premiership winning coach who is contracted for another season, had hit support. 'He's my favourite coach and he's a premiership coach, Gawn said. 'I find him extremely smart tactically and, in the end, he's had us 50-points up against St Kilda, a team that we were down by 50 [points] in Alice Springs. He's in it with us, but the last quarter is not solely on him,' Gawn said.

Defence and prosecution deliver closing arguments in Janelle Fletcher child sexual abuse trial
Defence and prosecution deliver closing arguments in Janelle Fletcher child sexual abuse trial

News.com.au

time20 minutes ago

  • News.com.au

Defence and prosecution deliver closing arguments in Janelle Fletcher child sexual abuse trial

The final arguments in the trial of a music teacher accused of sexually abusing a teen girl have circled around a movie night kiss captured in a photo booth and a series of emotionally charged emails. Janelle Colville Fletcher, 40, is contesting allegations that she groomed and sexually abused the underage girl some years ago and appeared again on Monday at the South Australian District Court before Judge Joanne Fuller. The prosecution, led by Chris Allen, allege Ms Fletcher abused the girl in various locations and also that she communicated with her and another teenage girl to make them amenable to sexual activity. Some of the alleged offending happened when the two girls and Ms Fletcher were alone together in a room, the prosecution said, with the teacher allegedly performing a lap dance on a chair. She then allegedly 'dared' the two girls to kiss each other and asked if they would 'date' each other. That same night, Mr Allen said, Ms Fletcher then spent time alone with one of the girls and touched her genital area. The alleged grooming and abuse of the girl then went on for months at various locations, the prosecution said, including the home of Ms Fletcher and in Ms Fletcher's car. Alongside oral evidence from the alleged victims, the prosecution presented a series of texts, emails and photographs to support its case, including a photo of Ms Fletcher and the girl kissing at a cinema photo booth. In his closing address, Mr Allen said the 'objective evidence' of the photo booth kiss showed an 'unlawful sexual act'. He argued further that the 'sheer volume' of photos of Ms Fletcher and the girl together suggested a sexual relationship. 'They look like girlfriends (in the photographs) … in a relationship between girlfriends,' Mr Allen said. In her testimony from last week, Ms Fletcher said the photo booth kiss was a 'pretend kiss' she did not want or mean to happen. 'It was meant to be a pretend kiss like we had done previously where our lips don't actually touch, and in that particular photo we got close and she did sort of pull me in and the photo went off, yeah,' Ms Fletcher said. There is dispute between the defence and prosecution about the correct sequence order of photos from the booth. The prosecution says the correct sequence runs from top to bottom in the order of one, two, three and then four. In 'photo 4', Ms Fletcher appears happy and the prosecution argues this shows she was happy to kiss the girl and not shocked or upset by it. Ms Fletcher and her defence team, led by Andrew Culshaw, claim that photo was taken before the kiss and should not be seen as approval of the act, with the correct sequence of photos running one, two, four and then three. Mr Culshaw also argued the photo did not show child sexual abuse because the girl had turned 17 at the time of the photo, and so she was therefore not a child when the kiss happened. The defence argued Ms Fletcher was also no longer in a position of authority at the time. 'What Your Honour has, in my submission, is evidence of a kiss at a time when it was legal,' Mr Culshaw said. The prosecution also argued that a series of emotionally expressive emails from Ms Fletcher to the girl revealed the 'true nature' of the relationship between them. In one email, Ms Fletcher told the girl 'I want something serious not something short term'. In others, she said 'my feelings for you are not lust but love' and 'right now, we can't be open. Right now we will have to continue as we are in secret …' Ms Fletcher had earlier argued the emails showed non-sexual 'love' for the girl, but Mr Allen dismissed that argument on Monday as 'absurd'. 'This is not 'I love you' in some sort of Catholic way,' Mr Allen said. Mr Culshaw, in his closing address, acknowledged under questioning from Judge Fuller that the emails appeared 'terrible' on a first or literal reading in that they seemed to suggest the pair had been in a sexual relationship. But he argued a deeper reading of the emails fit with Ms Fletcher's testimony. She claimed last week that they were written to keep the girl happy and guide her away to a more age-appropriate relationship. 'These emails are consistent with a relatively young teacher, in her early 30s, who had got herself in too deep … and so was trying to deal with the situation and extricate herself from it,' Mr Culshaw said. Ms Fletcher holds a PhD in music education. She told the court that she was heterosexual and believed in the Catholic faith. She was still legally married to a man, though the pair had separated, she told the court. The judge-alone trial continues.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store