RFK Jr.'s vaccine advisory panel to review shots for children
The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) will also weigh recommendations for vaccines that have long been on the market, including measles and hepatitis B.
Martin Kulldorf made the announcement at the start of the first meeting of the ACIP since Kennedy dismissed all 17 previous members less than two weeks ago, accusing them of conflicts of interest.
Kennedy appointed a new group of eight members two days later. One withdrew just before Wednesday's meeting during a review of his financial holdings, leaving seven members to vote on vaccine recommendations during the meeting.
'Secretary Kennedy has given this committee a clear mandate to use evidence based medicine. We're making vaccine recommendations and that is what we will do. Vaccines are not all good or bad,' Kulldorf said Wednesday.
The health chief, who co-founded the anti-vaccine group Children's Health Defense and served as its chairman before being confirmed to lead HHS, has long called for an investigation into the number of childhood shots, saying they have been inadequately studied.
The review will be undertaken by two new ACIP work groups, Kulldorff said, though it's not clear if they have been staffed yet. One group will be focused on the childhood and adolescent vaccine schedules and the other will focus on shots that have been approved for seven or more years.
He specifically mentioned the recommendation for giving newborns the hepatitis B vaccine as well as the combination measles, mumps, rubella (MMR) and chickenpox shots.
The panel chair added that the group will also consider religious objections to MMR vaccines derived from fetal cell lines and may look at an MMR vaccine approved in Japan.
'The number of vaccines that our children and adolescents receive today exceed what children in most other developed nations receive, and what most of us in this room received when we were children,' Kulldorf said.
He added that it is also important 'to evaluate the cumulative effect of the recommended vaccine schedule. This includes interaction effects between different vaccines, the total number of vaccines, cumulative amounts of vaccine ingredients and the relative timing of different vaccines.'
For decades, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) independent advisory panel recommended which shots Americans should get and when.
The Affordable Care Act requires all insurance companies to cover, for free, the vaccines recommended by the panel. Those recommendations also help states decide which shots should be mandated for schoolchildren.
Kennedy's shakeup is throwing that system into chaos. Outside physician and public health groups have been pressuring insurance companies to continue covering vaccines, no matter what ACIP does.
'Part of the role of ACIP is to look at vaccines across the lifespan,' said Chrissie Juliano, executive director of the Big Cities Health Coalition. 'I think the important thing to note is we need to reevaluate vaccine recommendations based on whether science has changed, not based on whether the people who sit on a committee change, or in administration changes. And I think that's where we start to lose the public's trust.'
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) announced Wednesday that it would no longer take part in ACIP hearings.
'We won't lend our name or our expertise to a system that is being politicized at the expense of children's health,' AAP President Susan Kressly said in a video posted on social platform X.
Ahead of the meeting, the insurance industry trade group America's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP) issued a statement that its plans are 'committed to ongoing coverage of vaccines to ensure access and affordability for this respiratory virus season.'
'We encourage all Americans to talk to their health care provider about vaccines,' the group wrote.
As the meeting kicked off, President Trump's nominee to lead the CDC, Susan Monarez, was on Capitol Hill testifying in front of the Senate Health, Education Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee during a confirmation hearing.
Monarez said she does not see a causal link between vaccines and autism, and told Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) she hopes experts will step up and volunteer to fill the panel's remaining slots.
'These are not easy positions to fill. It takes a lot of time and commitment from some of these highly trained technical experts to want to participate,' Monarez said. 'They need to have a depth and a breadth of technical experience to be able to understand immunological processes, to understand statistical analysis.'
Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-La.), HELP Committee, lamented the 'rushed' meeting with a diminished panel.
'Given that there is no confirmed CDC director, along with an ACIP panel which has very few members, many of whom lack broad vaccine and immunology immunological expertise, there are concerns about the rushed nature of this process,' Cassidy said.
The Louisiana Republican also expressed concern that Thursday's ACIP schedule will feature a presentation on thimerosal given by Lyn Redwood, a longtime anti-vaccine activist. Redwood is president emerita of Children's Health Defense.
