‘I want to remember Tina the way she was, not the way I made her': Richard Satchwell trial hears garda interview with accused
Richard Satchwell
told gardaí that if they produced any photographs of his wife's body in interview, he would not look at them, informing detectives: 'I want to remember Tina the way she was, not the way I made her,' his trial has heard.
The Central Criminal Court jury also heard on Thursday that gardaí told the murder accused his 'second story' about his
Tina Satchwell
's death, where he said he held her off by the belt of her bathrobe after she attacked him, had 'come apart' and did not match up with the evidence.
In his first interview with gardaí following his rearrest on October 12th, 2023 Mr Satchwell said that his wife Tina 'flew' at him with a chisel, that he had fallen backwards and described holding the belt of her bathrobe at her neck 'until she got heavier'.
At the outset of a fourth interview on October 13th, 2023, gardaí told Mr Satchwell they were going to show him some photographs. The accused said: 'If it's of Tina's body, I am not going to look. I want to remember Tina the way she was, not the way I made her'.
READ MORE
Detective Sergeant David Noonan showed the accused a photograph of the sittingroom in his home on Grattan Street taken during an initial garda search in 2017.
Gardaí asked which of the two brown couches he had put Tina on when she died. Mr Satchwell said his wife was laid out on 'the one without the tear' and he had since put that couch upstairs.
Det Sgt Noonan then asked the accused: 'Where are the marks you said were on the wall?'. The officer was referring to plasterboard which Mr Satchwell told gardaí his wife was 'destroying' with a chisel moments before she 'flew' at him.
The Det Sgt continued: 'You said the marks were still there and to go and have a look at them'. Mr Satchwell replied: 'I also said I can't remember, the marks weren't going all the way through the plasterboard and I never said that either.....I said it is there somewhere'.
Det Sgt told the accused: 'When we start to produce evidence, people start to tailor or incorporate their story and try to make slight manoeuvres to make it suit. You said you were coming here and have nothing to lose, that's not true you have a lot to lose as the story you are telling is not making sense'.
Mr Satchwell was questioned by officers about how he claimed his wife 'flew' or 'came at' him and he went 'off balance'.
Det Sgt Noonan said: 'Every interview you have told us how violent she was, she flew off the handle, she could punch you, knock glasses off your face and you do nothing, you continue driving and don't even stop. How all of a sudden is she bent over with the chisel, you come in and say 'what you doing', next thing she flies at you and all of a sudden you are falling on to your back: can you see how it sounds?'.
Mr Satchwell replied: 'I can see the way you want it to sound'. Det Sgt Noonan told the accused: 'This is your account. I'm not creating this account, these are not my words – they are your words, can you see from my perspective how it sounds?'.
The accused replied: 'I can see it is your job to tear it apart and bury me'. Det Sgt Noonan continued: 'My job is to point out that what you are saying doesn't match up with the evidence. There are so many things you have said that don't add up and it's very important you know these things'.
The trial continues this afternoon before Mr Justice Paul McDermott and a jury of five men and seven women.
The Central Criminal Court has heard that on March 24th, 2017, Mr Satchwell told gardaí that his wife Tina had left their home four days earlier but that he had no concerns over her welfare, feeling she had left due to a deterioration in their relationship. The accused formally reported Ms Satchwell missing the following May but her body was not discovered for over six years, when gardaí in October 2023 conducting 'an invasive search' of the Satchwell's home found her decomposed remains in a grave that had been dug underneath the stairs.
The trial has heard gardaí went with a search warrant to the accused's home on Grattan Street in Youghal on October 10th 2023, where they arrested him for the murder of Tina Satchwell on or about March 19th, 2017 and brought him to Cobh Garda station.
An invasive search of Grattan Street was conducted simultaneously, with gardaí bringing in building equipment to excavate the couple's home.
