NGT upholds ₹25L fine on MCD over neglect in Raghubir Nagar
The National Green Tribunal (NGT) has upheld a fine of ₹25 lakh levied on the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) for decades of neglect outside a school for the visually impaired in west Delhi's Raghubir Nagar.
Disposing of a plea by MCD, the tribunal said it had made 'no error' in ordering the civic body to pay compensation for the upkeep of the Akhil Bhartiya Netrahin Sangh School, which has provided free education and accommodation to over 100 visually impaired students annually since 1971.
The penalty was first imposed in November 2024 after the NGT found that MCD had violated Rule 15 of the Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016, by allowing a 'dhalao (garbage dump)' to operate outside the school's main gate. The tribunal took suo motu cognisance in April 2024 of a media report describing how garbage routinely spilled onto the road, hindering students' movement and creating health hazards.
A bench headed by NGT chairperson justice Prakash Shrivastava, in its August 5 order, dismissed MCD's argument that the fine was unjustified as the dhalao had been shut in November 2024.
'The dhalao was closed just four days before the delivery of the judgment. Even closure of the dhalao will have no effect on the matter because the environmental compensation has been imposed upon the respondent - MCD for the past violations. In the review application itself the MCD has admitted that the dhalao came in existence in 1984-85 much after the Akhil Bhartiya Nitrahin Sangh School was established in 1971, meaning thereby visually impaired students have suffered the agony and environmental harms for several decades,' the bench said in its latest order.
'Considering the health hazard and serious problem suffered by the visually impaired students studying and residing in the school, the compensation awarded is very reasonable… No ground for review is made out, which is accordingly dismissed,' the bench said.
School officials said while the dhalao has been removed, some residents from nearby areas continue throw waste at the same spot. 'The dhalao has been shut and removed, but some residents here still throw their daily waste here. We have sought a solution from the NGT and MCD in this regard too,' said Devendra Singh Rathore, general secretary of the school.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
4 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Barking up the wrong tree
The Municipal Corporation of Delhi is considering issuing an advisory to prevent the feeding of pigeons in public places, which includes our balconies and terraces. The MCD wants to ward off diseases associated with pigeon droppings. Children playing with street dogs in New Delhi. (Arun Sharma/Hindustan Times) In the concrete jungle that I live in, pigeons are the only birds I ever spot and feeding them is in my DNA. My interest in pigeons increased manifold when I read Twilight in Delhi (1940) by Ahmed Ali. In the book, the patriarch, Mir Nihal, loves pigeons and is an ace trainer with a family history of flying them at official functions such as the Delhi Durbar of 1903. The summer of 1911 has been exceptionally cruel, and many of Mir Nihal's pigeons have died. He visits the pigeon market held near the Jama Masjid every Friday to buy more 'Golays' and not 'Kabulis'. The Golays are a novelty in the Delhi market and are being eyed by wannabe flyers. Almost feral, these pigeons fly low over roofs in a straight line and are difficult to train. The Kabulis, however, fly just above their own homes, and, when tired, return. Downward dog (RAJ K RAJ /HT PHOTO) These days I wonder if Golays were like the stray dogs that people don't want to take home, and the Kabulis like the pedigreed status symbols they pay a fortune to procure, never mind that they are inbred and the products of illegal and inhumane breeding operations. Even as I was pondering over the fate of pigeons and how soon before I would be asked to not put out water or food for them, the Supreme Court delivered a shocker. The stray dogs across Delhi-NCR were to be rounded up and sent to pounds. This is to do with Indian breed dogs, also called Indies or desis or free ranging dogs, who do not find homes because 'dog lovers' prefer to decorate their homes with non-native pedigrees. There was a time when our Indies were prized possessions and exported across the world. S Theodore Baskaran in The Book of Indian Dogs quotes Pliny the Elder (23-79 CE) in this context: '…India is home to a number of indigenous breeds of dogs. Sadly, some of them have already disappeared, due to indifference. This is unfortunate, especially given that in ancient times they were much prized around the world… Historians have recorded that they were exported to Rome and to Egypt. Old travel accounts tell us that dogs from India were sent to Babylon… When Alexander the Great invaded India and overpowered the local rulers… he was gifted 150 dogs. Another story that has come down from the period says that to demonstrate the pluck of these dogs, two of them were set upon a lion. Even as one of the dogs suffered a badly injured leg, it held onto the lion. Alexander is said to have watched the display of tenacity with awe.' Baskaran goes on to add that although Indian dogs were in demand abroad, at home, except for kings and nobles who indulged in hunting, the upper and middle class shunned them. 