Line calling technology under fire after malfunction
Pavlyuchenkova had reached game point at 4-4 in the opening set on Centre Court and Kartal hit a shot that looked clearly long but there was no call and Pavlyuchenkova stopped play.
Confusion reigned with television replays showing that Kartal's shot was well out, but after seeking advice via telephone umpire Nico Helwerth said that because the Hawk-Eye technology had been unable to track the shot, the point had to be replayed.
Russian Pavlyuchenkova went on to have her serve broken and was clearly fuming at the changeover, telling the umpire: "Because she is local, they can say whatever. You took the game away from me. They stole the game from me. You stole the game from me".
She did, however, recover to win the opening set.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
14 minutes ago
- CNA
You cannot be serious! Wimbledon line-calling system under fire after glitch
LONDON : Wimbledon's automated line-calling technology came under fire on Sunday after an embarrassing malfunction robbed Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova of a point during her last-16 victory over Britain's Sonay Kartal on Centre Court. Russian Pavlyuchenkova had reached game point at 4-4 in the opening set and Kartal hit a shot that looked clearly long but there was no call and Pavlyuchenkova stopped play. An automated voice call of "STOP STOP" rang out and confusion reigned as umpire Nico Helwerth sought advice from tournament organisers via telephone. Television replays showed that Kartal's shot was clearly out, yet Helwerth ruled that because the Hawk-Eye technology had not tracked the ball, the point must be replayed. Pavlyuchenkova went on to have her serve broken and was clearly fuming at the changeover, telling the umpire: "Because she is local, they can say whatever. You took the game away from me. They stole the game from me. You stole the game from me". The 34-year-old quickly regrouped and showed the resilience that has marked her long career by reaching the quarter-finals with a 7-6(3) 6-4 win. But the main talking point was the first big glitch of Wimbledon's automated line-calling system that has replaced human line judges this year. OPERATOR ERROR Tournament officials later said the problem had been caused by operator error and that the umpire had followed the correct protocols, although Pavlyuchenkova felt that he should have intervened to correct an obvious mistake. "We were waiting for a decision as the system was down, but I was expecting to hear if they said the ball was in or out," Pavlyuchenkova told reporters. "Instead they just said, replay the point. It was tricky especially as it was a very crucial moment in the match. "I expected a different decision. I just thought also the chair umpire could take the initiative. That's why he's there sitting on the chair. He also saw it (was) out, he told me after the match. I thought he would do that, but he didn't. "I think it's also difficult for him. He probably was scared to take such a big decision." Asked how she would have felt if the point had cost her the match, Pavlyuchenkova raised a smile: "I would just say that I hate Wimbledon and never come back here." KARTAL UNSIGHTED Kartal said she had been unsighted as to whether her shot was out and was equally confused at the time. "That situation is a rarity. I don't think it's really ever happened," she said. "It's tough luck. What can you do? The umpire is trying his best. I think he handled it fine." Pavlyuchenkova, who felt a back-up system should be in place, is not the first person this week to question the automated line-calling system. Britain's Emma Raducanu claimed there were wrong calls during her loss to Aryna Sabalenka. "No, I don't (trust the system) - I think the other players would say the same thing, there were some pretty dodgy ones but what can you do?," she said after her defeat. Britain's Jack Draper also believed it was not 100 per cent accurate while Swiss player Belinda Bencic said this week that it was a hot topic in the locker rooms. Pavlyuchenkova said it was something that needed to be addressed. "I think since we have already automatic line-calling and so much invested into this, we should probably look into something else to have better decisions on it," she said.
