
Should we stop Asteroid 2024 YR4 from hitting the moon?
A few months ago, NASA noted that 2024 YR4 had a 3.1 percent chance of hitting the Earth in 2032. Since the rock is 50 to 90 meters in diameter, if it were to hit the Earth, it would cause an explosion equivalent to a nuclear bomb with the accompanying devastation.
Subsequently, NASA dialed down the threat 2024 YR4 posed to the Earth and everyone breathed a sigh of relief.
Now, the Earth approaching asteroid has a new target. A small chance exists that it will hit the moon in 2032. The prospect presents new dangers, though not as great as the destruction of a city.
According to ZME Science, new data from the James Webb Space Telescope, 2024 YR4 has a 4.3 percent chance of hitting the moon on December 22, 2032. 'If 2024 YR4 hits, it will create a blast equivalent to 6.5 million tons of TNT. The resulting crater would stretch about a kilometer across — bigger than almost any the Moon has seen in the last 5,000 years.'
Depending on whether the asteroid hits the near side of the moon —a 50-50 chance assuming it hits it at all — about 10 percent of the debris, about 100 million kilograms, ranging in size from flecks of dust to a small pebbles, could be captured by the Earth's gravity and reach the atmosphere in perhaps three to five days.
Little if any debris kicked up by a lunar impact would threaten the Earth's surface. At most, it would cause a spectacular meteor shower unlike anything in our lifetimes. Both scientists and casual sky watchers will be intrigued at this once in several millennia event.
The effects on space assets are another matter, however.
Satellites, ranging from relatively small Comsats to commercial space stations expected to be in operation by the 2030s, will be subjected to tiny objects traveling at tens of thousands of meters per second. SpaceX's Starlink constellation will be at particular risk.
'This debris won't likely destroy spacecraft and satellites, but it adds wear and tear,' writes ZME. 'In rare cases, a lucky — or unlucky — piece of rock could disable a satellite or trigger a cascade of debris collisions.'
Both NASA and Chinese astronauts may be living and working on the moon at the time 2024 YR4 hits and will be in jeopardy due to falling debris or other hazards. The Lunar Gateway, if it exists in seven years, could also be subject to impacts.
What, if anything, can be done about it?
The option exists of doing nothing. After all, a four percent chance of the asteroid hitting the moon means a 96 percent chance of it not hitting the moon.
However, if the powers that be were to decide to divert 2024 YR4 so that it doesn't hit the moon, the technical task should be relatively easy. NASA has already tested asteroid deflection with its DART mission, which diverted an asteroid named Dimorphos with a kinetic impactor.
The economic and political problems facing the diversion of 2024 YR4 are another matter. NASA is currently in turmoil due to proposed draconian budget cuts and a lack of a permanent administrator.
The Space Force, which is being lavished with money compared to NASA, might be assigned the task. Indeed, an asteroid diversion mission could be good practice for space operations by America's newest military branch.
The other alternative is to perform a redirection mission to 2024 YR4 privately. One of the things that Jared Isaacman, the billionaire entrepreneur whose nomination to be NASA administrator President Trump abruptly withdrew, is contemplating is private science missions. An asteroid redirect mission might fit into that model.
One can see SpaceX's Elon Musk financing such a mission. Musk has deep pockets and an incentive to divert 2024 YR4 if it threatens his Starlink constellation.
Asteroid diversion might become a good business for private launch companies such as SpaceX. If a really big space rock threatens the Earth, the nations of the world might be willing to pay a lot of money to ward it off. Someone like Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos, founder of SpaceX competitor Blue Origin, might literally save the world for a profit.
If such an asteroid is rich in useful natural resources, its diversion to a safe, stable orbit around the Earth would be even more profitable. Access to such a source of minerals could spark a space-based industrial revolution.
Save the world and get fabulously wealthy doing so. Someone really should make a movie out of that scenario, before it becomes true life.
