India won't take first step to normalise ties, onus on Pakistan: Shashi Tharoor
He was speaking at the launch of the book 'Whither India-Pakistan Relations Today?', an anthology edited by former Ambassador Surendra Kumar.
Delivered the keynote address before a galaxy of foreign policy eminences, including 101-year-old former Foreign Secretary MK Rasgotra, alongside former FS @KanwalSibal, Gen Deepak Kapoor, two former High Commissioners to Pakistan @tcaraghavan & SharatSabharwal, & Prof… pic.twitter.com/DPtIE9RMo4 — Shashi Tharoor (@ShashiTharoor) August 19, 2025
The Thiruvananthapuram MP said every Indian attempt at outreach — from Jawaharlal Nehru's pact with Liaqat Ali Khan in 1950, to Atal Bihari Vajpayee's bus journey to Lahore in 1999, and Narendra Modi's Lahore visit in 2015 — had been 'betrayed' by hostility from across the border.
'Given the record of Pakistani behaviour, the onus is on them. They're the ones who have to take the first steps to show some sincerity about dismantling terror infrastructure on their soil,' Mr. Tharoor said.
'Why can't they be serious about shutting down these terror camps? Everyone knows where they are. The United Nations committee has a list of 52 names of individuals, organisations and places in Pakistan. It's not that Pakistan doesn't know they exist,' he said.
He said, 'Shut them down, arrest some of these characters, show some serious intent.' India would be more than willing to reciprocate once such action is taken, but won't take the first step now, the Congress leader said.
Opinion | Pakistan's India war
Recalling the 2008 Mumbai terror attacks, Mr. Tharoor said India had provided 'overwhelming evidence' of Pakistani involvement, including live intercepts and dossiers, yet 'not one mastermind has been prosecuted'.
He noted that New Delhi showed 'extraordinary restraint' after attacks, but subsequent provocations left India with little choice, leading to surgical strikes in 2016 and 'Operation Sindoor'.
'In my book Pax Indica, which was published in 2012, I had warned that if there was ever another Mumbai-like attack of comparable impact, with clear evidence of Pakistani complicity, the restraint we had shown in 2008 might become impossible and all bets would be off,' he said.
'And indeed, that is exactly what happened. No democratic government, least of all in India with its long record of betrayals by Pakistan, could sit idle while its neighbour assaults its civilians and innocent holidaymakers with impunity,' he explained.
Opinion | The hazards of going global on India-Pakistan issues
Mr. Tharoor also stressed that 'peace and tranquillity on the borders is indispensable to our national interest' and cited the reconciliation between France and Germany after World War II, as well as the United States' eventual ties with Vietnam, as examples of adversaries turning into partners.
The discussion was also joined by former foreign secretary Kanwal Sibal, former Indian ambassador to Pakistan T.C.A. Raghavan, ex-Army chief general Deepak Kapoor and academician Amitabh Mattoo.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
17 minutes ago
- The Hindu
BJP accuses Congress government of unleashing ‘tax terrorism' to fund guarantees
The Opposition BJP on Wednesday accused the Congress government in the State of unleashing 'tax terrorism' in the last 27 months of its rule, which resulted in price rise of several essentials, and demanded that it stop raising additional taxes or quit. Leader of the Opposition R. Ashok, who initiated the debate in the Legislative Assembly on 'halted developments' in the State, said the government has increased taxes, user fees and hiked fares/prices, and mobilised ₹52,422 crore annually against the requirement of about ₹50,000 crore for funding five 'guarantees'. The tax hike was unprecedented in the State, he said. Additional taxes Mr. Ashok said that, for instance, by imposing additional taxes on fuel, the government earned additional revenue of ₹6,500 crore. He also cited bus fare hike (₹1,000 crore), vehicle registration fee hike (₹3,300 crore) and so on — together generating an additional ₹52,422 crore annually. The fee for a birth certificate doubled from ₹10 to ₹20, the stamp paper price from ₹10 to ₹100 and now the government is 'extorting' money in the name of e-khata and charging for car parking space in apartments and individual households, he alleged. He demanded to know why we should pay to computerise (e-khata) property documents which already exist and called it a 'scam'. He said the Congress government had imposed 'tax terrorism to burden the common people'. Hike in 'commission' The Congress party, which labelled the previous BJP regime as a '40% commission' government, has increased the 'commission rate' to 70% for issuing commencement certificates (CC) for buildings. More than ₹35,000 crore SC/ST funds had been diverted to funding guarantees, the BJP leader alleged. The Leader of the Opposition said the ruling Congress members, such as Raju Kage, B.R. Patil, Basavaraj Rayareddi, Home Minister G. Parameshwara, have themselves exposed Chief Minister Siddaramaiah's failures in funding the development works. State of roads 'Everywhere you look, there are potholes that have turned our roads into death traps. Continuous rains only expose government apathy,' said Mr. Ashok, criticising Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar's leadership. The bad roads reduced the speed of BMTC buses from 15 km per hour to 9 km per hour. More than ₹5,000 crore was spent on 874 km of arterial and sub-arterial roads around Bengaluru. Why were potholes seen on the roads, and where had the money gone?, asked Mr. Ashok.
