Letters: At The Marae – How many te reo Māori words are too many?
In 2015, then Prime Minister Sir John Key yelled across the House that the Labour opposition leader Andrew Little needed to 'get some guts' to support sending troops to Iraq.
Key incurred no Speaker's sanction. Why, then, in 2025 does Chlöe Swarbrick get dismissed from Parliament by Speaker Gerry Brownlee for a week for querying the spine of Government MPs for delaying their decision on whether to align with the overwhelming number of countries supporting a separate Palestinian state?
David Sanders, Torbay.
Leave it to the US and Israel
Chlöe Swarbrick was ejected from Parliament for the rest of the week.
We used to be such a humble country.
Surely if she took a reflective assessment, she would realise that she's a small person in a small country, far removed from the decisions regarding Gaza.
A more humble person would accept that Israel is backed by the greatest country on earth, with some of the greatest minds from the greatest universities.
The decisions as to the actions to deal with the 'Gaza problem' must be based upon sound analysis of weighty input and data from some of the top minds in both America and Israel.
Swarbrick should humbly accept that they are closer to the issues and must know best.
Simon Damerell, Ponsonby.
NZ's lack of integrity
I am bewildered by the lack of integrity and concern shown by our New Zealand Government.
Why do they need so many weeks to make a simple humanitarian decision and to recognise the state of Palestine?
In the past, I felt so proud of New Zealand, as we have led the world in so many similar times.
Please don't make me so embarrassed by this decision you keep sidestepping.
Mary Amoore, Pukekohe.
Do they want my vote?
Once upon a time, the National Party was the conservative one looking after big business and the rich. Labour was the socialist party supposedly concerned about the lower-income workers and the poor. Do they still?
It's no wonder the ordinary citizen has lost faith in these parties when everyday services that affect our ordinary lives are closing down or being minimalised.
For those who are not internet-connected, where does one buy a stamp? Post offices are being closed down, and now stationery and bookshops that sold stamps are also closing down.
In our area on the North Shore, the ASB Bank has closed down several offices and withdrawn ATMs, several Post Shops have shut, and very few places are selling stamps.
These are the little things that affect many ordinary people. We used to do so much government-related business at a Post Office. Now, so many government departments hide from taxpayers behind unhelpful automatic phone replies, or refer you to a website that only a teenager could get around.
The question now comes: why should I bother voting this year? The representatives on local boards and city council don't appear to be doing anything about these everyday inconveniences.
MPS have too many other important things to do, like stuffing up the country, to worry about us little people and our way of life, so I probably won't bother voting next year either.
If they can't be concerned about how I live, an ordinary everyday taxpayer, why should I worry about whether they get voted in, survive or whatever?
David Speary, Northcote.
Emissions add up
There are those who believe our country's carbon emissions are minuscule and will have no measurable effect on the changing climate.
Any emissions, minuscule or not, add to the global climate crisis. This is real and can't be ignored or denied because it's inconvenient for the likes of Shane Jones and his 'drill, baby, drill' approach to our future energy resources.
If more small countries follow the science, the greater the impact will be.
'Minuscule' is still an emission. It all adds up, either way. Only one way is the best way.