'In fact, the dog was despised, and the word 'dog' was used as a derogatory term in daily use and in literature,' he writes. A dog sitting pretty within a circle marked for social distancing during the COVID-19 pandemic (Raj K Raj/HT PHOTO) On August 11, when Supreme Court Justices JB Pardiwala and R Mahadevan ruled that every single dog on the streets will have to go to a pound – ignoring all earlier landmark judgements pertaining to reducing human-dog conflict and the reasoning and science behind them – the anti-dog brigade, which unfortunately includes pedigreed dog lovers, rejoiced. For lovers of the noble Indie, it was like witnessing the persecution of beloved friends and family. Though this grand idea to send around 10 lakh dogs to a pound is untenable – the government does not own even a single shelter as of today – the celebrations and pronouncements on social media continue unabated. Where will the government find funds to build these pounds and then feed these dogs, and in such a short period? Where will they find the catchers to nab these lakhs of dogs? There are just a handful of good catchers around and most of the time, when it comes to vaccination or providing medication, feeders usually help catch the dogs. The existing shelters (all private) are bursting at their seams and are poorly kept. It's not rare to have sleepless nights if one happens to visit such a facility. Ironically, the Supreme Court's pronouncement came after taking suo moto notice of a newspaper report which claimed a child had died of rabies, though it later turned out that the cause of the child's death was meningitis. According to The Lancet, there are 5,726 human rabies deaths annually in India. This study, conducted by the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), highlights that while rabies deaths have decreased in the past two decades, India still accounts for a significant portion of global rabies fatalities. The research also emphasises the need for a 'one-health approach' to accelerate progress towards the global target of eliminating dog-mediated rabies by 2030, according to The Lancet, which also states that there has been a '75 percent decrease in rabies deaths over the past two decades'. Most dog lovers know the skewed maths behind the anti-rabies shots. Depending on the severity of the bite, a patient gets four to five shots. What are the chances of every anti-rabies shot being registered as a separate dog bite case? What if the patient visits five different facilities for the anti-rabies shots? While dogs are being cornered as they are so conspicuous and disliked by many who are generally averse to animals, nobody seems to care about the other big 'monster killer' – mosquitoes. Not even the MCD. According to the reported deaths due to malaria in 2022 were 83, but the estimated deaths in the same period were 5,511. Malaria in pregnancy is a life-threatening condition with adverse outcomes. India has inadequate surveillance, but some studies show that 10 percent to 30 percent of pregnant women suffer from malaria. In his book The Mosquito: A Human History of Our Deadliest Predator (2019), Timothy C Winegard describes how mosquitoes and their diseases have shaped the outcomes of war, the spread of religion, and the development of modern culture. In the introduction, Winegard writes: 'The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, which has contributed nearly $4 billion to mosquito research since its creation in 2000, releases an annual report that identifies the animals most lethal to humans. The contest is not even close. The heavyweight champion, and our apex predator in perpetuity, is the mosquito. Since 2000, the annual average number of human deaths caused by the mosquito has hovered around 2 million. We come in a distant second at 475,000, followed by snakes (50,000), dogs and sand flies (25,000 each)…' According to WHO, India registers nearly 50,000 snake bite deaths annually. With one sweeping judgement, the Supreme Court justices have taken the long standing human-dog equation back in time. The dog carers, who prided themselves in the landmark judgment of Justice JR Midha – the Delhi High Court judge who ruled that community dogs had a right to food, must be treated with compassion and emphasised the right of citizens to feed stray dogs – are at a loss for words. The fear of dogs has been systematically unleashed over the past couple of years. Parents now repeatedly instruct their kids to run a mile if they spot a dog. And then there are odd cases such as the one reported from Greater Noida, where a woman in morbid fear of dogs fell off a walkway and fractured