CAT upholds CCP decision against PESCO
ISLAMABAD: The Competition Appellate Tribunal (CAT) has upheld the decision of the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) against Peshawar Electric Supply Company (PESCO) and directed it to restore the Right of Way (ROW) facility on fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory terms for all service providers, including fiber optic and local internet/cable TV operators. Disposing of the appeal, the CAT further directed PESCO to formulate a new policy within 30 days.
The CCP had initiated an enquiry after receiving formal complaints from Cyber Internet Services (Private) Limited and Nayatel (Private) Limited, alleging discriminatory practices in ROW charges. The investigation revealed that PESCO was charging Rs 100 per pole from internet service providers like Nayatel, while demanding only Rs 10 per pole from local cable TV operators.
Following the issuance of a show-cause notice by CCP, PESCO's Board of Directors annulled its existing policy and decided to withdraw the ROW facility entirely for all service providers, including both cable TV and fiber optic operators. In its final order, the Commission found that PESCO had abused its dominant position, constituting a violation of Section 3 of the Competition Act, 2010.
During proceedings before the CAT, CCP's counsel argued that PESCO's actions contravened the Public and Private Right of Way Policy Directives issued by the Government of Pakistan. The counsel further highlighted that, under the prevailing legal framework, licensed service providers are entitled to use poles owned by government-managed or private electricity distribution companies for aerial fiber optic installations—upon payment of government-determined rent.
The CCP maintained that PESCO holds a dominant position in the ROW market within its service jurisdiction, as it solely owns and controls the electricity poles used for such installations, with no viable alternatives available to service providers.
The Commission has reiterated its recommendation to all electricity distribution companies to develop a uniform and non-discriminatory policy for Right of Way and broadband deployment, addressing legitimate space, access, and safety concerns in the process.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
an hour ago
- Business Recorder
CCP grants exemptions to logistics and transport sector
The Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) has granted two conditional exemptions to undertakings in the transport and logistics sector, permitting limited restrictive provisions under joint venture agreements aimed at strengthening Pakistan's logistics capabilities. According to a press statement released on Monday, the exemptions were approved following a comprehensive review by CCP's Exemptions Department, which assessed the legal framework, potential market impact, and the long-term investment plans associated with the proposed collaborations. 'These arrangements were found to satisfy the requirements set out in Section 9 of the Competition Act, 2010. The joint ventures are expected to foster technical progress, enhance operational efficiency, and improve service standards in the logistics and freight sectors,' read the statement. CCP grants six exemptions to pharma sector CCP observed that the joint ventures will leverage international best practices alongside local expertise, contributing to infrastructure development, innovation, and greater consumer value. Specific provisions within the shareholders' agreements—such as non-compete and exclusivity clauses—were conditionally approved to ensure investment protection and coordination, while safeguarding against risks of market foreclosure. These approvals reaffirm CCP's commitment to facilitating strategic business collaboration that supports economic growth, while ensuring that competition remains open, fair, and free from abuse of dominance, said CCP. 'All exemptions are subject to strict compliance with conditions designed to preserve competitive dynamics in the market,' read the statement.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Substandard packaging: PPWSMA calls on govt to curb Atta wastage
ISLAMABAD: The Pakistan Polypropylene Woven Sack Manufacturers Association (PPWSMA) has appealed to the Minister for National Food Security and Research, Rana Tanveer Hussain, to take urgent action to prevent the wastage of wheat flour (Atta) caused by the use of substandard packaging. In a letter addressed to the Minister, PPWSMA Chairman Iskandar Khan highlighted that, according to the Food and Agriculture Organization, over 11 million Pakistanis face acute food insecurity. 'Wheat flour (Atta), as it is commonly known, is the staple food of our nation. For a vast majority of our people, a simple Roti with onions or chilies is often their only meal,' Khan wrote. 'To preserve this essential staple in the daily diet of the common man, it must be packed and distributed in compliant sacks and bags as per the official Gazette notification.' He emphasized that significant losses are occurring due to dusting and spillage from poor-quality, non-food grade sacks—resulting in a cumulative wastage valued at approximately Rs 594 billion. The Minister was reminded of Gazette Notification S.R.O. 46(KE)/2017, issued on May 19, 2017, which mandates the use of PSQCA-licensed, environment-friendly, recyclable, and food-grade polypropylene sacks to reduce losses during handling and transit. According to PPWSMA, failure to implement this notification has led to continuous flour wastage since 2017. Khan argued that the cost difference between non-food grade and food-grade sacks is minimal compared to the potential savings. For example, using compliant bags could save Rs 75 per 20kg sack and Rs 37.50 per 10kg sack—totaling an estimated annual savings of Rs 67.2 billion. 'We seek your assistance in ensuring the enforcement of the Gazette notification to stop this massive wastage of Atta, which directly contributes to food insecurity across the country,' Khan concluded. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
WHT regime: Finance Bill will introduce major changes
ISLAMABAD: Finance Bill (2025-26) will introduce major changes in withholding tax regime in budget (2025-26) to generate additional revenue. According to sources, the difference of withholding taxes between filers and non-filers would be further widened from next fiscal year. The heavy reliance on withholding taxes would continue in the next fiscal year. The withholding taxes (collected in sales tax mode) constitute over 70 percent of the direct taxes collection. One of the proposals under consideration is to raise tax rate on interest income. Cash withdrawals from banks: FBR proposes raise in WHT for non-filers The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has proposed to raise withholding tax on cash withdrawal from the banks by non-filers from 0.6 percent to 1 to 1.2 percent. Another proposal is to impose 1.5 percent withholding tax on the value of imports. The rates of Withholding Tax on immovable properties are expected to be rationalized in the upcoming budget (2025-26) to facilitate buyers and sellers of real estate sector from July 1 2025. Other proposals under consideration included raise in withholding tax on supplies, services and contracts. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