The Hindu
17 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Bhavnagar school play depicting burqa-clad ‘terrorists' triggers controversy; probe ordered
The Gujarat Education Department has sought a report after a primary school in Bhavnagar staged an Independence Day play in which burqa-clad girls were shown as 'terrorists', sparking protests from local Muslim groups. The District Education Officer issued a notice to the Bhavnagar Municipal School Board, which runs the institution, asking for an explanation within seven days, officials said on Wednesday (August 20, 2025). The move came after members of the Muslim community, under the banner of Bandharan Bachao Samiti, demanded stern action against the teachers for depicting their community 'in a bad light'. A video of the August 15 performance, widely circulated on social media, shows girls dressed in white dancing to a song praising Kashmir's beauty before three students in burqas, carrying toy guns, storm the stage and 'shoot' them. A background audio referred to terrorists killing civilians during the Pahalgam attack. Munjal Badmaliya, Administrative Officer of the Bhavnagar Municipal School Board, said the all-girls primary school in Kumbharwada had presented the play based on Operation Sindoor as part of Independence Day celebrations. 'The District Education Officer received a representation alleging that the play hurt Muslim sentiments. We have been asked to submit a factual report within seven days,' he said. The Municipal School Board has appointed a coordinator to probe the incident. A preliminary inquiry had indicated that the teachers and the Principal had no intention of offending any community, Mr. Badmaliya added. 'Students playing the role of terrorists were told to cover their faces with black cloth, but they used burqas as those were easily available,' he said. The Administrative Officer maintained that the purpose of the play was to honour the armed forces for their role in Operation Sindoor, and not to target any religion. 'We are examining the issue from all angles and will submit a detailed report to the District Education Officer,' he said. (With inputs from PTI)
The Hindu
17 minutes ago
- The Hindu
KTR accuses Congress cadres of urea black marketing, demands White Paper on fertilizer supplies
Bharat Rashtra Samithi (BRS) working president K.T. Rama Rao alleged that fertilizer stocks were being diverted and sold in the black market by Congress leaders, forcing lakhs of farmers to queue up for hours across the State. He also demanded that the State government release a White Paper on the fertilizer situation, providing details on the quota allocated and supplied to the State, stock position in warehouses, actual distribution to farmers and quantities diverted or missing. Speaking to the media from his residence in Nandinagar on Wednesday, he said, 'For the first time in Telangana's history, women farmers are spending nights outside depots, farmers are leaving shoes and Aadhaar cards in queues to save their place, and in some cases, even facing police cases for demanding fertilizers,' he said. The former Minister also urged the Centre to order a comprehensive investigation and take action against those responsible for the shortage of fertilizer in the State. On the upcoming Vice-Presidential election, Mr. Rama Rao declared that the BRS will extend support only to the party that ensures the supply of 2 lakh metric tonnes of urea before September 9. 'No alliance has approached us yet. But our decision will be taken solely in the interest of Telangana farmers. If the Congress Chief Minister nominates a candidate, we will oppose without hesitation,' he said. Mr. Rama Rao also accused the Congress of hypocrisy on social justice, pointing out that despite claiming affection for BCs, the party had not nominated a BC leader for the Vice-Presidential post. 'If they were serious, they could have fielded intellectuals like Kancha Ilaiah or any eminent BC leader,' he remarked. The BRS working president slammed both Congress and BJP for failing Telangana. He criticised Rahul Gandhi for remaining silent on the fertilizer crisis despite his 'Rythu Declaration' promises. 'Rahul has not uttered a single word in Parliament while Telangana farmers are in distress. This exposes his double standards,' Mr. Rama Rao said.
