logo
Israel denies visa extension to senior UN humanitarian official over Gaza 'lies'

Israel denies visa extension to senior UN humanitarian official over Gaza 'lies'

The National21-07-2025
Israel has refused to extend the residency visa of a senior UN humanitarian official due to his comments on the Gaza war, accusing him of spreading "lies".
Jonathan Whittall, head of the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs in Gaza and the West Bank, will be forced to leave his home in Jerusalem after Israel's Foreign Minister Gideon Saar ordered his permit be withdrawn.
Mr Whittall, a South African, regularly visits Gaza and has repeatedly condemned the humanitarian conditions in the enclave. In April, he said Gazans were "slowly dying" due to the effects of Israel's war.
"I have instructed not to extend the residency permit of the head of the OCHA office in Israel, Jonathan Whittall," Mr Saar wrote on X in Hebrew.
He said Mr Whittall had engaged in "biased and hostile conduct against Israel, which distorted reality, presented false reports, slandered Israel and even violated the UN's own rules regarding neutrality".
"Whoever spreads lies about Israel - Israel will not work with him," Mr Saar said.
Mr Saar's decision is the latest taken by Israel against senior UN officials. UN spokesman Stephane Dujarric said last week that visas for three heads of UN agencies working in Gaza – the OCHA, human rights agency OHCHR, and the UN's Palestinian relief agency UNRWA – had not been reissued.
'Visas are not renewed or reduced in duration by Israel, explicitly in response to our work on protection of civilians,' OCHA chief Tom Fletcher told the UN Security Council earlier this month.
The UN has been critical of Israel over the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. On Sunday the OCHA said Israel's latest eviction order in Gaza, this time in the Deir Al Balah area, would deal "another devastating blow" to aid efforts.
On Sunday morning, the Israeli military ordered Gazans in the area to leave immediately due to imminent operations. The area is where many international aid organisations have attempted to distribute aid.
But the OCHA said UN staff were "remaining" in the territory and their coordinates had been shared with "relevant parties", the agency said. At least 1,000 Gazan families had already fled, it added.
"UN staff are remaining in Deir Al Balah, spread across dozens of premises," it said. "These locations – as with all civilian sites – must be protected, regardless of displacement orders."
The area contains several humanitarian warehouses, four primary health clinics, four medical points, and critical water infrastructure including three wells, one reservoir, one solid waste dumping site and one wastewater pumping station, the OCHR said.
It warned that any damage to the facilities "will have life-threatening consequences".
Between 50,000 and 80,000 people were in the area when the evacuation order was issued, according to OCHA estimates.
Since the start of the war, nearly all of Gaza's population – which is also facing severe food shortages – has been displaced at least once by repeated Israeli eviction orders.
According to the OCHA, the latest order means that 87.8 per cent of Gaza's area is now under displacement orders or within Israeli militarised zones.
That leaves "2.1 million civilians squeezed into a fragmented 12 per cent of the strip, where essential services have collapsed", the UN agency said.
"The new order cuts through Deir Al Balah all the way to the Mediterranean Sea, further splintering the strip," it said. "It will limit the ability of the UN and our partners to move safely and effectively within Gaza, choking humanitarian access when it is needed most."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

UK Jewish body calls for open Gaza aid amid Starmer row
UK Jewish body calls for open Gaza aid amid Starmer row

The National

time23 minutes ago

  • The National

UK Jewish body calls for open Gaza aid amid Starmer row

The UK's largest Jewish body has called for across-the-board access for aid shipments into the Gaza Strip in a statement critical of Israeli restrictions. The message on the plight of Gazans came as the community group pushed back against UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer's pledge to recognise Palestine. The Board of Deputies of British Jews said the Israeli pause in fighting to allow aid was 'essential if long overdue', after a special meeting on Tuesday was called following Mr Starmer's announcement. 'We need to see a rapid, uninhibited, and sustained increase in aid through all available channels, and we need to see all agencies co-operating in this endeavour,' said the board's president, Phil Rosenberg. It is the BoD's first statement on the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, weeks after internal rifts over the organisation's position on the war deepened. However, it also challenged Mr Starmer's pledge that he would recognise a Palestinian state next month if Israel does not agree to a ceasefire. The board said the promise risked 'putting gestures ahead of substance', which could also 'empower or reward Hamas'. 'We are therefore seeking clarification that the UK Government will not recognise a Palestinian state while Hamas fails to meet UK demands, including accepting a ceasefire and releasing the hostages,' Mr Rosenberg said. 'Recognising a Palestinian state without a diplomatic agreement risks putting gestures ahead of substance. 'However, our primary concern regarding the government's announcement is to avoid empowering or rewarding Hamas, or giving it incentives to continue evading a ceasefire,' he added. The pushback is shared by former hostage Emily Damari, a British-Israeli who was held in Gaza by Hamas for more than a year. Ms Damari said Mr Starmer's pledge was not 'on the right side of history'. 'Prime Minister Starmer is not standing on the right side of history. Had he been in power during World War II, would he have advocated recognition for Nazi control of occupied countries like Holland, France, or Poland?' she wrote on social media. 'This is not diplomacy – it is a moral failure. Shame on you, Prime Minister.' The board has faced escalating internal tension in the past three months over its public stance on the Israel-Gaza war, which critics say failed to reflect the diversity of views among British Jews regarding the conflict. Last month, five members of the BoD who had written an open letter to the FT criticising Israel's renewed military campaign in Gaza from March this year were suspended for two years. The BoD said at the time that it did not take issue with members' criticism of the war, but with the fact that their letter had been presented as a statement from the organisation itself. Yet the rift has caused a small but growing number of British Jews to feel disillusioned with the organisation, which has historically been the community's representative to British officialdom. The campaign group Na'amod, a movement of British Jews seeking an end to the war and a solution to the Palestinian issue, organised a protest outside the Foreign Office earlier this week calling for 'forceful action' on Israel 'to stop Israel's starvation, displacement and bombing of Palestinians in Gaza'.

