Badenoch accused of wearing transphobia as ‘badge of honour' by Labour MP
A spokesman for the Conservative leader said she has 'always defended the rights of trans people' and accused Mr Quigley of twisting Mrs Badenoch's words.
As MPs discussed a petition calling for the ability of trans people to self-identify their legal gender, Mr Quigley said: 'It is disheartening to see figures, including the Leader of the Opposition, appear to wear their transphobia almost as a badge of honour.
'In this House we must not forget that our words matter and we can really impact the most vulnerable. I came into politics, and I believe many of us did, to champion minorities and give a voice to the voiceless.
'It is vital that we remember the power we hold, to raise the tone of debate rather than to lower it, to support the vulnerable, not scapegoat them.'
He added: 'What concerns me further is the growing narrative that improving trans rights somehow threatens the rights or dignity of women and girls.
'And I am not going to deny that in places such as the prison service there have been troubling examples of individuals playing the system to gain access to women's spaces. We must acknowledge and address these concerns seriously.
'But when I hear some from the Opposition declare themselves – well, if they were here – champions of women's rights, I find myself asking, where are they, well, now? Where have they been for the last 15 years?
'When violence against women and girls skyrocketed, where was the legislation? When women's shelters were chronically underfunded, where was the outrage? When domestic abuse cases surged, whilst court access diminished, where was the action?
'When male perpetrators played the legal system to harass their victims, where was the advocacy? I do not raise these points just to score political points, but rather to prompt reflection.
'If your defence of women's rights only surfaces in opposition to trans rights, then I question whether it is truly about supporting women, or simply targeting trans people under that guise.'
Intervening, Labour former minister Dame Meg Hillier said: 'So many people have been in touch with me, very frightened now, because of this Supreme Court ruling.
'Doesn't he agree, as he said, we need to speak well here, but the Government needs to make sure that that interim guidance is fast firmed up into proper guidance? Because the interim guidance is causing confusion and fear amongst so many people.'
Mr Quigley said he agreed 'entirely' with the MP for Hackney South and Shoreditch, adding: 'Words matter.'
A spokesman for Mrs Badenoch said: 'Kemi has always defended the rights of trans people, but she has been clear that those rights cannot come at the expense of women and girls.
'This issue has consistently been exploited by people, like Richard Quigley, who seek to misrepresent the law and twist Kemi's words for their own political gain.
'The Supreme Court judgment has now made the law abundantly clear, and it is what Kemi has argued throughout her political career – that sex is biological.'
Later in the debate, Dame Meg said the Government 'may need to step in to resolve' the issues caused by the Supreme Court ruling on the legal definition of a woman.
'The Equality Act itself was well written in order to deal with intersectional issues when they arose, the guidance around it was very clear and this ruling has muddied that,' she said.
Intervening earlier in the debate, Labour MP Will Stone said 'we should be doing our utmost to protect the trans community and ensure they have the same rights as everyone else and that they can live in dignity'.
The Swindon North MP added: 'What we say in this House matters, it ripples across communities, and regardless of what side you sit on or where you are in the argument, at the centre of that argument are people.'
Labour MP for Sheffield Hallam Olivia Blake said the uncertainty on the issue risked 'undermining' gender recognition certificates (GRC).
Ms Blake said: 'I'm pleased that Labour committed to making the GRC process simpler in our manifesto, but the recent judgment is very concerning and it risks undermining the existence of these certificates in themselves if we're not careful, and if the guidance goes the wrong way.'
Conservative shadow equalities minister Mims Davies said: 'Every individual should live a life of dignity and be free as to how to live their lives and be safe to do so, and safety has been very much raised today, and rightly should be supported in that. We are a party that is inclusive and focused on equality, and will always stand up for the rights of women and girls too.'
However, she added: 'I believe we must ensure that we work for a future where women do not have to fight for their rights every time and nobody has to keep fighting for all of their rights every time.'
Home Office minister Seema Malhotra said accounts of hate crime and transphobia were 'a concern to us all'. Ms Malhotra said the Government remained committed to both delivering a trans-inclusive ban on conversion therapy, and the Cass report. However, she said Labour did not believe in self identification.