her spine. The walkway had a low railing - a structural fault of the building – but her fall and her spine fracture was blamed on the dog. The dog's owner was arrested, though the dog did not even touch the woman. Such incidents, and the many fake videos and stories (such as the one the apex court based its decision on) constantly being circulated on social media have widened the gulf between dog lovers and dog haters. It would have been apt if the justices had pulled up the municipal corporation for not carrying out Animal Birth Control (ABC) programmes or vaccination drives with zest or for withholding payments to NGOs, which were hired to carry it out. Or pulled up pet shops that sell birds, cats, rabbits, dogs and what not and keep them unhygienically caged for long periods. They could have pulled up illegal breeders who sell pedigreed animals, even those unsuited for Indian climes such as huskies or large breeds that need exercise and cannot be confined in small apartments. They could have pulled up those who abandon pedigreed animals when they fall sick or when their reproductive organs fail; or those who abuse animals sexually and physically. They could have pulled up dog haters for abusing dog lovers, often physically, and preventing them from feeding dogs. Alas! A dog in the fog (Parveen Kumar/Hindustan Times) An interesting study conducted in West Bengal on 110 randomly selected free-ranging dogs (51 males and 59 females) was published in the Applied Animal Behaviour Science Journal (Volume 278, September 2024). The researchers observed that free-ranging dogs needed four interactions over four days to learn, and that they use the learned information to their benefit on subsequent days: 'Individual human recognition is important for species that live in close proximity to humans. Numerous studies on domesticated species and urban-adapted birds have highlighted this ability. One such species which is heavily reliant on humans is the free-ranging dog. Very little knowledge exists on the amount of time taken by free-ranging dogs to learn and remember individual humans.' This is the first study aiming to understand the time taken for individual human recognition in free-ranging dogs, and can serve as the scaffold for future studies to understand the dog-human relationship in open environments, like urban ecosystems, the researchers concluded. 'While some humans are a source of food, shelter and even care for them, others can be threats, as people's reactions towards free-ranging dogs range from extremely positive to extremely negative. It is thus interesting to understand the extent to which free-ranging dogs are capable of recognising individual humans, as this might be impacting their survival in the human-dominated landscape.' Sadly, we now seem set to trade this super easy four-interactions-over-four-days step to dog-less streets, pigeon-less skies and rocket-sized holes in our hearts. Lamat R Hasan is an independent journalist. She lives in New Delhi.
Hans India
5 hours ago
- Hans India
MCD to launch helpline as drive to remove stray dogs intensifies, says Delhi Mayor Raja Iqbal
New Delhi: Delhi Mayor Raja Iqbal on Wednesday told IANS that the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) will soon launch a dedicated helpline for residents to report aggressive or dangerous stray dogs, following a Supreme Court order directing their relocation from public spaces. Welcoming the court's directive, Iqbal said the judgment acknowledged the 'pain of Delhi's citizens' and outlined remedial measures. Acting on the order, the MCD has initiated a three-phase operation. 'In the first phase, we are targeting stray dogs against whom the highest number of biting complaints have been received, and which are causing maximum public distress. These dogs are being picked up from across the city and sent to shelter homes,' the mayor said. The second and third phases will address the remaining strays. Sensitive areas -- such as around schools, hospitals, courts, colleges, markets, and other public spaces -- are being prioritised. In the past two days, the MCD has removed nearly 100 stray dogs from different localities, he told IANS. The corporation is working with around 25 agencies to carry out the operation. MCD currently has 20 Animal Birth Control (ABC) centres, several of which are being converted into shelters. The largest facility is in Dwarka, where capacity is being expanded. Plans are also underway to build a large shelter home on 25 acres at Goga Dairy, he said. He further added that ahead of Independence Day celebrations, stray dogs are being removed from the Red Fort, Chandni Chowk, and surrounding areas to ensure the safety and comfort of visitors. Previously, strays picked up by MCD were sterilised and released back in the same locations. However, under the current order, they will not be returned to their original spots, he emphasised. The new helpline will allow residents to directly inform MCD about stray dogs causing public safety concerns, enabling swift action.
