Kohurau Contracting fined $70k for safety breach after forestry worker loses fingers
The victim was guiding the rope back on to the drum using a hammer while seated beneath the tower.
Another worker was operating a grapple loader to keep the cable elevated.
During the operation, the stabiliser ram supporting the tower fractured, and a broken section – known as the spear – fell on to the victim, seriously injuring him.
As a result, the victim was hospitalised for six weeks and had to have four fingers amputated.
Kohurau was charged by WorkSafe for failing to ensure the health and safety of its workers and pleaded not guilty.
A five-day judge-alone trial was held in the Dargaville District Court in November 2024, where several witnesses gave evidence including the victim and industry experts.
WorkSafe's mechanical engineer, John Mains, stated that winching without guy ropes was unacceptable and the accident would not have occurred had the tower been properly secured.
Kohurau's expert argued that guy ropes were unnecessary for the task and the force involved was minimal – claims Judge Peter Davey found inconsistent.
The court also heard that Kohurau lacked a specific safe system for clearing birds' nests and relied heavily on the experience of its crew.
The site where the accident occured, south of Whangārei. Photo / Worksafe
Judge Davey concluded Kohurau breached its duties under the Health and Safety Act and found the company guilty of exposing workers to serious risk.
This week at the Whangārei District Court the company was sentenced in the presence of its owner, Hamish John Owen.
Kohurau's lawyer Daniel Robinson argued the company was insolvent and had suffered a loss of $1.3 million because of the accident.
'Where do you get that from?' Judge Davey questioned before noting the company still had assets of around $400,000 and $250,000 in its bank account.
Judge Davey did not accept the losses were from the accident and stated the company had been downsizing prior to the accident.
Judge Davey repeatedly expressed his concern around whether reparation would be paid, to which Robinson assured him any amount ordered would be met.
'My instructions sir, is we will be able to be pay but that is limited to the reparation order,' Robinson responded.
Robinson also submitted the absence of any industry guidelines for winding cables was a mitigating factor that should be applied to the companies' overall sentence.
'He was good at his job'
Judge Davey noted the significant impact the accident had on the victim.
'He hasn't been able to return to work, he enjoyed the work, he had no plans of retiring,' Judge Davey said.
'He clearly took great pride in his work, took great satisfaction in his work and he was good at his job.
'Despite what's happened to him, he nevertheless tries to stay positive.'
Judge Davey said the price of an emotional harm reparation order was an intuitive exercise and there was no way to put a figure on the suffering caused.
'No amount of money can compensate the emotional harm that he has suffered.'
Judge Davey said Kohurau should have had a process in place to clear birds' nests and there was 'a real risk he could have been killed'.
Kohurau, which has already paid the victim $10,000, was ordered to pay him a further $50,000.
The company was also fined $70,000 and ordered to pay legal costs of $30,000.
The court also issued a project order with two key commitments to be completed within 12 months.
Kohurau must work in collaboration with the Forestry Industry Safety Council (FISC) and Forestry Industry Contractors Association (FICA) to develop guidance on winding in non-working ropes.
It must also publish an article in NZ Forestry magazine highlighting the case to raise awareness and promote safer practices across the industry.
'This project order is a way for Kohurau to take the lead on delivering initiatives that create genuine sector-wide improvements in forestry. We look forward to seeing the benefits that this industry-led guidance produces,' WorkSafe's spokesperson Mark Horgan said.
