What is a hedge? Neighbourly dispute occupies German high court
A dispute between two German neighbours over the height of a bamboo hedge occupied the German Federal Court of Justice (BGH) on Friday.
Two neighbouring property owners in the western German state of Hesse have been locked in a dispute about the hedge.
First planted in 2018, the bamboo has since reached a height of 6 metres.
The plaintiff in the case is demanding that his neighbour trim her hedge below 3 metres in height, even though it currently complies with all rules laid out in local law, which require that hedges over 2 metres in height must be set back at least 0.75 metres from neighbouring property.
At the heart of the case is the existential question: What is a hedge?
That's because stricter distance rules apply to trees and shrubs, raising a fundamental question about the nature of the garden bamboo.
The plaintiff argued that a hedge is characterized by the fact that it is maintained and regularly trimmed - so if it exceeded a certain height, it could therefore no longer be considered a hedge.
The defendant's side, on the other hand, did not consider the height of the hedge to be the determining factor, but emphasized the many advantages the bamboo hedge offers.
It was a "living element of horticulture" and also offered ecological value, the woman's lawyers contended.
Whether the hedge is a source of pleasure or a nuisance is "a matter of perspective," Peter Wassermann, the plaintiff's lawyer, retorted after the hearing.
For his client, the hedge was an inconvenience, he said, adding that the plaintiff's view is blocked by a bamboo wall when looking out the window.
"When it rains or snows, the precipitation weighs additionally on the leaves, causing the bamboo plants to bend over onto his property," Wassermann said, adding that the bamboo made the man feel "stifled."
If the woman must cut back her hedge, the judges are also being asked to decide the proper height, since the man's property is lower than his neighbour's. He wants the height of the hedge to be measured from the lower elevation on his side of the property line.
A decision from the BGH is expected on March 28.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
What did Springfield look like 200 years ago in the month of June
SPRINGFIELD, Mo. – Springfield has been around since the early 1800s, and many significant events have occurred over the last 200 years. What did Springfield look like 200 years ago in the month of May Here's a timeline of significant events that have happened in the month of June since 1861: 1861 Col. Franz Siegel with his federal St. Louis German troops marched up St. Louis St. into the Public Square at 11:30 a.m.; then to First Christian Church on College St. The congregation was compelled to take an oath of allegiance to the Union cause. 1868 At the opening of National Cemetery, Sempronius H. Boyd and W.E. Gilman made speeches, and a mile-long procession formed in the city with 65 wagons, 20 carriages, 500 on horseback and 150 men on foot. The 800 newly-made graves were decorated with flowers from two large floats. 1870 Ozark House, a hotel built by South Pacific Railway Company, was opened on Commercial Street near the RR station. It burned in 1874; rebuilt in 1879. 1875 Springfield observed a day of fasting and prayer, proclaimed statewide by Gov. Charles H. Hardin, because of grasshopper destruction. Later the town had a benefit concert for victims of the grasshopper onslaught. 1894 Springfield Post Office opened in new Federal Building on Boonville Avenue at Brower Street with T.C. Love as postmaster. An extensive addition to building was completed in 1914. After Federal Building at Boonville and Central was occupied, July 5, 1938, former site became City Hall, with lots owned by city between the two sites being exchanged. The city originally had planned to build a city hall on these lots 1902 In talking about the introduction of ping pong here the News & Leader says: 'Springfield is a town always ready to follow a fad as soon as the mandate comes forth that society is interested in it as New York, Chicago, Washington or wherever the social centers from which it emanates can be located.' 1904 St. Paul Methodist Episcopal Church, South, now St. Paul United Methodist Church, was dedicated at Jefferson and East Walnut. It replaced a building at southwest corner of South and Walnut started in late 1850's. The congregation's first building in Springfield was in 1842 at Patton and Pershing. 