Mark Whittington, who writes frequently about space policy, has published a political study of space exploration titled 'Why is It So Hard to Go Back to the Moon?' as well as 'The Moon, Mars and Beyond,' and, most recently, 'Why is America Going Back to the Moon?' He blogs at Curmudgeons Corner.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
22 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Comet 3I/ATLAS: A Cosmic Visitor From Beyond Our Stars
NASA scientists have discovered a rare visitor from beyond our solar system, a newly identified interstellar comet named '3I/ATLAS,' currently speeding by on a brief cosmic tour. Comets are typically named after their discoverers – here, the ATLAS survey team. The 'I' stands for 'interstellar,' showing it came from beyond our solar system, and the '3' marks it as only the third type of this comet ever found. The comet, first spotted on July 1 by the NASA-funded ATLAS survey telescope in Chile, is only the third known interstellar object ever observed passing through our neighborhood. It arrived from the direction of the star Sagittarius and is now cruising about 420 million miles away from Earth, the space agency reported earlier this month. Don't worry, NASA says that is more than enough of a safe distance from the Earth's atmosphere. Researchers say 3I/ATLAS poses no threat to our planet, whatsoever, regardless of its proximity and rare flight path. It will remain at least 150 million miles away at all times, comfortably farther than Mars' distance from Earth. The icy comet is scheduled to make its closest approach to the Sun on October 30, when it will pass just inside Mars' orbit. In a remarkable scientific twist, astronomers have since reviewed archives from three other ATLAS telescopes, uncovering images of the comet dating back to June 14. These 'pre-discovery' images and observations are helping NASA and its researchers learn more about the rare comet's trajectory and properties. 3I/ATLAS will stay visible to ground-based telescopes through September before it swings back behind the Sun. It's also expected to 'reappear' in early December, giving astronomers a second chance to observe this cosmic visitor before it drifts back into deep space. Interstellar comets like 3I/ATLAS offer scientists a rare glimpse into materials from other star systems, potentially unlocking clues about how comets form in distant corners of our galaxy. 'This is like our chance to randomly sample what's going on in the rest of the galaxy,' University of Oxford astrophysicist Chris Lintott told NPR. 'I think the idea that we could see bits of other solar systems flying through our own really captivated the attention of a whole lot of people who started trying to work on these things.'
Yahoo
22 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Over 60 UFO sightings reported whizzing across state in first half of 2025, national tracking group says
New York state has seen 66 reported Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAP) sightings during the first half of 2025, according to a report from the National UFO Reporting Center (NUFORC). With 66 distinct incidents logged between January and late June, the state has had reports of an array of mysterious aerial objects, ranging from glowing orbs and silent triangles to fast-moving disks and shape-shifting lights. The incidents, according to NUFORC, span rural hamlets, suburban skies and the bustling airspace of the Big Apple. The NUFORC had 65 reported UFO sightings in New York in the first half of 2024. Ufo Cover Used By Government To 'Hide A Lot Of Things,' Former Nasa Agent Says The phenomenon appears to be statewide, with hot spots in urban centers like New York City as well as multiple reports from smaller towns such as Chester, Ridge and Evans Mills. Read On The Fox News App Evans Mills, which is located near a military base, saw repeated orb sightings in March, prompting witness speculation about possible connections to defense activities. The most common shapes were orbs, spheres and triangles, frequently observed performing advanced maneuvers. Air Force F-16 Struck By Drone During Training Flight Over Arizona In 2023 Several reports detailed sharp right-angle turns, sudden accelerations and zigzagging flight paths. One particularly vivid sighting, according to NUFORC, took place in Chester on March 25, 2025, when someone walking their dog around 6 p.m. reported seeing two extremely fast white orbs flying in close formation. Scientists Discover Mysterious Sphere In Colombia, Sparking Ufo Speculation Initially, the witness believed the objects to be birds, but their unusual speed and synchronized, wavering flight pattern stood out. Midway through their trajectory across the sky, the objects executed a sharp, nearly 90-degree turn to the northwest without any deceleration, the witness claimed. At that moment, they transformed into dark, aerodynamic ovals that nearly disappeared into the night sky, according to the report. The witness described the orbs as momentarily pitch black. A handful of these sightings also included photographic or video evidence, although NUFORC has not released digital evidence. Other entries speculated about plausible explanations, like drones, aircraft, fireworks and even the International Space Station. The bulk of reports from NUFORC remain open and unexplained. April through June represented a peak in activity, aligning with warmer months that typically encourage outdoor observations. Another remarkable incident reportedly occurred on June 24, 2025, during a commercial flight approaching New York City. A passenger seated in 1A reported to NUFORC that they witnessed a metallic ball flying in the opposite direction, roughly 100 to 200 feet below the aircraft. The witness, arriving from Toronto, described the object as a perfectly round, shiny sphere that caught his eye due to its metallic gleam. The witness noted that the object did not resemble a balloon or stationary object, saying it moved steadily away from the aircraft. The passenger immediately alerted the pilots upon landing, though neither reported seeing the object. Despite this, the observer remained convinced of the object's extraordinary nature. WATCH: These states are best prepared for alien invasion, UFO expert says NUFORC was founded in 1974 by UFO investigator Robert J. Gribble and aims to document and investigate unexplained sightings across the world. "The Center's primary function over the past five decades has been to receive, record, and to the greatest degree possible, corroborate and document reports from individuals who have been witness to unusual, possibly UFO-related events," the website article source: Over 60 UFO sightings reported whizzing across state in first half of 2025, national tracking group says