Thimerosal is a preservative used in some influenza vaccines, and anti-vaccine leaders have long linked it to autism in children, a claim that's been debunked.
'I will note that there are people who are critics of thimerosal who've been asked to testify, but no one speaking of the substantial evidence that in the amounts used in vaccines, thimerosal is safe,' the senator said.
Prior to the meeting, a document was posted to ACIP's website summarizing that all available evidence shows thimerosal is safe and is not linked to autism or other neurological issues. That document was no longer available on Wednesday.
'I will say going forward, if the ACIP hearing today is being used to sow distrust, I would ask as you go forward that you would make sure that there really was a balanced perspective,' Cassidy said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
a minute ago
- Miami Herald
Health groups aim to counter growing ‘national scandal' of elder homelessness
At age 82, Roberta Rabinovitz realized she had no place to go. A widow, she had lost both her daughters to cancer, after living with one and then the other, nursing them until their deaths. Then she moved in with her brother in Florida, until he also died. And so last fall, while recovering from lung cancer, Rabinovitz ended up at her grandson's home in Burrillville, Rhode Island, where she slept on the couch and struggled to navigate the steep staircase to the shower. That wasn't sustainable, and with apartment rents out of reach, Rabinovitz joined the growing population of older Americans unsure of where to lay their heads at night. But Rabinovitz was fortunate. She found a place to live, through what might seem an unlikely source — a health care nonprofit, the PACE Organization of Rhode Island. Around the country, arranging for housing is a relatively new and growing challenge for such PACE groups, which are funded through Medicaid and Medicare. PACE stands for a Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly, and the organizations aim to keep frail, older people in their homes. But a patient can't stay at home if they don't have one. As housing costs rise, organizations responsible for people's medical care are realizing that to ensure their clients have a place to live, they must venture outside their lanes. Even hospitals — in Denver, New Orleans, New York City and elsewhere — have started investing in housing, recognizing that health isn't possible without it. And among older adults, the need is especially growing. In the U.S., 1 in 5 people who were homeless in 2024 were 55 or older, with the total older homeless population up 6% from the previous year. Dennis Culhane, a University of Pennsylvania professor who specializes in homelessness and housing policy, calculated that the number of men older than 60 living in shelters roughly tripled from 2000 to 2020. 'It's a national scandal, really, that the richest country in the world would have destitute elderly and disabled people,' Culhane said. Over decades of research, Culhane has documented the plight of people born between 1955 and 1965 who came of age during recessions and never got an economic foothold. Many in this group endured intermittent homelessness throughout their lives, and now their troubles are compounded by aging. But other homeless older adults are new to the experience. Many teeter on the edge of poverty, said Sandy Markwood, CEO of USAging, a national association representing what are known as area agencies on aging. A single incident can tip them into homelessness — the death of a spouse, job loss, a rent increase, an injury or illness. If cognitive decline starts, an older person may forget to pay their mortgage. Even those with paid-off houses often can't afford rising property taxes and upkeep. 'No one imagines anybody living on the street at 75 or 80,' Markwood said. 'But they are.' President Donald Trump's recent budget law, which makes substantial federal cuts to Medicaid, the public insurance program for those with low incomes or disabilities, will make matters worse for older people with limited incomes, said Yolanda Stevens, program and policy analyst with the National Alliance to End Homelessness. If people lose their health coverage or their local hospital closes, it will be harder for them to maintain their health and pay the rent. 'It's a perfect storm,' Stevens said. 