Jeremy Coleman, Hillpark.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Planned return of live cattle export gets held up
Photo: RNZ Legislation being drafted to bring back the controversial trade of live animal exports by sea is getting stuck in the cogs of Cabinet. The Labour government banned the trade two years ago, after the Gulf Livestock 1 vessel en route to China capsized in 2020 during a typhoon, resulting in the deaths of two New Zealand crew members and more than 5800 cattle . National and Act campaigned during the last election to bring back the trade, and it was a condition of the coalition agreement . The Parliamentary Counsel Office (PCO) was drafting the Animal Welfare Act amendment to bring back the trade - worth $374 million in 2022 - despite opposition from animal welfare groups, veterinarians and tens of thousands of petitioners. Associate Agriculture Minister Andrew Hoggard said the reinstatement was focused on the cattle trade, and it was working to lift industry standards. "What will come forward is for cattle only because that is where the market is for." Cabinet would approve the draft amendment before it was introduced to the House, while the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) developed updated regulations. Hoggard said it was working through the Cabinet approval process. "Hopefully soon. But there's a process I've got to go through and get Cabinet approval. So yeah, I'm working on that." In late April, aired in early May, Hoggard told RNZ he expected the legislation to go to Cabinet "soon" in the next month or so. But Hoggard said the PCO was facing a high workload of drafting legislation, which contributed to the current timeline . "There's quite a bit of challenge at the moment with the drafting of legislation. The lawyers are quite busy doing all sorts of things. So that's sort of added time to basically everyone's bills and pieces of work they're doing, just getting stuff done on time. "But I'm at the final stages now. I am hopeful that I'll be able to make some announcements shortly on this." Associate Agriculture Minister Mark Patterson of New Zealand First said it was of high public interest and it was important they got it right . However, Labour animal welfare spokesperson Rachel Boyack said the government should stop wasting time and money and leave the ban in place. "I understand things have gone to Cabinet but have got stuck at Cabinet, that there is probably some disagreement amongst coalition parties about whether this can be reinstated or not," Boyack said. "I think things are getting a bit sticky for the government." She said the public did not want the trade reinstated due in part to reputational harm it might cause globally . "They have failed to listen to animal welfare experts and vets who have been very clear for a number of years, that there is actually no way to reinstate this with improved animal welfare. It just cannot be done. "So the fact that we've got delayed legislation, I think shows that they have run into trouble in terms of actually delivering on what they promised." Photo: Supplied / Summer Jayne / Taranaki Animal Save Boyack said gold standard animal welfare for livestock on ships for months at a time was "impossible". Green Party agriculture spokesperson Steve Abel agreed, saying shipping cattle for weeks in poor conditions was incompatible with animal welfare . But Hoggard said they had consulted with vets and animal welfare exports to ensure the highest animal welfare standards. He said he was confident they could ensure animal welfare, while boosting jobs and economic growth from the industry. It came as Australia was planning to phase out live exports of sheep by sea to end the trade by May 2028. MPI and the PCO declined to comment. Meanwhile, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay (National) had nothing to add to Hoggard's comments. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Mass rally in Tel Aviv calls for end to Gaza war, hostage deal
Demonstrators block a Tel Aviv road during an anti-government protest demanding a deal to release Israelis detained by Hamas in the Gaza Strip. Photo: AFP / Gil Cohen-Magen Tens of thousands of demonstrators gathered in Tel Aviv to call for an end to the war in Gaza and the release of hostages , one of the largest demonstrations in Israel since the start of the fighting in October 2023. The rally on Sunday evening (local time) was the culmination of a day of nationwide protests and a general strike to pressure the government to halt the military campaign. "Bring them all home! Stop the war!" shouted the vast crowd which had converged on the so-called "Hostage Square" in Tel Aviv plaza - a focal point for protesters throughout the war. The Hostage and Missing Families Forum, the initiator of the day of protest, estimated that about 500,000 people joined the evening demonstration in Tel Aviv - a figure not confirmed by the police. "We demand a comprehensive and achievable agreement and an end to the war. We demand what is rightfully ours - our children," said Einav Zangauker, mother of hostage Matan and a leading figure of the protest movement. "The Israeli government has transformed a just war into a pointless war," she told the crowd. National media published a video message by Matan Zangauker on Sunday, in which the hostage, weak and emaciated, addressed his family and told them he missed them. The video was filmed by Hamas and found in Gaza by the army, the family said. "This is probably the last minute we have to save the hostages," demonstrator Ofir Penso, 50, told AFP. A member of the Israeli security forces scuffles with a protester holding a cutout of a hostage, during an anti-government protest in Tel Aviv on 17 August 2025 demanding a deal to release Israelis detained in the Gaza Strip by Hamas militants. Photo: AFP / Gil Cohen-Magen The protests come more than a week after Israel's security cabinet approved plans to capture Gaza City , 22 months into a war that has created a dire humanitarian crisis in the Palestinian territory. The Hostages and Missing Families Forum campaign group vowed Sunday that protesters would "shut down the country" with the goal of bringing back