She said: 'We understand these issues must be navigated sensitively. The Government's position embodies a belief that it is both possible and essential to uphold protections for trans individuals whilst respecting women's concerns around privacy, safety and dignity.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
High court asylum hotels ruling leaves Cooper scrambling for alternatives
Yvette Cooper, thanks to Tuesday's high court ruling, is facing potentially explosive decisions over where to house asylum seekers if courts rule that they must leave hotels. The Home Office, usually under Conservative ministers, has been struggling for five years to find an alternative to hotels so they can house a growing number of asylum seekers reaching these shores. Labour has said that it expects to empty the 200-odd hotels housing asylum seekers by 2029. Ministers may be forced to rip up that plan and move at a rapid pace because of the ruling's implications. If councils take to the high court to complain about the use of a hotel for housing asylum seekers – and many will be under immense political pressure from the public to do so – it could force officials to find alternative housing for thousands of people. Legal sources believe that there will be similar grounds to launch applications for interim injunctions from a number of councils. This case has centred on an alleged breach of planning laws by owners of the Bell hotel, who it was claimed did not get permission to switch use from a hotel to hostel-style accommodation. Other hotel owners are thought to be in similar positions to Somani Hotels Limited, which originally housed families in the Bell, but faced a legal challenge after the asylum seekers were switched to single men. Ominously for the government, the Reform UK deputy leader, Richard Tice, said his party would look at pursuing similar cases regarding hotels within the 10 council areas it controls, which include both North and West Northamptonshire councils, Doncaster, and Kent and Staffordshire county councils. And the high court rulings can require a rapid response. Epping's application for an interim was launched on 12 August. By 4pm on 12 September, all asylum seekers will have to be removed from The Bell hotel. There may yet be a lifeline for the government. They could convince the court of appeal to overturn the decision. The fact that the Home Office was not allowed to intervene in a case which was directly related to the home secretary's duties to house asylum seekers could well be seized upon by government lawyers. If they fail to overturn the decision, they will face the same dilemma as successive Tory home secretaries going back to Priti Patel, who promised and failed to find alternatives to hotels to house asylum seekers. The number of asylum hotels soared to 400 under successive Tory home secretaries because of a shortage of housing, a growing backlog in asylum applications, and a failure to establish large accommodation sites in buildings such as disused military barracks. Since coming to power, Labour has increased the speed at which applications are processed, by using more 'dispersal accommodation' such as flats and housing in the community. Questions will no doubt be asked inside the department as to why it took the Home Office until Monday to try to intervene in the case. If it had done so last week, when the case came to court, it would have stood a better chance of preventing the injunction. The political implications of the ruling will continue to unsettle Cooper and No 10. Yet again, the government has been caught flat-footed on an immigration-related issue, as it struggles with soaring numbers of small boats crossing the Channel. Anti-asylum seeker protesters will see this as a victory in response to their demonstrations across the country this summer. Reform UK and its leader, Nigel Farage, currently leading in most polls, will be buoyed by the prospect of further embarrassment for the government.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
I have no intention of reshuffling Cabinet, says John Swinney
More than 20 SNP MSPs are set to leave Holyrood, including some of his current ministerial team, when voters go to the polls next year. Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes is among them, along with Finance Secretary Shona Robison, Transport Secretary Fiona Hyslop, and Rural Affairs Secretary Mairi Gougeon. However, Swinney made clear he has no plans to reshape his top team in the light of the planned departures. READ MORE: Labour refuse to release files on secret meeting with Gideon Sa'ar Speaking at an event in Edinburgh organised by the think tank Enlighten, the First Minister said: 'I have no intention of reshuffling my team before the election.' While he spoke about his 'regret' about fellow MSPs leaving Holyrood, including 'close colleagues, friends and confidantes', he said he had reshuffled his Cabinet team after government minister Mairi McAllan returned to work earlier this year following her maternity leave. In June, McAllan was given the newly created post of Housing Secretary, with Swinney tasking