'It's an unfortunate, devastating storm for our older Americans.' Adding to the challenges, the Labor Department recently halted a job training program intended to keep low-income older people in the workforce. Those circumstances have sent PACE health plans throughout the country into uncharted waters, prompting them to set up shop within senior housing projects, partner with housing providers, or even join forces with nonprofit developers to build their own. A 1997 federal law recognized PACE organizations as a provider type for Medicare and Medicaid. Today, some 185 operate in the U.S., each serving a defined geographic area, with a total of more than 83,000 participants. They enroll people 55 and older who are sick enough for nursing home care, and then provide everything their patients need to stay home despite their frailty. They also run centers that function as medical clinics and adult day centers and provide transportation. These organizations primarily serve impoverished people with complex medical conditions who are eligible for both Medicaid and Medicare. They pool money from both programs and operate within a set budget for each participant. PACE officials worry that, as federal funding for Medicaid programs shrinks, states will curtail support. But the PACE concept has always had bipartisan support, said Robert Greenwood, a senior vice president at the National PACE Association, because its services are significantly less expensive than nursing home care. The financing structure gives PACE the flexibility to do what it takes to keep participants living on their own, even if it means buying an air conditioner or taking a patient's dog to the vet. Taking on the housing crisis is another step toward the same goal. In the Detroit area, PACE Southeast Michigan, which serves 2,200 participants, partners with the owners of senior housing. The landlords agree to keep the rent affordable, and PACE provides services to their tenants who are members. Housing providers 'like to be full, they like their seniors cared for, and we do all of that,' said Mary Naber, president and CEO of PACE Southeast Michigan. For participants who become too infirm to live on their own, the Michigan organization has leased a wing in an independent living center, where it provides round-the-clock supportive care. The organization also is partnering with a nonprofit developer to create a cluster of 21 shipping containers converted into little houses in Eastpointe, just outside Detroit. Still in the planning stages, Naber said, the refurbished containers will probably rent for about $1,000 to $1,100 a month. In San Diego, the PACE program at St. Paul's Senior Services cares for chronically homeless people as they move into housing, offering not just health services but the backup needed to keep tenants in their homes, such as guidance on paying bills on time and keeping their apartments clean. St. Paul's also helps those already in housing but clinging to precarious living arrangements, said Carol Castillon, vice president of its PACE operations, by connecting them with community resources, helping fill out forms for housing assistance, and providing meals and household items to lower expenses. At PACE Rhode Island, which serves nearly 500 people, about 10 to 15 participants each month become homeless or at risk of homelessness, a rare situation five or six years ago, CEO Joan Kwiatkowski said. The organization contracts with assisted living facilities, but its participants are sometimes rejected because of prior criminal records, substance use, or health care needs that the facilities feel they can't handle. And public housing providers often have no openings. So PACE Rhode Island is planning to buy its own housing, Kwiatkowski said. PACE also has reserved four apartments at an assisted living facility in Bristol for its participants, paying rent when they're unoccupied. Rabinovitz moved into one recently. Rabinovitz had worked as a senior credit analyst for a health care company, but now her only income is her Social Security check. She keeps $120 from that check for personal supplies, and the rest goes to rent, which includes meals. Once a week or so, Rabinovitz rides a PACE van to the organization's center, where she gets medical care, including dental work, physical therapy, and medication — always, she said, from 'incredibly loving people.' When she's not feeling well enough to make the trek, PACE sends someone to her. Recently, a technician with a portable X-ray machine scanned her sore hip as she lay in her own bed in her new studio apartment. 'It's tiny, but I love it,' she said of the apartment, which she's decorated in purple, her favorite color. KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF— an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism.