Mr Satchwell (58), with an address at Grattan Street, Youghal, Co Cork has pleaded not guilty to murdering his 45-year-old wife Tina Satchwell – née Dingivan – at that address between March 19th and March 20th, 2017, both dates inclusive.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Man arrested over Annie McCarrick murder was nominated to Garda as suspect in 1993
The man arrested for questioning on suspicion of the murder of Annie McCarrick was flagged to gardaí as a possible suspect in the case in the immediate aftermath of the New Yorker vanishing from Sandymount , South Dublin, in 1993. Friends of Ms McCarrick were concerned about the man, and the nature of his contacts with the 26-year-old in Dublin. They outlined those concerns, and the specific reasons for them, in fax messages to the Garda investigation team. However, they have always believed the information they supplied was not properly handled and was not factored into the initial inquiry in any meaningful way. The suspect, who is in his 60s and originally from Dublin, was arrested on Thursday morning and remained in Garda custody early on Friday. He was detained under Section 4 of the Criminal Justice Act, on suspicion of murder, and can be questioned for up to 24 hours, though questioning has been paused to allow breaks for rest. READ MORE [ Annie McCarrick's best friend is 'overwhelmed with emotion, crying over my coffee' after developments in case Opens in new window ] Gardaí yesterday extended his period of detention to the maximum 24 hours of interviews permitted under law and must either release him without charge, or charge him with an offence, later on Friday. The man has become a successful businessman over the last three decades and now lives outside Dublin. As well as being arrested on Thursday morning, his home in the east of the country was searched. And a house in Clondalkin, west Dublin, that he was linked to in 1993 was sealed off for searching and excavation, in an operation continuing on Friday morning. The Clondalkin property has been renovated by the current occupants, who bought the house over a decade ago. Gardaí have stressed the current occupants are completely unconnected to Ms McCarrick or the murder inquiry now under way. Some of Ms McCarrick's friends in the United States had remained in close and frequent contact with her when she moved back to Ireland in January, 1993, after first studying here. They said she felt pressured and harassed by an Irishman in her social circle in Dublin and that she told them the man struck her when he had been drinking. They flagged those concerns with gardaí in the initial stages of the investigation when she vanished. [ Annie McCarrick: Gardaí made first arrest in 32-year investigation after receiving new information Opens in new window ] However, at the time Ms McCarrick (26) went missing, there was a series of reported sightings of her getting on a bus bound for Enniskerry, Co Wicklow, and also sightings of her in the village. Other reports placed her 6km away in Johnnie Fox's Pub, Glencullen, Co Dublin. Those sightings, since discounted, all related to Friday, March 26th, the day of the last confirmed sighting of the murdered woman at her flat in Sandymount, South Dublin. Much of the Garda's attention in the first phased of investigation focused on pursuing those sightings in Enniskerry and Glencullen. Ms McCarrick knew the man arrested on Thursday, and was very close to him for a period. However, while her friends told gardaí about that man in 1993 – including Ms McCarrick saying he had harassed her and struck her – they felt their information was not actioned by detectives at the time. When none of the claimed sightings of Ms McCarrick in 1993 led to any breakaway, and her remains were never found, the case remained an unsolved missing person's inquiry until it was upgraded to a murder investigation two years ago. In recent years, after a cold case review and fresh investigation, detectives have come to focus on the arrested man as the main suspect in the case. They also have a particular interest in a close associate of his, who they went abroad to interview earlier this year. They believe the suspect and his close associate were together on the weekend Ms McCarrick vanished and detectives have sought to recheck their accounts of their movements, comparing statements taken in recent years. In March 1993 Ms McCarrick, from Long Island, New York, was living in rented accommodation at St Cathryn's Court, Sandymount, with two friends. They last spoke to her at the property on the morning of Friday, March 26th. . Amid rising concerns for her safety, Ms McCarrick was reported missing to gardaí that Sunday, more than 48 hours after the last confirmed sighting of her. Meanwhile, the US lawyer hired by the father of Annie McCarrick to represent the family in the period after her disappearance has said he is 'delighted' there has been arrest and remains hopeful the case will eventually be resolved with a conviction. Michael Griffith has criticised An Garda Síochána over its reluctance to engage with him and others working for the family in the aftermath of her disappearance in March 1993. He suggested then Director of Public Prosecutions Eamonn Barnes had been helpful to the team Mr Griffith had assembled to work on the case on behalf of the McCarrick family but that the Garda was reluctant to share information or engage. 