her with tackling the housing 'emergency' in Scotland. Asked if the impending departure of senior members of his government would bring about a reshuffle ahead of May's Scottish elections, the SNP leader said he had 'decided, actively and purposefully' that he had people in his Cabinet with 'experience and expertise in a number of roles that would help me to deliver to government's programme before the election'. (Image: PA) And he argued that if he was to 'put in a whole host of new faces' then 'it would take a while to get things back up to the level of delivery' 'I have no plans to reshuffle the government,' he insisted. His comments came as he spoke of his 'regret' over SNP MSPs leaving Holyrood, with the First Minister saying he 'very much' regretted Forbes' decision to quit the Scottish Parliament. The Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch MSP announced earlier this month she would not be running for election next year, saying she did not want to 'miss any more of the precious early years of family life'. Meanwhile, former first ministers Nicola Sturgeon and Humza Yousaf are also stepping down. READ MORE: Thousands object to Tesla bid to supply energy in UK – how to sign the petition Swinney said: 'Some of my colleagues are stepping down because they have done a very long shift.' While he said he was the 'longest serving' parliamentarian at Holyrood, having been first voted in as an MP 28 years ago before being elected as an MSP in the first devolved elections, he noted a number of those quitting had also been first elected in 1999. However, he added some MSPs were leaving because of the 'tough' nature of politics. 'We have to acknowledge that for many, I think particularly younger women, the climate is horrendous,' Swinney said. He continued: 'The social media endurance is hard to bear for some people, and it makes public service look frankly unattractive at times.' In these circumstances, he said, he tries to 'support my colleagues, understand and be an ally'. But the SNP leader added: 'Ultimately, I can not protect people from what is thrown at them, and some of the behaviours are appalling, so that affects a number of people as well.' Swinney also told the event he has to 'focus on the country and the future' as he refused to comment on claims Sturgeon made about her predecessor Alex Salmond. Swinney said while he has read some extracts from the former first minister's memoirs, Frankly, which were published last week, he has not yet read the entire book.
North Wales Chronicle
an hour ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Rylan Clark calls for more stories about transgender people amid ‘wave of hate'
In an appearance at the Edinburgh TV Festival, Clark, 36, who has presented on This Morning and Big Brother's Bit On The Side, spoke about the adversity LGBT+ people can face, as well as his own experience growing up gay. He said: 'I feel that there is a mass wave of hate just sweeping the community, especially trans people at the moment. 'There's a lot of people that are talking about bathrooms and spaces and things like this and people are just being tarnished with the same brush.' The presenter explained there is a mindset that because one transgender person does something bad 'that means all trans people are awful people'. He said: 'Trans people … they're going through a wave of hate at the minute, and I think there is space to show real stories, real trans people. 'A lot of people out there think trans people are the enemy, f*** me. 'I'd like you to walk a mile in their shoes and see who the real enemy is out there to people, because the stories that I know of friends of mine and people that I've grown up with, transitions are awful, absolutely awful.' Over the Easter period, the Supreme Court declared that the words 'woman' and 'sex' in the Equality Act refer to a biological woman and biological sex. The Equality And Human Rights Commission's interim update on the implications of the judgment said transgender people should not use toilets and other services of the gender they identify as. Trans rights protests took place across the country following the ruling and celebrities showed their support by signing an open letter in solidarity with transgender people. At the end of July, the London Trans Pride saw a record-breaking turnout of about 100,000 people, making it 'the largest Trans Pride event in history', according to organisers. Clark said he does not want or need Pride but added that the annual celebratory event is needed because of the way LGBT+ people are treated. At the Scottish TV event, the BBC Radio 2 presenter spoke to actor Russell Tovey and the two reflected on their respective experiences growing up gay in Essex. Speaking about a nightclub he would go to as a young man, Tovey said: 'It was a really important safe space, which I didn't realise at the time how important that was. 'And now you hear about so many safe spaces disappearing for so many queer people, and the importance of that, of somewhere where you can relax and be amongst the people who understand you. 'The disappearances of those is dangerous.'