1906 First session of Springfield State Normal School opened with enrollment of 543 at Cherry and Pickwick in a building that had been the privately owned Springfield Normal School, established in 1894 by J.A. Taylor and Frank P. Mayhugh. 1910 Aviator Charles F. Willard crashed in his Curtis biplane, falling 150 feet but escaping with slight injuries. 1911 Deed to Confederate Cemetery, combining with National, was signed by Harvey W. Salmon, president of State Confederate Association, and J.E. Elliott, secretary. 1913 Northeast corner of Public Square, including Heer's Store, burned; loss $800,000. 1914 Missouri Pythian Home formally opened. The massive gray stone structure became part of the facilities of O'Reilly Hospital during World War II and for a time a Pythian Home was maintained on South Campbell. The structure was the Army Reserve Center for a time and is now in private hands. 1916 The city's first automobile show was held in the new Holland Building. 1918 Headquarters of the Assemblies of God moved to Springfield from Hot Springs, Ark., where it had been organized in April, 1914. 1919 Last licensed saloon closed under Prohibition. An estimated $150,000 was spent for liquor that day. 1952 Thirty-fifth Division Reunion Parade was led by President Harry S. Truman. 1973 R.T. French Company dedicated a $12.7 million plant at 4455 East Mustard Way. 1992 Sherill Lewitt, Suzie Streeter and Stacy McCall disappeared from their homes. An intensive hunt took place but their whereabouts are still unknown. 2017 The Palace Theatre closes meanwhile, Alamo Drafthouse takes over the Campbell 16 Cine Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
WWII Veteran recalls landing on Utah Beach in Normandy
ABINGDON, Va. (WJHL) — 81 years ago, World War II allies invaded Normandy, liberating France and Western Europe, and laying the path to victory. 'We came in on a landing craft with the front down, and we jumped into the water,' Army veteran Don Parker recalled of landing on Utah Beach a few days later. 'They had some – we'll call them cannons, they may have been 88s. That's what finally hit me. Well, it wasn't exactly comfortable, I don't know how else to describe it. It was bloody, it was messy.' Landing in Normandy is something most people read about in history books, but Parker lived it. 'We crawled in front of Patton's tanks, and we probed with our bayonets to get the pressure bombs that were down under there. We had to get and disable the bombs,' he said. 'Patton brought his tanks across after that… He didn't lose any tanks there anyway.' The rifleman remembers capturing a German outpost and earning a Bronze Star. 'I didn't think the choices were very good, but I had enough patriotism that it had to be done,' he said. 'It was necessary. That's about the only sensible thing to say. We had to do it and we did it.' PREVIOUS STORY: World War II Army veteran celebrates 100th birthday He said there is a mix of emotions about his time in the 79th Division during WWII. 'I was in college, I wanted to stay there. But when they drafted me, I didn't run to Canada,' he said. 'They want me? I'll go. And I went.' Parker was later injured, almost losing his foot to gangrene. 'I was digging a foxhole, and a shell come in and [my feet were in fragments]. And then when they got me back to the surgeon, he looks at me and puts his hand on my shoulder and says, 'I'm sorry, son, but I have to cut off your left foot,'' Parker recalled. 'They were right, I was going to die, but I mean the timing was wrong because I've still got the foot and that was some years ago.' SEE MORE: Abingdon veteran celebrates 100th birthday And the 101-year-old has a message for those who are now the 'boots on the ground.' 'We did our best, that's what we'd want to see of the young soldiers now,' he said. 'D-Day | The Greatest Victory' is airing on WJHL+ at 9 p.m. on Friday to mark the 81st anniversary. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
18 hours ago
- Yahoo
Charlotte WWII airman accounted for nearly 80 years later
U.S. Army Air Forces Tech. Sgt. Clarence E. Gibbs, 21, of Charlotte, has been identified decades after he was killed during a 1944 bombing mission in Germany. ALSO READ: Remains of missing soldiers from World War II uncovered His remains were recovered in a German cemetery and confirmed using DNA and dental analysis. Gibbs will be buried in Clinton, South Carolina, at a later date. In late 1944, Gibbs was assigned to 368th Bombardment Squadron, 306th Bombardment Group, 1st Bombardment Division, 8th Air Force. VIDEO: World War II veteran shares her secret to long life on 100th birthday
