BHP, Vale accused of 'cheating' UK law firm out of $1.7 billion in fees
LONDON (Reuters) -BHP and Vale are facing a London lawsuit from the law firm representing hundreds of thousands of people over Brazil's worst environmental disaster, alleging the companies sought to cheat the firm out of legal fees by procuring settlements.
BHP said it rejected the allegations "in their entirety" and would contest them. Vale declined to comment.
Pogust Goodhead, which represents the claimants in an ongoing case against BHP over the 2015 collapse of the Fundao dam in Mariana, southeastern Brazil, says it will seek 1.3 billion pounds ($1.7 billion) for unpaid fees.
The firm was representing more than 600,000 Brazilians in the case at London's High Court. A June presentation by BHP and Vale's Samarco joint venture – which owned and operated the dam – said around 130,000 people had settled.
In a legal letter sent on Pogust Goodhead's behalf, lawyers representing the firm allege BHP, Vale and Samarco pressured claimants to "settle their claims at far below their true value".
Pogust Goodhead also alleges that a 170 billion-reais ($30.3 billion) compensation agreement which Brazil signed with BHP, Vale and Samarco in October 2024 prevented claimants from discussing the deal with the firm or paying its legal fees.
The firm says it has also incurred an extra $1 billion in borrowing costs to finance the English case over the dam's collapse.
BHP DENIES ALLEGATIONS
"We reject Pogust Goodhead's claims and allegations in their entirety and dispute their factual and legal basis," a BHP spokesperson said in a statement.
"These allegations and threatened claims are entirely without merit and BHP rejects and will vigorously contest them."
The BHP spokesperson pointed to last year's compensation deal, saying: "We continue to believe Brazil is the most appropriate, effective, and efficient place for compensation for the Fundao dam failure from Samarco to be delivered."
Pogust Goodhead's threat of legal action - in a so-called "letter before action" that is required as part of the process - is the latest development in the litigation, after the High Court last month ruled BHP should face a full contempt of court hearing for funding parallel litigation in Brazil.
BHP, meanwhile, still awaits judgment following a trial of the underlying lawsuit over the dam collapse, in which Pogust Goodhead said it was seeking damages of up to 36 billion pounds.
When the dam burst in 2015, it unleashed a wave of toxic sludge that killed 19 people, left thousands homeless, flooded forests and polluted the length of the Doce River.
The trial began in October and finished in March. BHP denies liability and says the case duplicates legal proceedings and reparation and repair programs in Brazil.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
3 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Fake immigration lawyer cashed in, put clients at risk of deportation, feds say
A woman posing as an immigration attorney in Pennsylvania lied on clients' asylum forms, putting them at risk of deportation, federal officials said. Fatima DeMaria, the 65-year-old owner of Immigration Matters Legal Services in Oxford, was arrested and charged with eight counts of asylum fraud and eight counts of mail fraud, the U.S. Attorney's Office in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania said in a July 31 news release. McClatchy News reached out to the woman's attorney but did not immediately receive a response. DeMaria is accused of filling out asylum applications for her clients, form I-589, but falsely claiming why they were seeking asylum in the U.S., prosecutors said. She did so between 2021 and 2024, prosecutors said. The form is meant for those who are in the United States but who are not citizens, according to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. She stated applicants were seeking to stay in the country due to 'political opinion' and 'Torture Convention,' federal officials said. However, this was not the reason her clients were seeking permission to stay in the U.S.. DeMaria did not tell her clients she was filing 'frivolous' forms as a way to help them obtain work permits, according to the U.S. Attorney's Office, but had them sign the documents. If those applications were denied, her clients could face deportation proceedings and the 'baseless asylum application' could jeopardize those people if they ever needed immigration benefits in the future, prosecutors said. She charged thousands for the immigration tasks she was not licensed to do, charging between up to $9,000 per individual or up to $15,000 per couple, federal officials said. Prosecutors say they believe she made up to $1 million fraudulently. DeMaria often asked her clients to pay her in cash or in transactions that were deposited into her personal bank accounts, officials said. 