'We met with the Garda. We tried to follow up leads at that time but nothing came of it,' he told RTÉ Radio 1's Morning Ireland programme on Friday. 'In the States here, attorneys tend to share evidence with investigations, with the police, but even though Eamonn Barnes wanted the Garda to open up the file to us, the Garda was quite reclusive about it, and we weren't able to get into the file, although there were a couple of persons of interest, one of whom I'm told may now be in custody.' He said had a meeting with Jean Kennedy Smith, then US ambassador to Ireland, who assured him the Department of State would do everything it could to assist but said this had no impact on the level of co-operation provided by An Garda Síochána. Mr Griffith said the disappearance of their daughter took a very considerable toll on her parents, John, now deceased, and Nancy. 'Obviously there was a lot of stress that came out of this and the McCarricks got divorced.' He said he would like to know what prompted an arrest in the case after so long but he remains hopeful the case will be resolved for the family. An Garda Síochána said they did not respond on individual cases but have a policy of appointing family liaison officers in major cases.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Behind each figure is a vulnerable child in care': Court kept in dark about 400 without social workers
Tusla's 'unprecedented' failure to notify the courts it had not allocated social workers to almost 400 children has broken trust in the agency, a District Court judge has said. Tusla, the child and family agency, is obliged to notify the court if a child is not appointed a social worker. Judge Conor Fottrell said 'shocking' and 'concerning figures' arising from a court-directed inquiry outline the extent of the agency's failure to comply with orders relating to children in State care. Appearing before the judge at a sitting of Dublin District childcare court this week, Tusla chief executive Kate Duggan apologised for shortcomings that led to the agency's widespread noncompliance with court orders. She stopped short of accepting sole responsibility for the failings. READ MORE Last July, Judge Fottrell directed Tusla to carry out the inquiry to identify instances where the agency did not notify the court about children in State care due to court orders who were not allocated social workers. He directed that the review must also consider compliance with other court directions relating to children subject to care orders. On foot of these directions, Tusla submitted a report to the court earlier this month. Citing the report, Judge Fottrell said the agency identified 395 cases of children subject to care orders and not allocated social workers that had not been flagged to the court. During the inquiry, Tusla considered the cases of 1,052 children subject to care orders stretching back to 2009, the judge noted. He said 859 court directions were breached in relation to 471 children. He said the court was not notified of the breaches. Judge Fottrell described Tusla's widespread failure to comply with court orders as 'unprecedented'. 'Behind each figure is a vulnerable child in care,' he said. The judge said it was early 2024 when he first became aware of issues relating to Tusla's failure to notify the court of non-allocation. It is 'regrettable' that the court had to raise questions to bring the information in the report to light. Judge Fottrell said the court's trust in the agency 'has been broken'. In a judgment published in March this year, following the court's inquiry into the matter, Judge Fottrell was heavily critical of the agency's 'extraordinary failure' to comply with orders relating to about 250 children granted over the last 15 years. Led by David Leahy, senior counsel for Tusla, Ms Duggan told the court that in December 2022, she was informed by the agency's regional chief for Dublin Mid Leinster of cases relating to 40 children left without a social worker, and a failure to notify the courts of such. Ms Duggan – who was then Tusla's director of services and integration – said her understanding at the time was that the issue was confined to a specific area. Ms Duggan agreed with the judge that she did not escalate the issue with the then-chief executive. She suggested she would have escalated it if aware of its scale at the time. While noting Tusla's position that no 'active' decision was made not to notify the court of the cases, Judge Fottrell said nobody brought the cases to the court's attention despite being aware of the issue since December 2022. 'That is a catastrophic failure at local, regional and national level,' he said. Asked by the judge if she, as chief executive of Tusla, accepted responsibility for the agency's failure to comply with court orders, Ms Duggan said: 'I think this is an agency-wide responsibility.' Ms Duggan said Tusla has commissioned an external review to examine how the situation arose. She outlined to the court efforts to increase recruitment of social workers to Tusla, to digitise file-management systems and other protocols aimed at mitigating risk of further breaches of court orders. She said everyone within Tusla is now aware breaches are not tolerated.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Israel launches attacks on Iran
Solidarity TD Ruth Coppinger played a recording of drones from her neighbour, 'in Blanchardstown, we've been suffering this for over a year and a half."