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
No longer in the running to head NASA, Jared Isaacman turns focus to private space missions
Jared Isaacman may no longer have a shot at leading NASA, but that doesn't mean the billionaire and private astronaut is done with space. In one of his first public appearances since President Donald Trump withdrew his nomination for him to be NASA administrator, Isaacman indicated he still has an interest in facilitating private spaceflight missions. The billionaire, who has been to space twice in two previous missions jointly funded with SpaceX, also hasn't ruled out making another cosmic venture now that he'll have more free time on his hands. Isaacman's recent comments came June 21 after he received the National Space Society's Wernher von Braun Award for Polaris Dawn, the private astronaut mission he commanded in September 2024, reported. After a prepared speech, Isaacman also spoke of what his priorities would have been had he been confirmed as NASA administrator. Here's what Isaacman recently discussed, as well as what to know about the billionaire spaceflight enthusiast. In comments after a speech at the National Space Society's conference, Isaacman reportedly indicated his interest in exploring space outside of the agency, according to SpaceNews. Isaacman's comments come at a difficult time for NASA − the agency faces steep budget cuts that can put several exploration missions at risk. Isaacman said in June that as NASA administrator, he would have sought partnerships with academic institutions that would have given such organizations a bigger role in funding. Rather than focusing on human spaceflights missions, Isaacman suggested he's more interested now in bankrolling uncrewed robotic missions. Isaacman's Polaris Dawn mission was intended to be the first of three missions he planned to fund under the Polaris Program. While he set those missions aside when he was nominated to lead NASA, it's unclear just when, or if, he'll pick them back up. But in previous comments on social media, Isaacmen left the door open to going to space again. "I have not flown my last mission," Isaacman said in a post May 31 on social media site X after Trump pulled his nomination to head NASA. "Whatever form that may ultimately take – but I remain incredibly optimistic that humanity's greatest spacefaring days lie ahead." Isaacman, founder of payment processing company Shift4 Payments, has been to space twice under his private spaceflight venture known as the Polaris Program. The most recent expedition drew plenty of headlines in September 2024 when Isaacman flew with an all-civilian crew of amateur spacefarers on a mission he jointly funded with Elon Musk's SpaceX. During the mission, known as Polaris Dawn, the four-member crew ascended to 870 miles above Earth's surface – higher than any crewed vehicle has traveled since NASA's Apollo era ended in the 1970s. Two days into the mission, they became the first non-government astronauts to complete a spacewalk when both Isaacman and crew member Sarah Gillis exited the Dragon capsule separately for about 10 minutes each to take in the endless black expanse of outer space. Isaacman's first trip to space came when he commanded the first all-civilian space crew in 2021 aboard a SpaceX capsule as part of a mission known as Inspiration4. Netflix filmed a documentary about the Inspiration4 mission. By that time, space tourists had already begun taking short trips to the edge of space with companies like Richard Branson's Virgin Galactic and Jeff Bezos' Blue Origin. But Inspiration4 became known as the world's first all-civilian extended mission to space, with Isaacman, who funded the spaceflight, and three others spending three days living in orbit and conducting research. Isaacman's nomination to lead NASA was well-received by most of the space community and members of Congress. But at a critical time when the U.S. space agency is preparing to return humans to the moon and send the first astronauts to Mars, Trump suddenly pulled Isaacman's bid in late May. The decision came after Isaacman had cleared the Senate Commerce Committee in April and appeared on track for a full Senate vote. Though Trump never offered a concrete reason for the about-face, Isaacman faced some pushback in the Senate for his close ties to Musk at a time when the SpaceX founder was on his way out of the White House. Other reports have suggested Isaacman's past donations to Democrats may have influenced Trumps decision, who said in a statement that "the next leader of NASA is in complete alignment with President Trump's America First agenda." Trump, who said on Truth Social that he will propose a new nominee, first announced Isaacman's nomination in a December 2024 post, saying, 'Jared will drive NASA's mission of discovery and inspiration, paving the way for groundbreaking achievements in space science, technology, and exploration.' NASA has now lacked a full-time administrator since Bill Nelson stepped down on Jan. 20, the day of Trump's inauguration. Contributing: Joey Garrison, USA TODAY; Brooke Edwards, FLORIDA TODAY Eric Lagatta is the Space Connect reporter for the USA TODAY Network. Reach him at elagatta@ This article originally appeared on Florida Today: After Trump pulls Isaacman NASA bid, billionaire eyes next space mission