Time of India
13 hours ago
- Time of India
Delhi stray dog crackdown: 700 caught near Red Fort ahead of Independence Day; helpline, phase-wise removal drive planned by MCD
NEW DELHI: Municipal Corporation of Delhi's veterinary wing plans to launch phase-wise action to address the city's stray dog problem. Following SC's Monday order, the department began action to remove aggressive or diseased dogs from east Delhi's Shahdara and Bhajanpura. The corporation did not release any data on the number of animals picked up on Tuesday. An MCD official said a majority of its dog-catching vehicles were deployed at Red Fort area, from where around 700 dogs had been caught prior to Independence Day. The drive will be intensified in other zones after Aug 15, the official added. Mayor Raja Iqbal Singh said while the process of locating dog shelter sites has started, the vet department has been instructed to act immediately on complaints regarding diseased dogs and those known to bite. These dogs will be shifted to existing facilities at sterilisation centres. You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi | Gold Rates Today in Delhi | Silver Rates Today in Delhi MCD set to launch helpline for stray-related complaints A process to locate unutilised community halls and other buildings in each zone for dog shelters has started," the mayor said. A helpline number will also be launched in a day or two for complaints related to stray dogs. "Meanwhile, people can use the 311 app," Singh added. On Tuesday, a meeting was called on the matter and officials were asked to devise a detailed plan. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Durgapur Sepco Township Users Prefers Toothsi Aligners Toothsi by MakeO Book Now Undo by Taboola by Taboola The meeting, attended by MCD commissioner Ashwani Kumar, will continue on Wednesday. A sub-committee formed under the chairmanship of deputy standing committee chairman Sundar Singh is working separately to identify key areas that need immediate attention after involving dog lovers and residents, such as feeding points and the working conditions of animal birth control units. The members had on Monday given directions to catch at least 1,000 stray dogs from each zone in one month. "However, the emphasis will remain on catching aggressive dogs to begin with," said Yogesh Verma, a member of the committee. The New Delhi Municipal Council is also doing an internal assessment on the matter and will soon make a decision, officials said. Ravinder Sharma, former MCD veterinary director, said finding sites for shelter homes won't be difficult if the task is taken up dedicatedly. "Already, there is a 1,000 sq-metre land available in Tehkhand and a 500 sq-metre area in Masoodpur where such facilities can be established. Multistorey structures can be developed for dogs. In places such as Dwarka, there are community halls that can be utilised for keeping dogs. These shelters would be different from animal birth control (ABC) centres as 12 feet space is required at ABC centres to keep a dog after sterilisation and immunisation. But for keeping a dog permanently at shelters, a kennel of minimum 45 feet area is needed," he said. A day after the court's direction to immediately catch, vaccinate and relocate stray dogs permanently to shelters, several residents welfare associations swung into action. They approached the civic body for fresh vaccination and sterilisation campaigns in their areas besides holding joint meetings to identify feeding points. Sanjay Gupta, president of Model Town Residents Society, said feeding of stray dogs has been a point of contention in the locality for a long time. "Feeding them anywhere in parks, such as walking tracks and spots close to entrances, only increases the risk for people. As an RWA, we tried resolving the matter and identified feeding points. Now we have requested the area councillors and veterinary officials to hold a joint meeting with residents and dog lovers after Aug 15 to resolve the problem on priority," he said. A dog vaccination camp was organised on Aug 5, and the RWA is demanding an increase in the frequency of such drives. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