Shannon Pitman is a Whangārei-based reporter for Open Justice covering courts in the Te Tai Tokerau region. She is of Ngāpuhi/ Ngāti Pūkenga descent and has worked in digital media for the past five years. She joined NZME in 2023.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
11 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Workers for Coogan Contracting not briefed on power line safety before Sean Clear's electrocution death
Clear's family say the tragedy could have been avoided if simple steps had been taken – for instance, having a safety spotter watching the excavator's movements. Coroner Mark Wilton said he agreed with WorkSafe's assessment that the overhead power lines should have been clearly identified as a risk. 'I also accept that the failure to identify and mitigate that risk resulted in Mr Clear's death.' The coroner said the dangers associated with operating equipment near overhead lines were not explained to Coogan's employees, either during their induction or at subsequent safety briefings. This had been confirmed by another worker, who had started at the same time as Clear. Coroner Mark Wilton said the overhead power lines' risks should have been clearly identified by Coogan Contracting. 'At the site of the incident, the overhead lines were not identified as a risk,' Coroner Wilton said. 'As a result, simple steps to mitigate that risk were not done, such as shortening the chain [being used to lift the mower unit] and using another employee as a safety observer.' The NP and MA Coogan Partnership was earlier prosecuted by WorkSafe, which said Clear died because the business failed to take proper care to ensure his safety. The partnership, but not the individuals who comprised it, was convicted and fined $25,000. It was also ordered to pay $100,000 in emotional harm payments to Clear's family, and $7500 in prosecution costs. Irishman in NZ for seasonal work Coroner Wilton said Clear came to New Zealand in October 2022 to do seasonal work, obtained employment with Coogan's and lived in Taumarunui with friends. On February 17, 2023, he was harvesting silage on Taurewa Station when the tractor and mower unit he was driving became stuck in mud. This was just after Cyclone Gabrielle, and Taurewa Station's paddocks were unusually wet. An excavator was brought in to help retrieve the equipment, and Clear was touching the mower unit when the excavator boom to which it was chained made contact with the power lines, which were just over 7m above the ground. Clear died at the scene despite attempts to revive him. Justice Jonathan Krebs said at the time of the WorkSafe prosecution that Clear was a 'fine young man with a promising future ahead of him'. 'He was loved by all and his premature death has left a deep sense of loss in all who knew him,' Justice Krebs said. Clear's family provided statements to the High Court in which they expressed disbelief at what had happened, and pain about simple steps not being taken that could have averted the accident. 'For instance, having a third person observe from a distance to make sure that nothing untoward occurred would have been a simple step, and one which almost certainly would have alerted the excavator operator to the risk that the machine's arm was moving close to the powerlines,' Justice Krebs said. Coroner Wilton recommended that Coogan's update its written hazard policy to take account of electrical safety regulations. He said the partnership should develop an induction policy to ensure all new workers were aware of all the operating risks, and were trained in mitigation practices. He said existing workers should receive this too. The coroner said a risk assessment and mitigation planning should be undertaken before starting at each site, even if work had been done there before. A principal of the partnership, Pat Coogan, told NZME the recommendations had already been implemented. He declined to make further comment. Coogan's had no prior health and safety convictions. After Clear's death, the partnership paid nearly $30,000 for his co-workers to travel to Ireland for his memorial service. The coroner said that a warning notice was displayed in the excavator cab showing a picture of a boom making contact with overhead lines, and a person being shocked. Although worn, it was able to be read by the operator. Ric Stevens spent many years working for the former New Zealand Press Association news agency, including as a political reporter at Parliament, before holding senior positions at various daily newspapers. He joined NZME's Open Justice team in 2022 and is based in Hawke's Bay.
RNZ News
13 hours ago
- RNZ News
Coroner finds NP & MA Coogan Partnership breached health and safety obligations prior to fatal accident
Sean Clear as electrocuted in February 2023 when an excavator came into contact with powerlines carrying 30,000 volts. File picture. Photo: RNZ / Rebekah Parsons-King The coroner says the employers of an Irish seasonal worker - killed when a digger touched with overhead powerlines - failed to brief workers on safety procedures ahead of the death. Sean Clear was electrocuted in February 2023 on Taurewa Station in the central North Island when an excavator being used to free a tractor and mower unit stuck in muddy conditions and came into contact with powerlines carrying 30,000 volts. In findings released on Thursday, coroner Mark Wilton said a WorkSafe investigation into the death had found Clear's employer, NP & MA Coogan Partnership had breached Health and Safety obligations in a number of ways in the lead-up to the accident. He said the company had failed to identify and communicate to staff the risk posed by powerlines at the worksite and had failed to take "reasonably practical steps" to ensure the safety of its workers. Clear had been harvesting silage on the station when the tractor and mower unit he was driving became stuck in mud. He was electrocuted when an excavator - being used to assist - contacted overhead power lines just over seven metres above the ground while chained to the mower unit that Clear was touching. The coroner said there was an absence of a safety observer or "spotter" to alert the driver of the digger before its boom came within minimum approach distance from the lines, as well as a failure to limit the length of the chain used to lift the mower. He also said the company had not contacted the power company for advice or requested a technician on site to supervise work near the lines. Last year Coogan's pled guilty to charges of failing to comply with its duties to keep workers safe and exposing them to the risk of