the hostages and ending the war. Throughout the country, demonstrators blocked traffic arteries, set tyres on fire and clashed with the police. More than 30 protesters were arrested, law enforcement said. In many places, though, AFP journalists saw businesses carrying on unimpeded. In Jerusalem's main shopping district, it was business as usual. A shop assistant in the city centre said the owner supported the campaign for the hostages' return but chose not to participate in the strike. "Everyone is helping the way they can," she said, declining to give her name. Netanyahu slammed the protesters, saying their actions "not only harden Hamas's position and draw out the release of our hostages, but also ensure that the horrors of October 7 will reoccur". Egypt said in recent days mediators were leading a renewed push to secure a 60-day truce deal that includes hostages being released, after the last round of talks in Qatar ended without a breakthrough. Some Israeli government members who oppose any deal with Hamas slammed Sunday's demonstrations. Israel's far-right Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich decried "a perverse and harmful campaign that plays into the hands of Hamas" and calls for "surrender". However, Benny Gantz, an opposition leader, condemned the government for "attacking the families of the hostages" while "bearing responsibility for the captivity of their children by Hamas for nearly two years". Demonstrators raise flags during the protest in Tel Aviv, 17 August 2025. Photo: AFP / Gil Cohen-Magen The Israeli plan to expand the war into Gaza City and nearby refugee camps has sparked an international outcry as well as domestic opposition. On Sunday, Israeli military chief of staff Lieutenant General Eya Zamir said the army was moving ahead with a plan "focusing on Gaza City". Hamas warned it would result in "a new wave of extermination and mass displacement". Army Radio said residents would be evacuated before troops encircled and seized Gaza City in the coming weeks, with tens of thousands of reservists called up. UN-backed experts have warned of widespread famine unfolding in the territory, where Israel has heavily limited the amount of humanitarian aid it allows in. Gaza's civil defence agency said Israeli fire on Sunday killed over sixty Palestinians, including at least 37 waiting to collect food aid near two sites. The conflict began with Palestinian militant group Hamas's 7 October, 2023 attack on Israel, during which 251 people were taken hostage. Forty-nine captives remain in Gaza, including 27 the Israeli military says are dead. Hamas's assault resulted in the deaths of 1219 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official figures. Israel's offensive has killed more than 61,944 Palestinians, most of them civilians, according to figures from the health ministry in Hamas-run Gaza which the United Nations considers reliable. - AFP
Otago Daily Times
2 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
'Focused 100%' on economy, not passport: Luxon
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon denies the government has lost its focus, as calls intensify for the government to take action to help pull Auckland out of its economic slump. Earlier this month Auckland Business Chamber boss Simon Bridges called on the government to do more to stimulate the economy in the supercity. The latest Stats NZ data showed Auckland's 6.1% unemployment rate for the June 2025 quarter was the worst of all regions, ahead of the national rate of 5.2%. An article in the the Sunday Star-Times at the weekend said "many business leaders and political insiders, including those from traditional centre-right bases of support for National, are beginning to doubt whether" Luxon's coalition has an economic plan. Heart of the City boss Viv Beck said "Rome is burning for some of our small businesses", and Newmarket Business Association head Mark Knoff-Thomas said it was "ludicrous" the government was spending its time reordering words on passport covers instead of focusing on the economy. Mayor Wayne Brown wants a bed night levy, which the government is not keen on. "They'll cave in. They want to be elected…. They'll cave in on this, mate. This is a third of New Zealand. This is the city that decides who's the government." Luxon said the government was "not focused on passport changes" but would not be implementing a bed tax. "We're actually focused 100% on actually growing this economy … We inherited the big recession. We've had a massive post-Covid hangover," he said. We've had a lot of international challenges with respect to tariffs, and what that's done for sentiment and confidence, but I just say to you, we're also seeing a recovery in New Zealand." Luxon said South Island primary industries were "growing strongly" but "we know we've got work to do in our cities". He pointed to the government's fast-track scheme for big projects, capital investment write-offs for small businesses and making it easier to get things built. "It's really tough in Auckland and also in Wellington, you know? If you're in Christchurch, it's different, as I said before, but, you know, there's no doubt about it," Luxon said "We're open to continuing to look at what more we can do. We're pretty dynamic and agile. We keep adjusting and doing things to adjust to the circumstances that we're in." One recent poll saw Labour surge ahead of National, and Luxon neck-and-neck with Labour's Chris Hipkins as preferred prime minister. Another had National and Labour in a statistical, ditto for Luxon and Hipkins, with just 1 percentage point separating the parties and leaders. When Bridges led the National Party, it regularly polled in the 40s. He was rolled as leader in 2020 after a collapse in the party's support as Covid-19 spread the world. Luxon said he would "absolutely" be leading National into the 2026 election. "For me it's actually staying focused on what New Zealanders care about and that is actually us fixing this economy. "I appreciate it's been difficult, you know, we've had a very difficult, you know, a poor inheritance, but, you know, our job is to fix it for New Zealanders and that's what we're going to do every day."