Gaza's 60,000 dead cannot be explained away
Gaza's 60,000 dead cannot be explained away

The National

time3 hours ago

  • The National

Gaza's 60,000 dead cannot be explained away

Possibly the most disturbing aspect of Monday's confirmation that more than 60,000 Palestinians have lost their lives in Gaza since October 2023 is what this macabre milestone does not tell us. Firstly, this death toll is almost certainly an underestimate. As far back as a year ago, British medical journal The Lancet was reporting that it was 'not implausible' for the number of fatalities to have reached 186,000 or more, once direct and indirect causes of death were considered. What that estimate could be 12 months on does not bear thinking about. The grim figure of 60,000 does not include those who have lost limb s, had their entire family killed or who will struggle for years to recover from psychological trauma and the effects of the manufactured starvation that is currently sweeping through Gaza's ruins, particularly affecting children, the elderly and the infirm. Nor does that figure take account of the intentional destruction of Palestinian institutions by the Israeli government's policy of collective punishment. Hospitals, schools and universities have all been reduced to fragments as Palestinian civilians are displaced time and again or hounded into tent cities and deadly queues for aid that resemble a shooting gallery more than a humanitarian operation. At the same time, Israel's decades-long military occupation of the West Bank, coupled with violence from radical settlers, continues to constrain and undermine Palestinian communities. It is a dispiriting picture but it is also clear that public opinion internationally is shifting to the point where Israel's response to the brutal Hamas-led attacks of October 7 is now widely viewed as wanton, illegal and unjust. Images of skeletal Palestinian children cannot be explained away by deflections about threats or anti-Israel bias. As Israel's leadership continues to shred what is left of the country's reputation and alienate many allies – even US President Donald Trump recently spoke out about the mass starvation in Gaza – other voices are offering a way out of this morass. This week's Saudi Arabia and France-led summit on the two-state solution not only reinforced the reality that there is no alternative to a just political settlement, but it also called for Hamas to lay down its arms and join a new Palestinian leadership. As Khalifa Al Marar, UAE Minister of State, told the UN in New York on Tuesday, every day that passes without a solution 'deepens the wounds and distances the chances of peace'. This grim figure does not include those who have lost limbs, had their entire family killed or who will struggle for years to recover from psychological trauma and the effects of manufactured starvation Meanwhile, more countries are moving closer to recognising Palestinian statehood. It now seems likely that the UK will do so later this year, given the remote possibility of Israel ending its war. With the UN General Assembly coming up soon, there is an opportunity to exert further political pressure on an Israeli government whose strategy – if it can be called that – is not only failing to recover its remaining hostages but leading its own people into a cul-de-sac of perpetual conflict and isolation. It may be true that diplomatic meetings and speeches can seem far removed from the realities of daily life in Gaza. Nevertheless, global diplomatic co-ordination remains the best hope of ending the possibility of reaching more ghastly milestones such as that seen on Monday and to eventually forging a path towards peace.

Qatar, Saudi, Egypt Urge Hamas to Disarm and Exit Gaza
Qatar, Saudi, Egypt Urge Hamas to Disarm and Exit Gaza

UAE Moments

time4 hours ago

  • UAE Moments

Qatar, Saudi, Egypt Urge Hamas to Disarm and Exit Gaza

Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt —alongside 14 other countries, the EU, and the Arab League —have publicly called for Hamas to disarm and step down from ruling Gaza. The bold move was made during a UN conference focused on reviving the long-stalled two-state solution between Israel and Palestine. Declaration Pushes for PA to Take Over Gaza The joint statement urged Hamas to hand over control of Gaza to the Palestinian Authority (PA) with international backing, aiming to pave the way for a sovereign and independent Palestinian state. This comes after the Palestinian delegation itself requested both Hamas and Israel withdraw from Gaza to allow the PA to govern. Condemning Hamas, Opening Doors What makes this stand out? For the first time, Arab states condemned the October 7 Hamas attacks and clearly called for the group's disarmament and removal from Palestinian governance. France, which co-hosted the event with Saudi Arabia, called the move ' historic and unprecedented.' The statement even hinted that some countries may be open to normalizing ties with Israel —a big deal in the region. What's Next? Possible Foreign Forces in Gaza The declaration also proposed a temporary international stabilization mission in Gaza, under UN leadership, once the war ends. The UN Security Council would have to greenlight it, and regional backing would be key. UK May Recognize Palestine Soon On the sidelines of the conference, Britain said it could recognize a Palestinian state by September —if Israel meets conditions like a Gaza ceasefire and increased humanitarian aid. The War Isn't Over Yet It's been 21 months since the latest war in Gaza began, following Hamas' October 2023 attack and Israel's massive military response. The fighting has caused widespread destruction and tens of thousands of Palestinian casualties. At the conference, UN Secretary-General António Guterres admitted the truth: ' The two-state solution is farther than ever. '

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store