CNA
18 minutes ago
- CNA
Norris wins in the wet as Piastri fumes and Hulkenberg stuns
SILVERSTONE, England :Lando Norris won his home British Grand Prix for the first time in a wave of elation as McLaren teammate Oscar Piastri finished second and made his unhappiness evident to all on a wet and chaotic Silverstone Sunday. The Australian, his championship lead cut to eight points from 15, had looked a more likely winner but a 10-second penalty for braking sharply behind the safety car while leading ultimately left Norris as the one celebrating. McLaren had indicated they could appeal, prompting Piastri to suggest more in hope than expectation that he and Norris switch places, but in the end the team told the drivers to continue racing for position. Norris was overcome by emotion, although he said he had not cried behind the visor, as he took the chequered flag 6.8 seconds clear. "We did it, at home. Oh my god, we did it. It's beautiful," he gasped over the radio after winning back-to-back races for the first time. "Apart from a championship, I think this is as good as it gets in terms of feelings and in terms of achievement, being proud, all of it," he said later. It was the Briton's fourth win of the season, one less than Piastri, and McLaren's fifth one-two. Piastri gave every impression of chewing on lemons as he was interviewed by 2009 world champion Jenson Button. "I'm not going to say much. I'll get myself in trouble. Well done to Nico. I think that's the highlight of the day," he said acidly of third-placed finisher Nico Hulkenberg. Hulkenberg's achievement was also emotional, the 37-year-old German making up 16 places to shed an unwanted record of the most races without a podium in Formula One history - Sunday being his first in 239 starts. "I don't think I can comprehend what we've just done," said the stunned German before wild pitlane celebrations with his teammates. "It feels good. It's been a long time coming, hasn't it? But I always knew we had it in us, I have it in me, somewhere." HAMILTON FOURTH Ferrari's Lewis Hamilton, last year's winner with Mercedes, finished fourth with Red Bull's Max Verstappen fifth after starting on pole position but spinning out of contention. Pierre Gasly was sixth for Alpine, Lance Stroll seventh for Aston Martin - after running third for a while - and Alex Albon eighth for Williams. Fernando Alonso gave Aston Martin a double points finish in ninth at their home race and George Russell bagged the final point for Mercedes. Organisers said 168,000 people attended the race with a record four-day crowd of half a million. The whole field had looked set to start on intermediates but Russell and Ferrari's Charles Leclerc peeled into the pitlane on the formation lap to switch to slicks, leaving grid slots four and six empty. Verstappen led away from pole, the rest following in the spray, with Racing Bulls' Liam Lawson colliding with Haas's Esteban Ocon and pulling off to retire on the Wellington straight. "Who the hell was that? I'm out," exclaimed the New Zealander. A virtual safety car was in place for a couple of laps, with Argentine rookie Franco Colapinto also retiring his Alpine with a gearbox problem after starting from the pit lane. The virtual safety car was triggered for a second time on lap six when Sauber's Gabriel Bortoleto spun into the gravel, got going again and then pulled over with a severely damaged rear wing. Piastri got past Verstappen on lap eight, shortly after racing resumed, and Norris moved up to second on lap 11 when the champion ran wide at Becketts with his tyres struggling for grip. Both McLarens pitted on lap 12, followed by Verstappen who regained second place when Norris was held up with a front-left wheel issue. The full safety car bunched up the field again on lap 14 as the rain fell more heavily and conditions became more treacherous, and stayed out for three laps. As soon as it came in Isack Hadjar crashed his Racing Bulls into the back of Kimi Antonelli's Mercedes in heavy spray and the safety car was back out again. When it returned to the pits on lap 22, Piastri suddenly slowed and Verstappen inadvertently went past in a breach of the rules and spun at Stowe on the restart, dropping down to 11th.
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
Sabalenka passes Mertens test to reach Wimbledon quarter-finals
LONDON :Aryna Sabalenka maintained her stranglehold over Belgian Elise Mertens with a hard-fought 6-4 7-6(4) victory on Sunday to reach the Wimbledon quarter-finals as she bids for a maiden title at the grasscourt Grand Slam. The Belarusian top seed came into the match on Centre Court having beaten Mertens 10 times in 12 meetings - the most for her against any player on the WTA Tour - and the one-sided rivalry looked set to continue after she made a strong start. That impression would change, however, as Sabalenka dropped her level and wasted a 4-1 lead but the three-times major winner recovered quickly and claimed the opening set with a break on the back of a searing backhand crosscourt winner. Sabalenka followed up with a cheeky volley that clipped the net cord in the opening game of the next set but her former doubles partner responded with solid returning in the next to break and surge ahead. Her momentum did not last long, though, as Sabalenka drew level after six games and the world number one stepped up again at crucial points in a see-saw tiebreak, which she finished with a forehand volley to book a last-eight meeting with Laura Siegemund.
