Heritage association objects to toilet block near Oval Maidan
In a letter dated May 16, the association criticized the proposed design as "a pastiche/ tasteless imitation," arguing that it disrespects the historical and architectural significance of the World Heritage precinct.
"We have earlier iterated that the toilet stands near the Grade I sites of the Oval Maidan (within 100m), the University of Mumbai, and the High Court; which are at the heart of the UNESCO World Heritage Site 'Victorian Gothic and Art Deco Ensembles of Mumbai'.
Additionally, this location is also a part of the Fort Heritage Precinct. As per the Heritage Control Regulations presented in Section 52 of the Development Control and Promotion Regulations (DCPR), any new construction at such an important site requires 'sensitive' development in terms of mass, scale, and setting and requires conservation of its heritage and cultural significance.
Any new addition should not alter the character of the precinct.
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Trade Bitcoin & Ethereum – No Wallet Needed!
IC Markets
Start Now
Undo
The new interventions could be contemporary but subtle or inspired by the original character, but should not be a pastiche/tasteless imitation of it," states the letter.
A public toilet that was earlier on the same location had been demolished.
The association stated that through documents obtained through a govt official in March 2025, they have observed that there are no updated designs nor has approval been sought from the Mumbai Heritage Conservation Committee (MHCC).
"The designs shared continue to expand the footprint and have a flat roof with a character that is insensitive to the heritage character of the World Heritage Site. Under the guise of providing a public amenity toilet, the structure also includes Rest Rooms, Store Areas, Waiting Area, Locker Rooms/ Luggage Rooms, Shower Rooms, Changing Areas, Office Room and Record Room," it said.
When contacted, civic officials clarified that the Mumbai Heritage Conservation Committee (MHCC) had granted approval on June 13, 2024, for the construction of a toilet block in front of the high court.
"During a review meeting on December 18, 2024, the Municipal Commissioner directed that the existing Solid Waste Management (SWM) labour chowky, adjacent to the proposed toilet block, also be integrated into this structure. A unified building was preferred," said a civic official.
Revised plans were accordingly submitted to the MHCC, featuring a ground-plus-one composite building that includes the toilet block and SWM chowky.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Assam scales up solid waste mgmt infra with 13 new plants by 2025
1 2 Guwahati: In a decisive move to bridge the waste processing gap, the state govt is ramping up infrastructure and implementing decentralized solutions across Urban Local Bodies (ULBs). Officials have announced the completion of 13 new Solid Waste Management (SWM) plants by Dec 2025. Currently, 10 SWM plants are operational across various districts. With the commissioning of the new plants, all 96 ULBs under the Swachh Bharat Mission are expected to be fully operational by early 2027. This expansion is set to address the state's waste disposal shortfall and promote scientific and sustainable practices. "All 96 ULBs in Assam are strategically working toward strengthening waste systems under Swachh Bharat Mission (Urban) 2.0. Solid waste management continues to be a critical challenge for the state's rapidly growing urban areas. However, recent efforts reflect a clear shift toward structured and scalable solutions. Across these ULBs, many have already initiated improvements in waste collection, segregation, and disposal mechanisms," said an official of Swachh Bharat Mission (Urban) - Assam. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like TV providers are furious: this gadget gives you access to all channels Techno Mag Learn More Undo The development of solid waste management plants — both operational and upcoming— will be instrumental in reducing landfill pressure, promoting recycling, and ensuring the scientific processing of municipal waste, as numerous ULBs in the state have seen solid wastes generated by households and commercial establishments piling up near residential or commercial areas. Among the existing SWM plants, the ones in North Lakhimpur Municipal Board and in Dibrugarh Municipal Corporation have the highest capacity with 125 TPD and 100 TPD, respectively. But the upcoming SWM facilities will be a big boost in solid waste treatment with enhanced capacities, with Tinsukia MB having a 130 TPD capacity, whereas Jorhat MB and Kharupetia MB have capacities of 100 TPD each. While the total capacity of the 10 already operational plants is 458 TPD, the overall capacity of the upcoming 13 plants expected to be made operational later this year will be 650 TPD. At present, as a temporary relief for ULBs where the plants are yet to be completed, the surplus capacity of operational SWM plants is being strategically leveraged to function as cluster facilities for treating waste from the neighbouring ULBs, which lacks SWM plants. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Deccan Herald
2 days ago
- Deccan Herald
BSWML delists 90% vendors after scrutiny, apartments left with little leverage
As per the Solid Waste Management (SWM) Rules, residential buildings with more than 100 dwelling units and commercial complexes with an area exceeding 5,000 square metres are considered bulk waste generators (BWGs).
Time of India
5 days ago
- Time of India
HC rejects plea to shift Hadapsar garbage plant
Pune: The Bombay high court on Tuesday rejected a petition seeking relocation of the garbage processing unit from the Hadapsar industrial estate to an alternate site and directed Pune Municipal Corporation and Pune Cantonment Board to ensure scientific processing of solid waste. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The court also directed the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board to act against any violation of Solid Waste Management (SWM) Rules by the civic bodies or their contractors at the site. The bench of Chief Justice Alok Aradhe and Justice Sandeep V Marne said the authorities must ensure that mixed solid waste was not dumped on the 28-acre site. Instead, municipal solid waste brought there should be processed and disposed of through methods like composting, recycling, and reusing dry waste, with non-biodegradable waste sent to suitable landfills, the bench said. The bench also ordered measures to control and suppress foul odours, toxic gases, dust and other pollutants from the waste processing facility, directing the use of modern techniques to prevent adverse health impacts on nearby residents. "Controlling odorous gas and dust from waste processing facilities is crucial for both environment and health," the bench said. The judgment puts to rest a decade-old demand by the local residents to relocate the waste processing unit. It gives hope to PMC to push its plan for decentralised garbage processing at different spots, to reduce cost of garbage transport to the Uruli Devachi processing facility. PCB, which generates 200 metric tonnes of garbage daily, has been using the Hadapsar facility for almost a century now, while PMC, which generates 800 metric tonnes of waste daily, started using the facility in 2000 as a decentralised facility for processing a part of its daily garbage. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Hadapsar Industrial Association, St Patrick's Town Cooperative Housing Society and Sopan Baug residents had filed PILs, citing issues like foul odour and health risks posed by the garbage plant to nearby residents. They sought relocation of the plant. The petition named PMC, PCB, MPCB, Pune collector and state govt as respondents. The bench, however, observed in its ruling, "We are unable to grant prayer of the petitioners for shifting the waste processing unit from the current site. The operation of the waste processing facility is in consonance with the SWM Rules and as per the order passed by the principal secretary of the Urban Development Department (UDD) of Sept 11, 2008. This court in fact does not appreciate repeated attempts being made for closure or shifting of the waste processing facility. " Instead of suggesting positive measures for better processing of solid municipal waste in a scientific manner without causing health hazards to nearby residents, the petitions were aimed at shifting the waste processing facility in someone else's backyard, the court said. The HC said PMC and PCB were duty-bound to ensure that processing waste has the least impact on residents and industrial units in the locality. The court noted, "PMC has implemented some measures like high jet spraying of the area every three hours to reduce dust and odour. It has also proposed certain measures like covering the compost plant to suppress odour. It has issued tenders for carrying out the erection work of fogging and misting system for controlling odour. PMC is proposing to install automatic chemical sprinklers at the composting plant. It has been planned to increase the height of the compound wall from 12ft to 16ft. These measures need to be implemented both by PMC and PCB." The HC directed PCB and PMC to make representation to state govt if they required additional land for disposal for operation of waste processing facilities.