serious injury or death. Coogan's was ordered to pay a fine of $25,000, as well as $100,000 in emotional harm reparation to Sean Clear's family. On Thursday, Coroner Wilton said he agreed with comments made by Clear's family at the company's sentencing last year. "Mr Clear's family and friends spoke at sentencing about their disbelief about what occurred. They were particularly pained that if simple steps had been taken at the time the mower was being moved, the tragedy could have been averted," Wilton said. The coroner recommended Coogan's update its hazard policy to include guidelines from Electric and Safety Regulations 2010, the New Zealand Electrical Code of Practice for Electrical Safe Distances and the WorkSafe guidelines regarding electrical safety in agriculture. Wilton said Coogan's needed to ensure existing workers were updated and trained in operating risks and mitigation procedures as well as develop an induction policy to educate and train new workers on the risk management practises in the policy. He said risk assessment and mitigation planning should be put in place ahead of work going ahead at each of the company's work sites "regardless of whether work has been carried out there in previous seasons". The coroner noted that WorkSafe had also issued a media release and a safety alert "urging businesses to prioritise safety near overhead electric lines" in response to Clear's death and a coroner's report on another death on a farm from powerline electrocution - issued earlier this year. Coogan Contracting declined to comment on the findings. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
29-07-2025
- RNZ News
Contractor fined $70k for safety breach after forestry worker loses fingers
By Shannon Pitman, Open Justice reporter of The hauler involved in the incident which left a forestry worker seriously injured. Photo / Worksafe Photo: Supplied / Worksafe A seasoned forestry worker lost four fingers in a workplace accident, which ended a 45-year career that was marked by pride, satisfaction and no intention to retire. Now, Kohurau Contracting has been ordered to pay $150,000 and must publish an educational article about the dangers of untangling cable snarls in forestry operations. In August 2021, the worker - who has name suppression - was at a forestry site near Waipu, south of Whangārei, helping clear a cable that had not been wound correctly on to the drum. The experienced crew were packing up to relocate to another location but the tail line had over-spooled on to the drum, creating a "bird's nest" similar to which can occur on a fishing reel. At least 1200m of cable had to be pulled out in order to clear the bird's nest. The victim was guiding the rope back on to the drum using a hammer while seated beneath the tower. Another worker was operating a grapple loader to keep the cable elevated. During the operation, the stabiliser ram supporting the tower fractured, and a broken section - known as the spear - fell on to the victim, seriously injuring him. As a result, the victim was hospitalised for six weeks and had to have four fingers amputated. Kohurau was charged by WorkSafe for failing to ensure the health and safety of its workers and pleaded not guilty. A five-day judge-alone trial was held in the Dargaville District Court in November 2024, where several witnesses gave evidence including the victim and industry experts. WorkSafe's mechanical engineer, John Mains, stated that winching without guy ropes was unacceptable and the accident would not have occurred had the tower been properly secured. Kohurau's expert argued that guy ropes were unnecessary for the task and the force involved was minimal - claims Judge Peter Davey found inconsistent. The court also heard that Kohurau lacked a specific safe system for clearing birds' nests and relied heavily on the experience of its crew. Judge Davey concluded Kohurau breached its duties under the Health and Safety Act and found the company guilty of exposing workers to serious risk. This week at the Whangārei District Court the company was sentenced in the presence of its owner, Hamish John Owen. Kohurau's lawyer Daniel Robinson argued the company was insolvent and had suffered a loss of $1.3 million because of the accident. "Where do you get that from?" Judge Davey questioned before noting the company still had assets of around $400,000 and $250,000 in its bank account. Judge Davey did not accept the losses were from the accident and stated the company had been downsizing prior to the accident. Judge Davey repeatedly expressed his concern around whether reparation would be paid, to which Robinson assured him any amount ordered would be met. "My instructions sir, is we will be able to be pay but that is limited to the reparation order," Robinson responded. Robinson also submitted the absence of any industry guidelines for winding cables was a mitigating factor that should be applied to the companies' overall sentence. Judge Davey noted the significant impact the accident had on the victim. "He hasn't been able to return to work, he enjoyed the work, he had no plans of retiring," Judge Davey said. "He clearly took great pride in his work, took great satisfaction in his work and he was good at his job. "Despite what's happened to him, he nevertheless tries to stay positive." Judge Davey said the price of an emotional harm reparation order was an intuitive exercise and there was no way to put a figure on the suffering caused. "No amount of money can compensate the emotional harm that he has suffered." Judge Davey said Kohurau should have had a process in place to clear birds' nests and there was "a real risk he could have been killed". Kohurau, which has already paid the victim $10,000, was ordered to pay him a further $50,000. The company was also fined $70,000 and ordered to pay legal costs of $30,000. The court also issued a project order with two key commitments to be completed within 12 months. Kohurau must work in collaboration with the Forestry Industry Safety Council (FISC) and Forestry Industry Contractors Association (FICA) to develop guidance on winding in non-working ropes. It must also publish an article in NZ Forestry magazine highlighting the case to raise awareness and promote safer practices across the industry. "This project order is a way for Kohurau to take the lead on delivering initiatives that create genuine sector-wide improvements in forestry. We look forward to seeing the benefits that this industry-led guidance produces," WorkSafe spokesperson Mark Horgan said. * This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald .
