
Closing arguments heard in case of Halifax dentist, 82, accused of slapping child patients
Dr. Errol Gaum, 82, appeared in Halifax provincial court Monday for final submissions in his trial, which heard evidence over several days in May. He is accused of slapping patients when they were children, with the earliest allegation dating back to 1970.
Defence lawyer Nick Fitch argued the charges should be dismissed. He questioned whether the "events" even occurred and, if they did, whether Gaum was the dentist who inflicted them. Even if he was, it was "done to protect the child from harm."
"Pediatric dentists are a specialist dentist that is referred the most difficult patients. These are children with behavioural issues that fight, bite, kick and are often sedated," Fitch said in his written submissions.
"There is no doubt that dentistry of combative children, particularly when these matters occurred, was not pretty. It is easy to imagine why a child may interpret an experience that involves pain, scary tools, restriction and harsh tones as an assault."
Gaum was charged in early 2022, a little more than a year after his licence was suspended after allegations of misconduct emerged, including that he used excessive force while treating child patients.
The defence has raised concerns about the role of a Facebook group about Gaum set up in the wake of the allegations being made public, with some witnesses testifying to being active on the page. It included photos of Gaum, and there were discussions about litigation.
Judge Elizabeth Buckle, who has reserved her decision in the case for Nov. 20, said the issue is whether there was inadvertent "tainting" in the case.
The court heard testimony from six alleged former patients. Gaum is formally charged with assaulting four of them, with two others giving "similar fact evidence."
Prosecutor Stephen Anstey argued that evidence from each alleged victim corroborates the others. Each testified that Gaum became angry while treating them and then slapped them across the face. Five of the six testified he told them to "shut up."
Anstey said the testimony of each has "striking similarities," even though they described events at different points during the 1970s and 1980s, and he argued the witnesses are telling the same story because they are "telling the truth."
He argued their recollections of what happened were not affected by stories they read in the news or on Facebook about other people's experiences with Gaum. He said there's no evidence to support the idea any of them fabricated their stories or are motivated by money.
"Each of our witnesses testified that while they had seen other stories online, it had not changed what had happened," Anstey said outside the courtroom.
"The vast majority of our witnesses further testified that prior to this story coming out in 2020, they had told other people about this beforehand. And our argument is that you can't make up something from seeing a story in 2020 if you've told somebody about it prior to 2020."
Gaum faced five assault charges at the beginning of trial. But the Crown dropped the prosecution of one because of issues surrounding the particular date of the alleged assault and provisions in the Criminal Code at the time.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
10 minutes ago
- CTV News
Saint John Police Force issues Canada-wide warrant for wanted person
The Saint John Police Force is asking for the public's assistance in locating 30-year-old Dwayne Richard. Richard is wanted on a Canada-wide warrant, issued on Sunday for breaching the conditions of his statutory release as he failed to report to the Parrtown Community Correctional Center in Saint John as directed, a news release reads. 'Richard is a serving a federal sentence of 2-years, 1-day for convictions of possession of property obtained by crime over $5000, assault with a weapon, extortion, fail to comply with an undertaking, and fail to attend court,' the release continued. He is described as six-foot-two, 189 pounds with brown hair and brown eyes. He has tattoos on his right forearm of 'DBD', on his chest of 'CYNIAH', and on his right shoulder of 'MY SPIDER.' Police are warning the public not to approach the suspect. Anyone with information on Richard's whereabouts are asked to contact Saint John Police Force at 506-648-3333 or Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-8477. For more New Brunswick news, visit our dedicated provincial page.


CTV News
10 minutes ago
- CTV News
LaSalle has lowest Crime Severity Index in Ontario municipal police services
LaSalle has lowest Crime Severity Index out of Ontario municipal police services, according to Statistics Canada. Stats Can released police-reported crime statistics for 2024 on Monday. Included in this batch of data is the Crime Severity Index (CSI). Of the 43 municipal police services in Ontario, LaSalle ranked #1, with the lowest Crime Severity Index of 21.26, representing a 15.8per cent decrease from the year prior. T This is also significantly lower than the provincial average of 60.69. LaSalle also ranked #1 within Windsor-Essex. This does not include all municipalities policed by the OPP, just the ones in Essex County. More stats are available online: Crime severity index and weighted clearance rates, police services in Ontario


National Post
10 minutes ago
- National Post
ICE goes public with a new report on Canadian man who died in custody
Article content A Canadian who died in ICE custody is documented to have had health concerns, according to a report made public by the U.S. government agency today. While in custody, the 49-year-old was prescribed medication for seizures and hypertension, and recommended to undergo mental health evaluation after he was reported to be feeling 'sad and depressed, and refused to go to the medical clinic for an evaluation.' Article content Article content Why was the Canadian man arrested by ICE? Article content Johnny Noviello entered the U.S. on a legal visa in 1988 and became a permanent resident in 1991. In 2023, he was convicted on the charges of drug trafficking, racketeering and the unlawful use of two-way communication device used to facilitate commission of crime. He was sentenced to prison for 12 months. Article content His arrest by ICE came in 2025, wherein he was issued a notice to appear in court and faced a removability charge. Article content What does the ICE report say about the health of the Canadian who died in custody? Article content The 49-year-old was pronounced dead late in June after being found unresponsive in a detention centre in Miami. Respecting the family's privacy, Global Affairs minister Anita Anand had said late in June that 'further details will not be provided at this time.' Article content Today, the Government of Canada was notified of the death of a Canadian citizen while in custody in the United States. Canadian consular officials are urgently seeking more information from US officials. I offer my sincere condolences to the family. In order to respect the… — Anita Anand (@AnitaAnandMP) June 26, 2025 Article content Article content The report released today highlighted health concerns that the officials flagged before he died. Here's what we know about the timeline since his arrest: Article content Article content May 15: Noviello was arrested and detained. Article content May 16: The 49-year-old underwent a routine health inspection. A registered nurse completed the medical intake screening and noted the diagnosis of 'hypertension and seizure disorder, slightly elevated blood pressure, high body mass index, and his reported medication list and sent a provider referral' for him. He was prescribed medication. Article content May 30: As per the documentation, the Canadian man is said to have refused a health history and a physical exam. Article content June 8: He was reported to be feeling sad and depressed and is said to have refused a health evaluation at a medical clinic. Article content June 9: Noviello reportedly maintained poor personal hygiene and stated he had not eaten in 'a while.' Documentation revealed his vitals to be normal, and that there was discussion with him around the importance of self-hygiene and proper diet.