'Hundreds of thousands of dollars' were eventually withdrawn at casinos, prosecutors said. If convicted, DeMaria faces up to 240 years in prison and a $4 million fine. The FBI in Philadelphia is looking to identify any victims of DeMaria/s through this form /vailable/in English and Spanish. Oxford is about a 55-mile drive southwest from Philadelphia.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Grupo Clarin S.A. To Host Webcast Presentation To Discuss Second Quarter 2025 Results
BUENOS AIRES, ARGENTINA / / August 1, 2025 / Grupo Clarín S.A. (BYMA:GCLA) will host a webcast presentation on Tuesday, August 12, 2025 at 11:00 am Eastern Time (12:00 pm Buenos Aires time) to discuss its Second Quarter 2025 Earnings Results. Presentations will be in English, based on the earnings release, which will be distributed on Monday, August 11, 2025, after markets close. To access the live stream and slide presentation, visit: The webcast presentation will also be available at About the Company Grupo Clarín is the largest media company in Argentina and a leading company in Digital and Printed Publications and broadcasting and programming markets. Its flagship newspaper -Diario Clarín- is one of the highest circulation newspapers and has the largest base of paid digital subscribers in Latin America. Grupo Clarín is the largest producer of media content in Argentina, including news, sports and entertainment and reaches substantially all segments of the Argentine population in terms of wealth, geography and age. Investor Relations Contacts In Buenos Aires:Grupo Clarín OlivieriTel: +54 11 4309 7104Email: investors@ In New York:Fig Corporate CommunicationsCamilla Ferreira | Marcella E. DragoneTel: +1 917 691 4047Email: fig@ SOURCE: Grupo Clarín S.A. View the original press release on ACCESS Newswire Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
NBC News
7 hours ago
- NBC News
1 person dead and multiple injured in fireworks explosion at Mohamed Ramadan concert in Egypt
One person is dead and multiple others are injured after a fireworks display malfunction at a Mohamed Ramadan concert Thursday night in a resort town on the north coast of Egypt. One of the fireworks canisters exploded the moment Ramadan came out on stage at the Porto Marina Theater, killing a member of the show's technical team responsible for operating the fireworks, according to Egypt's semi-official newspaper Al Ahram. The incident also injured at least six people, per the outlet's English counterpart. Ramadan, an Egyptian actor and musician, posted a video statement to his Instagram about the incident, extending his condolences to a victim he called "Hossam." Al Ahram identified the victim as Hossam Abdel Moneim, a 24-year-old graduate from Ain Shams University who worked in party planning and special effects for over a decade. "I extend my condolences to the family of Hossam, may God have mercy on him and grant him a place in his spacious paradise," Ramadan said in the video. "And grant patience to his loved ones, and his friends, and heal those who were injured." Ramadan said that he stopped the concert immediately after he saw what had happened. "I handled it like any human would, I went down to the audience and I helped get the injured to the ambulance," he said. "And I stopped the concert, and helped guide people so that their departure doesn't cause any crowd surge or additional accidents." Ramadan did not identify the victim beyond a first name, but alluded in his statement that the victim was working during the concert. Videos depicting the incident began circulating on social media shortly afterwards. One video shows Ramadan performing as an explosion go off near the stage. Seconds later, Ramadan can be heard saying "Stop, stop, stop!" before the music comes to a halt. Another video shows people in the audience carrying the body of a man who appears to be injured or deceased. Ramadan, who can be seen on the stage, is heard speaking into the mic, instructing them to bring the body on stage. The incident is being investigated by Egypt's Public Prosecution Office, according to Al Ahram. Ramadan has been gaining international recognition in recent years, releasing songs with French Montana, Future and Gims. His song, "Rayheen Neshar - Bum Bum" began going viral on TikTok in 2020. The artist posted to his Instagram that he will be performing again on Friday at another venue on Egypt's north coast.