The Hill
a minute ago
- The Hill
Tick-borne disease spreads, causing meat, dairy allergies
Emergency room visits have spiked across the Midwest this summer as millions of Americans grapple with tick bites, but a lesser-known tick-borne illness is causing particular alarm in some communities. Alpha-gal syndrome, transmitted by the lone star tick, creates severe allergies to meat and dairy products that can last for years. The condition essentially forces people to adopt vegan diets, with some patients experiencing life-threatening reactions even to the smell of cooking meat. The lone star tick, identifiable by a white dot on the female's back, is most common from Maine to Florida and in Texas, living primarily in wooded and grassy areas. These ticks carry a sugar molecule called alpha-gal that, when transmitted to humans, triggers severe allergic reactions to mammalian products. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates as many as 450,000 people in the U.S. may have it. Patients report reactions so severe that smelling burgers on a grill can cause unconsciousness. The syndrome also affects everyday items containing animal byproducts, including lip balms, lotions and some bottled water, causing hives, coughing and wheezing. Cases have become so widespread on Martha's Vineyard that restaurants there now offer special alpha-gal menus, according to report from The New York Times. Nicole Cooper of Virginia, diagnosed with alpha-gal syndrome in December 2021, experienced symptoms for more than a year before receiving proper diagnosis. She was rushed to an emergency room unable to breathe, where doctors recognized a recurring rash on her arms. 'I was shocked when they wanted to run the blood test,' Cooper told NewsNation's ' Elizabeth Vargas Reports.' 'I was, like, no, no, I really hate ticks,' she continued. 'I always wear my bug repellent when I'm out in the woods.' She became 'fume reactive,' unable to be around cooking meat or use cast iron pans previously used for meat. Even products such as dryer balls containing lanolin, derived from sheep, became off-limits. The delayed reaction between exposure and symptoms makes alpha-gal syndrome particularly difficult to diagnose and treat. Cooper remained highly reactive for two years before her symptoms began improving through strict avoidance of mammalian products.
New York Post
31 minutes ago
- New York Post
The 3 best travel pillows, according to an orthopedic surgeon — and the best position to sleep in
This is the stuffing that dreams are made of. A good pillow can help you maintain proper spinal alignment and posture by supporting the natural curves of your neck and spine. Most Americans sleep with two or four rest rectangles, according to survey data from Sleep Junkie. 4 Find yourself a pillow that you will fall head over heels for. Africa Studio – Unfortunately, too many pillows — especially ones that are too thick or stiff — can put stress on the cervical spine, potentially leading to neck pain, muscle spasms and breathing troubles. That's why it's important to have the right cranium cushion. Rest assured — Dr. Jason Snibbe, a board-certified orthopedic surgeon based in L.A., reveals the best pillows for travel and everyday use. The best sleep position Before we discuss pillows, let's talk about your sleeping habits. 4 Dr. Jason Snibbe, a board-certified orthopedic surgeon based in L.A., reveals the best pillows for travel and everyday use. justin phu media There are three main snooze positions — sleeping on your back, your side or your stomach. They are not created equal. 'Sleeping on your back can take stress off your shoulders, but it carries a higher chance of closing down your airway and making it difficult to breathe at night,' Snibbe told The Post. 'For people who have sleep apnea or snore, this is the worst position.' Sleep apnea sufferers stop breathing as they sleep because the muscles in their throat relax and repeatedly block their airway. Sleeping on your stomach is also the wrong move, Snibbe said, because it can flatten the natural curve of your spine and force your neck into an awkward position. 'The best sleeping position is side sleeping,' Snibbe declared. 'This position helps prevent snoring and sleep apnea by keeping your airway open,' he added. 'It's also beneficial to sleep in the fetal position, with your hips flexed and knees flexed, as this takes pressure off your lower back and knees.' 4 Side sleeping is often the best sleep position for optimal health, experts say. Svitlana – One issue with side sleeping is that it can cause shoulder pain due to prolonged pressure on the shoulder joint. Snibbe suggests side sleepers use a thick foam pillow to alleviate shoulder stress. 'Individuals with shoulder injuries might find a thicker pillow with denser memory foam particularly helpful for this purpose,' he said. 'Another important tip for side sleepers is that placing a pillow between your legs is much more comfortable, as it takes stress off your lower back and hips.' Get down with these pillows for travel It can feel impossible to get a good night's rest while traveling — but you can put your worries to bed if you get the right pillow. 'Sleeping on an airplane can be difficult,' Snibbe said. 'If you have an economy seat, I would recommend a supportive neck pillow.' 4 A neck pillow can help make an uncomfortable flight better. Getty Images/iStockphoto If you scored a lie-flat seat, he advises situating yourself in the fetal position as best you can. Place a pillow or a rolled-up jacket between your legs as support for your hips. Snibbe also suggests three types of pillows for life on the go:
